Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Zadina

wow Report from the Nostalrius and Blizzard Meeting

10 posts in this topic

20775-meeting-between-nostalrius-and-bli

The much anticipated meeting between Nostalrius and Blizzard took place last Friday and earlier today Nostalrius posted a report about it.

We already knew that Nostalrius and Blizzard were going to meet in the beginning of June, but we didn't know exactly when for security reasons. It turns out this meeting happened on Friday 3rd of June. Bear in mind that Blizzard also recently met with Mark Kern, another advocate of legacy servers.

From their part, Nostalrius posted an extensive report of this meeting; they were free to do so, since apparently they didn't have to sign an NDA. The staff of Nostalrius had prepared a very detailed presentation on their project, technical details and information about legacy servers in general and how popular they are. A lot of important Blizzard and World of Warcraft executives were present, like CEO Mike Morhaime, WoW Executive Producer J. Allen Brack and WoW Assistant Game Director Ion Hazzikostas. This shows how seriously Blizzard is taking this issue.

Nostalrius also commended Blizzard on their dedication and their interest in legacy servers. It is definite that Blizzard wants legacy servers, but things aren't that simple and they can certainly not be resolved in a single meeting! The technical details are the most important issue hindering the launch of legacy servers at the moment. Blizzard actually has the notorious vanilla source code, but the main problem is the following:

Quote

However, in order to generate the server (and the client), a complex build system is being used. It is not just about generating the “WoW.exe” and “Server.exe” files. The build process takes data, models, maps, etc. created by Blizzard and also generates client and server specific files. The client only has the information it needs and the server only has the information that it needs.

This means that before re-launching vanilla realms, all of the data needed for the build processes has to be gathered in one place with the code. Not all of this information was under a version control system. In the end, whichever of these parts were lost at any point, they will have to be recreated: this is likely to take a lot of resources through a long development process.

You can read the entire meeting report by Nostalrius here.

The community has taken this news extremely well and it's certainly a first step towards realising legacy realms in the live and official version of the game. A lot of people seem to think that Blizzard is going to announce legacy servers during this year's BlizzCon and honestly this is a very likely scenario. What do you guys think?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Nostralrius confuses me. This is a waste of resources on Blizzard's part.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Most of the people I know played on Private Servers because they are free. 

I highly doubt those people would pay subscription fee every month to play on a blizzard legacy server.

And because of the amount of work needed to build a legacy server as they mentioned, blizzard is not going to make the servers free to play. So I think if they run it, it's going to be a dead server.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, mnime said:

Most of the people I know played on Private Servers because they are free. 

I highly doubt those people would pay subscription fee every month to play on a blizzard legacy server.

And because of the amount of work needed to build a legacy server as they mentioned, blizzard is not going to make the servers free to play. So I think if they run it, it's going to be a dead server.

Its the playing for free on these private servers that make people to join them. If you have to pay for it to play, I doubt there will be any large population on those servers. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've looked at some youtube videos where they did a retrospective of how the legacy raids were. There were 2 concerning things that stood out:

1.Limited Debuffs mechanic.

Vanilla bosses had limited debuff slots (I think it was something like 10).

You will have 7 classes that places DoTs on their target as part of their dps rotation, and you also have classes that apply other status effects like Slow or reduce % armor. Now if the boss's debuff slots are full, the newly applied debuff will replace one of the slots. How would the feral druids, affliction locks, rogues and priests feel?

2.REQUIRED raid composition.

From Vanilla to Wrath of the Lich King, certain bosses where SOOO difficult, that they REQUIRED you to stack certain specs to even defeat them.

Frost Mages were for some reason (shrug) able to Freeze Ragnaros via one of their talents, then the next Frost mage spell were able to Shatter (Crit) of that freeze. Raid comps were made up of 75% frost mages so other classes won't override their chilling effect and benefit the most out of shatter.

People were required to have leatherworking just to chain use the Bloodlust drums (no Sated / Temp Displacement debuffs).

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Biggest problem is that you would have to move people who are involved in developing patches, next expansions and games would have to be moved to make the Legacy servers. I see no point in that, the only solution is letting Nostalrius getting their servers back, or hire them for blizzard to do the Legacys's. People don't realize how boring the game was, demanding but boring, comparing it to the WoW we have today.  The things Archimage pointed out destroy the gameplay too and if Nostalrius wasn't for free, I'm not sure if anyone would play that, maybe only RP servers.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Even though I would like to see legacy servers back, I do agree that some aspects of Vanilla were literally unplayable/super annoying (some of them were mentioned above). I know this is an unpopular opinion, but I truly believe LFG for dungeons (not LFR) was actually a good thing. Remember how fun (not) it was to spam for a tank in trade chat for at least an hour?

I do believe people are going to play in the legacy servers when there's a period with no content on live servers, but at some point they will eventually run out of things to do there as well. The issue of whether a subscription is required to play in these legacy servers is also very important.

Even though I'm quite curious to see how vanilla WoW looked like (I started playing in late TBC), I truly believe the best kind of legacy server would be wotlk. The game was very polished back then, didn't have some of the stupidities of vanilla or tbc, it was accessible to more people but not everyone, it had great PvE content and relatively balanced PvP.

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted (edited)

Regardless of what comes out of all this, I hope the community understands that Blizzard does listen and care about the community.  Everyone makes fun of the quote "You think you do, but you don't"  and they may have believed that at one time.. but people can be convinced and admit that they where wrong while listening to feedback.  That is clearly the case here and I believe that if Blizzard could "Flip a Switch" and turn on Legacy Servers.. then they would.  The blue posts have all been completely honest in their responses and I hope people see that.

Edited by Fenderxx

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
17 hours ago, Archimage said:

How would the feral druids, affliction locks, rogues and priests feel?

 

 

 

Feral druids and shadow priests dont have any raid slot in the "wonderfull" vanila, priest, druid, shaman and paladin was only acepted in raids as healers. Warriors was the only class to main tank raids too 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would pay subscription for each Vanila / TBC / WOTLK Legacy servers if they get them back.

You lunch costs as monthly subscription. Skip it once and you will be able to pay it.

Now you can pay with gold to play. If they implement same system (when gold was hardly obtained) you will have no problem playing it for free.

I hope there will be release date announcement on blizzcon this year. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Stan
      A new developer Q/A with Game Director Ion Hazzikostas is scheduled for December 7. You can submit your questions either via forums or Twitter using the hashtag #LegionQA.
      All questions will be answered live on Twitch.
      Blizzard Entertainment
      Join us live on Twitch Wednesday, December 7, as we sit down with Game Director Ion Hazzikostas for our next live developer Q&A. He’ll be answering many of your World of Warcraft questions.
      Feel free to submit any World of Warcraft questions by posting in this forum thread or via Twitter using the hashtag #LegionQA.
      We’re really looking forward to getting the chance to dive in and answer as much as we can, so we hope to see you Wednesday at 10:00 a.m. PST!
      (Source)
      We'll bring you the highlights once the Q/A comes to a close as we did last time, after the post-BlizzCon Q/A.
    • By Stan
      Mischief has been added to the Battle.net Shop and is now available for purchase for $10. 100% of the proceeds are donated to Make-A-Wish. A plush version of the pet can be purchased in the Gear Store for $25.
      The pet was supposed to be live yesterday, but got delayed.
      Blizzard Entertainment
      This holiday season, warm your hearth with a fuzzy little ball of fel fire. Meet Mischief, a curious kitten who followed the Burning Legion into Azeroth and is now looking for an Order Hall to call home.
      This new World of Warcraft® in-game pet is up for adoption now in the in-game Shop and the Battle.net Shop, with a plush companion available in the Gear Store—and for a limited time, when you purchase either one, you’ll be helping a great cause in the process.
      Mischief In-Game Pet
      Starting now until December 31, 2016, when you adopt the in-game version of Mischief, 100% of the purchase price ($10 in the US; pricing varies by region) will be donated to Make-A-Wish, helping give wish kids across the globe strength and courage as they fight their illnesses. 
      BUY NOW
      Mischief Plush
      If you’re looking for a fel feline to cuddle IRL (that won’t leave scorch marks on your furniture), the first batch of our new glow-in-the-dark Mischief Plush toys is now available for $25 each in the Blizzard Gear Store—and until December 31, sales of the the plush will benefit Make-A-Wish. Visit the Blizzard Gear Store to learn more.
      BUY NOW
        For more information about Make-A-Wish in the United States, visit wish.org. Outside the United States, visit worldwish.org.
      (Source)
    • By Stan
      Patch 7.1.5 brings tweaks to secondary stats as mentioned in the post-BlizzCon Q/A. The developers shared their insight how they are fixing the issue and highlighted several goals.
      Players are currently passing up +15 item levels in favor of secondary stats. This issue is fixed by increasing the amount of rating you need per percentage of a secondary stat. To improve rings and necks by only having secondary stats means that your choices of secondary stats in Legion are impactful, however, secondary stat distribution still dominates the choice of which items to equip. In 7.1.5, they increased how item level affects the amount of stats on Legion rings and necks. Significant item level jumps will be a clearer indicator of an upgrade. There are still situations where secondary stats are still a prevailing indicator to item level on Legion rings and necks. The last goal is not to lower player power. While in the latest build, player power is down a few percent compared to live. To make up for this As a compensation, a future build will increase the amount of stats granted by all items above item level 800 to account for this gap, such that the overall power of equipped items is the same if not slightly higher than it is now in 7.1. Additional tuning on a spec-by-spec basis will be done, because this will affect all classes differently. TL;DR
      Item level will become a more impactful indicator related to upgrades in Patch 7.1.5. The amount of rating required per percentage of a secondary stat has been increased. These changes will impact classes differently and more tuning will come on a spec-by-spec basis. Here's a blue post by Josh Alen.
      Lore
      The changes to secondary stat ratings in 7.1.5 have a few goals, and certain pieces are not yet in the current build.

      Goal 1: Increase the importance of item level as a guideline for upgrading items. Moreso than in the past, large item level increases are not a reliable indicator of an upgrade due to the variance in power of secondary stats on an item. Increasing the amount of rating that you need per percentage of a secondary stat tips the balance of an item’s power more heavily toward primary stat. We’re okay with very small item level upgrades being a tougher choice, but some specs are currently passing up 15+ item levels in favor of secondary stats. That shouldn’t be something players are encouraged to do – with the occasional exception on rings and necks, which brings us to our second goal.

      Goal 2: Improve rings and necks. The removal of primary stats from those slots on Legion gear means that your choices of secondary stats there are impactful, which we like. However, they still suffer from the problem of secondary stat distribution dominating the choice of which item to equip. We’ve increased how heavily item level affects the amount of stats on Legion rings and necks in 7.1.5, which will make significant item level jumps a clearer indicator of an upgrade on these slots. You’ll still find situations in which secondary stat choice is more important than item level for rings and necks, which is intentional; we’re just dialing it back a bit.

      Goal 3: Don’t lower player power. This is a key part of the overall strategy that isn’t yet complete. Right now, on the PTR, player power is definitely down a few percent compared to live. The next build will have changes that increase the total amount of stats given by all items above level 800 to account for this gap, such that the overall power of your equipped items should be about the same (if not slightly higher) than it is currently in 7.1. 

      As you might expect, these changes will affect some classes more strongly than others. More overall character power will come from your primary stats than it did before, so all of your abilities will hit harder, even if they crit less or happen less frequently. Additionally, as we continue tuning for Patch 7.1.5, we’ll make adjustments as necessary on a spec-by-spec basis.
      Apologies if I'm reading this wrong. But it sounds like the plan is to make us require more of a secondary stat, then provide us a higher value of secondary stats on existing gear. Isn't this counterproductive or am I just derp?
      It's a tough bit of mathematical gymnastics that's tough to explain succinctly, but the long and the short of it is that the way that the item's primary stat (or sheer amount of secondary stats, in the case of rings and necks) make the higher-ilevel piece an upgrade more often.
      I think they need to look into specs that rely on extreme cases of secondary dependence and adjust those specs accordingly. This blanket nerf is going to cause more problems.
      That's what I was getting at in the last paragraph.
      (Source)
    • By Khayman
      Hey guys! Just want to share my experience as survival hunter so far! I used icy veins giude for long time, assuming that versaility is best stat choice for surv, but after some tests i tried to drop versatility to pump mastery. Well as result i'v raised my dps (874 ilvl) from 235k to 307k on boss dummy and 280k-290k in raid (tested on Odyn, and Emerald nightmare). I'm currently running 29% crit, 25% haste, 14% mastery, 1% versatility. Pumping mastery gave me a huuuuge dmg increase cause basically i always have 2-3 moongose bite on. I tried to switch back to versatility gear since i got a lucky trinket drop (885 agi-haste wq trinket), but i had too many dead times w/o focus and it was a great dps lost!
      Of course in some fights i have to switch in BM or MM just to help our healers cause we have too many melee in guild XD, but i'd like to know if there are some hunters currently using  surv spec in hero/mithycs raid or 8+ mithycs dungeons.
      Here is my armory link just in case you wanna give it a check! http://eu.battle.net/wow/it/character/pozzo-delleternita/Khâyman/advanced
       
    • By Starym
      A new month is here, the last of the year, in fact, and we get our very own preview of what's coming up in the next 30ish days! Highlights include the PvP Season rollower, Winter Veil, the Darkmoon Faire and a list of all the upcoming weekly events!
      Blizzard (source)
      December is here, and that means the end of the year! There’s much to see and do, and we have our eye on what the community's up to, too. In this December edition of This Month in WoW, we're looking forward to some of the more remarkable things going on in the World of Warcraft community.
      December 4: The Great Collegiate Dungeon Race Concludes
      Look out for the end of a six-week crusade—the teams in the Great Collegiate Dungeon Race are conquering Mythic Keystone dungeons and competing for a share of $20,000 in scholarship prizing! Are there adventurers on your campus who have what it takes to destroy the Burning Legion?
      The Grand Finals take place on December 4. Check out the standings here.
      December 13: Legion PvP Season Rollover
      On December 13 at 6:00 a.m. PST, Legion PvP Season 1 will come to a close. But the battle will pick up again just two hours later at 8:00 a.m. PST, when Legion PvP Season 2 begins!

      Here are some quick details:
      Legion Season 1 titles and mounts will be awarded approximately two weeks after the season ends. With Legion Season 2, the maximum number of times you can Prestige will increase from 4 to 8. Weekly Rated Quest rewards will increase. The transmog look for Season 2 PvP reward gear will remain the same as Season 1, so if you haven’t gotten your full set, you still have time! WoW Podcasts
      When you find yourself looking for a new show to check out over the holidays, consider a few of our favorites:
       
      For Azeroth! (New)
      Featuring Jocelyn Moffett and Garrett Weinzierl
      Amovetv on YouTube
      Final Boss
      Featuring Bay
       on Twitter
      The Instance  
      Featuring Scott Johnson, Mark “Turpster” Turpin, Patrick Beja, and Willie “Dills” Gregory
      @instanceshow on Twitter
      All Things Azeroth
      Featuring Medros, Toasty, and Phandeth
      @AllThingsAz on Twitter
      Holidays
      Feast of Winter Veil [December 16-January 2]
      The Feast of Winter Veil is one of the most anticipated events of the year! While enjoying a freshly nutmegged cup of nog, and crunching on a crumbly cookie or two, be sure to visit Greatfather Winter in Ironforge if you’re Alliance, or Great-father Winter in Orgrimmar if you’re Horde. While there, you’ll find a few treats, and surely a few tasks to take on as well.

      Greatfather Winter is visiting the great cities of Ironforge and Orgrimmar—courtesy of the fine folks of Smokywood Pastures—and he's spreading cheer in celebration of the Feast of Winter Veil. But, all the cheer—spreading is making Greatfather Winter hungry, and he's looking for helpful adventurers to fetch him some milk and cookies.
      Darkmoon Faire [December 4-11]
      The wondrous and mystical Darkmoon Faire returns to Azeroth on December 4, and if you haven’t completed all of Silas Darkmoon’s new Darkmoon Races, now’s the time! Test your speed and agility on a variety of racing mounts as you dodge electrifying obstacles and zip all over Darkmoon Island for rewards and achievements. You may also want to take a few moments to be a kid again by going for a ride on the new Darkmoon Seesaw.
      The faire continues to be one of the best ways to acquire heirloom gear, and don’t forget all of the toys, mounts, and pets that can only be gotten here. There’s even a pair of Feasels!
      Bonus Events:
      The Bonus Events system consists of a rotating schedule of different activities that each grant a passive bonus to players and offer a once-per-event quest with a noteworthy reward for accomplishing a related goal. Check out the Adventure Guide in-game for a direct link to active Bonus Events, allowing you to easily accept any associated quests.
      Battleground Bonus Event — December 6-13
      While this event is active, random Battlegrounds will award Honor at an increased rate.
      Legion Dungeon Event — December 13-20
      While this event is active, the final boss of each Legion dungeon awards an extra item when defeated.
      Pet Battle Bonus Event – December 20-27
      While this event is active, your pets will earn experience at triple the usual rate.
      Timewalking Dungeon Event: The Burning Crusade — December 27-January 2
      While this event is active, players level 81 or higher may access a special Timewalking Dungeon Finder queue, which scales players and their items down to revisit past dungeons from the Burning Crusade expansion. While Timewalking, bosses will yield loot appropriate for a player’s natural level.