Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Wolfdy

Death coil Vs Death strike

6 posts in this topic

1 - I've been thinking about something a friend of mine theorized about Death strike and Dark arbiter, he thought it was batter to dump runic power with Death strike because it buffs the dark arbiter faster (45 runic) then Death coil (30 Runic + Sudden doom procs getting in the way of spending), why ins't this actualy a thing? i makes a LOT of sense, it's 1,5+ the runic power spending buff to the arbiter

 

2 - This made me look to Death coil and Death strike and i notice something, Death coil hits for barely nothing in pre-patch, while death strike hits for OK dmg, i cant do rly much testing besides theorycrafting about this, but i gathered  some numbers and i think that unholy rotation should be using death strike instead of Death coil (besides dudden doom procs)

My 685 equiped weapon only lvl 100 DK (22% mastery) hits for 
- 1801 (Shadow) Death coil + 10 energy for ghoul (1/4 of his 589 cleaver attack = ~147)
- 7845 - 9654 (Physical) Death strike

Full gear 699 ilvl (41%mastery)
- 6506  (Shadow) Death coil + 10 energy for ghoul (1/4 of his 1834 cleaver attack = ~458)
- 16945 - 18841  (Physical) Death strike

Edited by Wolfdy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Moved to the appropriate class forum.

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You have to add the weapon ability Scourge of Worlds to the death coil side of that argument to. (post-patch)
But a doom proc is still dmg for both you and your pet, if you want to set that aside then yeah, DS is probably a faster way to boost DA.

Remember to adjust the numbers to dmg per runepower (dmg/45) and (dmg/35) and add some dmg to one da-strike in benefit for DS, i dont think the benefit is more then that because you have to wait longer to get the third DS on target then you do with DC and in that moment DC is past DS if DA gets a shot of.

I probably missed alot here.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
8 hours ago, Gammelvarg said:

You have to add the weapon ability Scourge of Worlds to the death coil side of that argument to. (post-patch)
But a doom proc is still dmg for both you and your pet, if you want to set that aside then yeah, DS is probably a faster way to boost DA.

Remember to adjust the numbers to dmg per runepower (dmg/45) and (dmg/35) and add some dmg to one da-strike in benefit for DS, i dont think the benefit is more then that because you have to wait longer to get the third DS on target then you do with DC and in that moment DC is past DS if DA gets a shot of.

I probably missed alot here.

this is basically it. the damage between death coil and death strike is negligible to your overall dps. with death coil you are praying for the sudden doom procs so you can squeeze in extra death coils, vs only getting a guaranteed 2-3 death strikes. also once we have artifact weapon one trait gives us more sudden doom procs and another increases death coils damage. so once legion hits death coil is the preferred spender by a long margin. pre patch, death strike might guarantee a little bit more rp if rngesus isn't good to you, but death coil will still eek out a little more rp overall. in addition there is a fair chance you will have at least one sudden doom proc before you even summon DA. so its very easy to get 5-6 death coils in the window. so 3 - 45 rp death strike = 135 rp vs 5-30 rp death coil = 150. the 150 can be higher with sudden doom procs and potentially a little help from haste scaling.  

so an intriguing idea for certain. if pvp still shared talents with pve i imagine death strike would likely have been the spender. but given everything death coil is a larger rp gain. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Icy veins it's currently covering only pre-patch theorycrafting, sorry if i didn't said so, but i'm not considering The artifact nor the shadow infusion talent

I'm also implying that during this time DS should replace DC entirely from the unholy rotation (Besides sudden doom procs), not only during DA

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, Wolfdy said:

Icy veins it's currently covering only pre-patch theorycrafting, sorry if i didn't said so, but i'm not considering The artifact nor the shadow infusion talent

I'm also implying that during this time DS should replace DC entirely from the unholy rotation (Besides sudden doom procs), not only during DA

yes, the math (can i call it that? lol) I did was for prepatch. Going into DA window with a sudden doom proc guarantees (for the most part) more rune power generated than Death Strike. In addition Death coil scales with mastery so at higher gear levels Death coil should be hitting a lot harder than Death strike. You also have to consider shadow damage vs physical damage. In addition death coil is giving juice to your pet who is a lot bigger contribution to your damage then ever before, especially with HFC 4 piece bonus. Even then, when looking at your total dps contribution, your runic spenders are a low part of your dps, so optimization there, especially with HFC nerf has no huge impact on your total dps. 

I could go into all the theorycrafting numbers and that but thats no fun. Just another place to check whats viable is to see what the top players are doing. so if you check warcraft logs you can see the top DKS in the world https://www.warcraftlogs.com/rankings/8#class=DeathKnight&spec=Unholy  . The basics of it is, that with the higher gear DC is what is utilized due to more damage, but even then at best, its contributing 3% of the total dps. Even then, you will notice with most, that the sludge belcher pet is usually around the 3rd highest contributor to their dps. Typically around 10-12 percent. So, it behooves you to help increase your pets power, over a (if applicable) slightly more damaging death strike. 

So, its possible at certain gear levels and stats that Death strike could do more damage, however, the other effects of death coil are too valuable to dps. Inside DA window you get more RP with DC and outside of it DC keeps your pets dps high.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By bwaargh
      So, i'm lvl 866 crit - castigator - soul reaper. Crit 27%, haste 18%, mastery 29%.  Draugr, Girdle of the Everlasting King and Sephuz's Secret. I simc at 305k dps single target. When i switch to CS - necrosis - dark arbiter, i simc at 298k dps. But my gear is crit-heavy low-mastery and i've no Deadliest coil traits yet, so i wonder if mastery build is really better now. But icy and noxxic still suggest crit-build. Does anyone have the possibility and gear to simc two of this builds with the same ilvl gear. Please share.
    • By Gendibal
      Hello, I'm sure I'm no the one who noticed that we unholy dks can proc sephuz secret on dungeon and raid bosses using the pet stun (if you haven't you can try using pet stun even without the successful stun the ring procs).
      Last patch this was a something I lol'd cuz many classes said sephuz secret was useless for them. And with the legendary updates this ring got a plus% of haste, so it is better than before (with this update I still don't know if now every class can activate the effect).
      Problem is I have 3 legendaries, Sephu'z, Prydaz and the uh dk Belt (Draugr, Girdle of the Everlasting king). I will obviously keep the belt but I'm not sure if with the update Prydaz (with 3 stats now) is better than Sephu'z (activating 25% haste every pet stun (90 sec)).
      I'd like to know your ideas or if anyone had run some numbers please share, and if you are unholy with sephuz and you did'nt know you can activate the proc, try it now!
      Thanks for your answers.
    • By orazzledazzle
      Hey all. I was wondering what out of the legendaries I have would be best to use together? I got Tak'theritrix's Shoulderpads, Prydaz, Acherus Drape and Uvanimor the Beautiful. I've been using the shoulders and the ring, but I've read that the ring is either broken or has a tool tip error so I'm not sure if that is even worth using or not. I have an 860 crit/haste ring I can equip if that one is not worth using atm and I got gear for any slot if I need to change legionaries. That brings me to my next question for the patch coming up on which legionaries you would suggest upgrading first? The shoulders sound strong just because the gouls are already getting buffed but I have no idea so any help would be awesome.
       
      My last question is with the shoulderpad legendary when I use it I saw that there is a 10 second window to pop Dark Transformation to get the full benefit with the Army and the gargoyle. But I was wondering if when I pop Apocalypse do I need to wait for the gouls to be up and summoned before I hit dark Transormation or should I hit Dark Trans right as soon as I pop the wounds with apocalypse? Normally I've been waiting to see that the gouls are above ground before popping Dark Transformation. Thank you.
       
      Armory - http://us.battle.net/wow/en/character/kiljaeden/valicia/simple
    • By Oro
      So, I am maining a Blood DK. I recently started playing some Unholy (Love the Lore and class Art ;) ). My dilemma is that I'm not that good, so in an attempt to truly understand the class I tried my hand at creating a DPS prio WeakAura.
       

      The WeakAura does:
      Not track CDs
      Not track Talents
      Shows (what I understands is the) single-target rotation
       
      Now I am looking for feedback on it. So if anyone wants, have the time and so on, pleas leave a comment if I got something wrong.
       

    • By FireWater
      The advice for frost dks on this site right now seems very... oversimplified. With so much different gear, with different legendary combinations things can get rather variable, so I had a few thoughts and questions. 
      Firstly, base 'rotation'. Recommended talents tend to go:  Runic Attenuation and Obliteration for single target, or Frostscythe and Glacial advance for the aoe true 'machinegun build'. Single target with obliterate is simple enough, but using machinegun build during periods of single target dps, all they have is a base priority list that seems lacking. 
      They recommend: 
      Frost fever up>Glacial Advance>Remorseless Winter>Frostscythe>Frost Strike
      And that's really all it says. I've been sticking with the same talents even in single target, and I've been making due with the following:
      Frost Fever up
      Frost strike to keep Icy Talons from dropping (typically once every 2-3 global cooldowns) or if your RP is almost capped.
      Frostscythe with KM proc
      Howling blast with Rime proc
      Glacial advance and Remorseless Winter when available
      Obliterate for rune dump and rime procs
       
      Done properly, and with normal luck on procs (and decent haste), you should be able to keep Icy Talons at near 100% uptime. 
      Beyond that, the stats it advises amounts to soft crit and haste caps, then Versatility > Mastery. But a spec using lots of RW, GA, and big Frostscythe crits makes me wonder if more mastery wouldn't be better. Especially if you get  the legendary bracers (Toravon's whiteout bindings) which give an extra 15% frost damage during PoF.
      With the same legendary in mind, is it worth using Frostscythe on single targets during PoF?
      And if you have the bracers AND the ring that gives 2x charges of Empower Rune Weapon, how does dps compare for Breath of Sindragosa build? I can imagine amazing burst dps every 2 minutes, but would that make up for the lack of avalache and glacial advance?