Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

[RET] Mastery vs Crit and 50% vs 40% at Lower Gear

5 posts in this topic

So after reading in the other topic a lot about it, I came to the conclusion that at heroic/heroic warforged gear, we are better of going with 50% haste and then reforge all into crit, going as far as getting gear with Haste+Crit, as seen here:


My question tho is, when is it viable to make the switch, when should I stop capping my haste at 40% and when should I start to go for crit?


This is my character at the moment, I decided to reforge and gem without capping myself at the 40% haste to see what it would feel like, still haven't raided with this setup:


My last question is, should I be aiming to get the gear that Zardox is using, the gear found here or a mix of both? Or neither? ohmy.png


Thank you everyone for your posts so far, as someone that just came back after cataclysm, I learned a lot from reading this forums!

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Ahh I love this topic! It seems to be the most discussed topic lately among Ret Paladins, and yet there seems to be no definitive answer one way or the other. I myself tried 50% haste>Crit>Mastery a month or so ago and I did see some good rankings but nothing that was really impressive compared to my previous and future rankings. A big draw back for me was that I was lacking a HWF Sword and the HWF Chest from Immerseus. I don't know if those items really would have made a big difference but I imagine that they would have. The one draw back for Crit is that it seems to lack in comparison to mastery on AoE fights. With the exception of a few fights, most encounters have some AoE components to them.


Do you have HWF Bracers from Nuro or a HWF Neck from Malk? I was using the HWF Bracer from Nuro and HWF Neck form IJ when I was trying out the previously stated build and moved them around until I got my stats where I wanted them. When you get a chance, I would really like to see some logs of the different stat priorities that you have tried/will be trying.

Edited by Bitshinbetty

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

This goes beyond my knowledge but I think this top tier scenario is getting into SimC territory in working out what is more effective. It's been mentioned that mastery tends to come out ahead of favouring crit when aoe is involved although I'm not sure of that. One thing I'll say on 50%  vs 40% haste is that it will be more demanding to actually utilise your stats, you need to have higher apm or you're wasting stats that could be passive such as mastery/crit. Those are just my thoughts, don't really have a suggestion :P

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Having the APM to sustain DPS during lust means someone will have the APM for 50% haste. It's a completely moot point and is generally raised without any real thought as to just how big an issue it is in reality.


SimC allegedly doesn't account for the full effect of haste, leading people to doubt its accuracy at these gear levels. 50% is obviously superior to 40% based on empirical evidence but nobody really knows how to build up to it efficiently. Personally, I'd stick with the aim prior to 40% haste of simply putting everything into haste and redistributing what's left so that mastery and crit ratings will be somewhat close to each other, with crit slightly ahead. That's, of course, based on the assumption that SimC at least gets the mastery:crit ratio right.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Yeah the lust thing is a good point and most players that will be clearing content that would allow them to get those stats most likely are above the skill threshold of playing 'fast'. The only difference i'll point out for lust is that you need higher apm for 30sec burst as opposed to higher apm for the entire duration of a fight, but again I don' think that's a problem for most people at that level of gear/content.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Cerenitee
      Moist is a Horde guild located on Illidan and is recruiting for our Core Mythic raid group. We are a 9 hour raiding guild making quick progression through The Emerald Nightmare!

      We are currently looking to fill Core DPS/Healing raid spots.

      Current Recruitment Needs

      Monk: Windwalker
      Hunter: Marksmen
      Paladin: Ret
      Priest: Shadow

      Druid: Resto
      Paladin: Holy

      Other specs will be considered assuming you can perform to a superior standard.

      Current Progression

      The Emerald Nightmare
      7/7 Normal
      5/7 Heroic

      Raid Times

      Monday - 8:30 PM EST - 11:30 PM EST
      Tuesday - 8:30 PM EST - 11:30 PM EST
      Wednesday - 8:30 PM EST - 11:30 PM EST

      About us

      <Moist> is a guild that strives to push progression with a very short raid week. We expect our top raiders to know the insides and outs of their class and come to raid prepared. With a 9 hour raid week we expect everyone to play the best to their ability. Outside of raid nights we have plenty of activities happening ranging from alt runs, mount runs to other games outside of WoW such as League of Legends, HoTs, Hearthstone, and random steam games just to name a few.

      What we expect from you:
      A reasonable level of dedication
      The ability to take criticism
      The ability to learn from your mistakes
      Something, something sense of humor

      What to expect from us:
      Friendly environment
      People to laugh, and have fun with
      Progress oriented raid nights
      Optional non-raid-night activities (mog and mount runs, BGs, Arenas)

      We are currently using Personal Loot. So far everyone really seems to be enjoying it. There is a lot less drama with Personal Loot than the normal Master loot most guilds do.

      If you're interested in learning more about us or applying to the guild please apply at - Click on the Recruitment tab on the menu bar. If you have any questions please feel free to message us in game or post below.

      Cerenitie (Cerenitee#1650)
      Pip (Piptooth#1430)
    • By Booty
      <Deceive> Is reforming after a couple of years and looking for mythic raiders for Legion. Previously we have been top 10 on the server in Seige of Orgrimmar with little time in the patch to reach there. We are mainly looking for Ret Paladin, Balance Druid, Windwalker Monk and Ranged Hunter. 
      Raid times are Wednesday/Thursday 7-11 AEST with monday as a backup day.

      Add me @Unknown#1430 to talk further.
    • By Transistor
      Hey! So the guide says that the #1 priority for a ret paladin is "cast divine storm if you have empowered DS and the FV buff".
      Does this imply you're already at 5 Holy Power, and if you're at 2 holy power, you should at least cast your HP builders and then DS once you're at 5 [or before the buff runs out]?
      I feel weird casting my FV+empowered divine storm when I'm only at 2 holy power, because it feels like I could easily get a few HP builders on cooldown before I do so.
      Am I missing a specific reason to cast DS immediately, or is the guide implying you're already at 5 HP?
      Thanks in advance!
    • By Tier1853
      i am trying to work our my bad performance,,and not the sort in the sack. here are some logs and gear.
      i have read every thing i can and from what i can see my rotation or priority list are in the right sequence.
      more logs 
      please advise still not happy with proformance.(that's what she said)
      thank you in advance
      144 people have read this post and no one can help me????
    • By tokoo
      So I have been a long time raider, returning to WoW. I have to say, I haven't really liked my Ret dps. I mean did N-HFC, and I Burst up to about 44-52k dps at the beginning of the fights, but by the end of the fights I am about 32-37k dps. I would think with my gear it should be a lot better. I follow the correct priorities, I also you destruction for dummies, just to make sure. Only thing I know I am doing wrong is not spamming HoW sometimes due slight lag, but I may miss that 2-3 times a fight. 
      Armory link is