Stan

Patch 7.3: Upcoming Elemental Shaman Changes & Monks

9 posts in this topic

AbU5AOy.jpg

Elemental Shamans will receive changes in a future 7.3 PTR build next week and Windwalker Monk discussion about scaling continues.

Elemental Shaman Changes

Blizzard LogoBlizzard (Source)

Next PTR will have a small set of Elemental changes meant to focus on a couple specific problems.

Mastery capping


Some of the power of mastery is shifted from proc rate into damage. The nerfs to Totem MasteryTotem Mastery and Elemental BlastElemental Blast don't require talent rebalancing, since they are minor and those are talents are already generally favored. The slight total DPS loss from those changes is counteracted in the baseline spec. With both talents, the mastery cap (with all these changes) would increase from 10400 rating to 15067.

Chain Lightning dominating Earthquake

Chain LightningChain Lightning is so strong that Earthquake is often not attractive to cast. There are also secondary issues such as the importance of Lightning Rod procs and resource overflow in AoE.

Damage is shifted from Chain LightningChain Lightning into EarthquakeEarthquake, and EarthquakeEarthquake is further increased to account for generating less Maelstrom (which helps the overflow issues, including on Static OverloadStatic Overload procs). The Earth ShockEarth Shock buff helps stave off the potential for Earthquake to get too close to it again, and a buff to Earth ShockEarth Shock was pretty reasonable generally.

Again, the goal is to address these issues in a relatively contained way. 7.3 is generally light on class changes, but we wanted to try to get at these known problems. As always, open to feedback on any complications that these look like they might introduce.

--If Elemental BlastElemental Blast is actually behind after the small nerf, it should be relatively easy to correct by buffing its own damage. That said, the current set bonus pushes Primal ElementalistPrimal Elementalist (and that sort of thing is generally acceptable for a tier), which means it's unsurprising if it's slightly ahead on its row for right now.


--We agree EarthquakeEarthquake should be more of a "finisher" out of the two, and this set of changes is trying to go in that direction. It should at least be used consistently in its intended role. It sounds a little odd that changing one spell's damage 45% relative to the other (plus the Maelstrom change) doesn't at all change the number of targets at which you'd use EarthquakeEarthquake, but we're happy to keep looking at any more detailed discussion of why that would be the case.

--The Maelstrom change would be a pacing change, but I think there are some advantages if we keep it and instead put value into buffing EarthquakeEarthquake (further than this if needed). It helps the above discussion of EarthquakeEarthquake actually being worth enough to stand out. The current version where, on average, each Chain LightningChain Lightning pays for more than one EarthquakeEarthquake is a pretty weird builder/spender relationship--and is part of the answer to your question of why EarthquakeEarthquake isn't stronger. Also, Maelstrom overflow is a significant issue currently. In your example of Static OverloadStatic Overload, it currently overflows in literally every case (on 5 targets). Pulling back on that and giving EarthquakeEarthquake  much higher value cuts down on resource waste while making it more valuable when you spend it.

If the main problem is that the EarthquakeEarthquake buff here isn't enough to accomplish the goals as described, that's something we can review further (and of course welcome any further input on that question).

Windwalker Monks Scaling

The concerns were previously raised during the reddit AMA.

Blizzard LogoBlizzard (Source)

I don't know if there's a better thread where this is being discussed, but this thread seems closely related to the work done in the post.

Restating something I'd already said to the author--stat scaling is a massively complicated problem, and basically any rigorous knowledge fed in about it is a helpful addition. The main impediment to discussion on such a large dataset being offered as feedback is having to go through the whole methodology--enough to be sure we're all on the same page as to exactly what it's showing. I expect something as ambitious as "make a chart of all stats for all DPS specs at once" is likely to wind up as a project of perpetual refinement rather than something you can just "do" one day.

Which is all to say: basically all I can do is start with scattered questions/comments as I go through, rather than any kind of grand conclusion.

----

The best chart to spent most time on is probably the "% DPS gained per 475 stats" one.
--Versatility clocks in at 1.00% (+/- 0.01) on nearly all specs. Does that mean that the profiles being used have 0 Versatility?
--More broadly, what "current" stats are being used to generate the weights? As explained above, that affects how stats look relative to each other when viewed as a % of total DPS. If the profiles aren't constructed in a uniform way, some might have more lopsided stat distributions than others.
--Given how few things remain that are left out of Versatility, it might be cleanest to bring them all in at this point. No promise yet.
--For specs that are significantly above 1.00%, are they double-dipping Versatility or is that a simulation artifact?

"I didn’t include Weapon DPS in the averages as there was no easy way to do so and be fair to all specs. If you come up with a way that works, let me know."
--I believe the correct way is to make a weighted sum of Primary and WDPS based on whatever ratio they exist at currently on typical gear (similar to the advice I gave for Stamina).
--The variation in primary stats is a bit curious--looking at casters, where there's no WDPS complication. If, on a caster, all DPS other than trinkets is proportional to Int, the value of Int on all of them should be nearly identical (again after correcting for special cases such as the portion of Demonology damage that scales with Stam). Maybe what I'm saying is: the variation in Int's value seems like a sort of "control"--one way of getting insight into the magnitude of systematic error in the model.
--Trinkets also throw a minor wrench in the works if they're not treated uniformly in the comparison. It seems like you'd have to either avoid RPPM-damage-proc trinkets on everybody (those don't scale with primary), or add another factor representing trinket ilvl and fold it into primary just as with Stam and WDPS.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is fine.

Everything is fine.

*burns with the rest of the house and melts away*

Edited by Suoson
add more meme
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Did a good job with the mastery capping issue, lowers the value of mastery a bit but that's not awful... but the rest...

Elemental shamans- Earthquake isn't strong enough! Blizz- Did someone say chain lightning was too strong? ES- No...we're casting CL because of how EQ hits like a noodle and adds can move out of it. Blizz- EQ not good enough, make the builder worse! ES-.....Blizz why

Our ST and cleave already is middling, that seems like a far more urgent issue. Also redesign static overload, that's the issue with maelstrom capping, not that CL generates too much, the 4 maelstrom chain lightning felt bad when we had it before, I hope they revert that change. Kinda missed the mark here, I hope they do another pass on elemental before live, they probably will. 

Edited by Rag

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

They just keep on juggling with these numbers for EQ and ES. I mentioned this in the other thread as well a month or two back. They just can't get it done.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was so happy when I read the first bit.

Why oh why did you have to ruin it? Single target is the weakness. AoE fights is where we shine. Why do you have to take that tiny bit of "yeah, actually, let's bring an elemental shaman" away from us? 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 22/07/2017 at 4:48 PM, Yridaa said:

They just keep on juggling with these numbers for EQ and ES. I mentioned this in the other thread as well a month or two back. They just can't get it done.

I remember the thread! With suggestions about what they could do to fix it, like having damage of one dependent on the other etc.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, Prophet001 said:

lol that screenshot

 

"This is fine."

Sometimes you just have to embrace it as it burns around you :P

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Starym

       
      Featuring all the articles related to the Tier 21 raid race.
      This is the hub for the Antorus: the Burning Throne Mythic progress coverage, featuring all the articles related to the race.
      Mythic Argus World First Kill by Method - Method close out the raid and end up on top at the start of the second reset.
      Antorus M Race Day 7: Aggramar WF Video - 19 guilds now progressing on Argus and Method and Limit share their Aggramar kill videos.
      Antorus M Race Day 6: Argus Mythic Footage - Style War stream Argus progress and we get to see the Mythic phase, 9 guilds on Argus now and Sco explains why Antorus isn't clear yet.
      Antorus M Race Day 3: Exorsus 10/11, Coven Video - Some hotfix troubles slow Exorsus down but they still catch up, we get another WF video and Asia guilds are back in the overall top 5.
      Antorus M Progress Day 2: Only Argus Left - Method are back on top, there's only 1 boss remaining and we get WF kill videos up to 8/11.
      Antorus M Progress Day 1: 9 Down 2 to Go - Limit dominate day one and we see all but 2 bosses die.
      Antorus Mythic Progress + History of WF Stats - A primer for the race and a rundown of old World Firsts by faction.
    • By Stan

      Method is the first guild to defeat Argus the Unmaker and clear Antorus, the Burning Throne on Mythic difficulty. Congratulations!
      Killshot

      It took 320 wipes to down Legion's final boss.
      Placeholder for tweet 940978088053178368 Placeholder for tweet 940981561377345536
    • By joat
      Who We Are
      Tequila Sundown is a growing raid team formed within the <Karma Horde> guild on US-Stormreaver. Lead by a husband/wife team with high-level raiding experience dating back to WotLK, we're a "positively determined" progression team that maintains a light-hearted atmosphere while tackling mythic difficulty content. We're mature adults with jobs and family seeking like-minded players who have a passion for the game but want to avoid the needless angst or drama that often gets associated with progression raiding. We log on to have fun - so come have some fun with us!

      A Team Within a Community
      Our raid team is one of four within the larger guild of <Karma Horde>, which was formed back during WotLK. As such, the guild and Discord are very active and social. There are always people around online and in-game. The community atmosphere is welcoming and friendly to players of all levels. The guild enforces a Code of Conduct that has zero tolerance for hate/offensive speech.

      We care more about the people we play with than their item levels or progression rankings. We want players who are going to log in on non-raid nights and be down for all the other things we're into: pushing mythic+, doing world quests, PVP shenanigans, achievement hunting, hyper-competitive fishing.. there's so much to do and so many ways to enjoy the game. This is our favorite hobby and we'd like to play with you if it is yours, too.

      Progression Goals
      We are 5/11-Heroic 11/11-Normal Antorus, having killed every boss we've pulled.
      We strive for a fun environment that takes the challenges of mythic seriously and giving the content the respect it deserves. Our aim is, as all mythic teams, full clear of content but with always keeping the friendly spirit of camaraderie alive. Performance matters, but so does staying positive and finding the fun in the difficulty of a raid.
      We do not require mythic raid experience to join our team but we do expect mythic-level dedication and accountability from all of our raiders.

      Raid Days/Times
      Our mandatory raids are:
      Tuesdays 8:45pm PT - 11:45pm PT
      Thursdays 8:45pm PT - 11:45pm PT
      Optional:
      Sundays 8:45pm PT - 11:45pm PT
      Sundays are for raiding the previous raid difficulty.

      Recruitment Needs
      DPS:  YES. Ranged DPS - will consider all, but would love to pick up a Hunter and a Mage. Melee DPS - prefer Enhance Shaman or Survival Hunter.
      Healers: NO. No current needs.
      Tank: NO. No current needs.

      The Nitty Gritty
      If you're intrigued, please check out our wiki on the <Karma Horde> subreddit. This will give you the inside picture on how we operate as a raid team.
      https://www.reddit.com/r/FTH/wiki/tequilasundown

      Contact Us
      You can reach us on bnet: joat#1832 & lambkill#1856
      or Discord: joat#6049 & saever#4432
    • By Stan

      An overview of this week's most important events in Azeroth.
      Antorus Mythic Race
      19 guilds are now at Mythic Argus. Check out our latest coverage of the race here!
      Mythic Keystone Affixes
      Teeming Explosive Fortified World Bosses (Upcoming World Boss Schedule (Until February 2018)
      Don't forget to bring a Seal of Broken Fate for a bonus roll in the Greater Invasion Point.
      Flotsam
      Enhancement Shamans can get The Warmace of Shirvallah from this week's world boss.
      Blackwater Raider Handguards Faded Bloodsail Handwraps Kezan Pirate's Mitts "Liberated" Un'goro Relic Marshstomper Oracle's Loop Ragged Azsharan Sail Fragment Salt-Stained Tuskarr Gloves Sothanator
      Sothanator is up on Argus and the portal is located in Mac'Aree (44, 50).
      Bracers of Diabolic Fury Enthralling Chain Armor Fel-Linked Crushers Gauntlets of Barbaric Cruelty Gloves of Grim Direction Gore-Soaked Legplates Horned Hood of Retaliation Robes of Demonic Purpose Spaulders of Vile Determination Spike of Immortal Command Sotanathor's Thundering Hoof Subjugated Drudge's Leggings Waistguard of Devilish Deeds World Events
      Arena Skirmishes Bonus Event (December 12 - 19)
      Complete "The Arena Calls" to get Badge of Honor, Champion's Strongbox & Glory of the Melee (Artifact Power token).
      Blizzard (Source)
      Sharpen your swords and reinforce your boards, because you’re called to the PvP Arena for the hectic mayhem of Skirmishes.
      THIS WEEK: ARENA SKIRMISHES
      All week, from anywhere in Azeroth, open the Group Finder (default hotkey: i), select the Player vs. Player tab on the bottom of the window, and then under Casual, choose Arena Skirmish and JOIN BATTLE. You’ll be matched up with teammates and provided with opponents to kill in the Arena. You can also queue for a Premade group or create your own group within the Premade tab. 
      Look for the following all week long:
      Archmage Lan’dalock near Violet Hold in Dalaran has a quest for you. Or, if you forget to pick it up there, you can start it from within the Adventure Journal. Quest requirement: Win 10 Arena PvP Skirmishes Reward: A PvP loot box Passive buff: +50% honor gains from Skirmishes (Sign of the Skirmisher) If you’ve been looking to make some Honor gains, this is the week to do it!
      WHAT ARE BONUS EVENTS?
      The Bonus Events system consists of a rotating schedule of different activities, currently scheduled to run each week beginning on Tuesdays. Each Bonus Event grants a passive bonus to a particular game activity and offers a once-per-event quest with a noteworthy reward for accomplishing a related goal. The in-game calendar can serve as your one-stop reference for the event schedule. The Adventure Guide also offers a direct link to active Bonus Events, allowing you to easily accept any associated quests.
      Gravity Lapse PvP Brawl (December 12 - 19)
      Don't forget to complete the weekly quest "Something Different" to get Brawler's Footlocker, 3 Marks of Honor and Soldier's Legacy (Artifact Power token).
      Blizzard (Source)
      Gravity getting you down? Step into the Eye of the Storm and be prepared for a whole new en-lighten-ing experience. Every minute, players on the battlefield will find themselves launched into the air, only to gently fall toward the ground again in a perpetual aerial ballet as they try to accrue enough resources to take the win home for their team.
      Feast of Winter Veil (December 16 - January 2)
      The celebration starts this Saturday. For more details check out our Feast of Winter Veil guide.
    • By Starym

       
      Vengeance DH Pain generation fixes, Antorus fixes as well as a Varimathras Mythic nerf are the focus of today's hotfixes.
      December 12 (source)
      Classes
      Demon Hunter Vengeance Demon Hunters now correctly generate Pain when damaged by certain abilities.  
      Dungeons and Raids
      Seat of the Triumvirate Players may now complete "Seat of the Triumvirate: The Crest of Knowledge" while in a raid group. Antorus, The Burning Throne Corrected an issue where raids that queued for LFR difficulty could fail to get loot. Garothi Worldbreaker The damage reduction from Apocalypse Drive and from a Druid’s Earthwarden can now activate during the Garothi Worldbreaker encounter. Hounds of Sargeras Resolved an issue that could cause multiple tank-specialization characters to gain Shadowtouched (or Flametouched) simultaneously. Portal Keeper Hasabel Traversing any of the portals within Portal Keeper Hasabel's arena no longer removes your Well Fed buff. Varimathras [WITH SERVER RESTARTS IN EACH REGION] Varimathras' health lowered by 10% in Mythic difficulty. [WITH SERVER RESTARTS IN EACH REGION] Necrotic Embrace will no longer miss players who are under the effects of Aspect of the Turtle or Cloak of Shadows. Previous patch 7.3.2 hotfixes:
      December 6 December 5 December 1 November 21 November 14