Help to choose weapon (2 replies to this topic)

Hi, i recently got two Claws of Shek'zeer and yesterday i got Gara'kal, Fist of the Spiritbinder .  I asked to many peoples if I should keep my two claws of sheekzer from LFR or if I should replace one of them with the 489 ilvl fist.  Seems that keeping the two claws is the solution that is the most popular but i am not sure.

Which ones of the 3 should i use?

Since you have *two* claws you might consider using MH Claws and OH Fist. Reason being that the extra DPS from the fist translates into harder hitting Lava Lash (good). If you keep the MH claws with the Sha gem and reforge according to Ask Mr Robot, you'll probably end up better.

Here are some simulation results with the Enhancement Shaman T14N profile in simc ( Enchant Weapon - Dancing Steel on both weapons and Crystallized Dread on one of the Sha-touched weapons)

• 2x Claws of Shek'zeer: 101648.1 DPS (+/- 43.8 DPS)
  
• MH Gara'kal, Fist of the Spiritbinder and OH Claws of Shek'zeer: 101919.4 DPS (+/- 44.5 DPS)
  
• MH Claws of Shek'zeer and OH Gara'kal, Fist of the Spiritbinder: 101856.6 DPS (+/- 44.3 DPS)

As you can see, there is very little difference between the various possibilities.