Odinn

Does Warlords Need More Pruning?

Sign in to follow this  

7 posts in this topic

10001-does-warlords-need-more-pruning.jp

 

One of the major iterative design processes that underpinned Warlords of Draenor's overall direction was simplification. With the removal of old stats, various forms of crowd control, class abilities, guild leveling/bonuses, reforging, and more, Blizzard hinted that they wanted the game to evolve to a place that was more accessible. Is there more to come?

 

Looking at some of the other changes that have been made so far with this expansion, there are certainly possibilities. The challenge for the developers, of course, is balancing things that demonstrate character progression or significant time investments with long-term game health and playability.

 

So, what are some further adjustments that could be considered in the future? Here are a handful of examples:

  • Mount riding skills/passives. These seem largely redundant in an era of character boosts; with no ability to fly in Draenor, all of the riding passives seem largely obsolete.
  • In-game languages. These are functionally an adorable artifact of the game's much more RPG-driven roots.
  • Gathering professions. These have been made almost entirely redundant by the Garrison, and it certainly feels as if Blizzard has a long-term vision that would eliminate them altogether based on the Garrison implementation.
  • First Aid. An entirely separate secondary profession whose purpose is the creation of a singular item (and could be obviated by making Healthstones heal for the same amount as Healing Tonics) seems absurd.
  • Profession features like Prospecting and Smelting (and, long term, Milling and Disenchanting). Neither of these function on modern materials anyway - a minor update to deal with old world recipes/materials would eliminate them outright.
  • Deprecated currencies. Many old currencies are already no longer functional, and eliminating the clutter and confusion of currencies from non-current content would be a welcome improvement.

In addition to wholesale removals, there are certainly places where intelligent tweaks could be made. Efforts to consolidate or limit the effects of absent buffs for groups/raids, consumables, etc. have progressed steadily throughout Warcraft's history, but a number of them still have bizarre places in the game. With the irrelevant cost of materials for things like Savage Feasts, the time wasted by players to utilize them after wipes feels strange (and flies in the face of mechanics like the major cooldown reset, which explicitly eliminates the stand-around-and-wait effect!).

 

(As an aside - Draenor Perks feel like the type of feature that is absolutely designed to be removed eventually. Those level-driven random upgrades could easily be unlocked and treated as a baseline part of the affected abilities as early as next tier.)

 

Would you like to see further pruning to clean up some of the game's bloat? Are there features or inclusions that seem redundant or unnecessary to you that aren't mentioned here? Let us know what you think.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just the other day I was considering this.

 

Profession levels feel largely obsolete in WoD. All of the relevant crafting products can be learned and created equally by new and experienced crafters alike. The only differences I was able to find are that daily cooldowns produce more at higher levels (a system that doesn't actually reward the time you spend with a profession, rather it rewards the amount of money you have to drop on leveling it) and the existence of old-world items that very few would craft.

 

As you pointed out, "Draenor Perks" feels like a feature that was added only to be eventually removed. It adds needless complication to your spellbook and makes abilities work differently from when you learn them only for the sake of making the leveling process feel rewarding (going back to cast time Rebirth while leveling a new druid was a pain, and I had gotten so used to it that I didn't understand why it wouldn't work at first). I can't see them continueing to add perks for expansions to come without making some of these effects baseline. I don't want to have to fish through a page of 12 passives to remember why an ability is different.

 

This isn't quite a feature that needs pruning, but realms have begun to feel like an archaic feature that Blizzard continues to try to breath life into. Whether it's for the sake of nostalgia, comfort, familiarity, or money from realm transfers -- the artificial division of players that realms provide feels more and more out of place with each expansion as the World of Warcraft grows more interconnected. While realms and guilds have provided a sense of comradery and companionship in the past; it now feels like you are explicitly excluded from certain activities if you find a cross-realm group that you like (you can raid heroic, but can't raid mythic -- you can join parties, but can't join the guild).

Edited by Deathshiver

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This isn't quite a feature that needs pruning, but realms have begun to feel like an archaic feature that Blizzard continues to try to breath life into. Whether it's for the sake of nostalgia, comfort, familiarity, or money from realm transfers -- the artificial division of players that realms provide feels more and more out of place with each expansion as the World of Warcraft grows more interconnected. While realms and guilds have provided a sense of comradery and companionship in the past; it now feels like you are explicitly excluded from certain activities if you find a cross-realm group that you like (you can raid heroic, but can't raid mythic -- you can join parties, but can't join the guild).

The problem here is actually physical - the load that the servers can take is only so much, and once it gets to be too much everyone starts to get lag, and you can see an example of this with the launch of warlords.  The advent of cross realm zones and connected realms are improvements on this technology, but it is still limited in what can be done.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The problem here is actually physical - the load that the servers can take is only so much, and once it gets to be too much everyone starts to get lag, and you can see an example of this with the launch of warlords.  The advent of cross realm zones and connected realms are improvements on this technology, but it is still limited in what can be done.

Yeah, I totally get that. There's clearly physical reasons for realms, but their inter-connectivity is still divided. What physical reason is there for not allowing cross-realm mythic raiding? There are alternative approaches to a lot of things in the game that won't require this artificial division which can only be overcome with a paid transfer. It's this separation of players that I feel is archaic from a time where the technology to play with other realms didn't exist.

Edited by Deathshiver

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yeah, I totally get that. There's clearly physical reasons for realms, but their inter-connectivity is still divided. What physical reason is there for not allowing cross-realm mythic raiding? There are alternative approaches to a lot of things in the game that won't require this artificial division which can only be overcome with a paid transfer. It's this separation of players that I feel is archaic from a time where the technology to play with other realms didn't exist.

There isn't a physical reason for not doing cross realm mythic, and they did do that with the end of SoO.  However, as for doing it for Highmaul, there is a blue post explaining why they don't:

 

Mythic is a different concept from all other difficulties and it's not meant to be PUG friendly.

Not enabling cross-realm mythic is a design decision. Enabling this option would imply that this content should be doable by PUGs, and because it clearly isn't, it would only lead to frustration, complaints and nerf requests.

What is happening is that some players are finding mythic Kargath to be doable with very good PUGs, but we have to keep in mind that this is only happening because he's the very first raid boss from this expansion, so he's a bit more accessible than the rest.

When Blackrock Foundry (our next raid tier) launches, it's unlikely that the difficulty level from the first boss will be proportional to Kargath's when compared to the rest of the bosses of each respective tier.

Also, we're likely going to enable cross-realm mythic Highmaul when the next tier arrives.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There isn't a physical reason for not doing cross realm mythic, and they did do that with the end of SoO.  However, as for doing it for Highmaul, there is a blue post explaining why they don't:

That was the entire point I was trying to make. It's not like the players on one person's realm are inherently better than cross-realm. As an example, I'm really good friends with a number of players on Cenarion Circle, all of which are mythic-ready raiders that I raided with a little over a year ago. Unfortunately, my characters are now on Area 52 because I transferred to play with a friend. Without another realm transfer, I can't play high level content with them. Them being on a different realm doesn't inherently make them pugs or not capable of mythic as Blizzard would suggest to you here. Why is it that when you join a random group with people not on your realm it is worse than joining a random group with people in trade chat? The division here is purely artificial. The reason it implies that the content is doable by pugs is because the only content currently available cross-realm is pug content. Rather than reinforcing that the only good groups are the ones on your server, Blizzard should be trying to improve the resources that allow you to find a perfect group suited to you. It's an archaic system that, for one reason or another, they want to keep around.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I haven't had the opportunity to play WOD yet, but it sounds like professions are in a weird place. The thing I wish for WOW's future is for professions to be more customizable. I am an artist in real life, and I wish there was a way to express that through the game. Imagine how cool it would be if there was a new profession like Sculpting, or Painting. I also feel this way about blacksmithing or leatherworking. The ability to design patterns into cloaks or shoulder pads or whatever would be so awesome.

 

Imagine walking into someone's garrison (if that becomes an option someday) and seeing a badass statue. Someone would be like "Whoa man where'd you get that?" You could then casually smirk and be all like, "Oh yeah, it's an Oddin." And then just smoothly walk away like a boss. XD

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Starym
      Several redditors spotted a new entry in the beta/PTR event calendar, featuring the pre-expansion event. It's already started on the PTR and it's called the War of the Thorns, featuring conflict in Darkshore for control of Teldrassil. Now, we know how that particular "control" ends up, but hopefully the event itself won't be as fire-y!
      Also, based on the length of the event, it seems most likely we'll be seeing it come up on live servers on or around July 17th, if we assume it will last until the expansion launch itself, so we have a little over three and a half weeks until we see the pre-expansion event and the pre-patch itself as well! It's a little unclear if the Battle for Lordaeron will be part of the pre-patch or will be available at launch, so the date might actually be a little earlier since it seems logical that the events won't overlap, as one is caused by the other. so another possible date would be July 10th.

      Also, check out what you should do before the pre-patch goes live, as there are achievements to be had that will be removed.
    • By Zadina
      A little bit before the end of Legion, it's time to determine once and for all who's the best Mythic+ team worldwide in the second installment of the Mythic Dungeon Invitational!
      The action begins tomorrow at 09:00 am PDT and will continue on for the entire weekend. You can tune in on the official Warcraft Twitch channel to watch the final showdown between the eight finalists. The team compositions aren't known yet, so it's not sure if any changes have been made for the grand finals. Still, let's find out a bit more about them!
      Representing China, we have Skyline D and Sun Sky, both of whom unfortunately couldn't fly to Columbus, Ohio, so they will be playing from their home country. Being the first region to start the Group Stage, China was the one to look for. Skyline D went undefeated with their 3-melee DPS composition and they displayed various tactics that were subsequently copied from teams from other regions. Sun Sky showed what a beast Arcane Mage is in Black Rook Hold, prompting Blizzard to finally hotfix the buff Mages could spellsteal in that dungeon.
      In the Americas, we see crowd favourites and record setters Method NA, as well as Team Omegasniped. Even though they don't have their Demon Hunter tank Shakib, Method NA is still in it to win it. Earlier this year, Starym sat down with this all-star team in a two-part interview (Part 1 + Part 2)! Team Omegasniped also has some well known players, who are pretty versatile in the class they play with depending on the dungeon.
      Europe is my region, so I am excited to see one of our two teams be victorious. Kjell's Angels, the only finalist team with a Balance Druid (Kjell), were victorious in the European Group Stage. Team PogChamp also shined through their regionals and they were subsequently picked up by Method. Method PogChamp is a team with popular streamers, two caster DPS and Drjay is ready to set things on fire!
      Lastly, from the APAC region we have the defending champions from the previous MDI, Free Marsy. Even though they were considered an outsider last year, they finished victorious and they had a pretty convincing performance in the Group Stage. Unfortunately, for the Global finals they've had to sub their healer. The other APAC team is Gulch Trotters, who are also a force to be reckoned with.
      The rules are slightly different from the Group Stage; we have covered them in this article. Essentially, we will see higher keys (23 to 25), affixes locked per map with Skittish making a return, greater variation of maps and an increase of the Artifact weapon's item level to 995. The rules for remakes, which plagued the Group Stage, are much clearer and stricter now.
      May the best team win!
    • By Stan
      Blizzard just released a preview of PvP changes coming in Battle for Azeroth. Your rank will be displayed in real time, rated play in any bracket will count toward earning Vicious mounts, and more!
      Highlights
      Blizzard wants to increase clarity and offer a structured progression that recognizes players' accomplishments in real time as they climb through ranks in BfA. Rewards that await in specific brackets will be clearly displayed in the game's interface. Conquest points are back as a measure of Rated PvP activity. If you've filled up your Conquest bar for the week, you'll receive a reward in the chest of an appropriate item level (similar to the weekly Grand Challenger's Bounty chest). in Battle for Azeroth, Rated play in any bracket—including 2v2! —will count toward earning Vicious PvP mounts. Blizzard (Source)
      With the upcoming Battle for Azeroth expansion, we’re overhauling the game’s PvP progression and reward systems. Today, we wanted to take some time to break down those changes and provide some information on what Rated Battleground and Arena participants can look forward to.
      New Tiers and Rating Bands
      For years, participants in World of Warcraft’s Rated PvP have received numerical Elo-based ratings based on their performance, but what that number means to a player is fairly opaque. Participants currently have to wait until the very end of a PvP season for us to review the full standings and assign titles like Gladiator or Rival based on their relative standing.
      In Battle for Azeroth, we want to increase clarity and offer a more structured progression that recognizes players’ accomplishments in real time as they climb through the ranks. As players reach the following rating thresholds, they will enter formal brackets:
      Combatant: 1400–1599 Challenger: 1600–1799 Rival: 1800–2099 Duelist: 2100–2399 Gladiator: 2400+ The specific rewards available in each of these brackets which will be clearly shown in the game’s interface so players can work their way toward earning the items they want most.
      Skill and Participation Rewards
      We’re focusing on two things as we delve into how players earn rewards for taking part in Rated PvP. One focus is refining and clarifying how we reward skill, and the other focus is providing clarity around how we reward participation at varying levels.
      PARTICIPATION MATTERS
      The feedback we heard around Legion’s PvP rewards pointed toward players’ desire for a more controllable and predictable gearing path. To that end, we’re bringing back Conquest points as a measure of Rated PvP activity; we’re also offering a specific piece of raid-quality gear each week, adding up to full sets of increasing quality over the course of a season. This will make it so players have better visibility into how much time and effort they’ll need to put into earning a specific item and will counterbalance the random nature of rewards elsewhere in the system.
      We’re also changing how players can earn Vicious mounts. In the current Legion system, you need to win 100 Rated 3v3 Arena or 40 Rated Battleground matches. In Battle for Azeroth, Rated play in any bracket—including 2v2! —will count toward earning these mounts. And in line with our philosophy around making cosmetic rewards account-wide, your PvP efforts account-wide will count toward earning these rewards for your collection.
      IN FOR THE SKILL
      With these updates, we want to make sure we’re providing PvP rewards that are commensurate with someone’s level of play. To this end, we’re adding an end-of-the week reward along the lines of the weekly Grand Challenger’s Bounty chests you can earn for doing Mythic Keystone dungeons. These weekly rewards can be collected from a chest in the Dueler’s Guild PvP hub in either Zuldazar (Horde) or Boralus (Alliance).
      If you’ve filled up your Conquest bar for the week, you’ll receive a reward in the chest of an appropriate item level. The item level of the reward will be based on the highest bracket in which you won at least one game last week. For example, if you played and won at Duelist in 3v3, expect to receive a reward with an appropriate item level for your ranking at the end of the week. However, if you were rated as a Duelist in 3v3, but only participated in 2v2, you wouldn’t receive a Duelist level item unless you had won a game in 3v3.
      WHO’S THE GREATEST?
      To help provide even more transparency, we’re adding regional tracking so that once you’ve reached Gladiator, you will be able to see where you rank in your region right within the interface. For those aiming to make your way to the very top of the rankings, you’ll be able to keep a close eye on just how far you have to go to get there, or even brag to your friends about just how far you’ve gone.
      END OF THE SEASON?
      We’re still in the process of working out the possible end-of-season rewards, but for now we can say we’ll be keeping the special seasonal Gladiator titles for the very top players at the end of each season. Those who get the Gladiator title will also need to win an additional number of games to earn the mount as their reward.
      We have more in store for PvP beyond Rated play, so be sure to check back here for more!
    • By Blainie
      A new week with new chances for beta keys!
      It's a new week and the perfect opportunity to give out a new batch of beta keys for Battle for Azeroth! This week, we're going to be putting multiple contests into certain news posts that discuss something WoW-related. Each post will act as a separate contest that users can enter, with a total of 4 going live on the forums and an additional 1 on Twitter.
      We understand that it can be tough to keep track of which contest is where, so this post will act as a homepage for the upcoming contests. You can check back here to see exactly which contests are live, what you have to do to enter and how many keys are being given away.
      Please note that you cannot enter any contests on this post directly; you will need to follow the link to the contest and enter there.
      Here is the list of this week's contests:
      [FORUM] Giveaway 1 - [Closed] All winners for G1 have been contacted by PM. [FORUM] Giveaway 2 - [Closed] All winners for G2 have been contacted by PM. [FORUM] Will go live 22/06 [FORUM] Will go live 22/06 [FORUM] Will go live 23/06 While the giveaway-specific rules are listed above, we also have a general set of rules that apply to every giveaway. You can find them listed here.
      We wish any entrants the best of luck in each giveaway they enter and hope that we'll see many of you enjoying the beta shortly after! For any questions you might have about this post or the giveaways, you can ask them in this thread and I will do my best to answer them promptly.
    • By Stan
      Save up to 25% on select character services during the latest sale! The offer is available through June 24.
      Earlier today, Blizzard upgraded inactive accounts to WoD and gave them free game time. You can find more details here. You can now save 25% on the following services:
      Appearance Change Character Transfer Faction Change Name Change Race Change Blizzard Shop [US] // Blizzard Shop [EU]