Protection Paladin Tank Best Gems, Enchants, and Consumables — Midnight Season 1

In general, the gearing you will do with gems and enchants will all go in the same direction as the general way of gearing your character for specific stats. You can read more about it in the Stat page linked below.

You should use a Indecipherable Eversong Diamond in your first available gem socket, and fill every other with Flawless Masterful Peridot.

Slot	Enchantment
Head	Enchant Helm - Empowered Blessing of Speed
Shoulders	Enchant Shoulders - Akil'zon's Swiftness
Chest	Enchant Chest - Mark of the Worldsoul
Legs	Blood Knight's Armor Kit
Feet	Enchant Boots - Farstrider's Hunt
Rings	Enchant Ring - Silvermoon's Tenacity
Weapon	Enchant Weapon - Acuity of the Ren'dorei

Use Flask of the Shattered Sun as a general-use flask.

Thalassian Phoenix Oil as Templar or Rite of Sanctification as Lightsmith.

Light's Potential should be your combat potion of choice.

You should use Silvermoon Health Potion for in-combat healing. Healing potions do not share a cooldown with Healthstones, so you can use both independently if you can access a Warlock.

When deciding what food type to use it would be advisable to sim both options to identify which one is better for you. Primary Stat (Strength) and Highest Secondary Stat options are available for both feasts and personal food buffs.

As a general recommendation without simming the Secondary Stat variants are a safe choice.

Use Royal Roast (primary stat) or Champion's Bento (secondary stat) as your food buff of choice if a Feast is not available.

If a Harandar Celebration (primary stat) / Blooming Feast (secondary stat) is available, use this instead.

In addition, if you can afford it, you should use Void-Touched Augment Runes to increase your primary stat. Augment Runes will be expensive until the final Season of the expansion, and disappear on death, so use them wisely!