andreios

Dual-wield vs 2-hander logic

6 posts in this topic

I have a question regarding weapon choice for Windwalker monks.  I have seen many references here and elsewhere that dual-wielding is better than two-hand; generally I have seen the statement that a 2H weapon needs to be about 10ilvl better than the average of a dual-wield pair.  What I have not been able to find is the logic behind this.  What is going on that makes dual-wield so much stronger?  Is it inherent to the class (Way of the Monk?) or simply a product of current itemization?  Thanks!

 

P.S. - Feel free to get as deeply in-depth as you like.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

2 Handed weapons (Staves and such in this case) give close to or equal base stats than the dual-wielded counterparts, but end up with lower spellpower/intellect generally than Dual Wielded weapons of equal ilvl, as well as being able to have 2 enchants (offhand and mainhand).

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

generally you'll want dual wielded over twohanded because of the double enchantment possibilities, and staves/twohanders of equal level only give ~about the~ same base stats anyway (aside from spellpower/intellect), so enchanting an offhand with 160+ intellect or so is a nice, if small, addition. for most classes you'll find dual wielding has had a little extra weight added to its side of the scales.

as another example, frost deathknights do roughly the same dps at same ilvl in both twohanded or dual wield, but dual wielders get the on-hit auto attack procs more often, like killing machine and rime, than the two handed counterparts do, so they are able to use buffed abilities much more often, allowing them to pull ahead with the right timing for cooldowns and suchlike, aswell as being able to have two enchantments, which then also gives higher damage output. Twohanded frosts' usually go for fallenc rusader, 15% str and 5% heal or something, but a dual wielder can get both that and razor ice, increasing frost damage done or damage to targets affected by frost, something like that.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is regarding Windwalkers not Mistweavers.

 

I couldn't reply to this because I genuinely don't have a good answer. The way I heard it originally was that they didn't do the averaging of the enchants, autoattacks, or other procs very well, and that more hits meant more frequent trinket and Dancing Steel procs, along with slightly more autoattack damage (due to Way of the Monk)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Im fairly sure there is also a relationship with the number of melee swings 1H vs 2h and the resulting stacks/smoothness of TeB generation and as hybris mentioned more trinket proc "chances" and enchant proc "chances".

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That all makes sense.  With the math I was trying to work out it seemed like the damage itself was almost a wash, but the proc frequency increase definitely makes the switch worth it.  Thanks for your insight!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Plagueblade
      So currently our guild is progressing through all the available content as everyone else is, and on most attempts i come second or third on the healing charts, however i have started falling behind lately and i'm hoping that someone on this site can assist with bringing my heals back up.
       
      Armory: http://eu.battle.net/wow/en/character/the-maelstrom/Mongolish/simple
      Warcraft logs for last fight: https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/ycw3GVFdKDW76H41#type=healing
       
      please if any other monks can recommend any changes or just something to help
    • By Duvy44
      Eclipse is recruiting to fill up the last few spots for our mythic roster as we step into mythic progression.

      Raid Times

      Tues/Thurs/Sun 8-11EST

      Progression

      EN 7/7H

      EN 1/7M

      What we want from you:

      Heroic raid xp

      Prefer 860+ ilvl

      Ability to attend most raids

      Recruitment Priority

      Deathknight – LOW - DPS w/ tank OS

      Druid – LOW - Balance w/ tank OS

      Hunter – LOW

      Mage – HIGH

      Monk – LOW - DPS w/ tank OS

      Priest – HIGH – Shadow

      Rogue – HIGH

      Warlock – HIGH

      How to Apply

      Apply directly here at http://eclipsesr.shivtr.com/forums/1905665

      Contacts:

      Falfurious#1181

      Duvy#1803

    • By Dereek
      Váde Enim is a friendly guild on Draenor EU 
      We are currently 7/7 normal and 7/7 heroic
      We are looking to expand to a 20+ man team and tackle mythic content. 
      We cover a number of events in guild including alt raids, mythic dungeons and mythic + content.
      Raiding days are Wednesday and Thursday 1945 - 2300 (server time) 
      We run Mythic + groups on throughout the week 
      We're looking for the following; (But all may be considered)
      Mages
      Shadow Priests
      Hunters
      Feral and Balance Druids 
      Rogues 
      Demon Hunters (Havoc)
      Arms Warrior
      We're mainly looking for Melee DPS on top of the classes we already have just to spread out our Melee / Ranged ratio.
      If you'd like to join and trial please contact Dereek, Rentend, Pettz, Vaior in game or add my bnet tag Villain #2997
       
      Many thanks
      http://vadeenim.guildomatic.com/

    • By Cmx
      Hello fellow monks,
      i came here for help, i feel like i underperforming on most single target situation. My big problem is, i have such a low dmg from FoF, i dont even know why. I must do something very wrong with my FoF. Can please someone look at this and try to find why iam such a lefthanded ?
      I ready every guides, i still learning with Serenity, but i think its not major problem, why i have 10M dmg lowest on FoF dmg then others.
       
      Thank you !!
       
      Armory: http://eu.battle.net/wow/en/character/drakthul/Cmx/advanced
       
      i compare logs with random players with similiar ilvl, same encounter time etc,
      Mythic Nythendra logs:
      https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/compare/LM7V6zpZKWdrwNmF/7rbC1QFNd98qRjvH#fight=4,8&source=3,Nutellã&type=damage-done
      https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/compare/LM7V6zpZKWdrwNmF/L1jZXxcTqYWANka3#fight=4,23&source=3,Dangleesac&type=damage-done
      Mythic Elerethe logs:
      https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/compare/LM7V6zpZKWdrwNmF/VA8jx2MLqY6phzJ1#fight=20,6&source=3,Rüsselcrowe&type=damage-done
      Mythic Ursoc logs:
      https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/compare/LM7V6zpZKWdrwNmF/QRV4YzvpcxJhrtjm#fight=13,5&source=3,Mithrilangel&type=damage-done
      https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/compare/LM7V6zpZKWdrwNmF/kZ1rXq2xLhfPmbCF#fight=13,6&source=3,Lavinath&type=damage-done