Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

The meaning of "crit"

5 posts in this topic



I was just a little bit stuck about, let say, the underlying reason behind the crit priority in this tiers.


Let me explain. At the beginning main focus was on Mastery, in order to up poison damages. Then, came the legendary clock, the metageme, cool tinkerts and a RPPM "law" that push to focus on Haste mainly.


Now: crit. It seems after having at least 2 token. But I do not understand the real why of focusing on crit/haste/mastery


Could someone kindly explain me the reason why ? The goald of this focus


Furthermore, a second question. By trying to understand the stat focus i was playing with shadowcraft. Equilibrium of the rule crit/haste/mastery seems not so clear and robust.

For example, at my current gear set up  I had reforges following mast/haste/crit. Shadow craft gave at this time an order of stat weight like this :  crit/haste/mastery. So I reforged according this. But then the new order showed calculated by Shadow craft put this order :Mastery/haste/focus.So I Am puzzled. Am I missing something obvious?

You will find a link to my character if you want to test


Kind regards

Edited by Slevin

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
Meta gem and cloak tend to favor haste, but once you get enough haste and mastery on your base gear, then crit becomes more valuable. Also, don't forget about the tier 2 piece, upping the value of crit for assassination and subtlety.


There is a point, when all the stats become pretty much equal. The reforge priority is a priority based on your current gear's rating, so when you reforge into say, crit/haste/mastery, your new priority changes and can become haste/mastery/crit, so every time you reforge into a new one, the priority changes again.

Edited by Quidamtyra

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites


thks very much for your answer.

Very clear. agree with you.

Could you kindly say me if you are ok with the 4 following points:?


- So an extension of this, is that : if you reforge/regemme with crit/haste/mastery and then you mastery drop under the 50% threshold, it is not a good signal (ie. could much more greater than 50%, it is a too dramatic decrease of mastery with respect to mastery/haste/crit or haste/mastery/crit that lead to twice more mastery). 


- Which refer then to an underlying question : is there a cap about mastery and haste. By reading the net, it seems not.


- if the tiers 16 -2 items is good for crit : it is because the proc of nrj can give less importance to haste

- the stat priority are so closed that maybe we could say : play the rogue you like (which has always been true, but here again smile.png )
With KR
Edited by Slevin

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Stat priorities are not static. Any list is usually based on high level gear and don't account for anything else.

Shadowcraft bases its weighting on your current gear and current stats. If the three stats are very close, then stacking a lot of mastery decreases its value and can make haste/crit more valuable.


As you say, when they're close enough, you can play how you like. If you prefer faster energy regen and more trinket/cloak/meta gem procs, go for lots of energy. If you want lots of on-demand damage from poisons, go for mastery. It will make a little difference, but nothing huge, and probably won't be noticeable in game anyway.


There is no cap for haste or mastery, but after a while it can increase damage more by reforging/regemming to other stats.


The 2-set bonus is related to Seal Fate, which awards a combo point for crits. Everytime that happens, the 2-set bonus means your next combo point-generating spell will cost less energy. More crit means you (potentially) have more combo points and have to spend less energy.


Also be aware that haste is more beneficial for long, single-target fights. RNG is still RNG, but longer fights should even out enough that lots of haste will be good. 

For multiple targets, you could still have bad luck, so haste is less valuable, whereas mastery will give you a reliable source of damage.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Lifvana
      Hello all, with 7.1 coming soon, I am wondering what % of each stat I should be aiming for, mainly just interested in mythic+ and normal raids. My armory is . Not sure why it's saying I have 34.5% haste, it's more like 20-22% in game, with 28% crit and 25% mastery. My gear is kinda all over the place cause I play blood as well. I can give the exact percents I have once I get home in a couple hours, and  I have another 835 ring which I will post the stats of it when I get home. Sorry if the formatting is bad, first post and on my phone haha. Edit: Once I get the exact percentages of my stats, if someone could let me know the ideal enchants I should use, it would be greatly appreciated. Thank you very much! :)
    • By rauter
      I'm trying to decide which gear is better for me, betweeen these trinkets -> and these wrists -> .
      According to the icy veins fire mage guide, the ones i am using are better in terms of DPS. (reference: 2- Evaluating Upgrades Using Stat Weights on
      But from a second source, Askmrrobot, these two with higher item level are better than mine. I was wondering if anyone have a take on this specific situation. My guess is that Askmrrobor is taking to account the Stamina too.

      So, which ones should i be using and why?

      Here are my current stats for reference:
    • By Nieria
      Hi! So upon viewing the Outlaw rogue stat priority, I'm a bit confused as to why Haste is the lowest stat for us. With Outlaw's heavy influence of RNG, there are times where saber slash won't proc a Pistol Shot, causing my dps to drop tremendously. With more haste to generate energy with for more saber slashes, resulting more Run Throughs. I feel this would benefit more for constant dps rather than stacking crit just because the crit isn't going to benefit me that much if I'm taking my sweet time building up combo points for a single Run Through. I think a stat priority of Vers>Haste>Crit>Mastery might be better, however I do not have the gear to test this out yet. 
      Finally, I have both Quick Draw and Deeper Stratagem talented, and a problem I've ran into is having five combo points with a Pistol Shot proc, but not knowing if I should hold the proc and spend my current points, or use the proc while wasting that one extra combo point. The guide mentions that there isn't a big difference in dps regarding this, but I feel it can at least matter when in cleave/big aoe pulls since a six point Run Through does more than a five point in big pulls.
      Any insight will be appreciated. Thanks!
    • By drwienerful
      With the new expansion coming up and numerous class changes, I was wondering if it would be a good idea to swap from Troll to orc, because orc racials sync up with the cooldowns of the new Legion enhancement shaman better than the troll racial. I also thought that with Ascendance being an optional talent (Lets face it, it's not nearly as good as landslide is) the 3-min burst is no longer chained up with anything other than spirit wolves at the beginning of a fight. Those obviously aren't the only reasons why you would roll troll (15% haste is just straight up over powered when your classes best PVE stat is haste), but I was also wondering if haste was the best stat to have in legion as well?
    • By Haumph
      Hey all,
      One of the things I have been concerned about as my gear catches up to that of my guildmates (new addition to the roster) is that my stats are drastically shifting away from where I feel I want them to be. For example, I got the Mannoroth chest and Archi belt, the former of which also allowed me to change from tier gloves to a surprisingly well-statted and socketed pair of  5-man gloves (shown on my Armory)
      Swapping from my old 3 items (Soc Chest w/ Socket, Isk Belt, Tier Gloves), my stat changes are:
      + 11% mastery
      + 6.09% haste
      - 4.7% multistrike
      - 7% crit (down to 14% unbuffed)
      Intellect gain: 18
      For reference, here is a parse while wearing the old gear -- I'm perfectly happy with my performance as is:
      My concern going forward is, while sure there's a notable haste and mastery gain, the 7% crit seems absolutely huge. I myself have already experienced Shooting Stars droughts, and dropping that much crit would make those droughts more frequent. 
      Obviously the sims are showing that every balance druid should wear X set of gear, but I'm just curious as to the thoughts from other high parsing or high gear point druids on the forums about whether or not you feel the loss of crit in your gearing. 
      - Haumph