Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
JohnnyZ

Dusting Old Sets

To Dust, Or Not To Dust   7 members have voted

  1. 1. Should I dust all my GvG and Naxx cards?

    • You should have done this when TOG was released!
      5
    • They will be handy to have for brawls and all the memories.
      2

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

15 posts in this topic

When TOG was released I spent my first real money on the pre-purchase and made a decision to play standard, as I didn't believe I could ever be competitive in wild. I have never since played a wild game. However, I never dusted the GvG and Naxx cards I had then. My draw from MSG was quite poor, and I still lack staple legendaries like Sylvanas Windrunner and Ragnaros the Firelord. But I love Webspinner and others. I dont really want to do without any card, but I have so many holes in my collection. Any opinions and advice would be appreciated.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm in the same boat. I never play wild, but I still have Naxx and a good amount of GVG cards.  They do come in handy for the occasional tavern brawl. But other than that, Im really thinking the dust would be worth it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I really could use the dust, but I am Loath(eb) to dust them. But what else am I going to do with them?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Why no wild though? Wild is more fun than standard. Pirate warriors are a joke (thank you, Deathlord) and the diversity is much better. 

If you REALLY don't want to play wild, dusting it depends on how much you want to have the cards in your collection - how sentimental you are. If you are not sentimental, just dust them. If you are, keep them. Nobody knows better than you do.

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
8 minutes ago, positiv2 said:

Why no wild though? Wild is more fun than standard. Pirate warriors are a joke (thank you, Deathlord) and the diversity is much better. 

Good question. I guess I just thought that there are so many more holes to fill if I were to play wild, and with TGT rotating out early next year then I will be closer to having a complete standard set. Is it more fun though? Right now I am having heaps of fun trying to turn out a 30/30 Jade Golum and buffing minions in my Grimy hands, even without Don Han'Cho.

Edited by JohnnyZ

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In wild you can do everything that you can do in standard, but with more cards available! And it's not like you can't revert back to standard. However, if you go full standard, you can't go back to wild. Also, what good is complete standard set if you use only one fifth of it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

you make some interesting arguments. It's probably enough to keep me from dusting them all for right now. At least I know they'll be there for when I am drunk, impulsive, uninhibited, and I've decided I need Sergeant Sally.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

personally I dusted everything that rotated out as soon as standard was announced (yes even before it released).

The reason I decided not to play wild is because I know whats going to happen in the future. This is actually something almost all trading card games end up at. What is going to happen is there will be insane combos at some point. if you can fill a deck with 4 different ways to win before turn 3 it's not fun to play anymore. Hearthstone isn't at this point yet. but give it a few years. when hundreds of new cards are released there's bound to be something that will break the game in wild. This is the whole reason they implemented standard in the first place.

I have to say I do miss certain cards. I'm not even talking about tavern brawls here, I'm just talking about heroic bosses in adventures

I still didn't get some bosses because the only decks that really do work require cards I haven't had in a long time. I'm not about to craft 4 wild epics any time soon so I'm probably going to be stuck on those for a while.

Even without legendaries just disenchanting all your common and rare cards should already yield enough dust or 1-2 legendaries. maybe you could look into that. if you ever do need a common card for something it's not that expensive to craft.

 

in any case, do what you feel is right and live with the consequences.

Also, I'm missing a 'yes you should' option in your poll

Edited by Shine

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
44 minutes ago, Shine said:

Also, I'm missing a 'yes you should' option in your poll

Thanks for your input. I'm gonna sit the fence a bit longer I think, but all this will help me finally decide at some point in the future. the first option is the yes you should option. I was trying to be clever. guess thats not working out too well for me either. :P

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I say dust most of them but keep some things like Kel'thuzad and Baron Rivendare and the like that you think you might want for future adventure content. Yeah, there's no real way of knowing what you might want for future adventures because there's no way of knowing what they'll be like, but I feel like you can make some safe assumptions. Look at Naxx, for example.

You can probably do without Maexxna, Feugen, and Stalagg for sure. None of them really bring anything irreplaceable to the table. Loatheb is a bit iffier. He's a powerhouse in Wild and you might want him in a Tavern Brawl, but if you don't care about Wild and ignore Tavern Brawl past the free pack he's probably also safe to dust as far as adventure content goes.

Kel'thuzad, though, he's the kind of card that can wind up being the centerpiece of an boss-specific deck. Same for Rivendare.  So I'd dust Loatheb/Stalagg/Feugen/Maexxna and keep Rivendare and Kel'thuzad. 

And personally I prefer Standard over Wild because as the game gets older too many stupid synergies will develop and decks will get more and more gimmicky. I also like the fact that shit will rotate out eventually. I don't want to be dropping Deathlords every game until they release Deathlord+1.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
21 hours ago, JohnnyZ said:

Thanks for your input. I'm gonna sit the fence a bit longer I think, but all this will help me finally decide at some point in the future. the first option is the yes you should option. I was trying to be clever. guess thats not working out too well for me either. :P

I guess it's more of a 'yes you should' than the other option at least. you should have don't it back then indeed because they were worth more dust then. but there's simply nothing you can do about that now. so just decide for yourself what to keep and what to dust.

2 hours ago, Nazihk said:

I say dust most of them but keep some things like Kel'thuzad and Baron Rivendare and the like that you think you might want for future adventure content. Yeah, there's no real way of knowing what you might want for future adventures because there's no way of knowing what they'll be like, but I feel like you can make some safe assumptions. Look at Naxx, for example.

You can probably do without Maexxna, Feugen, and Stalagg for sure. None of them really bring anything irreplaceable to the table. Loatheb is a bit iffier. He's a powerhouse in Wild and you might want him in a Tavern Brawl, but if you don't care about Wild and ignore Tavern Brawl past the free pack he's probably also safe to dust as far as adventure content goes.

Kel'thuzad, though, he's the kind of card that can wind up being the centerpiece of an boss-specific deck. Same for Rivendare.  So I'd dust Loatheb/Stalagg/Feugen/Maexxna and keep Rivendare and Kel'thuzad. 

And personally I prefer Standard over Wild because as the game gets older too many stupid synergies will develop and decks will get more and more gimmicky. I also like the fact that shit will rotate out eventually. I don't want to be dropping Deathlords every game until they release Deathlord+1.

besides legendaries: deathlord is a must keep in some heroic boss fights, same goes for sludge belcher. piloted shredder is also a very strong card in brawls (like the current one - double deathrattles) and some bosses. theres probably some more common/rare cards worth keeping but those stand out the most.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I dust the old expansions and adventures. Except for the really strong cards. You need them in boss fights just like the poster above me mentioned. 

Edited by Aexra

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I kept them, not just for the brawls, boss fights or even wild. (mostly for wild though) I kept them because I am a collector and as such I would one day like to have 100% of all cards made. Right now I'm sitting on roughly 85%-90%. I'm not going to be much help with your decision though because I see both sides of the argument. 

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dusted them here. I'm not a fan of Wild at all. There are cards in there that I just don't want to have to deal with. The way I see it:

I don't like some cards in Standard. I don't like some cards in Wild. Might as well only deal with half of the ones I don't like! :D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Moos
      Hey,
      are there any viable crating options in the game besides the ones Kanai's Cube? Should I do anything at the blacksmith or jewelery crafter? I have used the extract legendary power recipie, change set item, upgrade rare and change gem recipe in the cube, are there any other good ones? I have so many of the crafting ingridients (other then Deaths Breath), that I would love to do something with them..
    • By internallydeluded
      I can no longer say I'm new just not great at building decks. Those on this site have helped me greatly as well as the arena guides. In any case I'm going to have saved enough dust to craft a legendary soon. I dusted all the cards that went the way of the wild and was able to craft Sylvanas and ysera. Other notable legendaries I've been lucky enough to open are happy rag Tyrion and the shaman wind lord aliakbar or whatever. Because of that I focused on shaman for a while but since I'm not great with Aggro I can't really hit top ranks with it. Priest was my other focus but by the time I got ysera it seems like dragon priest is no longer as strong as it may have once been. I've found I'm best with control and midrange decks. The highest I've made it on the ladder is rank 8 with the midrange shaman deck on this site and dragon priest.  Generally I hover somewhere between 12-15. I was trying to decide between Nzgoth or the twin Cthun guy to have the final piece for a priest Cthun deck and to get closer to Cthun Druid and warrior but some googling tells me maybe I should go with ragnaros. I'd also like to experiment with Nzgoth because of my Sylvanas and Tyrion and also the hunter bug death rattle rare I got that automatically triggers a death rattle. I've got all the adventures so I also have those cards available.  I'm missing critical epic cards to effectively play warrior and rogue and I'm not very good with rogue although I do have bloodmage. I do like playing Mage as well but haven't had a ton of experience with it or paladin but since opening Tyrion would really like to give paladin more love. Any suggestions? I'd really like to get a strong ladder deck going. 
    • By Twily
      So I've been trying to get through the heroic mode of Naxxramas lately. One thing I've noticed is, that its pretty hard to beat the heroic bosses without the Naxxramas cards. I'm currently stuck at Thaddius & pretty much every guide I saw, tells me to put Feugen & Stalagg into my deck. Sadly I've dusted all my wild cards when Wotog launched. Is it even possible to win against the Heroic Thaddius without any Naxx cards? Because as it seems Feugen & Stalagg are your only win condition in this match.
      I'd really appreciate some help. :<
      Btw. I know that freeze mage works, but I don't have all the cards for it.
    • By Sepums
      Sorry for such a bad first post.
      I am a fairly mediocre player who hasn't bought any adventures yet but is eager to, and while I see that loe might be the adventure most worth purchasing for now, I am still interested in buying naxx and brm.
      The thing is, with the new way to play coming to hearthstone, seeing that naxx cards will become craftable (correct me if I'm wrong?) I don't exactly need to buy naxx to get the good cards that I want it for.
      So, is it worth buying naxxramas for the experience of the adventure, and not having to grind dust for the cards? or should I just ignore naxx (in addition to gvg) and just stick to standard when it comes out?
      I feel okay since I haven't spent any money on the game so far and I know that I can simply ignore wild and stick to standard, but wild seems more fun at the moment with all the decks that I have seen but never was able to play because I didn't buy any adventures.
      As many people have already stated, we will still need to collect various cards from current and later expansions for standard, and cards from current adventures/expansions will become obsolete as time goes, so I just don't know how I'm supposed to deal with this.
      I don't understand the direction with the new way to play, it doesn't make much sense to me.
    • By Valkyr
      Hey, with the community buzzing with the latest format news, I bet it has shaken up many people's crafting, disenchanting, pack buying and gold amassing strategy. So wondering what strategy are people following? I guessing it would depend on if you plan on which format you want to play in (or if you wanna play both). 
       
      Edit: thought I'd mention some strategies I was contemplating. 
       
      1. Collect all your gold and dust for update and then see whats what. May result in the next two months to be a bit boring and stagnant.
       
      2. spend gold on classic since that will remain no matter what. Any cards you get which end up being nerfed will be equal to free dust for crafting (either from classic or new set)
       
      3. Save gold and dust for new expansion even though it will retire in 2 years.
       
      4. Spend gold on GvG to complete collection or get that particular card for Wild instead of having to craft it.
       
      5. Get TgT since it will become relevant past update.
       
      What are you all thinking?