Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

Which 2Hander to pick? :-/

8 posts in this topic

G'day my fellow Paladins! Posted Image

I have wandered around in Stormwind the last few days with a little, but nontheless - important question in my head.

Which weapon is infact best for a Retribution Paladin?

I am aware that 99% of the times (with exceptions ofc) that higher ilvl is prefered, but my little mind have been trying to come up a reasonable answer, but simply cant.. so I hope you, my fellow paladins, can assist me on this.. little "quest" ;-)

- Gurthalak, Voice of the Deeps -


- Experimental Specimen Slicer - ?

I could imagine, if the Gurthalak proc'd constantly.. that would be preferable, but it dont, so.. what do you think.

Best wishes

Rofus of Turalyon

PS: I am aware of Ataraxis, Cudgel of the Warmaster but the stats only is not that preferable as the Slicer.. IMO.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

And hehe I know that there ofc are a HC version, but.. I hope you all know what I am after ;-)

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Gurthalak is your winner and by a pretty decent margin. I actually think Normal Gurth is better than Heroic E.S.S.

1 person likes this

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Experimental Specimen Slicer should definitely be your weapon of choice.

If you look, Gurthalak is going to usually proc to do about 0-3% (as a ret Pally) of your main damage, which is by far not enough to compensate the stat loss that you happens when you equip it.

// While it does about 6-10% damage on my Warrior

When you look at that difference, you see that the weapon procs much less when being used by a Paladin

Why is Gurthalak not BiS for Paladins, but for many other meeles?

- Simply because Gurthalak procced of Censure (Mastery!), which was far too overpowered, so Blizzard removed it, and after Censure was removed, the Proc chance decreased significantly to a level where it does not not Proc as often as it does with e.G a warrior.

- Imagine that you are a hybrid caster-meele, and like as a DK, your damage partially/mainly comes from Spells, now if a spell doesn't proc it, then you are going to have less chance to have a tentacle.

- Retribution Paladins scale worst with the weapon Proc. Warriors most important stat after Strength is Crit, and the DK's stats are Haste>Mastery, and the Paladins is Mastery>Crit. Paladins try to mainly focus on Mastery, and Mastery has absolutely no effect on the tentacle Proc, whereas the Crit/Haste/Mastery that the DK/Warrior naturally have m o r e off is going to influence it a bit more.



Edited by Jaenny

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Jaenny , on all the charts that I've seen from our warrior is that the Proc seem to be scoring around 7-10% of the warrior's damage.

infact the 390 Gurth is better than 397 ESS , so the 403 Gurth is better than 410 ESS

always go with Gurth , unless you have a 390 compare to 410 ESS which the ESS410 in that case is better.

Edited by Amajed

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

I am linking the top 4 Retribution Paladin logs in WorldofLogs for Ultraxion (2 for 10 man heroic and 2 for 25 man heroic), as well as 2 for Madness of Deathwing (25 man heroic). As you can see, all of these players are using inv_sword_2h_deathwingraiddw_d_01.jpgGurthalak, Voice of the Deeps, even though it can be assumed that they have access to every other item in the game.

Even if we disregard the fact that these players are part of the top of the raiding community and also part of very good guilds, we cannot dispute the fact that their results outrank those of any Paladins using any other weapon.

I think this is more than enough evidence to prove that Gurthalak is the best weapon.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

You have a Point there, and the weapon is good enough IF it proccs often, (which it doesnt,) in the end you have to make the choice

and i suppose we have given you enough feedback to make an opinion

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Ludavyk
      Server: Zul'jin - Horde
      Raid Times: 7-10pm EST - T/W
      Celestial Being is recruiting to round out our mythic roster. The core of our team has Mythic experience including top 50 US experience. Mythic experience is preferred, along with current logs. We raid on a brief schedule and expect people prepared to progress.
      Current Needs:
      Priest - All Specs
      Shaman - Elemental/Enhancement
      Druid - Feral
      Paladin - Ret
      Exceptional players of all classes will be considered, feel free to discuss.
      Please contact for more information.
    • By Stenbock
      I recently switched from DK Tank to Paladin Tank (Similar stat prios) and I was wondering how much haste should I aim for and is Versatility more important than Haste like AskMrRobot says? 
      I raid twice a week but I mainly do M+ Content and I seem to be stuck at M+7 so if you have any advice there I will gladly take it. 
      Here's a link to my Paladin.
      I am in my raid spec currently and I switch my lvl 100 talent to Last Defender when I do M+.
      Any help is appreciated. :)
    • By Wixii
      Boom Time is currently recruiting healers (and as always exceptional dps).
      What healers do we need?
      - Paladin (high)
      - Monk
      - 860+ (Not absolute minimum)
      - Mythic experience or impressive logs
      - A sense of humour
      Wednesday - 19:00-23:00
      Thursday - 19:00-23:00
      Sunday - 19:00-23:00
      Contact info, about us, etc
      Wixii#2580 (Healing Officer)
      Origin#2634 (Ranged Officer)
      Warlofd#2979 (Melee Officer)
    • By donaging
      Hi guys,
      I'm trying to use an uncommon build: Crit - mastery - versatility - haste - because I thought to max my dps without lose too much survivality.
      These are my stats atm, with 2 different trinket.
      What do you think? am I doing a huge mistake?
      I'm 4/7 HC without problem, but i can't find a good trinket so i'm thinking that maybe i'm going to a wrong direction.

    • By Deathyield
      So the two stat priorities basically either favor Versatility/Haste(for the survivability spec) Or Crit/haste (for the damage build). Im conflicted with what is more beneficial in heroic/mythic raid content. Especially since most trinkets/gear in EN/Nighthold have crit on them. Does anyone know if its more beneficial to start leaning more toward the dps build as you progress through higher level content, or to just keep sticking with being a brick wall with the Survivability build (haste/Vers).

      When I compare the two as far as raw survivability totally taking dps weights out of the equation, the vers/haste build of course gives you a constant damage taken reduction, though im not sure if the versatility has any baring on how much Hand of the Protector (the % based heal) heals for

      Where as the Crit build You dont have that raw survivbility from that versatility, however you do get parry which totally negates physical attacks, and also making the Hand of the Protector heal for more if it crits. Only drawback i see is the fact that now you simply take more damage, but at the same time if you are doing higher tier content shouldnt the healers be able to pick up that slack?

      TL;DR Is the crit build more viable for higher tier content as opposed to the Versatility build due to your raw damage output/parry chance, Or is the Versatility build more viable then the Crit one due to the raw damage taken reduction you get from it.