Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
nidosarg

Ask Mr Robot Fail or Mine Configuration Weigths Fail

24 posts in this topic

Hellos guys!! I am playing a little bit with Simcraft, and AskMrRobot.

 

Seeing, reading, studing, in every forum or guide i can find about MM.

 

Well, the trouble is here, i configured stats using Azortharion & Niix's Marksmanship Hunter Guide.

 

2.80 - Weapon DPS

1.00 - Agility

0.90 - Attack Power

0.71 - Crit to 53%

0.64 - Multistrike

0.60 Versatility

0.59 - Mastery

0.58 - Haste

 

Ask Mr Robot tells me that i have to change some Items becouse is better for me. (Best in Bags) but if i do those changes in simcraft i lose 1.5k DPS.

 

I dont know if i am doing wrong something, or if AskMrRobot is not helping Me.

 

Actual Gear 50411 DPS

 

ASK MR ROBOT GEAR 48939 DPS

 

I add you a Google Doc with captures for more explination:

 

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1tACreeT4wa45xgkskAx-8j6tgoFjwJpVAeTk_hz7nTc/edit?usp=sharing

 

 

 

Again Really Sorry for me primitive English.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

More than likely something got messed up on your end.  Got an armory and AMR BiB string for me to test?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes this is my Armory:

 

http://us.battle.net/wow/es/character/ragnaros/Cordob%C3%A9s/advanced

hunter=cordobés
origin="http://www.askmrrobot.com/wow/player/us/ragnaros/cordob%c3%a9s"
level=100
race=blood_elf
role=attack
spec=marksmanship
professions=
talents=3123333
glyphs=56850/57902/119447/119462/132106

head=rylakstalkers_headguard,id=115545,bonus_id=566
neck=choker_of_reciprocity,id=127976,enchant_id=5317
shoulders=rylakstalkers_spaulders,id=115547,bonus_id=566
chest=rylakstalkers_tunic,id=115548,bonus_id=566
waist=cursed_demonchain_belt,id=124311,bonus_id=566
legs=wayfaring_leggings,id=116189,bonus_id=66/536/618
feet=unhallowed_voidlink_boots,id=124288,bonus_id=564/566,gem_id=127760
wrists=bracers_of_the_wolfs_cunning,id=113943,bonus_id=566
hands=rylakstalkers_gloves,id=115549,bonus_id=566
finger1=unexploded_explosive_shard,id=113877,bonus_id=566,enchant_id=5324
finger2=spellbound_solium_band_of_fatal_strikes,id=118302,enchant_id=5324
trinket1=stone_of_the_elements,id=128024
trinket2=skull_of_war,id=112318,bonus_id=529/618
back=gossamer_felscorched_scarf,id=127971,enchant_id=5310
main_hand=felfire_munitions_launcher,id=124370,bonus_id=566,enchant_id=5276

summon_pet=cat


----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

And this is the BiB from AskMrRobot:

hunter=cordobés
origin="http://www.askmrrobot.com/wow/player/us/ragnaros/cordob%c3%a9s"
level=100
race=blood_elf
role=attack
spec=marksmanship
professions=
talents=3123333
glyphs=56850/57902/119447/119462/132106

head=rylakstalkers_headguard,id=115545,bonus_id=566
neck=choker_of_reciprocity,id=127976,enchant_id=5317
shoulders=rylakstalkers_spaulders,id=115547,bonus_id=566
chest=rylakstalkers_tunic,id=115548,bonus_id=566
waist=cursed_demonchain_belt,id=124311,bonus_id=566
legs=wayfaring_leggings,id=116189,bonus_id=66/536/618
feet=unhallowed_voidlink_boots,id=124288,bonus_id=564/566,gem_id=127760
wrists=bracers_of_the_wolfs_cunning,id=113943,bonus_id=566
hands=rylakstalkers_gloves,id=115549,bonus_id=566
finger1=unexploded_explosive_shard,id=113877,bonus_id=566,enchant_id=5324
finger2=spellbound_solium_band_of_fatal_strikes,id=118302,enchant_id=5324
trinket1=stone_of_the_elements,id=128024
trinket2=meaty_dragonspine_trophy,id=118114,bonus_id=564/566,gem_id=127760
back=gossamer_felscorched_scarf,id=127971,enchant_id=5310
main_hand=shredirons_shredder,id=109168,bonus_id=82/532/620,enchant_id=5275

summon_pet=cat

 

 

Thanks for the Really Fast Answer!!

Edited by nidosarg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Also i dont know why when i change the new stats from the guide is better Weapon Enchant Multi than Crit..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well, i more wanted the string from the AMR addon that gave you the BiB suggestions, but I can kinda work with this.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sorry i cant find a good translation for String (i only find something like cord, musicall).

 

Where can i get that string? Is the ingame Addon Code? I have saved in AskMrRobot, i can give you that in a few hours when i can go back home.

 

Also i have 1 Tier 18 Helm H (i dont use that becouse i have to break 4 parts of tier T17)

 

Also have parts 685 with crit multy but doing test with simcraft is better some parts from Kazzak 710

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ok, so the big thing was the trinket, AMR isn't the best resource when it comes to trinkets.  It values them based on the weight of the static stats + the weight of the dynamic stats multiplied by it's "average" uptime.  After that, the weapon difference will be rather small due to them being the same ilvl.  The crafted weapon should be better though due to it being crit/ms.

 

This is what I meant by string:

WT7UeMH.jpg

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So you say that is better to change Skull of War +6 for Meaty Dragonspine Trophy H + Socket 75 Crit.

 

And use Weapon Crafted +6 Crit Multi instead Felfire Munitions Launcher

 

I have done a simcraft and equip Gear (Skull and Felfire) give me more dps than the BiB.

 

Thats its why i am little confused right now jaja

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I will give my string at soon i can get my home.

 

Becouse i also have Beating Heart of the Mountain H (No sockets) but i think is better becouse procs Multi rater than Haste. TESTED IN SIMCRAFT is better keep the equip gear 49064 with BHofM.

 

So Ask Mr Robot is Not 100% improved for better dps dry.png

Edited by nidosarg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Your current gear (without seeing the BiB string) is the best setup, no need to change anything.  

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks Orthios i will post my string soon as i get my home.

 

Edith Weigths are well configurated? (Google Docs)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Nidosarg, I'm from Ask Mr. Robot. We do give you the single best solution, based on stat weights. It's possible different stat weights may work better for you. Also, what sim setup are you using (single target, multi target, any special settings?)

Edited by Zoopercat

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I can't answer for Nidosarg specifically, but this is the result I get from simming his character vs. the changes that AMR is suggesting.

 

5GNSZIJ.png

 

Full settings are 10k iterations, 350s +/- 20%, 1 target, patchwerk.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hello and loool didnt know that Ask Mr Robot have support here too.. Thats nice..

 

First of all here is my String Orthios:

$28;US;Ragnaros;Cordobés;Nazgrims Legacy;1;2;100;13:1,15:2,14:1;1;.s1;9;3123333;56850,1052,61545,15,12644;.s2;8;3131333;19573,1322,36971,36,61562,12642;.q1;112318s14b529b89;1559s11b-52e5324;66s9b0;1602s1b0;2s3b0;1s5b0;1s10b0;640s7b-500b470b82;2113s12e0;5986s8b-54b2x5413;23s6b0;59s16b0e-48;3601s15e34;5s2e7;48s13;.q2;109168s16b82b449b88;649s7b23b1;2501s13b-113b87;1275s10b-50;2598s5b-374b343b81;2106s12;511s15;54s11;14s14;19s1;439s9b-51;5s8b0;4972s6;3665s2;375s3b-375b460b2;.r;1269:3,1337:5,1341:3,1375:3,1387:0,1376:0,1435:4,1388:4,1270:4;.inv;50363;14911;6129f293;14;20;20;30381f354u491;7330b82b450b88e5276;4681b-580;16b526;27b-2b2;7b-5b5;0b0;30b-525b523b2;2b0;35b0;5b0e34;2054;2;164b-491b460b82;1923b-53b2x5346;6094;82;6b0;0;13;2;1;3820$

Second: 

 

The config i am setting up is Default, Single Target. 200 ms (thats my latency generally)

 

Here is a Print Screen of the setup:

 

http://prntscr.com/7w5a36

 

Third: 

 

I didnt want to be ofensive at any moment with my coment:

 

 

 

So Ask Mr Robot is Not 100% improved for better dps dry.png 

 

Just i didnt knew that trinkets stats was priority in AskMrRobot, i thougt that the addon makes like a SimCraft of the Gear and then give a BiB. smile.png

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hello and loool didnt know that Ask Mr Robot have support here too.. Thats nice..

 

First of all here is my String Orthios:

$28;US;Ragnaros;Cordobés;Nazgrims Legacy;1;2;100;13:1,15:2,14:1;1;.s1;9;3123333;56850,1052,61545,15,12644;.s2;8;3131333;19573,1322,36971,36,61562,12642;.q1;112318s14b529b89;1559s11b-52e5324;66s9b0;1602s1b0;2s3b0;1s5b0;1s10b0;640s7b-500b470b82;2113s12e0;5986s8b-54b2x5413;23s6b0;59s16b0e-48;3601s15e34;5s2e7;48s13;.q2;109168s16b82b449b88;649s7b23b1;2501s13b-113b87;1275s10b-50;2598s5b-374b343b81;2106s12;511s15;54s11;14s14;19s1;439s9b-51;5s8b0;4972s6;3665s2;375s3b-375b460b2;.r;1269:3,1337:5,1341:3,1375:3,1387:0,1376:0,1435:4,1388:4,1270:4;.inv;50363;14911;6129f293;14;20;20;30381f354u491;7330b82b450b88e5276;4681b-580;16b526;27b-2b2;7b-5b5;0b0;30b-525b523b2;2b0;35b0;5b0e34;2054;2;164b-491b460b82;1923b-53b2x5346;6094;82;6b0;0;13;2;1;3820$

Second: 

 

The config i am setting up is Default, Single Target. 200 ms (thats my latency generally)

 

Here is a Print Screen of the setup:

 

http://prntscr.com/7w5a36

 

Third: 

 

I didnt want to be ofensive at any moment with my coment:

 

 

Just i didnt knew that trinkets stats was priority in AskMrRobot, i thougt that the addon makes like a SimCraft of the Gear and then give a BiB. smile.png

Well, I'm not sure where you were getting the earlier suggestions from, because when I imported the string, the only thing it suggests to change is the bracers:

ZkQ34Nu.png

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Look Orthios:

 

flHqxof.png

 

I think the problem maybe be the Weigths Stats:

 

 

86rWPiX.png

 

I can see in your pickture you dont have soft cap.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes, I don't include a crit cap when optimizing on AMR.  You also have anything after 53% as having 0 weight, which AMR interprets as you absolutely do NOT want to go above 53% crit.  AMR does something odd when it comes to stat caps and procs, in that it values everything up to the cap at the weight before the cap, and everything after the cap at the weight that's set for that stat after you reach that cap.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No offense, and I know english isn't your first language. I just wanted to make sure there was a distinction, that our results are 100% optimal, but based on stat weights. 

 

What happens if you use Azorathian's preset weights? Have you looked at the weights SimC suggests and put those into our site? 

 

Keep us posted!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Back here again and with a few new things !

 

Azortharion Stats are not actualized, the stats on the guide and the newone are not the same.

 

I tried with default Azhortarion stats and this is whats happen:

 

DboRZUS.png

 

 

I am doing something wrong?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Edit: I found his guides. I updated them on our master spreadsheet, and they will be in our next site update. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1I8dysLq559MGWoXyS3eC3Ib9xnmsTcE4oWwkMalp578/edit#gid=1584123107

One thing that bothers me with this is that there isn't a weight for crit post 53% (or rather, it has a weight of 0), which isn't true.  Crit is still valuable after hitting 53%, and even M WF Socketed BiS doesn't get to that much static crit unless you run Fel Coil.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I talked with Azortharion about it. He said you can't reach the crit cap, so adding a value after doesn't matter. Unless you drop iLevels to get wierd garrison mission pieces with just 1 secondary stat on them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I talked with Azortharion about it. He said you can't reach the crit cap, so adding a value after doesn't matter. Unless you drop iLevels to get wierd garrison mission pieces with just 1 secondary stat on them.

The problem isn't with the static stats on gear though, it's with trinkets and procs that would potentially put you over the 53% cap.  How AMR currently works (from my observations) is that if you have a weight of 0 for crit post 53%, then anything that would put you over 53% crit is devalued immensely.  It values all crit up to 53% at the weight given for crit to 53%, and then any and all leftover crit rating post 53% is valued at the weight of crit post 53%. Since this post 53% weight is 0, it heavily devalues trinkets such as Skull of War, and that was what brought about this thread in the first place.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think i am understanding the point of view of Orthios.

 

I am doing a LOT of test of all the trinkets i have with simcraft and also the crafted gear (becouse in my server i can do mythic yet so crafted gear is good for increase stats) and a im noticing that some variables can be modified to get "that 53% crit (i obviously cant get)" with trinkets ups, and put more items on Multistrike. (When i say ITEMS, i am mention the ITEMS in my Bag).

 

I am changin 1 item, test, changing, test, changing, test. I think its one of the best way to do. It become hard to do when i dont have crafted the item +6 yet.

 

If i understand wrong tell me, becouse i really tried to follow the post on Orthios but have too many IF.

 

All the suggestion will be accepted, i am really new at this (Simcraft, TherorityCraft, AskMrRobot, Pawn (lastone didnt like so much becouse if the item have the same ilvl dont show as an upgrade for stats and i delete it from my addons)

 

Also i will be really apreciated if you can bring to me some sites that do test or simcraft for better understanding all this.

 

Goodnight guys! smile.png

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.