Zadina

HotS: The Current State of Matchmaking

Sign in to follow this  

7 posts in this topic

16006-hots-the-current-state-of-matchmak

Spyrian made a blog post on the official forums regarding matchmaking in Heroes of the Storm and its present state.

 

Matchmaking improvements have been a work in progress for the Heroes of the Storm dev team since last December. Most recently, we saw improvements in matchmaking for Rank 1 players. Spyrian posted an article regarding the current state of matchmaking.

 

Blizzard Icon Spyrian

Over the past few months, we’ve been hard at work on a game system that has been the subject of much feedback and discussion within the Heroes of the Storm community: matchmaking. In that time, we’ve completely rebuilt the matchmaker and rolled out a number of improvements for our new version of the system. While we’re still hard at work on further improvements for matchmaking, we’re already seeing very encouraging results from our efforts.

 

Today, we’d like to take a look at some of the adjustments we’ve made since BlizzCon 2015, as well as the impact those changes have had on matchmaking in Heroes of the Storm. Before we dig in, it’s important to note that many of the restrictions and rules that we’ve put into place can be relaxed under certain conditions, such as very long queue times. This means that there will almost always be a few exceptions to each rule, as you’ll see below.

 

Improvements So Far

 

Priority #1: Fair Matches

 

Last December, we rolled out phase one of our improvements for matchmaking, which featured an entirely new matchmaker built specifically to suit Heroes of the Storm. This new system primarily focuses on providing players with close games, in which each team has a 45% – 55% chance to win. Since the new matchmaker was implemented, we’ve seen great improvements in overall match quality and fairness. Take a look at stats from before the new matchmaker went live, and after:

 

WY8WSRPUCWM21455729853477.png

 

As you can see in the charts above, the likelihood that you will receive a match within our target range of 45% – 55% win probability has been dramatically increased, from 66% of games before the new system went live, to 97% of games after.

 

New Players vs. Veterans

 

Along with the rebuilt matchmaker, we also decreased the likelihood that inexperienced players will be matched up against those with a lot of games, and game knowledge, under their belts. Prior to phase one, about 500 games out of every 10,000 pit new players against veterans. After phase one, this has dropped to roughly 5 games in 10,000 —which we feel is a significant reduction.

 

Team Composition Rules

 

Our December 15 patch brought a new rule to Quick Match that prevents teams with one or more Warriors in their compositions from matching against teams without one. While we’re still working to bring further improvements to team compositions in Quick Match, this “Warrior” rule, along with a similar rule for Supports, has dropped the number of matches featuring a Warrior or Support on one team, but not the other, to roughly 3 in 10,000 games.

 

We’d like to mention once again that, while we want all games to be as fair as possible, Quick Match was designed as a game mode where almost anything can happen. If you’re hoping for a specific hero lineup in your games, then you might prefer to step into Hero League, or even queue for Quick Match with a party, which both offer players the ability to tailor team compositions to their liking.

 

Party Size Restrictions

 

Full parties were playing against solo players a little too often prior to our first phase of matchmaking improvements. After rolling out phase one of matchmaking changes, we heard feedback that playing against parties as a group of solos was still a source of frustration for some players and, after investigation, implemented a new rule that greatly reduced the chance that this could occur.

 

Now that this rule has been live for a few weeks, we’re happy to share that the number of games in which five-player parties are matched against teams of solo players has dropped to just 29 of every 10,000 matches.

 

Ranked Match Consistency

 

Our most recent release brought a new rule for Hero League matchmaking, which greatly reduces the likelihood that Rank 1 players will be matched with or against others below Rank 4. This change also resolved an edge-case scenario, in which players with extremely high skill ratings could occasionally be matched with or against one or more low-ranked players.

 

We’re still actively collecting and reviewing data after making this change, so it’s a little too early to share statistics at this point. In the meantime, we’d like to encourage those of you at the top of the ranking system to jump back into Hero League and let us know how your games feel. Going forward, we’ll continue to keep an eye on Hero League data, as well as player feedback, and will make further adjustments as needed.

 

Reviewing Further Feedback

 

Distinctive Heroes in Quick Match

 

Our rules for Supports and Warriors in Quick Match have helped level the playing field in terms of team composition, but we’ve also seen feedback from the community indicating that receiving several heroes who have limited lane presence, or fill unique roles, on one Quick Match team can make for a challenging experience.

 

We’d like to limit cases like these, and we’re currently planning to implement a new rule for Quick Match that will prevent more than one of the heroes listed below from being placed on the same team:

  • Abathur
  • Cho’gall
  • Lt. Morales
  • Murky
  • Nova
  • The Lost Vikings

As with all of the team composition restrictions we’ve implemented so far, parties can still bend this rule. This means that you may still see heroes like Abathur and Cho’gall on the same team if those players entered the queue as a party.

 

Additionally, we’re working to resolve a rare bug that can occasionally cause players to receive a different hero than the one they selected after entering a match.

 

Queue Times

 

We’ve seen players mention that queue times feel longer now that the rebuilt matchmaking system has been implemented. We knew that this was a strong possibility, due to the system’s prioritization of match fairness over quick game creation, but also because the more rules we add to matchmaking, the higher wait times will rise. Between November 2015 and today, we’ve seen Quick Match wait times increase from about 80 to 130 seconds on average. While we wouldn’t prefer to see queues get any longer, we’re okay with this time gain if it means we’re creating high-quality games.

 

Looking Ahead

 

We’ve mentioned this time and again, but we’d like to emphasize once more that we aren’t finished making improvements for matchmaking in Heroes of the Storm. While we aren’t ready to share details about what those changes are just yet, we would like to thank everyone who continues to provide us with their thoughts on the current state of matchmaking. We’re still investigating your reports and reviewing internal data as we work toward further improvements, and your feedback is a great sounding board as we make changes over time.

 

Stay tuned to the official Heroes website to catch all the latest news as it is announced. Until next time, we’ll see you in the Nexus!

(source)

 

Are you pleased with the state of the matchmaking improvements? Would you change or recommend anything?

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Why don't they just release something like Team Builder in League of Legends? for example I want to play abathur for like 10 games, or someone wants to play any hero to reach lvl 5, 

Now I said this before, there is a supp and a specialist on each team, good ones, and 3 assassins on each side too. But one team has kt, jaina, li ming, all squishy with no engage potential. On the other side is Butcher , zeratul and Thrall. Is this match up fair? Happened to me a lot. You can't compare assassins like jaina with no engage or disengage potentials with melee assassins like Thrall or Butcher with self heals and tons of damage with good gap close.

a team builder system on the other hand, can solve this problem, you make your desirable comp, anything you like, Tripple Warrior, Tripple Ranged Assassins and many other comps that are popular among best teams around the world. You don't want Murky as a specialist on your team? Fine, reject. Get zagara and be op. You want to play Murky? Build a team and invite ppl, you know what kind of comp and heroes work with Murky, or you just want to try something different to see the result, you can have it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think most of the things you are asking for will be implemented in Arena Mode.

 

Nevertheless, you are obviously right. Just look at the response this blog post had and you will understand that there's still a lot of work to be done.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My wait time have got up as high as at least 6 minutes in the past. Though to be fair, I've also had no waiting at all.

Anyway, I think all this is good. Sadly the main problem is just being matched with people who go AFK or just play solo all the time and ignorer map pings - then get annoyed at everyone else when their team starts to lose. I don't think matchmaking can do much about that. I just had one person wander around on their own the whole game and never help the team out. When I asked them what they were doing, they called me a noob and then said "Russians always ruin online games" even though I'm not Russian and didn't say anything Russian. Yeah... If only Blizzard could do something about not matching me up with people like that.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you are using the same username, it does sound a bit Russian (although I know it isn't :P )

 

I don't think Blizzard or any company can fix players' attitudes :( Unfortunately, no matchmaking is perfect.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Blizzard is trying so hard as they mentioned themselves, to fight toxicity in their games. They have already banned a lot of botters and cheaters in all of their games specially WoW and Hearthstone, I see more and more silenced players in HotS, so that means toxic players are being punished. But punishment is not enough and we can see that in League of Legends. There are still a lot of toxic players there. But what I'm thinking is that Blizzard has always been the "Idea Master" company, so they are definitely planning on some new ways to reduce toxicity in their games. 

 

 

I think most of the things you are asking for will be implemented in Arena Mode.

I thought arena mode is like ARAM? Random Heroes in 1 arena with no lanes, am I wrong?

Team Builder is something very different, it's like practice games for ranked. Same maps as ranked, no points, with any comp you want to build, for example you want to play Double Warrior, you wait for 2 warriors to join, you don't have to invite ppl into your group and beg them to pick a hero you want to try your comp with :D

People like to play anything they want, so joining a group automatically will give them that, they can accept and join the team or deny and find another one.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ah yeah, you are right about Arena mode.

 

I guess partially what you are asking for can be satisfied by playing a Custom Game. But, it's not really close to a Team Builder at all...

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Stan

      The image above is fan art by DanOliveira.
      Gamescom 2017 approaches and Blizzard started teasing what could be the quarters of Naxxramas.
      Redditor Caprificus wrote that the teasers are representing the Arachnid and Military Quarters of Naxxramas. According to the most recent Hero leaks, we're expecting Kel'thuzad to be unveiled soon.
      Teaser #1
      Placeholder for tweet 898591030337040384 Teaser #2
      Placeholder for tweet 898960293048406016 Another possibility is that we're getting a Naxxramas-themed map in Heroes of the Storm or both teasers could indicate upcoming skins for existing Heroes.
      Naxxramas in World of Warcraft
      Naxxramas was the last 40-player raid added to the game in Patch 1.11 and Kel'thuzad was the final boss.
      Players were able to obtain Tier 3 sets that can now be bought only on the Black Market Auction House and the legendary weapon - Atiesh, that's currently wielded by Khadgar. There were multiple variations of the caster weapon:
      Atiesh, Greatstaff of the Guardian (Druid) Atiesh, Greatstaff of the Guardian (Mage) Atiesh, Greatstaff of the Guardian (Priest) Atiesh, Greatstaff of the Guardian (Warlock) The raid was removed in Patch 3.0.2 (Source) and in Wrath of the Lich King it was moved to Northrend and reintroduced as a 10/25-player entry-level raid. (Source)
      Tier 7 sets were heavily inspired by the original Tier 3 sets.
    • By Stan

      In next week's sale you can grab two Specialists - Probius, Sylvanas, and a bunch of skins and mounts!
      If you want to grab everything, no problem! You can purchase the Weekly Bundle with all Heroes, skins and mounts that are on sale for the week.
      Blizzard (Source)
      Every Tuesday, we place a number of Heroes on sale, and swap a fresh set of cosmetics into the featured item rotation. Check out this week’s items and then head in-game to pick up anything that catches your eye. Weekly Collection Update: Aug 22 – 29, 2017
      Next week's Collection Update will begin Tuesday, August 22! Check out the new list of featured items and Hero discounts below: Upcoming Hero Sales
      Probius — Sale Price: 375 Gems Sylvanas — Sale Price: 312 Gems
      The following Skins and Mounts will enter the Featured Item Rotation, and will be unlockable using Gems until next week's Collection Update: Upcoming Featured Skins
      Ascendant Probius Prime Indigo Li-Ming Real Dream Azmodunk Fervent Love Goddess Tyrande Nightmare Shan’do Illidan Molten Druid of the Flame Malfurion Upcoming Featured Mounts
      Azure Nimbus Cloud Armored War Steed Weekly Sale Bundle
      If you’d rather pick up everything at once, we’re also going to add a new Weekly Sale Bundle to the Featured tab in your Collection. This limited-time bundle contains all of the items above at a discounted Gem price, but will only be available until next week’s Collection Update takes place.
    • By Oxygen

      We present our ninth Heroes of the Storm Meta Tier List for the Garrosh patch of August 2017.
      Our ninth Heroes of the Storm Meta Tier List for the month of August 2017 is here!
       
      Welcome to Icy Veins's Meta Tier List for the Garrosh patch. The goal if of this list is to try and detail game's current metagame state. The prime goal of such lists is to inform players regarding popular and trending team composition drafting strategies (i.e. the drafting metagame). Although tier listings are generally the product of balance, many factors come into play when discussing the relative perceived strengths of heroes, including player regions, maps, play style, skill level, and, of course, personal perception. As such, any tier list—including this very one—should never be interpreted as gospel, but rather, as a guide to better grasp what to expect with regards to typical drafting experiences. One useful application of such lists is to allow you know which heroes to look out for in terms of practice and counterplay, ultimately improving your knowledge of the game.
       
      Using the list
      As stated above, tier lists are easy to mistake for gospel. As new strategies are discovered and experimented with, so changes the perception of the relative strengths of each hero. Tier lists still prove to be useful as a snapshot of player expectations in terms of drafting. Although it is generally considered preferable to focus on high tier heroes (Prime and Core tiers), it is important to note that Heroes of the Storm's wild character and map designs make it so that any given hero's tier position is prone to fluctuate depending on the situation at hand.
      One classic example of such is that of Kerrigan on the Infernal Shrines map. Although we currently judge her to be a mid-tier hero, her drafting priority shoots up to first-pick or first-ban material on this specific map due to the nature of its objective. Certain heroes also synergise so well with each other that the sole fact of having the opportunity of drafting them together is generally enough to increase their potential. Tassadar and Tracer, for instance, are generally nightmarish to deal with for many. There are too many examples of these interactions to reasonably produce here, but we invite you to consult our guides to know exactly where and when each hero shines. The guides have been linked in the lists below for your convenience - just click any of the hero names to access them.
      A ↑ next to a hero's name means its tier list position has increased since the previous month whereas a ↓ means just the opposite. Additionally, a + or - sign indicates short-to-medium term predictions (which is to say, about a month) for tier increase(s) or decrease(s), respectively. These are often updated after significant balance patches and/or when clear trends are emerging.
      If you're newer to the game, also consider visiting our glossary for a comprehensive list of discrete Heroes of the Storm terms.
       
      Prime Tier
      Warrior Assassin Support Specialist Anub'arak  Genji Uther - Stitches↑ Greymane↑ Tassadar↑     Malthael     Prime tier heroes are considered to be extremely strong in all situations, and show no obvious weakness. They are very often banned or picked right away, as they generally dictate the pace of most matches.
       
      Core Tier
      Warrior Assassin Support Specialist Arthas Falstad Auriel Nazeebo Dehaka Gul'dan- Rehgar Sylvanas Diablo+ Li-Ming Stukov Xul↑ E.T.C.↑ The Butcher↑     Garrosh (new!) Valla     Sonya Zeratul     Varian (Tank)                       Core tier heroes are strong in a wide variety of situations and have few counter-picking possibility. They should form the core of your team, and be picked after Prime Tier heroes have been distributed.
       
      Viable Tier
      Warrior Assassin Support Specialist Artanis Alarak Brightwing Abathur Chen Cassia↑ Kharazim Azmodan D.Va↓ Chromie Li Li Zagara+ Johanna↓ Jaina Lt. Morales Probius Leoric Kael'thas Lúcio   Muradin Lunara Malfurion↓   Tyrael Ragnaros Tyrande   Zarya↓ Samuro       Thrall↓       Tracer↑       Varian (Damage)-       Zul'jin             Viable tier heroes are generally well-rounded that have either fallen out of favour, or, inversely, are on the rise in popularity, due to the current Prime tier contenders.
       
      Niche Tier
      Warrior Assassin Support Specialist Cho'gall Cho'gall - Gazlowe↓ Rexxar↓ Illidan   Medivh   Kerrigan↓   Murky   Nova   Sgt. Hammer   Raynor       Valeera↓       Tychus     Niche tier heroes have niche application on certain maps or for certain team compositions. They are generally picked to "round out" your team composition when your team composition is missing out on key components, such as a "jungler" (mercenary camps), a solo laner, or solid waveclear.
       
      Bottom Tier
      The Lost Vikings Bottom tier Heroes are deemed to be either considerably weaker than the majority of other Heroes, or much more challenging to play properly. Although they may situationally shine, these Heroes are generally avoided by most players.
       
      Metagame assessment
      Greetings. Regulars may have noticed that the changes featured in this month's list have been more aggressive than usual. In essence, I feel like a clear metagame is finally begin to emerge after a slew of important changes, making it easier for me to pinpoint notable trends. And so, the result is a volatile tier list that should be extremely stable next month. Shall we begin?
      I like Garrosh quite a bit, and I can't help but feel that the combined novelty and high skill cap skew his win rates towards the bottom of the roster. Case in point: his Master level win rates are nearly 12% higher than his Bronze level win rates. This is a case of Medivh all over again; however, whereas both Garrosh and Medivh did start at 30-something-percent win rates, Garrosh has been steadily climbing over the week. Both Diablo and Stitches are currently very popular picks, and Garrosh provides similar utility through his Groundbreaker + Wrecking Ball combo. Talents to watch out for are undoubtedly Warbreaker (reduced cooldown on Groundbreaker, level 1) and Intimidation (40% reduced attack speed on targets hit by Groundbreaker, level 7), which allow Garrosh to neuter basic attack reliant heroes much earlier than other heroes can. Into the Fray (can use Wrecking Ball on allies once every 30 seconds, level 7) is also an interesting one as it gives Garrosh his own version of Cleanse and  the ability to say 'hey, you're mispositioned, stop it', which should come in handy whenever an ally is, well, not standing where they should be. It also breaks Lamb to the Slaughter on top of a few other nasty heroic abilities, which is great.
      Stitches has finally ascended to godhood, and although I was slow to give him a seat in the core tier, repeated high level hero league bans and a high amount of tournament play speak for themselves. As stated last month, the Slam build remains an easy way of topping the damage charts all while being difficult to kill. Gorge has also seen an upsurge in popularity, and particularly on maps where combat tends to happen close by fortifications, such as Dragon Shire, Tomb of the Spider Queen, Towers of Doom, et cetera. Couple this with Falstad's Mighty Gust, and you have a game winning combo that isn't all that difficult to pull off.
      I don't have much to say about Greymane that isn't self-obvious; Cursed Bullet is a great choice in a meta where healthy tanks are popular, though Go for the Throat is also re-emerging for blowup team compositions, thanks to its reliable damage and gap closing feature, on top of its ability to reset.
      To shoehorn last month's tier list again, I made a snarky comment about Tassadar always being either too strong or too weak. Right now, he enables two borderline heroes–Illidan and Tracer–on top of providing flexible heroic ability choices for both more defensive and blowout team compositions. His versatility just makes him never feel like a bad pick, and Oracle keeps the Zeratuls at bay as a bonus.
      E.T.C. is this month's surprise as players sift through forgotten heroes to solo tank, provide potential mapwide mobility through Stage Dive, and just generally provide reliable crowd control. You'll note a sore lack of interruption from a lot of high tier picks as well, making Mosh Pit about as good as it'll get.
      We haven't seen The Butcher be more than a one trick for nearly two years now, but the brute is back in force, thanks for buffs several players have misinterpreted as nerfs. I suspect, however, that some of his newfound success may be due to players having some difficulty adapting to his new gank-heavy playstyle and generally counterpicking him. Shall the Brightwings, Cassias, and Li Lis of the world rise up to the challenge?
      Xul has continued to perform well, and although he is the second least popular core tier hero (right behind Zeratul), he will keep on being effective on Blackheart's Bay, Dragon Shire, Gardens of Terror, Infernal Shrines, and Towers of Doom simply due to the importance of having a strong split pusher on these maps. Just make sure you go for Skeletal Mages, which tend to block a lot of those abilities strong tanks currently rely upon to get picks, on top of being generally disruptive.
    • By Stan

      Lost Cavern is a single-lane battleground that has been chosen for this week's brawl! Complete three matches to earn a Loot Chest.
      Blizzard (Source)
      This week’s brawl is Lost Cavern! It’s all-out mayhem on our single-lane battleground – Lost Cavern. Queue up, choose your Hero, and try to best to bring down the enemy Core!

      Rules:
      Shuffle pick - Choose from one of three Heroes before entering the battle. Standard play - no talent or level restrictions. The first team to destroy the enemy Core wins! Rewards:
      Complete three matches of Lost Cavern to earn a Loot Chest! Find out more about the Heroes Brawl game mode on our Heroes Brawl site; and as always, you can find more information on this week’s Brawl by clicking the Brawl Info button at the bottom of the play screen when preparing to queue for the Brawl game mode.
    • By Stan

      The 90th episode of WTF Moments is here.
      Heroes of the Storm Highlights is back with the 90th episode of WTF Moments.