Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
EvilCalamari

Why do we use arcane blast only >93% ?

7 posts in this topic

Is there some mathematical significance to 93% specifically? Does the percentage increase as we increase mastery?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Arcane is a mathematical clusterfuck to model properly. You need really, really complex shit, so really, the answer is "because math says it's optimal".

 

This is a thread from EJ with the math i'm talking about (Markov chains), back when we found out about Arcane's mastery: http://forums.elitistjerks.com/topic/39999-mathematics-of-dynamic-cycles/. Have fun! xD

2 people like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Leo is spot on. Arcane is fucked up so simcraft is the only reason we play as we play.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A simpler explanation of why:

 

http://altered-time.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=972

 

Many popular Arcane Mage guides have the following line in their rotation description:
Cast Arcane Blast, if you are above 93% Mana before your start casting.
The same logic can be found in SimulationCraft's Arcane Mage APL:
arcane_blast,if=buff.arcane_charge.stack=4&mana.pct>93
This has lead to people asking where the 93% "magical number" came from, which I plan to address in this thread.
 
The TL;DR answer is "Using ABar instead of AB at >=93% mana leads to wasted mana". Technically speak, 93% isn't completely on-point, because it's a rounded number. The exact number is actually closer to 92.78% for non Arcane Orb users.
 
Here is a spreadsheet of how an Arcane Mage's mana fluctuates as you dump Arcane Charges and rebuild. As seen in the first section, the highest mana level (highlighted in green) is observed just before you finish casting the second Arcane Blast (AB1, which stands for Arcane Blast with 1 Arcane Charge).
1dccb206ceb411cbaae6c5e9a863130a.png
What this means is that if you cast Arcane Barrage at any point above 92.78% mana, you will reach 100% mana when rebuilding Arcane Charges. This means wasted mana. Another way to look at this is any excess mana above 92.78% when casting Arcane Barrage is wasted, because you're already at the highest level of mana possible after rebuilding Arcane Charges.
 
Note that due to Nether Attunement, the spreadsheet applies to all Arcane Mages regardless of haste levels. The numbers are determined by player regen %, base mana costs and the effect of Arcane Charges, not by any character statistic such as haste or mastery.
 
How does Arcane Orb change things? By shortcutting the first 2 Arcane Charges, the player can now stay at a slightly higher mana level before casting Arcane Barrage. But as you see in the spreadsheet, the difference is very small; 93% is still a valid number.
 
The current metagame for Arcane Mage DPS can be interpreted as "Cast as many Arcane Blasts at 4 Arcane Charges as possible". To do this, you want to be efficient with your regen, stay close to maximum mana, while casting the maximum amount on 4 Arcane Charge spells. This is why we avoid mana capping - wasting regen leads to a lower amount of "excess" that can be spent on AB4s.
 
In SimulationCraft, "93%" was chosen not only by spreadsheet analysis, but also through trial-and-error. After experimenting with numbers between 90-95%, it was chosen because it offered the best results.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So most of the time i have 89-ish% mana when i want to cast AB but I'm not at 93% (or 92,78) before the cast goes through.

I recorded it and it seems that I'm at 92,409-92,484%. Does that mean I should have used arcane barrage when i was at 89-ish% mana? Isn't it more worthy to keep 4 stacks of arcane charge and ignore the 0,38% loss?

Edited by causevha

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Fenodoree
      Hi everyone. I've a question, What spect should we roll for 7.1.5?
      So patch notes for 7.1.5 (November the 29th) are out.
      And I have 2 things to remark
      1.Strong buff to Arcane Mana cost for Arcane Blast has been reduced from 125% to 60% per Arcane Charge, since they are mana dependent. This does not apply It Was a tooltip bug.
      2.Almost all fire skills were buffed in damage, Fireball,Flame Blast, PyroBlast, Scorch, FlameStrike, CinderStorm,Meteor,Conflag and Phoenix's Flames. BUT Critical Mass % was reduced from 15% to 10% and Pyretic Incantation was nerfed from 5% per stack  to 2% per stack = 15%  less damage from consecutive Critical Strikes.
      I haven't done the math yet, but since Arcane has gotten a lot of buffs lately, and Fire is getting "balanced" (Since i've no idea how the patch will afect fire dps), and Frost Topping dps in rankings, and with no significant buffs or nerfs in the patch notes i suppose they will stay in tops.
      So if anyone would be so kind to enlighten me what spect you guys think it would be the best for 7.1.5 and why.
       
       
       
       
       
       
    • By Flux
      Hi,
      Enjoying arcane alot right now. On the guide on the site (thumbs up for the fast update of the stat priority btw!) usage of Nether Tempest is not mentioned in the opening sequence or the burn phase. Do you apply NT in the burn phase so it can profit from Arcane Power and the Rune or before? According to my own testing, on single target, with 4 Stacks, NT does about the same damage as AB but only uses a GCD, so it should be worth using it with Rune/AP right? 
      btw: What about Mark of Aluneth? In the guide the opening sequence says you should apply it BEFORE Rune/AP, but i don't see the point here aswell, why not use it WITH Rune/AP?
      Maybe NT is worth bcs it can procc Arcane Missiles? The guide says that you can refresh it on 4- seconds left. Why not let it run out? Am I wrong when i say that only the inital cast can procc AM? In this case we should let it run out right?
    • By wsaedmd
      Hello everyone! First of all, thanks a bunch for your awesome guides, I don't know where I would be on my mage or on my shammy main without them :) Secondly, I see that most guides don't yet reflect the changes that the recent nerfs and buffs brought along, so I wanted to ask here about the actual viability of Arcane in a raid environment as of right now. I used to play fire, but I really really didn't like it, and I'd love the possibility to switch to arcane without having to give up my spot :)
    • By Batraaf
      Hello, 
      I was wondering wich mage spec is the best pve spec.
      I've ask a couple of people and in general fire mage is the spec to go they say, but there were also some who said that arcane and frost get some major buffs on the hotfix wednesday, so now I don't know wich spec to choose.
      Can anyone help me with this issue?
    • By krochlikmiov
      This change is going to change a lot of what is currently listed on Icy Veins - Namely stat weights, and BiS listings. I wanted to hear peoples opinions, theory crafting and any other useful input on the upcoming changes. If anyone is able to math this baby up to get some new stat weights for example, that'd save me a headache.