After Atempting to use Simulation Craft , Ask Mr.Robot i have found that neather one theys programs has used Simulation Craft.
Ask Mr.Robot does not go off your guide it says it also uses simulation craft , and icy-vans guide but they use there own stat prioritys
can some one from icy-veins please explain how they got there info and in what methods they use to retrive the best optimal out come as a guardian tank
I mean this as respectfully as I can (especially as I'm a new poster here), but AMR, Icy-Veins, and Simulation craft are all sites that are created to try and aid the player in making the best possible decision about how to setup their character. I personally see it VERY disrespectful to title a post "Bulls#!+" and call them liars in a post rife with mispellings and misunderstandings about the way your spec works.
All tanking classes (that I'm aware of) balance things like DPS, Healing, and survival. You need all three. That balance to my knowledge is also largely dependent on the players personal likes. Paladins (which I'm most familiar with) can now be vastly different stat wise, yet all three are viable. You could depend heavily on your attacks to give yourself active mitigation, or you could go the opposite way and give yourself a lot of passive mitigation at the expense of dps, but being easier to learn tanking.
Just remember to be respectful of the time and energy that people put into sites like these and the people that work hard to maintain them
Edited by Lightrox, 03 February 2013 - 02:31 AM.