FranciscoSamuelSilva, on 04 November 2012 - 04:38 PM, said:
This is my first post here but I've been an every-day visitor for some time now. I love the guides and I read them over and over, especially the Holy Paladin one.
This thread is (also) about leaving feedback on the guides so I think I will leave mine. I hope it doesn't get lost.
Since Mysts of Pandaria is all about dailies I think it would be nice to have a guide containing the gear that can be obtained from farming reputation with each faction. Sure the Gearing Up and Best in Slot section on the Class/Spec guides contain all these items cleary identified but for a player starting to farm reputation after dinging 90 it's a little hard to pick which factions are worth spending time grinding reputation ASAP and which can be left for later.
As for the Holy Paladin guide, I don't know if similar situations occur in other classes but I personally think that items without Spirit, such as Paleblade Shoulderguards
should not be part of the Gearing Up and Best in Slot section.
Thank you for this. We're going to fix it
Sorry, it was my mistake to assume the item you linked in the last part of your post was in the BiS section of the Holy Paladin guide. It doesn't belong there, since Spirit is so valuable. But it's merely listed in the gearing up section - even though it's generally poorly itemised for Holy Paladins, it is STILL a Holy Paladin item (and exclusively so, I might say), so it does belong there.
Regarding your first question, we believe that it's fairly well done as it is, although it does require a bit of looking up to see what comes from Valor Points/faction rewards. That said, we're going to look into ways of improving it