Krazyito

Bear tanking Stone Guard

29 posts in this topic

So the only fight I have to tank for my raid is Stone Guard. I am an off tank that only handles one guardian at a time. I am fairly certain that we will unlock heroics this week and have some attempts next week so I want to be ready.

So I have a few questions about gearing/reforging/gemming. For that specific fight mastery is useless because of the bleed effect they put, correct? The same goes for dodge because I don't think I can dodge that bleed enough to make a difference.

So correct me if I'm wrong, but most of my survivablilty will come form using Frenzied Regen and gaining as much rage as I can, which entails me getting hit/exp capped OR gaining more crit, or both with proper gear. How would you go about gemming for example? should I put more agi? More stam? Stam/crit? Stam/Agi?

Lastly, what potion should I use? Since bleeds ignore armor should I just use an Agility one? Same with flask. I've been using Stam for now.

I think though, the biggest thing I'll need is Stamina, since I wont get very much raid loot for my Off-spec until our rogues/feral's get it for main spec. So I'll just be getting loot from dungeons/valor/JP. (LFR I still need healing gear). Though that should suffice for the first heroic boss of this tier

Your thoughts?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So the only fight I have to tank for my raid is Stone Guard. I am an off tank that only handles one guardian at a time. I am fairly certain that we will unlock heroics this week and have some attempts next week so I want to be ready.

So I have a few questions about gearing/reforging/gemming. For that specific fight mastery is useless because of the bleed effect they put, correct? The same goes for dodge because I don't think I can dodge that bleed enough to make a difference.

So correct me if I'm wrong, but most of my survivablilty will come form using Frenzied Regen and gaining as much rage as I can, which entails me getting hit/exp capped OR gaining more crit, or both with proper gear. How would you go about gemming for example? should I put more agi? More stam? Stam/crit? Stam/Agi?

Lastly, what potion should I use? Since bleeds ignore armor should I just use an Agility one? Same with flask. I've been using Stam for now.

I think though, the biggest thing I'll need is Stamina, since I wont get very much raid loot for my Off-spec until our rogues/feral's get it for main spec. So I'll just be getting loot from dungeons/valor/JP. (LFR I still need healing gear). Though that should suffice for the first heroic boss of this tier

Your thoughts?

My thoughts are bear tanks for this fight are over powered, aka being Vengence and my guild's bear tank being Top 3 on in our 25 man group! ITS CRAZY! I also wish your guild best of luck! My guild just hit 4/6 last night! woot woot! Edited by Clisis

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well, our paladin is our main tank for our raid and I'm just off-speccing tank. I'm trying to figure out what gear and how I should reforge/gem for this specific fight.

I think I'm going to go with a crit/hit/expertise build to generate tons of rage for FR spamming.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi, my main spec is guardian tank. You are correct in thinking you cannot dodge the bleed and the bleed will be your main damage source . Ignore dodge for this fight. Also since you say you only will be tanking the 1 guard, your dps will be nullified by his shield so ignore agility as a stat as well for this specific fight . What you want to do is make sure you have a lot of stamina and secondary stat is mastery as a steady passive armor buff. You should use hybrid gems to match socket colurs with a hybrid stamina + hit/crit/expertise gem. Basically all you have to do is be the biggest sponge to soak up damage you can be. This strategy is especially true if your goal is heroic stone guard. Use stamina trinkets (even the brewfest one is fine regardless of the weak on use ability).

When using the basic rotation mangle, lacerate, trash, lacerate (6 sec rotation) you should have enough rage to cast frenzied regen (also lasting 6 seconds).

Symbiosis on a rogue will help you defend againd some of the aoe abilities from the traps,

Edited by stitcherr

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You say to have a lot of mastery, but I was to my understanding that bleeds ignore armor. Am I correct in that? or is the stone guard bleed a special case?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You say to have a lot of mastery, but I was to my understanding that bleeds ignore armor. Am I correct in that? or is the stone guard bleed a special case?

The bleed hits for its full amount, I just double checked World of Logs on my personal fights to make sure. Mastery in my opinion is still a good secondary stat because of the other sources of damage you have to endure. I took 66% of my damage from the bleed and 26 % from melee atacks. If you look at the leather gear, youll find a lot of pieces that have the preferred combination of crit and mastery (the crafted pieces are fine examples). Reforging mastery to hit/expertise on those items should make you a more stable tank to heal instead of going for full leather dps gear focussing on hit or expertise (often combined with haste) without mastery for adittional incoming damage.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well, I'm stuck with what ever gear I have right now. I haven't really tried to pick up specific pieces but yes, I was gonna try for more crit/mastery gear anyway. I thought when you were talking about mastery you meant gemming.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just a few things I've found helpful. First of all more mastery (armour) is good yes but on this fight say you're taking on average 50k dps from the bleed. You manage to go all in mastery and get 6k more mastery than you currently have! (This is probably really high) With 6k more mastery you get about 3% less physical damage taken...

Damage Taken: 50000dps

Decrease in Damage Taken: 1500dps

New Damage Taken: 48500 dps

You`re going to take 1500 less dps for 6k off stats!!!!

Now let`s look at 6k more say... crit.

Around 36% crit you need about 580 rating for one crit out of bear... in bear you only need 387!

Therefore 6000 rating gives 15% crit!!!

Ok this is a little over the top but you get the idea... you`re looking at 1% crit for every 100dps less you take... think of all the rage.

If you want to work out you`re stat weights and how much rage/sec you're getting I have a ton of stuff posted at http://theetova.blogspot.ca/

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So you are telling me, bleeds do not ignore armor? that with more mastery, I'm taking less damage over all?

Please correct me if I'm wrong but, it was to my understanding that since the rend debuff is a bleed, my mastery is useless against that.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Physical damage bleeds do not ignore armour. I'm still trying to confirm but I've looked at a number of logs and no where do I see any tank taking the 85k ticks that the ingame dungeon journal says. Granted though I'm seeing tanks taking ~62-65k ticks when we have about -58% damage reduction from 93s.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Physical damage bleeds do not ignore armour. I'm still trying to confirm but I've looked at a number of logs and no where do I see any tank taking the 85k ticks that the ingame dungeon journal says. Granted though I'm seeing tanks taking ~62-65k ticks when we have about -58% damage reduction from 93s.

I don't know, testing it would require time tho, I know for a fact that during the dungeon Mogu Palace, as a bear tank i bearly (hahaha) take much damage, yet the final pack of mobs (The four statues in front of boss) literally tears me up if the healer is not prepared, which usually they do not expect unless they are used to the bleeds being insane at that part.

Guess one can easily test it out in that dungeon since the bleeds work the same.

Edited by Sneakyferret

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Either way, putting your stats into RPS generating stats is going to give you a lot more HPS from FR then the amount that you would mitigate from armour (from mastery). It just takes way too much rating (about 2k) to get 1% less damage taken.

This goes further to why I personally <3 stam. You can never go wrong being fat! Take a little more damage, get sweet healers and heal yourself for more with FR because you have that higher RPS.

Everything is so subjective, like I've said play smart, play bear.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My guild jsut started doing HM attempts for this fight this week and i was lookign at the dmg taken and i am taking way more rend damage over our other 2 tanks is this correct? Also is there any more info on if stacking more mastery for this fight would help with the rend bleed dmg?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I noticed at first I was taking quite a bit more damage too but I'm usually the one tanking two in ten man. I really found it helpful to go all in rage per second and be another healer. This week I did almost 40k HPS. It wasn't even the amount of healing it was the fact they were all instant and under my control.

Here is a video of this weeks kill from my PoV

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Im in a 25man guild and im only tanking 1 of the dogs, our dk tank is actually the one tanking 2 but that really doesnt matter since you only have 1 rend bleed on you. It just seems that it ticks harder on a guardian druid than both our dk and monk tanks. Now can u explain all in rage per sec im just a OT, im mostly feral kitty only tank when we need that 3rd tank for fights. And ty for all the info you have given so far its really helpful for me since i focus more on the dps side of the druid than tanking.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The biggest reason that you'll see you taking more bleed damage is the monk has stagger (part of the bleed damage is taken over time so it will show up under stagger and not bleed damage) and the dk has the absorbs from their mastery (blood shield I believe it's called).

As for rage per second, it's just how much rage you generate to use on FR specifically for Stone Guards. The more rage you can generate the more healing you can do. Further, this is why crit becomes so important. First we get 15 extra rage from crits with melees and mangles (which is more than double the base rage for a hit) and we get 50% more crit rating in bear form.

Example:

Say you have 5 RPS

It will take you 12 seconds to get 60 rage (the best time to use a FR)

If you can double the amount of rage you generate

You have 10 RPS

Taking only 6 second to get a full FR

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@tova, been checking your blogspot. What your posting on rage stats over more classic mitigation states makes sense. The sheet on rage over time needed for maximum uptime for example, helpful. Do you or anyone else have a link for calculator for bear rps? Been searching my ass, checking internet sites for a calcualtor off with no luck. I'm very curious to see the actual numbers based on the input of actual stats to see how close I am to the required rage generation per second without having to reforge/gem/enchant my acual gear to find out.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Tova thanks for the input i was able to stay alive alot better last night which helped us in downing this fight, reforging things to crit to help generate more rage helped a ton. Once again much apreciated Posted Image .

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@stitcherr if you have a Google account you can save my spreadsheet as your own and change numbers. I've highlighted the cells in green that you need to change based on your character. All the numbers should update for you.

Very happy to help Wayguard.

The only thing I noticed with your logs Krazy is your aveage FR was only about 140k. You were just tanking one correct? If so that's why this might be a bit low. The other reason would be using it too much before 60 rage. Second 29% overheal! I didn't do much better but I'm shooting to get my overhealing down.

Edited by Tova

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The only thing I noticed with your logs Krazy is your aveage FR was only about 140k. You were just tanking one correct? If so that's why this might be a bit low. The other reason would be using it too much before 60 rage. Second 29% overheal! I didn't do much better but I'm shooting to get my overhealing down.

Yea I just kinda spammed it a bit mindlessly sometimes, especially when I was sub 50%~. with FR being off the GCD, its pretty easy to spam... lol

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I definitely do the same thing, have to get back into the old school healing mind set :P

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So more news from the world of bear. Not much discussion has gone on about FR and glyphed or not so, mostly to the credit to thefool808 on EJ, here's some more info.

Glyph or Unglyphed FR, That Is The Question

From TheFool808 on EJ

total healing = t, FR healing percent = p

t*p = (t - t*p)* .4

p = .4 - .4p

1.4p = .4

p = .4/1.4

p = 28.57%

Essentially we're looking at about >28.57% of our healing Unglyphed is better.

Note in the blog post I extended it to account for your RPS if you're interested in seeing that.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Oops should have posted that in the other bear thread, sorry for double posting here and there.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Did you manage to positively confirm if Rend Flesh is mitigated by armor?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • Druid Cheap Standard
      By Damien
      This thread is for comments about our Druid Cheap Standard deck.
    • Legendary Ramp Druid Standard
      By Damien
      This thread is for comments about our Legendary Ramp Druid Standard deck.
    • Research Survey For College Student
      By collegechic
      Hello,
       
      I am a college student studying communications. I am currently taking a communications theory class and I need some help! I am writing a case study on WoW using symbolic interactionism to understand realism and relationships inside of WoW. If you could take my short 12 question survey it would be a HUGE help. I am trying to get more players of the game to make my results more diverse. As well I hope to compare the answers from non-players to players. Thank you so much to whoever helps out!! 
       
      https://www.surveymonkey.com/r/LKHFPZ5
       
    • Low Budget Druid Beast Midrange Standard
      By Damien
      This thread is for comments about our Low Budget Druid Beast Midrange Standard deck.
    • Legendary Druid Beast Midrange Standard
      By Damien
      This thread is for comments about our Legendary Druid Beast Midrange Standard deck.