Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
demonardvark

overwatch Overwatch: Is The Brawl Mode a Hit or Miss?

5 posts in this topic

JJNWmIW.jpg

To all agents of Overwatch, we are fast approaching the one month anniversary of Overwatch. Overwatch was launched initially with four modes, namely Quick Play, Play vs. AI. Custom Game, and a Weekly Brawl. The weekly brawl implements a specific set of rules and potential character restrictions to each match. So far we have seen five different brawls, including Arcade, Super Shamida Bros, Mystery Heroes, We're All Soldiers Now, and Overly Defensive.

I went out to the internet to ask the community what their opinion of each brawl was. Both polls and interviews were made and conducted on various outlets, including Icy Veins, Gamefaqs, Twitter, and Reddit. The results were collected and analyzed, however I do not possess hard numbers on how many matches were played (that info is hard to obtain).

The results were actually rather surprising. The two most popular brawls were "Arcade" and "Mystery Heroes". Arcade was applauded for its reduced cooldowns and Mystery Heroes was favoured for the spontaneity of it. The other brawls however, were frowned upon in general. "We're all Heroes now" was rated the worst and referred to as "Call of Duty: Overwatch". Truth be told, although "Arcade" and "Mystery Heroes" scored the highest of the brawls, they still scored very low. 

People in general don't seem to like the brawl mode, but why?

The Brawls are viewed as pointless and wastes of time. They are also considered poorly balanced, as is in the case of Arcade, where some heroes become flat out broken. The brawls are criticized as being restrictive or just stupid. Lastly, there is reduced experience gained in brawl mode. Why bother brawling under restrictive measures and getting reduced rewards for it? There needs to be some incentive for actually playing these brawls.

Is there something that can raise the opinion of brawls? Something that would make the players want to do them? Well, the community in fact, had an answer for that. Again the results were almost unanimous as to what people wanted. So, what is this magic fix for brawls? What can make people rush home to queue up for them? The answer is this magic little box, known as the loot box.

This is the incentive players want for Brawl mode. The biggest comparison made was with another blizzard franchise, Hearthstone. In their weekly mode, you get rewarded for participating, and people want to see that from the Brawl mode in Overwatch. Ideas have ranged from rewarding for first brawl win of the week, for playing X games, or for playing simply one game. People hesitate for it to require a win amount because trolls could try to make the process miserable for people. Having it after only one game wouldn't help in the long run, since everyone would play the one match and stop. Regardless, many agree that Blizzard should change it so that in some way, you are rewarded loot boxes for playing Brawl mode. 

So, will Blizzard listen to the community? Will Brawl mode ever get loot box rewards, or will the mode slowly fade into obscurity? Especially with "Competitive Mode" looming, brawl mode may be struggling to stay afloat. It's very likely that people will go for either Competitive or Quick Play and forsake all other modes. 

Tell us what you think. Would you play brawl mode if there were loot box rewards? Do you think they need rewards, or do you think brawl mode will develop its own niche following? Let us know in the comments below.

Happy Brawling!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Either give a loot box for your first win each day/week or some currency.  Right now there's now reward or incentive to play te brawls besides curiosity and the want for a bit of a change.

2 people like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think in its current incarnation that the weekly brawl is a miss.  While it may be fun once it does not offer the same creativeness as the Hearthstone brawl.  Also it has no incentive to try the mode.  The easy way to fix this is eliminate the worst brawls and reward players for playing outside the box (A.k.a Loot box).  I suggest maybe a contest or something to allow the community to invent new weekly brawls they would like to see.  As in Hearthstone, give a loot crate for first win that week. 

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think most people who would play 1 brawl a week for a lootbox will play a brawl a week just to see how it plays, even without any rewards at all.

The easy way to make brawl mode played more would be to make it also competitive, with each week having it's own ranking.

Then you could also give rewards for position, some formula like  roundUp(1000/position) gold. (obviously a better formula, but that gives the idea) Whatever gives "you won a single match and that's it" people ~10 gold, and the best player of the week 1000 gold, second 995 gold, etc...

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 hours ago, DashivaDan said:

I think most people who would play 1 brawl a week for a lootbox will play a brawl a week just to see how it plays, even without any rewards at all.

The easy way to make brawl mode played more would be to make it also competitive, with each week having it's own ranking.

Then you could also give rewards for position, some formula like  roundUp(1000/position) gold. (obviously a better formula, but that gives the idea) Whatever gives "you won a single match and that's it" people ~10 gold, and the best player of the week 1000 gold, second 995 gold, etc...

That is actually a really good idea I don't think I've heard yet. Doing competitive brawl mode. If you add a ladder there will be people who want to climb it :D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Starym
      At least two new skins are coming, for Mei and D.Va and we get to see a sneak peek of them.
      The Year of the Rooster is coming to OW and Blizzard have started teasing it already, if you can call straight up announcing the release date a tease. We don't know much more about it other than it will feature at least two new skins for Mei and D.Va, but it seems likely it'll be on par with all the other events so far and have more than just that. If not, it could be the first of a new type of smaller-scale theme event that comes around more frequently (or only for very special occasions), which isn't a bad idea either. In any case, here are the two new skins and teaser videos, courtesy of the official OW twitter and its Korean counterpart:
      Meanwhile, Jeff Kaplan is set to deliver a keynote speech at the 2017 DICE Summit titled "Overwatch: How Blizzard Created a Hopeful Vision of the Future".
    • By Starym
      Dev goals for Sombra, Roadhog's hook, D.Va and Ana thoughts, how the PTR is not just for community feedback on the changes, why there's no PTR on consoles and more.
      The big Roadhog and D.Va changes on the PTR recently, as you'd expect caused a civilized, calm and measured discourse in the OW community, without any overreactions or hyperbole whatsoever. So mild was the reaction that Jeff Kaplan felt the need to restate the purpose of the PTR and that changes done there aren't necessarily the end of the world. Of Overwatch.
      The actual details go into other purposes of the PTR other than community feedback on changes, goals or Sombra, Roadhog's hook, how D.Va is doing "too much" right now, small Ana changes, why there isn't a PTR on consoles and more:
    • By Starym
      A small patch mainly just fixing Mercy's "rez you while you're still falling off the map and then you fall again and die" bug and some Sombra reaching unintended locations bugs. Geoff Goodman also explained the reasoning and intentions behind the current changes to D.Va on the PTR.
      Josh Engen (source)
      PATCH HIGHLIGHTS
      New Feature: Simple Checkout
      Purchasing Loot Boxes has never been easier. Our streamlined system gives players access more payment options from directly within the Overwatch client.
      GENERAL UPDATES
      General
      Decreased the volume of passing cars on the Oasis background in the Hero Gallery
      BUG FIXES
      Heroes
      Fixed a bug that was allowing Mercy to resurrect players that had fallen off the map to their death
      Maps
      Fixed a bug to prevent the garden point on Oasis from being contested/captured from the second-floor walkway above it Fixed a bug that allowed Sombra to reach unintended locations on several maps  
      Geoff Goodman (source)
      This is great feedback, thanks.
      Keep in mind her spread didn't actually change, but her shots 'fill in' her spread more evenly now, meaning her damage per shot is generally more consistent. For example, in the video provided from the live game, if you take that same shot multiple times you'll see a greater diversity in damage results than you would on the PTR, because sometimes some of those bullets would just miss. Overall though, the change to her damage is intended to be a small nerf.
      As for her health/armor, the bottom line is shes intended to be weaker vs faster firing weapons (and shotguns), such as Reaper and Tracer. The game is a lot healthier when heroes have strengths and weaknesses versus other heroes. As she was, it was common to hear people ask 'What do I do about D.Va?'. People often would try to use Zarya or Roadhog, since they both have the potential to deal high damage and pierce her Matrix, but even those answers were marginal at best. Heroes like Reaper that are generally supposed to be good at taking down tanks weren't very effective because of all the armor they had to get through. With lowered armor, she now has more legitimate counters and she still counters many heroes and abilities in the game, especially considering her Defense Matrix wasn't touched.
      I understand that people feel like she may be too weak overall after these changes, and if that turns out to be the case we'll look at helping her out. That said, that help isn't likely to come back in the form of a bunch of armor, since that would just put us back the problems we had to begin with. We'll be watching her impact closely after these changes.
    • By Starym
      The ongoing saga of Hook 2.0 continues on the PTR as Roadhog gets closer and closer to not violating the space-time continuum, getting less broken hooks and less problems with people peeking around corners being un-targetable. Ana got a duration buff to the previously nerfed Biotic Grenade and Sombra got a significant cooldown reduction on Hack as well.
      Geoff Goodman (source)
      We're about to push a new build to the PTR with some new changes:
      Roadhog Hook
      - Added some more line of sight checks towards the left/right of a potential hook target. This means it should be easier to hook someone who is sticking halfway out of a doorway, or behind a thin pole, etc. These checks are also used for the persistent line of sight check, so if a hook target moves behind a slim object like a stump or a lightpole, they won't be released anymore.
      - Hooked targets are now slowed heavily while they are stunned, even if they are in the air. This means if someone is strafe jumping away from you and you land a hook, they are a lot less likely to slide out of line on sight, breaking the hook.
      - Fixed a bug that could allow you to hook someone and pull them behind you if you spun around before the hook landed.
      Ana
      - Biotic Grenade duration reduced from 5s to 4s
      Sombra
      - Hack cooldown reduced from 12s to 8s
      Thanks for the feedback so far! Hopefully we'll have this new patch up very soon so you guys can check it out and let us know what you think.
      Here's the big issue that is addressed in these fixes:

      Previous PTR patch notes.
    • By Starym
      Mostly funny stuff, good plays and even an informative clip or two. This week Roadhog gets confused, Zarya cleans a room (literally) and Mei... gets what's coming to her.
      The play of the game and highlight features are some of the best in Overwatch, so it's no surprise the entire community is obsessed with sharing them. Looking through reddit trying to find some rule 34 stuff interesting discussions you have to get through a lot of clips and, the thing is they're pretty much all really, really good. I thought I'd share some of my favorites each week here so let me know if you like the idea and/or clips in the comments and if you'd like actual explanations of what the hell just happened in them in future posts. Let's get started.
       
      As Hook 2.0 has been a big topic this week we start off with a very confused Roadhog, seemingly unable to understand the difference between his hook and Widowmaker's grapple. (Source)
      A hole in one. (Source)
      Then it's time for a lesson, a physics lesson, in fact, as Zarya's ult both cleans and messes up a room on Eichenwalde. (Source)
      Sticking with the science theme, someone has come up with a foolproof new way of communication, absolutely 100% ensuring you get to pick the hero you want. Sometimes. (Source)
      Back to actual good plays, this Genji illustrates that you don't really need your team's ults or weapons at all, reflecting both Zarya and Tracer ults for that juicy 4 kill. (Source)
      No collection of clips would be complete without the mandatory Reinhardt crazy charge kill. (Source)
      And, finally, everyone's "favorite" shows off just why she's so popular as poor Genji clings to life as long as he possibly can. (Source)
      And then gets punished for her wicked ways. Repeatedly. (Source 1)(Source 2)
      Ah, there really is nothing more "feelgood" than watching Mei die repeatedly is there? So, let me know if this is the kind of thing you'd want to see again and if there's something that could be added or changed for future articles. Hope to see you in some of these clips one day!