Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Stoove

Resto in [Beta] MoP: Greater Healing Wave vs. Healing Surge

6 posts in this topic

Hi all,

Just thought I'd raise a note about a calculation I made recently for Resto Shaman in pre-raid "BiS" blues. You can find the whole calculation here, but the upshot is that Greater Healing Wave is nowhere near as good as Healing Surge in the current version of MoP Beta. In fact, it's better to the point where I'd suggest you were crazy for not using Healing Surge.

Any comments? :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think that this is not intended. I mean, Healing Surge has always been an emergency heal and I believe that it will remain an emergency heal in MoP. I'd quote the "Core Abilities" page of your spellbook but I cannot log into the beta currently (there's a mega-bug that Blizzard is trying to fix and that prevents a lot of players from accessible their characters).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I finally have access to my Shaman again on the beta. Here's what I wanted to share with you:

Posted Image

What do you think?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think, that they just need to buff Greater Healing wave by 10%.. To make it a heal thats more worth than using the Tidal waves + healing surge healing combination.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think, that they just need to buff Greater Healing wave by 10%.. To make it a heal thats more worth than using the Tidal waves + healing surge healing combination.

Actually Vixsin talked about that in a comment on the blog post I linked. Apparently, even with the T14 2pc (+10% healing to GHW), HS is still better in every way.

What do you think?

Thanks for the info Damien!

What I think is that someone needs to point this out on the Beta Class Balance Analysis thread on the US forums. Unfortunately, I can't since I don't have a US account ='[

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just as a note - the costs and healing values changed over last week. The calculations I did are, sadly, no longer valid. I'll be redoing them at some point, but I suspect that GHW will be marginally better in this iteration.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Kyo
      Hello, I've been mythic raiding as a hunter for a while but recently changed my main to Mistweaver for HFC. I don't have a ton of experience healing mythics, but I feel as though I am not getting the output I should be, I was hoping someone could potentially look at my logs and see if I am making any blatant errors. Ask Mr.Robot says I'm ranked very low among mistweavers with a similar ilvl.
       
      Ask Mr.Robot and recent logs
      Armory
       
      I feel like I'm finally at a good place spirit/mana wise, but can't figure out what I'm doing wrong. Maybe it's the lack of the legendary ring and phylactery?
    • By Doobz
      Hi there, 
       
      So the mistweaver monk in my guild is an awesome raider, she is never standing in fire, dodges the mechanics, and generally won't die to much of anything. This makes her an extremely valuable player in our group. Unfortunately, her numbers seem to be a bit low amongst our healers. None of my officers or myself have ANY experience playing a mistweaver, so we are at a stand still on how to help her. Granted, she just got her 4 piece and I'm sure they will increase once she learns how to utilize that a bit more, and she was also pretty sick when she was raiding this week, but I was hoping somebody could look these logs over and just give some helpful tips and tricks, and maybe see what she's doing (or should be doing) to increase her heals. Thank you so much in advance!
       
      Logs:
       
      https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/a9JgAfm3bW2p8QjM
      (^she bowed out on Archimonde due to sickness)
       
      https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/JQXW1hxgFwZ7BdLy
       
      This is her armory:
       
      http://us.battle.net/wow/en/character/kilrogg/Sylinna/simple
    • By Moonsunier
      Hey guys,
       
      My wow name is Moonsunier and I am now doing mythic progression with my guild (currently 4/10 mythic) I  was told to up my hps before raiding with them on mythic (this was told to me because of a REALLY bad attempt at Hanz and Franz mythic because I had jetlag - lesson learntxD) but I wanted to up it anyway, so I came here because you helped a lot last time.
       
      Log:
      https:/www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/nvpt9bRXyPThL2rN/#type=healing
       
      Armory:
       
      eu.battle.net/wow/en/character/bladefist/Moonsunier/simple
       
      I am aware that I do need a better tinket as well as my wild mushroom and swiftmend not being on the optimal tick range because it was Blackhand lfr..and regrowth was required..alot.
       
      Appreciate all the help,
       
      Moonsunier
       
    • By Toulip
      link to my armory http://us.battle.net/wow/en/character/turalyon/Toulip/simple
       
      For the heck of it link to logs for 2 weeks ago to compare improvement over last few weeks https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/pFmCaw2DfVL1q3gG#fight=3
       
      link to logs for last week Heroic clear, 1 Mythic
      https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/x7aP2p4LgkBWrNCj#fight=2&type=healing
      https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/AMgzTG1jQyxthRmr#type=healing
      Note for last weeks logs I had talents in Echo of the Ele and High Tide, Imperator I think I went Primal Ele instead of Ele Blast. I was using Primal Ele initially across the board on all fights and really just started using Ele Blast last week.
      From my experience if you're going to take High Tide you pretty much need to take EoftheE, otherwise by the time you get your 3rd Riptide and a Chain Heal off, our 1st RP falls off. Correct me if I'm wrong but with High Tide, will it only bounce to a 4th person that has RP or will it still bounce these additional times and just not be as effective?  
       
      link to log for Tuesday's Mythic, 1st time using CBT
      https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/gBmFhN3pzxC7AWwM#fight=2&type=healing
      Last night I went back to Ancestral Swift, stayed EB and tried out CBT for the 1st time ever after reading a bunch of threads. I also just got the Winged Hourglass last night so it was the 1st night using it. 
       
      Usually for glyphs I keep HW and HST then sub out Grace with Focus fight depending. Overall I know I need to hit spiritwalker more when moving instead of just running out of stuff and not healing. My active time though is usually pretty good I think regardless.
       
      I honestly JUST started raid healing on the shaman last summer, tail end of MOP. I know I have lots of room for improvement I just dont know exactly how to do it. I have the highest ilvl out of all the healers in my guild so its my mechanics. Even comparing my logs to other resto shamans in other guilds I have gotten better over the past month but my HPS is still lower or about the same of shamans 10 ilvls lower than me. I know shamans arent the best healers and at least I'm not always on the bottom of my healer group, but with my ilvl I know I should be doing better. 
       
      I use Elvui, used to use grid all the time but it stopped working for me after Dec patch. Tried a few times since, not in the last few weeks but it still wasnt working. I can't figure out how to show other healers incoming HOTS or bubbles, I can only see priests raid wide heal. 
       
      Last night I focused on making sure my Ascendance was followed by Healing Rain and then Chain heals. With my UI I can see when my HST and CBT are active, I need to get better at timing them one right after another. On Mythic Twins it got pretty hairy and I know I was more worried about not dying in fire than keeping these 2 totems up. Again since this was the 1st night trying CBT I did at least notice a difference on Kargath as an improvement since last week. 
       
      On a side note my tank/melee group hollers out for Healing Rain all the damn time... so I've adjusted and pretty much forced to keep putting one down every time its off cooldown. I dont know if this is a factor to my lower HPS? 
       
      1/15 Edit: We cleared Heroic last night in about 1.25 hrs and boy was my game off. I noticed with CBT and trying to watch my totem timers that I wasnt using EB as often as I had been. There are a ton of buttons and options for shamans to have to monitor during a fight. I really need to start using WeakAuras... I'm just afraid of the setup since I'm not very techy. I saw the pinned threads about WA and will test things out over the weekend as I'm sure I'll be back with more questions. 
       
      Any pointers or suggestion, or other questions I can answer please let me know. I appreciate any guidance you can provide.
       
      Thanks Toulip