Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

wow Artifact Preview & Watcher on Artifact Power Scaling with Artifact Knowledge

6 posts in this topic


Two new videos have been released, briefly introducing Artifacts and how they work. Meanwhile, Ion "Watcher" Hazzikostas clarified that Artifact Power from quests and treasures will scale with Artifact Knowledge.

Are you ready to get your hands on your Artifacts in less than a week? Two new videos present Artifact weapons and their systems. As it is mentioned in the videos, they barely touch the surface of this whole topic.

Blizzard LogoBlizzard Entertainment

To defeat the Legion, you’ll need to wield the most powerful weapons on Azeroth. To help you learn more about these weapons and the new Artifact system, we’ve put together two new feature videos to provide you more insight.


The Artifact Forge

On the topic of Artifacts, Ion "Watcher" Hazzikostas explained that it is intended that Artifact Power from quests and treasures to scale with Artifact Knowledge. Think of Artifact Power as a raw currency that you will use to unlock the traits on your weapon, whereas Artifact Knowledge is just a raw increase of the rate you gain Artifact Power from all sources.

A lot of people felt that with AP scaling with AK, it would be better to intentionally leave quests and treasures and grab them at a higher (or max) level, so they could get more AP. In a lengthy post, Watcher explained why it is better to just grab anything that yields Artifact Power immediately and not save it for a later time.

Blizzard LogoWatcher

+ Show
The fact that Artifact Power rewards from quests and treasures now scale with Knowledge is not a bug.

We started off the design of the system thinking along the exact same lines as many of the posters in this thread: We figured that we should make sure that one-time AP rewards did not scale, or else the "right" answer might be to delay completing key quests or collecting any treasures until you had higher Knowledge. And that didn't sound like much fun.

So we spent the first half of beta with all repeatable AP sources (world quests, item drops, missions, etc.) scaling, and all story quests and treasures flat. We added multipliers to things like Suramar or Order Campaign quests that tried to incorporate a likely expected Knowledge level at the point where players would get to that content. So, for example, finishing the third chapter of the Suramar campaign awarded a flat 10k Artifact Power, since by that point we expected players to likely have a ~14x multiplier from being around Knowledge Level 12, and we wanted to make sure that the reward still felt meaningful to that player.

But as we were actually playtesting extensively and getting into endgame ourselves and going through the Artifact Power and Knowledge progressions, we realized two things:
  • Artifact Power isn't a limited resource. There's always more available. There are world quests popping up every few hours, dungeons that can be repeatedly run, and so forth. And regardless of what we did with one-time sources, the vast majority of a player's AP over the course of the expansion would come from repeatable sources.
  • Even trying to account for an expected "par" Knowledge level, any time you came across a non-scaling reward that was aimed at someone with a lower Knowledge level, it felt pretty bad. Stumbling across a zone side-quest you'd missed and getting 100 AP from it when you needed 70k for your next trait felt like a waste of time. Opening a treasure to get 25 AP when you needed 300k for your next trait felt insulting. The system we'd set up actually encouraged trying to front-load all your AP while it still mattered (e.g. doing a full world tour to collect every treasure possible while still at Knowledge Level 1, since if you waited they'd no longer be worth the time relative to other activities).
So we started changing it. The first step was making treasures and level-up quests scale. That helped, but we still found that someone who delayed doing much in Suramar beyond the initial Friendly unlock, and instead focused on other content (dungeons, world quests, etc.), found all the rewards in the zone incredibly underwhelming once they got around to doing those quests. So just over a month ago, we also converted those rewards to be scaling sources.

Now, we haven't had a new client build since then, so community sites and datamining likely still show the values of the old items. That Suramar Chapter 3 capstone reward mentioned above is not a 10k AP item that gets multiplied by Artifact Power - that'd be pretty crazy. It's now just a 750 AP base item, which will give around 10k AP when you get there if you've been keeping up with your Knowledge.

It's not necessarily intuitive, since at first glance it seems like an obvious flaw in our system that if you wait until Knowledge Level 20 (a month and a half longer) to complete that quest, it'd give over 70k AP instead of 10k. Aren't you "wasting" 60k AP if you don't do that? The key here is that everything is relative. That Suramar quest capstone reward is equal to ~5 world quests. It'll be equal to 5 world quests if you do it ASAP; it'll be equal to 5 world quests if you do it two months later. And it'll contribute roughly the same amount towards whatever trait you're working on at the time.

Finally, it's also worth noting that the biggest one-time sources of AP are the Order Hall campaign, and the Suramar campaign. From a pure min-max perspective (probably the mindset most associated with the competitive raider), you really don't want to delay turning in either of those. The former leads to unlocking your third Artifact relic slot; the latter unlocks additional repeatable sources of AP (new world quests) and eventually access to the two Mythic dungeons, for an extra two Mythic clears each week.

tl;dr: Just get Artifact Power when you find it, as you find it. Enjoy the rewards and the immediate benefit, and you aren't hurting yourself in the long run. (source)

If all this talk about Artifacts, Artifact Power and Artifact Knowledge confused you, it might help reading our recap of the Artifacts and Order Halls Q&A with Craig Amai. Blizzard has promised that this whole system will seem much easier and will feel natural once it goes live and we get our hands on it.

If you are interested in learning more about the history and lore of each Artifact, Blainie has written an excellent series of articles for each class. Here they are:

1 person likes this

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

awww yisss 5 more days boys

1 person likes this

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

This is a great article.  I love all the behind the scenes looks that Blizzard gives us on the process of development.  It always makes me feel better about games knowing that they have developers hard at work right down to the last second. 

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

1 day to go! OO ya

1 person likes this

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Starym
      The first hotfixes for the new patch are in! A lot of PvP stuff as well as M+ questing issues, among many smaller fixes.
      New patch, new problems that need to be fixed, but Blizz was on the case very quickly as we already have the first hotfixes of 7.1! A lot of fixes, predominately in the PvP area, with the biggest one being Kara attunement and the weekly bonus event being completable in M+ dungeons.
      October 25th
      Bonus Event
      Completing a dungeon on any Mythic Keystone difficulty will now count towards progress on the weekly Bonus Event quest, "Emissary of War". Classes
      Luffa Wrappings should once again function correctly for non-Feral Druids. Prowl should once again have the correct stealth effectiveness. Mass Entanglement should now reliably chain to nearby targets. Paladin
      (Retribution) Fixed a bug preventing the Sword of Light passive from being fully calculated into baseline damage. Shaman
      (Restoration) Lava Burst should correctly deal a critical strike against targets with Flame Shock, at level 20 or higher. Warrior
      (Arms) Fixed a bug preventing the Seasoned Soldier passive from being fully calculated into baseline damage. Dungeons and Raids
      Quest Items related to Karazhan attunement now drop in Mythic Keystone dungeons in addition to Mythic difficulty dungeons. Game Client
      (Work in progress) Sheathing and unsheathing a weapon should no longer cause the game to crash. PvP
      Warden Towers temporarily rewarded 150 Honor. They have been convinced to once again reward 300 Honor. Honor rewards from Tol Barad have been reduced by 50%. Class Adjustments Relentless reduces crowd control duration by 20% (was 25%). Developers’ Notes: We feel Relentless is over-represented in a lot of situations, so we’re slightly reducing its effect. Demon Hunter Fixed a bug that was preventing Imprison modified by Detainment from being removed by Divine Shield and Ice Block. Fury of the Illidari no longer causes reduced damage in PvP. Mage (Fire) Stamina reduced by 10% in PvP. (Frost) Stamina reduced by 10% in PvP Developers’ Notes: Fire and Frost Mages have felt a bit too tanky. (Frost) Deep Shatter increases the damage of Frostbolt by 150% (was 200%). Monk (Mistweaver) Surge of Mist now causes Enveloping Mist to incur an 8 second cooldown (was 6 seconds). Developers’ Notes: Mistweavers Monks have often relied on Soothing Mist to do most of their healing. Now, when choosing Surge of Mist, you may have to cast another healing spell during the Enveloping Mists cooldown. (Mistweaver) Counteract magic increases the healing of Renewing Mist by 125% (was 150%). Developers’ Notes: Counteract Magic has felt a bit too strong against damage-over-time compositions. Paladin Avenging Crusader now properly increases the cooldown recovery rate of Judgment and Crusader Strike. Avenging Crusader no longer increases the cooldown recovery rate of Tyr's Deliverance. Priest (Discipline) Searing Light increases the damage of Smite by 15%, down from 30%. Developers’ Notes: The Discipline Priest is intended to be an offensive healer, but we feel they were over-performing in 2v2 Arena. Rogue Agility reduced by 10% in PvP. Stamina reduced by 5% in PvP. Developers’ Notes: Rogues are intended to be strong, yet vulnerable to focused-fire. We feel they have too much survivability while dealing too much damage with both utility and survivability, so we’re toning them down. (Assassination) System Shock duration reduced to 2 seconds (was 4 seconds). (Subtlety) Stamina reduced by 5% in PvP. (Assassination, Outlaw) Stamina reduced by 15% in PvP. Shaman (Enhancement) Agility reduced by 10%. Warlock (Demonology) Doom, Doubled now increases the damage of Doom by 33% in PvP situations. (Demonology) Grimoire of Synergy increases the Warlock's and Pet's damage by 30% in PvP situations. (Demonology) Implosion damage reduced by 20% in PvP situations. Warrior Bladestorm now deals full damage in PvP situations. Developers’ Notes: Bladestorm is intended to be a strong damage cooldown for the Arms Warrior. In Legion Beta testing, Arms Warriors felt too strong, so we reduced the damage Bladestorm did in PvP. We feel we’re back to a place where returning it to full damage makes sense. Execute now deals 15% more damage in PvP situations. Developers’ Notes: Execute is designed to be a signature strength of the Warrior, and should always be the right choice on targets within Execute range in PvP. We’ve found that there are some situations where that wasn’t true, so we’re increasing the damage of Execute to make it always the right choice. Quests
      Players should no longer fail to get credit for completing world boss World Quests. Players with a full inventory should now be able to complete “Edict of the God-King” and accept “Unwanted Evidence” after defeating God-King Skovald in Halls of Valor. The quest drops for “Uncovering Orders” should now come from the final boss in each of the three named dungeons, Assault on Violet Hold, Black Rook Hold, and Vault of the Wardens. World
      Bloodgazer Falcosaurs should now respawn more quickly. Previous Hotfixes.
    • By Stan
      All our class guides have been updated for Patch 7.1.
      Good news, everyone! All our class guides have been updated for Patch 7.1!
      Feedback As we strive to constantly improve our guides, constructive feedback is always welcome. Each guide has its appropriate section for feedback indicated by the comments count at its beginning. Death Knight
      Blood Frost Unholy Demon Hunter
      Havoc Vengeance Druid
      Balance Feral Guardian Restoration Hunter
      Beast Mastery Marksmanship Survival Mage
      Arcane Fire Frost Monk
      Brewmaster Mistweaver Windwalker Paladin
      Holy Protection Retribution Priest
      Discipline Holy Shadow Rogue
      Assassination Outlaw Subtlety Shaman
      Elemental Enhancement Restoration Warlock
      Affliction Demonology Destruction Warrior
      Arms Fury Protection
    • By Stan
      With Patch 7.1 releasing today, there's so much to do after maintenance!
      Karazhan Attunement
      Karazhan attunement starts with Khadgar in Dalaran. You'll have to farm a few dungeons on Mythic difficulty to get attuned.
      Edict of the God-King - Defeat God-King Skovald in Halls of Valor on Mythic difficulty. Unwanted Evidence - Bring the Fel Crystal Fragment to Archmage Khadgar in Dalaran. Uncovering Orders - Recover the Fragment of Spite from Blackrook Hold (Mythic), the Fragment of Power from Violet Hold (Mythic), and the Fragment of Torment from Vault of the Wardens (Mythic). Addon Update
      Don't forget to update your addons for the newest patch. World Boss
      Drugon the Frostblood is up this week.
      World Boss Loot Tables
      Assorted Dragonscale Bracers Drugon's Snowglobe Ettin Fingernail Ettinbone Bracers Giant's Handkerchief Snowdrift Bracers Wax-Sealed Leather Bracers Mythic+ Affixes (US)
      Sanguine, Volcanic, Fortified Mythic+ Affixes (EU)
      TBA Legion Dungeon Event
      Sign of the Warrior is active this week: The final boss of each Legion dungeon will drop an extra item. The quest can now be picked up from within the Adventure Journal. To get Cache of Nightmarish Treasures, you have to finish 4 dungeons in Mythic difficulty, which shouldn't be an issue given the Karazhan attunement. Other
      Hallow's End continues until October 28. For a complete overview, don't forget to check our Survival Guide.
    • By Stan
      Learn everything about Patch 7.1 in our own Survival Guide!
      In preparation for the 7.1 release, we've been busy working around the clock to preview everything what the new patch contains. Here's our own survival guide!
      All our class guides have been updated for Patch 7.1. Full Patch Notes are available here.
      Alt-Friendly Changes No need to be Friendly to unlock World Quests. Falcosaur Pets & Mounts A new rare breed of falcosaurs can be adopted as pets. New Adventures in the Broken Isles New pets to earn, Alcaz Isle is getting new content, hunters will be able to tame mechanospiders. Professions
      Blood of Sargeras Trader & New Profession Recipes Preview of the trader along with new recipes for your profession to pick up. Raids
      Trial of Valor New world quests, encounter previews, loot tables. Karazhan Is making a glorious return as a 5-player "raid". Encounters & loot tables. Nightbane 9th Boss Rumor has it that Karazhan will feature Nightbane as a secret boss. Quests
      Illidan's Story Illidan's story continues to unravel with two new quests. Suramar Campaign Quests Suramar is in danger and the elven races must unite for a common purpose. PvP
      PvP Reward Changes Many reward changes are coming in the latest patch. Nagrand Arena Visual Update Nagrand Arena receives a facelift. Reputations
      Talon's Vengeance Preview of the new PvP reputation in the Broken Isles, including rewards. Misc
      Action Camera Returning The Action Camera makes a glorious return!
    • By Starym
      See what your friends are up to (and queued for) and join them more easily!
      It seems we're getting even more tools to connect to each other! After the recent addition of Blizzard Voice now 7.1 brings with it another way to check out what your friends are doing and join them!
      Now, while this is a very handy tool and will certainly make life easier (and more social!) for a lot of people, it seems it only emphasizes the need for an "appear offline" or "private" option in the game, as some players don't feel like sharing absolutely everything with their friends. The latest status on that was that the feature is on the backburner, and that was two years ago.
      We’re making it even easier to find your friends and join them on their adventures through Azeroth with the addition of a Quick Join option in patch 7.1: Return to Karazahn.
      You’ll be able to quickly and easily see friends who have queued for select eligible content within your Social tab (o) in the “Quick Join” tab. You’ll also be able to recommend others by using /invite to join the group even if they aren’t already friends with the group leader. Additionally, friends won’t need to leave their queue to add you and will receive a join request that they can accept or deny for each additional member.
      What content queues will you be able to join your friends for?
      Dungeon Finder Raid Finder Premade Group Listings (once the friend has joined the group) Non-rated Battlegrounds Non-rated Arenas World PvP such as Ashran So whether it’s your guildmate, your friend, or your Real ID friend, you’ll be able to find each other and take part in a variety of game aspects without the need to ask the age old questions of– “What are you doing?” “Any room in your group?” “Can my other friend join?”  You’ll just be able to see all of your friends, see what they’re up to, and ask to join with just a couple of clicks. It’s so easy, a drogbar can do it!