Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Odinn

heroes Heroes of the Storm - Composition Balance

1 post in this topic

2Y4TGO7.png

 

With hundreds of thousands of games of Heroes being played every week, the rapidly growing beta test is providing a ton of data for interested players and would-be pros alike to analyze. Individual Heroes appear to be reasonably balanced, with only a handful of outliers - but what about the team compositions?

 

The good folks over at HotS Logs provide a service for uploading and analyzing Heroes replays, and they publish some statistical data using matches from recent memory (the last week for individual Hero statistics, and games from the last 60 days for team compositions). Heroes Tempest ran through some of their data, and published an analysis of compositions and win rates in matchmaking.

 

While recreating the exact data snapshot they've used here is almost impossible, since the data pool on HotS Logs changes so fast, it's worth discussing their findings - namely, that a handful of particular Heroes are insanely powerful when taken as a team, irrespective of variables like map/other.

 

While at first pass, you would expect that the strong compositions would just be a byproduct of taking a balanced team (common wisdom is one Warrior, one Support, and one or two of each of Assassins and Specialists [typically, two Assassins]), there are 'balanced' compositions appearing in their Bottom 10 list. What this suggests is that, despite roughly equal overall distribution statistically (every Hero has a global individual win ratio between 42% and 57%), certain compositions have too many favourable interactions.

 

Two takeaways jump out at me, personally:

  1. Team compositions should be more balanced by default. If you solo queue, you shouldn't get hung with a team with four Assassins, or no Support. If you queue as a full team with a gimmick composition, that's fine, but the matchmaking system wouldn't send a party into a dungeon in WoW with no healer.
  2. Heroes need to be balanced with team compositions in mind. As much as I read (and loved!) John Hodgson's piece on imbalances being cool, that kind of analysis makes a ton of sense on an individual Hero level - but even if there are dud Heroes, the way there are dud Hearthstone cards, a healthy variety of team compositions should be viable and balanced.

Looking at the data on HotS Logs myself, it's apparent that there are some underlying influences - stronger teams/players choosing certain Heroes out of comfort, or for strategic reasons - but anyone who has played the game can tell you that there are a core set of maybe a third of the Heroes that get used at a competitive level. Certain unique exceptions, like Gazlowe on Sky Temple, absolutely exist, but they don't tend to be reliable parts of team strategies (fundamentally, the best team comps are ones that work regardless of map).

 

Blizzard has a few options for solutions at their disposal - patching existing Heroes, or introducing new Heroes to fill gaps or create new viable compositions. Being that it is a free to play game, I would err on the expectation of the latter - we haven't seen a ton of major characters yet, and clearly later introductions on to the field can have a major impact (e.g. Thrall).

 

If you've played a composition that blows some of the listed ones out of the water, we'd love to hear about it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Stan
      Next week, Ragnaros will hit test servers. It's likely there will also be a balance update. Trikslyr wrote on reddit that a new balance Q/A is scheduled for December 6 and will last roughly 1.5 hours.
      Trikslyr
      BlizzCon has come and gone, and as we move forward, we’d like to touch base with the community in regards to Heroes of the Storm’s Balance! We’ll be hosting a Q&A on Tuesday, December 6th at 1:30 p.m. PST right here in /r/HeroesoftheStorm, and the following game designers will be here tackle your questions about upholding balance in the Nexus:
      /u/Blizz_Daybringer – Brett Crawford (Balance Designer) /u/BlizzCooper – Matt Cooper (Lead Balance Designer) /u/BlizzNeyman – Alex Neyman (Balance Designer) /u/BlizzAZJackson – Adam Jackson (Balance Designer) /u/BlizzClaudio – Claudio Gentilini (Producer) /u/Blizz_AKlontzas - Alexander Klontzas (Producer) The Q&A will last roughly 1.5 hours, so make sure to post your questions about game balance and live updates in the thread we’ll be creating on the morning of December 6th. We look forward to seeing you there!
      Please note: We’ll also be asking players from non-English speaking communities to partake in the Q&A by submitting their questions to the Community Managers representing their regions. As such, you might see a few Blizzard Community Managers posting questions (in English) on behalf of their communities during the Q&A. Feel free to upvote those questions if you’d like to see answers to them.
      (Source)
      The last balance update dates back to November 15 when Varian was released. We've seen some hotfixes on November 21. My wild guess would be balance update next week and Ragnaros live the week after. Reworked Haunted Mines should be back too.
    • By Stan
      Weekly Sale items for the week of December 6 have been announced.
      Weekly Sale Items: December 6 - 13, 2016:
      The following items have been selected for next week
      Gul'dan —  4.99 EUR // 3.69 GBP Balespider Gul'dan Skin — 4.99 EUR // 3.69 GBP Marshal Raynor Skin — 4.99 EUR // 3.69 GBP (Source)
      Weekly Sale Items Reminder
      This week's sale items can be found here.
      Druid of the Flame Malfurion Skin
      The Druid of the Flame Malfurion Bundle was added to the game lately and it has themed abilities. Details are available in our preview.
    • By Stan
      One shot, one kill! All players are locked in as Nova. A single Snipe will eliminate the opponent. Ghost Protocol is this week's brawl!
      Players have access to all talents. All deaths remove 1 point from the enemy core. The first team to bring down the enemy core to 0 wins. Completing three matches awards the Ghost Protocol portrait and 1,000 Gold.
      Blizzard Entertainment
      Lock and load, Heroes! Our newest Heroes Brawl mode is Ghost Protocol, an all-Nova snipe-battle on Towers of Doom. Be sure to practice your aim before heading into battle, because every shot counts in this game mode – Snipe not only instantly kills enemy Heroes, but it also reduces the enemy team’s Core health by 1! Good luck, have fun!

      RULES:
      Every player is locked in as Nova, Default skin vs. Spectres Landing a Snipe on an enemy Hero will instantly kill them All deaths remove one health from the opposing team’s Core All players have full access to Talents and Heroic Abilities Be the first team to bring the enemy’s Core health to zero to secure victory! REWARDS:
      Complete three matches of Ghost Protocol to earn 1,000 Gold and the following portrait:
      (Source)
    • By Stan
      The Nexus Challenge has been introduced in mid-November and is here to stay until January 4, 2017. It offers quite interesting Heroes that are a beneficial addition to your roster, a 31-day Stimpack and even more rewards if you're into Overwatch.
      If you feel like it's taking too long to complete the 30 games then you're doing it wrong! Most of this is common sense, but you can easily finish it in several hours, because AI games with Friends count towards the 30 game requirement.
      First, join an in-game chat, such as /lfg or /reddit. It makes looking for other people who also want to complete the objective much easier. The easiest method is to complete 30 games with AI set to Beginner with 4 other players. You can completely ignore objectives and all players should focus on pushing a single lane together. This is called AI rush and my games usually take no more than 5-6 minutes before we destroy the enemy core.  I've been even able to complete a game in 4:40.
      Tips
      If you're joining a random group, don't forget to right-click a player's portrait and add him as a friend. I usually do this with every group member, because sometimes a single person doesn't confirm it. Don't start the game by clicking "Ready" unless at least one player has accepted your friend request or the next game played won't count toward the Nexus Challenge requirement. We've got guides ready for all the Heroes you get from the challenge Auriel Greymane Kerrigan Li-Ming Zarya Ideal compositions for speed runs, should include Sylvanas (to disable structures), Auriel (no mana dependency), Zarya or Tassadar for shields etc. (thanks to @Krazyito for pointing out).
    • By Stan
      In celebration of the Gold Club World Championship in China, XP gains will be increased by 50% for the weekend of the finals starting December 2.
      The bonus XP event will be active in all regions starting December 2, 10:00 a.m. PST (click here for time zone assistance) and ends on December 5, 10:00 a.m. PST. It's a great way to level up your Heroes  to Levels 5 or 9 to get some extra gold. This effect stacks with other bonuses that increase experience such as Stimpacks or the friendly bonus.
      Blizzard Entertainment
      Top Heroes of the Storm teams from across the globe have been battling it out in China at the Gold Club World Championship event and the finals are fast approaching! In celebration of these hard fought battles in the Nexus, we’re granting all players 50% bonus XP for the weekend of the finals.
      Log in to Heroes during the following time frames to take part in this event:
      50% Bonus XP Event
      December 2, 10:00 a.m. PST (All Regions) – December 5, 10:00 a.m. PST (All Regions)
      Don’t forget, with the new XP bonuses available in-game, you can earn even more XP by playing with a party of friends!
      It’s a great time to get a favorite hero leveled up, watch an exciting global Heroes of the Storm esports tournament, and work on the Nexus Challenge with your friends!
      Find out more about Gold Club World Championship event here.
      (Source)