Odinn

Does Warlords Need More Pruning?

Sign in to follow this  

7 posts in this topic

10001-does-warlords-need-more-pruning.jp

 

One of the major iterative design processes that underpinned Warlords of Draenor's overall direction was simplification. With the removal of old stats, various forms of crowd control, class abilities, guild leveling/bonuses, reforging, and more, Blizzard hinted that they wanted the game to evolve to a place that was more accessible. Is there more to come?

 

Looking at some of the other changes that have been made so far with this expansion, there are certainly possibilities. The challenge for the developers, of course, is balancing things that demonstrate character progression or significant time investments with long-term game health and playability.

 

So, what are some further adjustments that could be considered in the future? Here are a handful of examples:

  • Mount riding skills/passives. These seem largely redundant in an era of character boosts; with no ability to fly in Draenor, all of the riding passives seem largely obsolete.
  • In-game languages. These are functionally an adorable artifact of the game's much more RPG-driven roots.
  • Gathering professions. These have been made almost entirely redundant by the Garrison, and it certainly feels as if Blizzard has a long-term vision that would eliminate them altogether based on the Garrison implementation.
  • First Aid. An entirely separate secondary profession whose purpose is the creation of a singular item (and could be obviated by making Healthstones heal for the same amount as Healing Tonics) seems absurd.
  • Profession features like Prospecting and Smelting (and, long term, Milling and Disenchanting). Neither of these function on modern materials anyway - a minor update to deal with old world recipes/materials would eliminate them outright.
  • Deprecated currencies. Many old currencies are already no longer functional, and eliminating the clutter and confusion of currencies from non-current content would be a welcome improvement.

In addition to wholesale removals, there are certainly places where intelligent tweaks could be made. Efforts to consolidate or limit the effects of absent buffs for groups/raids, consumables, etc. have progressed steadily throughout Warcraft's history, but a number of them still have bizarre places in the game. With the irrelevant cost of materials for things like Savage Feasts, the time wasted by players to utilize them after wipes feels strange (and flies in the face of mechanics like the major cooldown reset, which explicitly eliminates the stand-around-and-wait effect!).

 

(As an aside - Draenor Perks feel like the type of feature that is absolutely designed to be removed eventually. Those level-driven random upgrades could easily be unlocked and treated as a baseline part of the affected abilities as early as next tier.)

 

Would you like to see further pruning to clean up some of the game's bloat? Are there features or inclusions that seem redundant or unnecessary to you that aren't mentioned here? Let us know what you think.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just the other day I was considering this.

 

Profession levels feel largely obsolete in WoD. All of the relevant crafting products can be learned and created equally by new and experienced crafters alike. The only differences I was able to find are that daily cooldowns produce more at higher levels (a system that doesn't actually reward the time you spend with a profession, rather it rewards the amount of money you have to drop on leveling it) and the existence of old-world items that very few would craft.

 

As you pointed out, "Draenor Perks" feels like a feature that was added only to be eventually removed. It adds needless complication to your spellbook and makes abilities work differently from when you learn them only for the sake of making the leveling process feel rewarding (going back to cast time Rebirth while leveling a new druid was a pain, and I had gotten so used to it that I didn't understand why it wouldn't work at first). I can't see them continueing to add perks for expansions to come without making some of these effects baseline. I don't want to have to fish through a page of 12 passives to remember why an ability is different.

 

This isn't quite a feature that needs pruning, but realms have begun to feel like an archaic feature that Blizzard continues to try to breath life into. Whether it's for the sake of nostalgia, comfort, familiarity, or money from realm transfers -- the artificial division of players that realms provide feels more and more out of place with each expansion as the World of Warcraft grows more interconnected. While realms and guilds have provided a sense of comradery and companionship in the past; it now feels like you are explicitly excluded from certain activities if you find a cross-realm group that you like (you can raid heroic, but can't raid mythic -- you can join parties, but can't join the guild).

Edited by Deathshiver

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This isn't quite a feature that needs pruning, but realms have begun to feel like an archaic feature that Blizzard continues to try to breath life into. Whether it's for the sake of nostalgia, comfort, familiarity, or money from realm transfers -- the artificial division of players that realms provide feels more and more out of place with each expansion as the World of Warcraft grows more interconnected. While realms and guilds have provided a sense of comradery and companionship in the past; it now feels like you are explicitly excluded from certain activities if you find a cross-realm group that you like (you can raid heroic, but can't raid mythic -- you can join parties, but can't join the guild).

The problem here is actually physical - the load that the servers can take is only so much, and once it gets to be too much everyone starts to get lag, and you can see an example of this with the launch of warlords.  The advent of cross realm zones and connected realms are improvements on this technology, but it is still limited in what can be done.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The problem here is actually physical - the load that the servers can take is only so much, and once it gets to be too much everyone starts to get lag, and you can see an example of this with the launch of warlords.  The advent of cross realm zones and connected realms are improvements on this technology, but it is still limited in what can be done.

Yeah, I totally get that. There's clearly physical reasons for realms, but their inter-connectivity is still divided. What physical reason is there for not allowing cross-realm mythic raiding? There are alternative approaches to a lot of things in the game that won't require this artificial division which can only be overcome with a paid transfer. It's this separation of players that I feel is archaic from a time where the technology to play with other realms didn't exist.

Edited by Deathshiver

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yeah, I totally get that. There's clearly physical reasons for realms, but their inter-connectivity is still divided. What physical reason is there for not allowing cross-realm mythic raiding? There are alternative approaches to a lot of things in the game that won't require this artificial division which can only be overcome with a paid transfer. It's this separation of players that I feel is archaic from a time where the technology to play with other realms didn't exist.

There isn't a physical reason for not doing cross realm mythic, and they did do that with the end of SoO.  However, as for doing it for Highmaul, there is a blue post explaining why they don't:

 

Mythic is a different concept from all other difficulties and it's not meant to be PUG friendly.

Not enabling cross-realm mythic is a design decision. Enabling this option would imply that this content should be doable by PUGs, and because it clearly isn't, it would only lead to frustration, complaints and nerf requests.

What is happening is that some players are finding mythic Kargath to be doable with very good PUGs, but we have to keep in mind that this is only happening because he's the very first raid boss from this expansion, so he's a bit more accessible than the rest.

When Blackrock Foundry (our next raid tier) launches, it's unlikely that the difficulty level from the first boss will be proportional to Kargath's when compared to the rest of the bosses of each respective tier.

Also, we're likely going to enable cross-realm mythic Highmaul when the next tier arrives.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There isn't a physical reason for not doing cross realm mythic, and they did do that with the end of SoO.  However, as for doing it for Highmaul, there is a blue post explaining why they don't:

That was the entire point I was trying to make. It's not like the players on one person's realm are inherently better than cross-realm. As an example, I'm really good friends with a number of players on Cenarion Circle, all of which are mythic-ready raiders that I raided with a little over a year ago. Unfortunately, my characters are now on Area 52 because I transferred to play with a friend. Without another realm transfer, I can't play high level content with them. Them being on a different realm doesn't inherently make them pugs or not capable of mythic as Blizzard would suggest to you here. Why is it that when you join a random group with people not on your realm it is worse than joining a random group with people in trade chat? The division here is purely artificial. The reason it implies that the content is doable by pugs is because the only content currently available cross-realm is pug content. Rather than reinforcing that the only good groups are the ones on your server, Blizzard should be trying to improve the resources that allow you to find a perfect group suited to you. It's an archaic system that, for one reason or another, they want to keep around.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I haven't had the opportunity to play WOD yet, but it sounds like professions are in a weird place. The thing I wish for WOW's future is for professions to be more customizable. I am an artist in real life, and I wish there was a way to express that through the game. Imagine how cool it would be if there was a new profession like Sculpting, or Painting. I also feel this way about blacksmithing or leatherworking. The ability to design patterns into cloaks or shoulder pads or whatever would be so awesome.

 

Imagine walking into someone's garrison (if that becomes an option someday) and seeing a badass statue. Someone would be like "Whoa man where'd you get that?" You could then casually smirk and be all like, "Oh yeah, it's an Oddin." And then just smoothly walk away like a boss. XD

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Stan

      A look at the remaining battle pets added in Patch 7.3.
      Raiding with Leashes V: Cuteaclysm is coming and we did a preview of all new pets obtainabable from Cataclysm raids here. In another article we looked at Naxxy and Model D1-BB-L3R. Now's time to explore the rest of the pets added in Patch 7.3.
      Achievements
      Felclaw Marsuul from Family Fighter.
      Argus Zones
      Antoran Wastes
      Antoran Bile Larva Antoran Bilescourge Cross Gazer from A Pile of Intact Demon Eyes Rebellious Imp Uuna
      Mac'Aree
      Arcane Gorger Felcrazed Wyrm Grasping Manifestation Pygmy Marsuul Skyfin Juvenile Void Shardling Voidstalker Runt Warpstalker Runt
      Krokuun
      Bile Larva Bilescourge Flickering Argunite
      Egg (from Fel-Spotted Egg (5 days hatch time)
      Docile Skyfin  Fel-Afflicted Skyfin
      N/A
      Golden Retriever (Source: PH)
      Professions
      Fel Lasher (Herbalism) Fossorial Bile Larva (Skinning) Ghost Shark (Fishing)
      Reputation
      Orphaned Marsuul (Argussian Reach Honored)
      Winter Veil
      Globe Yeti
    • By Stan

      Two weeks ago, Blizzard started the PvP Like a Pro series, where they talk to world best Arena players. The first part was about finding the right partners and the second discussed team composition. Part 3 is devoted to effective practicing.
      Blizzard (Source)
      Part 3 - Practicing Effectively
      Minpojke of team Northern Gaming Blue has achieved rank one in Arena every season since 2011. His current squad has been playing together for more than two years, and came third in the Global Finals at BlizzCon 2016. With his help, we’ve built a five-step guide to help you practice like a pro!
      Synergy - Align Your Team
      Before setting out on your quest to the top, make sure you’re “aligned as a team,” says Minpojke. Like in any group activity, “it’s very important that everyone has the same goals and the same drive to do what it takes to win.” Make sure your team shares similar ambitions, and is aligned on how much effort will be required to achieve them. And of course, make sure you have similar gaming schedules so you can play and practice together!
      Atmosphere - Stay Positive
      It’s important to have a good atmosphere while playing. Minpojke says, “If you and your group get along and even become friends, you’ll like playing and actually learn more as well.” Be sure that the mood stays positive so that you can enjoy competing and improving together. It’s much easier to keep a team motivated if you’re all having fun—it’s a game after all!
      Stated more simply, Minpojke says, “It’s easy to win as a team—in the sense that it’s easy to be happy and celebrate—but if you’re capable of losing together, then you’ll be a great team.”
      Strategy - Know the Meta
      When it comes to making practice effective, Minpojke feels it’s a priority to stay up to date with the current meta. He told us that the best way to do this is to follow tournaments, high-level Arena streams, and the PvP Leaderboards to see which classes are on top.
      “It’s quite easy to keep up with the meta. Watch streams to see what the pros are playing, and track the ladder to see which classes and compositions are at the top. And don’t forget to follow tournaments to see the best comps shine.” Once you’re confident in what you want to play, it’s time to queue up! As FabsS discussed in our previous interview, Minpojke says that it’s important to set your win condition before the gates open. “Ask what you want to achieve as a team; will you focus on a lot of CC or try to draw out the game longer?” Since you know what matchup you’ll be playing against, you can start to ask these questions and develop your strategy.
      Analysis - Review Your Games
      If your setup supports it, Minpojke recommends recording as many sessions as you can—they’re much more valuable then looking at a damage meter. He says that the first objective is to see if you followed your game plan. Did you stick to it? Did it work? If the answer to either of these questions is no, you need to work on executing the plan better in future or possibly changing it up all together.
      Watching your own recordings is also a chance to highlight individual mistakes. As Minpojke says, “Always stay self-critical, and always look for ways to improve—you’ll notice pretty quickly your most crucial and common mistakes.” While Minpojke emphasizes that “losing is arguably the best way of learning,” he also reminded us that “it’s very important to recognize when you do well.” Think positively here: no one can play the perfect game, but there are often good takeaways to be emulated going forward.
      Reviewing recordings of his gameplay is a regular part of Minpojke’s routine, as well as discussing previous matches with his team between games while queueing. You can learn from a win as well as a loss!
      Execute - Implement Your Analysis
      After watching the replays, it’s time to set your goals. Decide what you want to focus on, and “make plans before you queue for a session.” If there was a specific matchup you were struggling with, you can discuss plans for how you’ll react to it next time.
      In some instances, it could be worth writing some notes, especially if you have many things to focus on versus many compositions. Minpojke equated it to studying for a test, “Practice it, and read it over and over until it sticks in your head.”
      Minpojke attended his first BlizzCon with current teammate Zunniyaki in 2013, finishing in second place. Northern Gaming Blue are the defending European Champions, and with nine BlizzCon appearances between their players, they’re one of the most experienced rosters in the field.
      You can watch Minpojke and Northern Gaming Blue compete live at gamescom from August 23-26. For the full details on when and where you can watch, head on over to our European Championship Finals blog.
    • By Vlad
      This thread is for comments about our Army of the Light Reputation Farming guide.
    • By Stan

      With 7.3 on the horizon, Blizzard did an official preview of new caster animations with videos and developer comments.
      Blizzard (Source)
      With patch 7.3 on the horizon, we thought it was time to share some updates to combat animations for several casting classes. Similar to what we did with the melee classes at the launch of Legion, these updates are all about priests, mages, Restoration and Elemental shaman, and some additional refinements to Restoration druid casting animations! We’re also continuing to work on even more enhancements for additional classes at a later point in development.
      A little over two years ago, we set our sights on revamping combat animations. The team has wanted to renovate it somehow, but what exactly does that mean? To determine the answer, our development leadership put together a small group of people to come up with a prototype of what we thought could use some cleaning up. You are currently experiencing the fruits of this work with the new melee animations. Our final goal was to create new melee moves that would make the game feel better, but not change how the game was played. During this prototype phase, we also came up with a plan for casters, but didn’t have time to put it into production until now. Let’s dig into some of the things we did.
      We hope you enjoyed this behind-the-scenes look at the new caster visual updates. We had lots of fun creating all these animations and effects and look forward to hearing your thoughts on them.
    • By Stan

      In Patch 7.3, Blizzard will be increasing the difficulty and rewards from dungeons across the board. The changes help keep dungeons relevant even at the end of the expansion.
      The following changes will be effective when Patch 7.3 goes live:
      Normal Difficulty
      Item level 845 (up from 825). Heroic Difficulty
      Item level 865 (up from 845). Mythic Difficulty
      Item level 885 (up from 865). Mythic Keystone
      Loot item level will be increased only after Antorus the Burning Throne raid opens. World Bosses
      Loot from old world bosses remains at 860. Loot from Broken Shore world bosses remains at 900. Loot from Argus world bosses in Greater Invasion Points is at 930.