Blainie

overwatch Is Mercy the Villain of Overwatch?

12 posts in this topic

pZcybTb.jpg

Given her appearance and skillset, who would have thought Mercy might be the true villain of the game?

If you're an Overwatch lore fan, I would definitely recommend checking this theory out. It's very well thought out and alludes to the relationship between Mercy, Genji and Reaper, as well as what her motives might actually be.

Posted by Reddit user OJPaper, their post goes through the following theories:

  • The backstory of Mercy and what her role is in Overwatch
  • Her relationship with Genji, Reaper, and later, Sombra
  • Where is Mercy in present day Overwatch?
  • What was Reaper's motive in Recall?
  • Name and design choices of Mercy

A comment on the post also adds another interaction with Mei, which adds slightly more information to the theory. The comment comes from user phluke-, where they point out that these voice lines exist:

Mercy: Mei, you haven't aged a day. What's your secret?

Mei: Cryostasis. But I'm not sure if I'd recommend it.

This voice line points towards Mercy's interest in staying young and immortality, which then leads to the following exchange between the two.

Mei: Doctor Ziegler, I don't think you've aged a day since I last saw you.

Mercy: And neither have you, Mei.

While this confirms nothing, it definitely points towards Mercy's interest in staying young and her youthful appearance to Mei.

What do you think of all this? Is Mercy truly the villain of Overwatch?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Oh dem Blizzard Conspiracy theories. Classic. I've been chasing The Old Gods since I was 10yo.

WoW is often claimed to be stopped with its 12+ rating - they can't really stick such blurred lines and gray moralities left and right. IDK how exactly they play it out this time with OW, but it's going to be really cool.

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
8 hours ago, Paracel said:

Oh dem Blizzard Conspiracy theories. Classic. I've been chasing The Old Gods since I was 10yo.

WoW is often claimed to be stopped with its 12+ rating - they can't really stick such blurred lines and gray moralities left and right. IDK how exactly they play it out this time with OW, but it's going to be really cool.

I think WoW's lore can be as deep as you want it to be. A lot of the Vanilla based stuff drew a lot from the Lovecraftian themes, as well as certain zone designs. There's definitely a rich adult loreset to be delved into there, once you get past the pop-culture stuff.

Going to start reading a lot more about the Overwatch background with this!

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I do plan to read the Reddit thread, but haven't yet. As far as the Mei/Mercy interaction? Um... that's like, super common IRL. Do the people spinning these theories even KNOW any women IRL? Or even on social media?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
38 minutes ago, solitha said:

I do plan to read the Reddit thread, but haven't yet. As far as the Mei/Mercy interaction? Um... that's like, super common IRL. Do the people spinning these theories even KNOW any women IRL? Or even on social media?

When there are so many pointers all heading towards her being obsessed with immortality and experimenting with life, it becomes a bit more than womanly banter :p

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ehhh i just don't know if deep lore stuff works in games like overwatch. Yes blizz allegedly made this huge backstory and that but as a player you don't experience it. It's sort of like Destiny when it launched. Oh you  want lore? Well go to our website and decipher the letters seen in the alphabet soup. Sure there are audio clips and maybe teaser images in the levels but as far as this big story goes we don't have much. The world needs overwatch again, so we are going to kill each other over and over. In a way it feels battleborn esque, where blizz wanted a single player mode for overwatch but scrapped it in order to work on legion some more.

Don't get me wrong, I love overwatch, just not sure about trying to add in deep lore to it. Someone lock metzen in a closet.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
21 hours ago, Paracel said:

Oh dem Blizzard Conspiracy theories. Classic. I've been chasing The Old Gods since I was 10yo.

WoW is often claimed to be stopped with its 12+ rating - they can't really stick such blurred lines and gray moralities left and right. IDK how exactly they play it out this time with OW, but it's going to be really cool.

Same here on the Old Gods front. I couldn't believe it when I found out N'zoth was going to be unveiled outside of WoW. It was like all my investigative work was for nothing :p

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Any game that implies competition as design value tends to be slightly off the point. 

Remember TF2? (oh boy mentioning this in any OW thread can start a war) Lore was over when we've been told there are two corps - B.L.U.E and R.E.D - fightning. No idea who they are, no idea what for. 

Counter-Strike? Nameless good guys, nameless bad guys, middle of nowhere, still a good game.

MOBA games tend to have lore behind their characters but not behind the conflict. DOTA 1 made sense because it was a WC3 related thing - everybody knew what The Frozen Throne and Tree of Life are, and why are we defending them.  And who the hell are Radiant and Dire? What are those new Ancients and why do we even care?
What are we doing in HOTS and why Arthas fights alongside Diablo and Raynor? Still a mystery for me. Hats off to the old League of Legends lore though - summoners made a ton of sense, shame that they've cut them completely.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Where are the voice lines from?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Damien said:

Where are the voice lines from?

They're interactions when the two heroes are on the same team. They don't always happen, it often picks an interaction for the whole team, rather than everyone having them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We could list them all. That'd be nice.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The main theory behind Mercy (and by correlation, Reaper) starts to unravel when you consider some of their other voice lines. The theory suggests Reaper is not actually hunting Overwatch people, but just Mercy. And yet:

If Reaper kills an Overwatch member: "Another one off the list."

Repear at Watchpoint: Gibraltar: "Overwatch. I'll put an end to your sad story."

Suggesting he went out of his way to avoid killing Winston starts to strain Occam's Razor a bit. There was a basic story to be told, that Reaper is trying to get the location of Overwatch members, and Winston needs to stop him. It wouldn't be much of a story if Reaper killed Winston, nor if Reaper got that list and wiped out Overwatch. The short was exciting and entertaining, and showed off a bit of expected gameplay. It's kind of like that list of things Not to Do if I Become an Evil Overlord. Some "details" are only shown for entertainment purposes.

He does clearly blame Mercy for his current condition, but it's a bit much to suggest she's his sole target.

 

Mercy herself is rather typical of aid-givers throughout history. Few of us like the situations in which we are required, but feel that it's necessary that SOMEone steps in and does his/her best to ease the inevitable hurt. Do you think Doctors Without Borders is performing similar experiments? There they go straight into war zones, just like Mercy.

 

As far as Sombra, I favor the theory that she's actually Alejandra, from the "Hero" short, especially when considering timeline clues.

 

When I shared the Mercy theory with a group, someone pointed out that it's just like the "Jar-Jar is the ultimate Sith" stuff. I really feel a lot of it's being overthought - for instance, I could believe someone at Blizzard reads stuff like this and says, "Wait, I named Mercy's staff after what? I TOTALLY thought it was the healer's symbol! Crap!"

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Stan
      Blizzard was nominated in several categories in the Game Awards 2016 and Overwatch won two!
      Game of the Year: Overwatch
      Overwatch won the Best Game of the Year award. Other nominees included Titanfall 2, Doom, Inside and  Uncharted 4: A Thief's End.
      Placeholder for tweet 804538964010860544 Best Game Direction: Blizzard (Overwatch)
      The second award for Best Game Direction was won by Blizzard for Overwatch. Other nominees were Dice, Naughty Dog, id Software and Respawn.
      Placeholder for tweet 804532014376361985 Congratulations!
    • By Starym
      The third season of Overwatch competitive play has gone live and brought with it some changes in they way skill rating is calculated, and there was also a smaller patch with just bug fixes deployed earlier today. You can check out both below:
      Blizzard
      BUG FIXES:
      Arcade
      Fixed a bug that prevented Ana from being selected in 1v1 matches
      Heroes
      Fixed a bug that allowed Mercy to receive Ultimate charge when using her Cadueus Staff to increase teammates’ damage when they’re not damaging enemies Fixed a bug preventing Reinhardt from deactivating his Barrier Field after being hacked by Sombra Fixed a bug preventing Sombra’s Hack from cancelling Soldier: 76’s Sprint ability Sombra no longer receives credit toward her on-fire meter when her EMP ultimate hits Symmetra’s turrets When multiple Sombras attempt to hack a health pack, the player that initialized the hack first will now control it Fixed a bug preventing Sombra from seeing practice bots, whose health has fallen below 50%, through the walls on the Practice Range Fixed a bug preventing Sombra’s reticle from consistently expanding while firing her machine pistol  
      Blizzard
      Season 3 has begun! Before you crack your knuckles and kick off your placement matches, here’s a quick overview of what's new in Competitive Play.

      If you’re an avid player, you undoubtedly noticed that Competitive Play wasn’t completely disabled when Season 2 ended last week. Instead, it was replaced with an Off-Season mode, which allows you to continue using the Competitive Play ruleset without your skill rating being affected.

      This gives everyone the freedom to break away from the meta and experiment with new hero combinations and strategies without having to worry about being moved to a lower tier. Players in the Diamond, Master, and Grandmaster tiers can also take a week-long breather and avoid any skill rating decay.
      We’re expecting each off-season to last about seven days, after which everyone will need to complete their placement matches for the new season.

      After giving the Skill Rating system a major overhaul in Season 2, we noticed both the Gold and Platinum tiers were significantly overpopulated. This meant that some players were initially achieving inappropriately high skill ratings and then experiencing a downward adjustment within the first few matches of the season. This also meant that competition within the Gold and Platinum tiers could vary widely from match to match.

      To address these issues, we’ve made some slight adjustments to the Skill Rating system—and, as a result, skill ratings will be more widely distributed across all tiers for Season 3. Many players will be ranked lower than expected after their Season 3 placement matches; however, this should normalize as the season progresses.

      Now that you're up to speed on the latest changes to Competitive Play, it’s time to put your skills to the test! Season 3 is live right now on PC, Xbox One, and PlayStation 4.
      Be sure to follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter for a steady stream of Overwatch information, and we’ll see you on the battlefield.
       
    • By Starym
      The developer update video goes into how Symmetra will be the first OW Hero to have 2 ultimates and also talks more changes coming to her on the PTR soon.
       
      It's time for Game Director Jeff Kaplan to discuss the very long awaited Symmetra changes, coming to the PTR soon. He talks about how situational she currently is, the long amount of time she needs to set up and more.
      But the headline is that she'll be the first OW Hero to have 2 ultimates to choose from at all times. You'll be able to toggle between the current teleporter and a shield generator that puts a substantial shield on all team mates in a large radius, ignoring line of sight. Check out the full video for a more in-depth description as well as other Symmterish topics:
       
    • By Starym
      This one goes straight into the rumor department, but there's a fair amount of evidence and common sense backing it up: Blizzard have posted two jobs in the "unannounced games/projects" section, working on a first person engine.
      This one goes straight into the rumor department, but there's a fair amount of evidence and common sense backing it up: Blizzard have posted two jobs in the "unannounced games/projects" section, working on a first person engine. They have also recently cancelled a large graphic novel that was going to go into the backstory and founding of the Overwatch organization, saying that the story has changed since its inception. The other reason behind it might be because they want to tell that story in an actual separate game, using the Overwatch engine. With the main game being so popular, having so many well liked/loved characters and the animated shorts adding more and more backstory and character to the Heroes, it seems Blizzard may have decided to go full out and make a whole single player experience around it.
      Now, usually these job listings will at least mention the franchise they're related to, even for an unannounced project, so this could still be related to a new IP or even a first person foray into a different franchise (anyone remember Starcraft: Ghost?). In any case, Overwatch seems to be the perfect candidate, especially since Blizzard had already said there will probably be an Overwatch 2.
      Blizzard job opportunities
      Lead Software Engineer, Engine
      Unannounced Games/Projects Blizzard Entertainment is seeking an experienced engine engineer to work on a robust first-person engine for an unannounced project. The ideal applicant has demonstrated ability to lead a team of engineers to success, has a vision for how a scalable, performant and technically excellent engine should be built, and has a passion for adopting state of the art rendering technology to implement visually stunning games.
      Pluses
      Previous experience working on first-person or other action-oriented games.   (Full listing)
      Lead Software Engineer, Tools
      Unannounced Games/Projects
      Blizzard Entertainment is seeking an experienced tools engineer to work on an unannounced project that utilizes a robust first-person engine. The ideal applicant has demonstrated ability to lead a team of engineers to success, has a vision for how tools should be built, and has an unwavering passion for developing content creation tools.
      Pluses Previous experience working on first-person or other action-oriented games.   (Full listing)
    • By Starym
      The free weekend we mentioned a while ago is here now and you can try out the game, well, for free! And in case you like what you see Blizzard have also gone ahead and prepared a special discount for the next 11 days, 40% off.
       
      Blizzard
      Over 20 million people have already joined the fight for the future, but the world could always use a few more heroes. Now, becoming an Overwatch agent is a little easier—at least for the next eleven days.
      Starting today, participating retailers are taking a Rocket Hammer to the price tag on Overwatch: Origins Edition, smashing 40% off for Windows PC, PlayStation 4, and Xbox One. If you'd like to pick up a copy, visit www.buyoverwatch.com or head to one of our participating retailers.
      Don't wait! The sale ends November 28.

      Are you with us?
       
      Blizzard
      Attention, recruits! If you haven't already had the opportunity to suit up and save the world as one of Overwatch's heroes, now's your chance.
      From November 18–21, we're putting out the call to any prospective agents: assemble your team and dive in during the Overwatch Free Weekend on PC, PlayStation 4, or Xbox One!
      For this free weekend, we're making Overwatch's full roster of 23 heroes and 13 maps available for play in a variety of modes, including Quick Play, Custom Games, and the latest Weekly Brawl. Players will also have the ability to level up, earn Loot Boxes, and unlock a variety of different customization options.
      (Plus, if you decide to purchase a copy of Overwatch after test driving the game, you'll get to keep any progress that you made during the weekend—just be sure to use the same Battle.net, Xbox Live or Sony Entertainment account that you played on.)
      For more details and to learn how you can participate, read on below!
       
      Deployment Schedule Installation and Play Instructions Free Weekend FAQ
      The Overwatch Free Weekend will run from November 18–21. PlayStation 4 owners with a PlayStation Plus membership, Xbox One owners with an Xbox Live Gold membership, and Windows PC users with a Battle.net account will be able to download and play Overwatch for FREE during this period—no special keys or sign-up codes needed!
      The free period will begin on November 18 at 11 a.m. PT (19:00 UTC) and end on November 21 at 4:00 p.m. PT (23:00 UTC) in all gameplay regions. If you'd like to see when the weekend will go live in your region, check out the reference guides below. 
       

       
      EUROPE: THE AMERICAS: ASIA: 20:00 BST on Nov 18
      20:00 CEST on Nov 18
      20:00 MSK on Nov 18
      11:00 a.m. PST on Nov 18
      12:00 p.m. MST on Nov 18
      1:00 p.m. CST on Nov 18
      2:00 p.m. EST on Nov 18
      3:00 p.m. AST on Nov 18
      3:30 p.m. NST on Nov 18
      5:00 p.m. BRST on Nov 18
      3:00 a.m. SGT on Nov 19
      6:00 a.m. AEDT on Nov 19
      8:00 a.m. NZDT on Nov 19
      3:00 a.m. CST on Nov 19
      4:00 a.m. KST on Nov 19
      4:00 a.m. JST on Nov 19
       

      Before your watch can begin, you'll first need to install Overwatch on your chosen platform. Every platform is a little different—to install and play on November 18, please follow the instructions below.
      FOR WINDOWS PC:
      Step 1: Download and install the Battle.net desktop app, if you haven't already, and launch it.
      Step 2: Create a FREE Battle.net account, or log in with an existing account. 
      Step 3: Click the "Overwatch" icon, located on the left-hand side of the Battle.net desktop app.
      Step 4: Select your region from the drop-down menu, then click "Install" to begin the installation process.
      Step 5: Once installed, click "Play" to begin!
      FOR PLAYSTATION 4:
      Step 1: Turn on your PlayStation 4 and log in to your preferred local user. 
      Step 2: Go to PlayStation Store and select "Search" from the top menu. 
      Step 3: In the search field, type in "Overwatch."
      Step 4: Select "Overwatch Free Weekend" from the search results and then click "Download."
      Step 5: Once the download and installation process is complete, click "Start" to begin!
      FOR XBOX ONE:
      Step 1: Turn on your Xbox One and log in to your Xbox Live account.
      Step 2: Go to the Xbox One Store, then select "Search."
      Step 3: In the search field, type in "Overwatch."
      Step 4: Select "Overwatch: Origins Edition" from the search results and then click "Free Trial."
      Step 5: Once the download and installation process is complete, click "Launch" to begin!
      The Overwatch Free Weekend client will be available for download on Windows PC, PlayStation 4, and Xbox One from November 18–21. 

      Q. What game content will be available during the Free Weekend?
      A. During the Free Weekend, players will have access to Overwatch's full roster of heroes, maps, and a selection of features—including Quick Play, Custom Games, the Arcade, and Loot Boxes.
      Q. How many heroes are available in Overwatch?
      A. There are 23 heroes available to play in Overwatch! To learn more about these heroes, click here.
      Q. How many maps are available in Overwatch?
      A. There are four different game modes and 13 different maps available in Overwatch!
      Assault: Hanamura, Temple of Anubis, and Volskaya Industries Escort: Dorado, Route 66, and Watchpoint: Gibraltar Assault/Escort Hybrid: Eichenwalde, Hollywood, King's Row, and Numbani Control: Ilios, Lijiang Tower, and Nepal Q. How many players does each mode support?
      A. Quick Play maps supports 12 players in a 6v6 format. The Arcade features alternate games modes and maps that support players in a 1v1, 3v3, and 6v6 formats. 
      Q. What different play modes are available in Overwatch during the Free Weekend?
      A. There are a variety of ways to play Overwatch during the Free Weekend! 
      Quick Play: Jump into a game against other players of similar skill. Play vs. AI: Hone your skills against a team of AI-controlled heroes. Custom Game: Customize the rules and play a game with your friends or AI. The Arcade: Change things up with alternate games modes featuring different rules sets and restrictions. Players can also learn the ropes in a series of training modes: Tutorial, Practice Range, and Practice vs. AI.
      Q. What's the approximate download size of the Free Weekend client?
      A.  The approximate download size is 12GBs. 
      Q. Do I need Xbox Live Gold or PlayStation Plus to participate in the Free Weekend?
      A. Xbox Live Gold and PlayStation Plus are required to play during the Free Weekend. 
      Q. What languages are supported during Free Weekend?
      A. The Free Weekend will be supported by 10 languages across both platforms: English, French, German, Castilian Spanish, Polish, Italian, Russian, Latin American Spanish, Brazilian Portuguese, and Japanese.
      Q. Will my progress from the Free Weekend carry over if I purchase Overwatch  later?
      A. Yes. Any progression you earn, including levels as well as skins and other items you get from Loot Boxes, will carry over to the full game if you purchase Overwatch: Origins Edition on Xbox One or PlayStation 4 or any version of Overwatch on PC—just be sure you purchase the game on the same console account you played on during this free weekend.
      Your stats will also be retained. (Trophies and achievements, however, have been disabled for the Free Weekend.)
      Q. Will PC and console gamers be able to play together during the Free Weekend?
      A: No, cross-platform play is not available in Overwatch. 
      Q. Will there be any sort of maintenance planned during the Free Weekend?
      A. There's no downtime or maintenance currently planned for the Free Weekend. If this plan changes at any point, we'll be sure to provide information about major service interruptions in the official forums. For additional status updates, be sure to follow @PlayOverwatch on Twitter.