Odinn

Does Warlords Need More Pruning?

Sign in to follow this  

7 posts in this topic

10001-does-warlords-need-more-pruning.jp

 

One of the major iterative design processes that underpinned Warlords of Draenor's overall direction was simplification. With the removal of old stats, various forms of crowd control, class abilities, guild leveling/bonuses, reforging, and more, Blizzard hinted that they wanted the game to evolve to a place that was more accessible. Is there more to come?

 

Looking at some of the other changes that have been made so far with this expansion, there are certainly possibilities. The challenge for the developers, of course, is balancing things that demonstrate character progression or significant time investments with long-term game health and playability.

 

So, what are some further adjustments that could be considered in the future? Here are a handful of examples:

  • Mount riding skills/passives. These seem largely redundant in an era of character boosts; with no ability to fly in Draenor, all of the riding passives seem largely obsolete.
  • In-game languages. These are functionally an adorable artifact of the game's much more RPG-driven roots.
  • Gathering professions. These have been made almost entirely redundant by the Garrison, and it certainly feels as if Blizzard has a long-term vision that would eliminate them altogether based on the Garrison implementation.
  • First Aid. An entirely separate secondary profession whose purpose is the creation of a singular item (and could be obviated by making Healthstones heal for the same amount as Healing Tonics) seems absurd.
  • Profession features like Prospecting and Smelting (and, long term, Milling and Disenchanting). Neither of these function on modern materials anyway - a minor update to deal with old world recipes/materials would eliminate them outright.
  • Deprecated currencies. Many old currencies are already no longer functional, and eliminating the clutter and confusion of currencies from non-current content would be a welcome improvement.

In addition to wholesale removals, there are certainly places where intelligent tweaks could be made. Efforts to consolidate or limit the effects of absent buffs for groups/raids, consumables, etc. have progressed steadily throughout Warcraft's history, but a number of them still have bizarre places in the game. With the irrelevant cost of materials for things like Savage Feasts, the time wasted by players to utilize them after wipes feels strange (and flies in the face of mechanics like the major cooldown reset, which explicitly eliminates the stand-around-and-wait effect!).

 

(As an aside - Draenor Perks feel like the type of feature that is absolutely designed to be removed eventually. Those level-driven random upgrades could easily be unlocked and treated as a baseline part of the affected abilities as early as next tier.)

 

Would you like to see further pruning to clean up some of the game's bloat? Are there features or inclusions that seem redundant or unnecessary to you that aren't mentioned here? Let us know what you think.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just the other day I was considering this.

 

Profession levels feel largely obsolete in WoD. All of the relevant crafting products can be learned and created equally by new and experienced crafters alike. The only differences I was able to find are that daily cooldowns produce more at higher levels (a system that doesn't actually reward the time you spend with a profession, rather it rewards the amount of money you have to drop on leveling it) and the existence of old-world items that very few would craft.

 

As you pointed out, "Draenor Perks" feels like a feature that was added only to be eventually removed. It adds needless complication to your spellbook and makes abilities work differently from when you learn them only for the sake of making the leveling process feel rewarding (going back to cast time Rebirth while leveling a new druid was a pain, and I had gotten so used to it that I didn't understand why it wouldn't work at first). I can't see them continueing to add perks for expansions to come without making some of these effects baseline. I don't want to have to fish through a page of 12 passives to remember why an ability is different.

 

This isn't quite a feature that needs pruning, but realms have begun to feel like an archaic feature that Blizzard continues to try to breath life into. Whether it's for the sake of nostalgia, comfort, familiarity, or money from realm transfers -- the artificial division of players that realms provide feels more and more out of place with each expansion as the World of Warcraft grows more interconnected. While realms and guilds have provided a sense of comradery and companionship in the past; it now feels like you are explicitly excluded from certain activities if you find a cross-realm group that you like (you can raid heroic, but can't raid mythic -- you can join parties, but can't join the guild).

Edited by Deathshiver

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This isn't quite a feature that needs pruning, but realms have begun to feel like an archaic feature that Blizzard continues to try to breath life into. Whether it's for the sake of nostalgia, comfort, familiarity, or money from realm transfers -- the artificial division of players that realms provide feels more and more out of place with each expansion as the World of Warcraft grows more interconnected. While realms and guilds have provided a sense of comradery and companionship in the past; it now feels like you are explicitly excluded from certain activities if you find a cross-realm group that you like (you can raid heroic, but can't raid mythic -- you can join parties, but can't join the guild).

The problem here is actually physical - the load that the servers can take is only so much, and once it gets to be too much everyone starts to get lag, and you can see an example of this with the launch of warlords.  The advent of cross realm zones and connected realms are improvements on this technology, but it is still limited in what can be done.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The problem here is actually physical - the load that the servers can take is only so much, and once it gets to be too much everyone starts to get lag, and you can see an example of this with the launch of warlords.  The advent of cross realm zones and connected realms are improvements on this technology, but it is still limited in what can be done.

Yeah, I totally get that. There's clearly physical reasons for realms, but their inter-connectivity is still divided. What physical reason is there for not allowing cross-realm mythic raiding? There are alternative approaches to a lot of things in the game that won't require this artificial division which can only be overcome with a paid transfer. It's this separation of players that I feel is archaic from a time where the technology to play with other realms didn't exist.

Edited by Deathshiver

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yeah, I totally get that. There's clearly physical reasons for realms, but their inter-connectivity is still divided. What physical reason is there for not allowing cross-realm mythic raiding? There are alternative approaches to a lot of things in the game that won't require this artificial division which can only be overcome with a paid transfer. It's this separation of players that I feel is archaic from a time where the technology to play with other realms didn't exist.

There isn't a physical reason for not doing cross realm mythic, and they did do that with the end of SoO.  However, as for doing it for Highmaul, there is a blue post explaining why they don't:

 

Mythic is a different concept from all other difficulties and it's not meant to be PUG friendly.

Not enabling cross-realm mythic is a design decision. Enabling this option would imply that this content should be doable by PUGs, and because it clearly isn't, it would only lead to frustration, complaints and nerf requests.

What is happening is that some players are finding mythic Kargath to be doable with very good PUGs, but we have to keep in mind that this is only happening because he's the very first raid boss from this expansion, so he's a bit more accessible than the rest.

When Blackrock Foundry (our next raid tier) launches, it's unlikely that the difficulty level from the first boss will be proportional to Kargath's when compared to the rest of the bosses of each respective tier.

Also, we're likely going to enable cross-realm mythic Highmaul when the next tier arrives.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There isn't a physical reason for not doing cross realm mythic, and they did do that with the end of SoO.  However, as for doing it for Highmaul, there is a blue post explaining why they don't:

That was the entire point I was trying to make. It's not like the players on one person's realm are inherently better than cross-realm. As an example, I'm really good friends with a number of players on Cenarion Circle, all of which are mythic-ready raiders that I raided with a little over a year ago. Unfortunately, my characters are now on Area 52 because I transferred to play with a friend. Without another realm transfer, I can't play high level content with them. Them being on a different realm doesn't inherently make them pugs or not capable of mythic as Blizzard would suggest to you here. Why is it that when you join a random group with people not on your realm it is worse than joining a random group with people in trade chat? The division here is purely artificial. The reason it implies that the content is doable by pugs is because the only content currently available cross-realm is pug content. Rather than reinforcing that the only good groups are the ones on your server, Blizzard should be trying to improve the resources that allow you to find a perfect group suited to you. It's an archaic system that, for one reason or another, they want to keep around.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I haven't had the opportunity to play WOD yet, but it sounds like professions are in a weird place. The thing I wish for WOW's future is for professions to be more customizable. I am an artist in real life, and I wish there was a way to express that through the game. Imagine how cool it would be if there was a new profession like Sculpting, or Painting. I also feel this way about blacksmithing or leatherworking. The ability to design patterns into cloaks or shoulder pads or whatever would be so awesome.

 

Imagine walking into someone's garrison (if that becomes an option someday) and seeing a badass statue. Someone would be like "Whoa man where'd you get that?" You could then casually smirk and be all like, "Oh yeah, it's an Oddin." And then just smoothly walk away like a boss. XD

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Starym
      Here comes the big one, as yesterday's hotfixes were just a warmup and today we have the main event. We have the profession high item level requirements change from yesterday reverted, Expulsom tweaks for recipes, returning Scouting Maps, another big wave of Azerite Trait changes this time in PvE, while PvP gets a whole lot of class changes and fixes.
      December 12 (source)
      Classes
      Monk Windwalker Good Karma no longer incorrectly increases Touch of Karma 's absorption.  
      Dungeons and Raids
      Uldir Vectis Fixed a bug causing Vectis to cast an extra Contagion prior to casting Liquefy. Items
      Scouting maps that teach flight paths to your alts have returned to the Honorbound and 7th Legion vendors. Island Flotsam will now correctly change to Dented Coin s when a Horde character changes to Alliance. Dented Coins will now correctly change to Island Flotsam when an Alliance character swaps to Horde. Heart of Azeroth Fixed a bug that caused damage effects such as Laser Matrix and Ricocheting Inflatable Pyrosaw to target enemies that were crowd-controlled. Good Karma no longer incorrectly increases Touch of Karma 's absorption. Healing from Glimmer of Light is now correctly modified by Mastery: Lightbringer . Echoing Blades ’ Fan of Knives explosion now always critically hits. Its base damage has been reduced by 75%. Developers’ note: This change allows the trait to scale with the talent Master Assassin in a more reasonable way. The total reduction of the Echo comes out to around 50%, with some variance depending on your Critical Strike chance. Missions
      Fixed a bug that caused Treasure Map missions to expire in 8 hours. They now expire in 72 hours. Developers’ note: This won’t affect missions that are currently in a player’s mission list, only newly-created missions. Professions
      Reverted yesterday's change to require Profession skill for using high iLvl crafted items. A number of recipes have been adjusted so that the Expulsom required by the recipe matches the amount of Expulsom returned when you scrapped the crafted item. Player versus Player
      Fixed a bug that caused players who have earned seasonal Gladiator achievements in Legion: Season 5 and Battle for Azeroth: Season 1 to not earn the Gladiator achievement. Death Knight Unholy Fixed an issue that caused the Zombie summoned by Reanimation (PvP Talent) to have more health than 5. Fixed a bug that caused Necrotic Strike 's initial damage to not be increased by Mastery: Dreadblade . Fixed a bug that could cause Necrotic Strike to apply too large of a healing absorb against non-player targets. Fixed a bug that caused the heal generated by Life and Death (PvP Talent) to be a critical heal. Fixed a bug that caused the heal of Life and Death to be larger than 10% of a heal cast on a target with your Festering Wound . Paladin Holy Cleanse the Weak will no longer incorrectly cause Cleanse to go on cooldown when it removes effects from friendly targets. Retribution Templar's Verdict and Divine Storm no longer deal reduced damage to enemy players. Priest Discipline Resolved an issue that caused Power Word: Shield 's value to be lower than intended when engaged in combat with enemy players. Power Word: Shield absorbs an additional 10% when engaged in combat with enemy players. Developers’ note: Shadow Priests’ Power Word: Shield was unaffected by the above and is unchanged. Shadow Fixed a bug that caused Greater Fade to be removed by Shadowy Apparitions . Rogue Fixed a bug that caused Vanish to end before the normal duration when taking damage and harmful effects. Assassination, Subtlety Fixed a bug that caused Subterfuge to not be applied when attacking during Vanish. World Quests
      Captured Zandalari no longer knockback NPCs during “Azerite Mining ”. Fixed an issue where Fozruk can sometimes fail to grant you World Quest credit. Fixed a bug that could remove a player from their manasaber mount on “Ley Race ”. Previous hotfixes.
    • By Stan
      Redditor Makesmashgreatagain noticed after 8.1 went live that ilvl 385 crafted items no longer work if you abandoned the profession used to craft them.
      Update: This was an unintended bug that was recently reverted.
      Placeholder for tweet 1072993206856380416 Emblazoned Deep Sea Breeches now require Zandalari Tailoring (110) as depicted in the screenshot below. The player switched to Alchemy/Enchanting and after Tides of Vengeance, the crafted item was red and gave no stats. The change was omitted from the official patch notes. We don't know at this time if it's just a bug or intended.

      (Source)
    • By Stan
      Tides of Vengeance is now live and our hub contains all the latest information!
      Welcome to our Tides of Vengeance hub. Here, you'll find all the latest information about Battle for Azeroth's first content patch 8.1. 
      Introduction
      Patch 8.1 titled Tides of Vengeance was pushed to PTR on September 21. The patch went live on December 11. You can check out our latest coverage by visiting the links below:
      Tides of Vengeance Patch Notes Class Guides for Patch 8.1 Tides of Vengeance Survival Guide New Patch 8.1 Folder Structure List of Known Issues [8.1] Crafted Gear Now Requires the Profession to Equip Artifact Power Catchup Disabled Until January 22 New Food in Tides of Vengeance Not all content will be available immediately upon launch and you can find the full unlock schedule here.
      PTR Coverage
      This section contains old PTR news coverage.
      Patch 8.1 Build #28616
      Patch 8.1 Build 28616 Highlights Highmountain Tauren Druid New Moonkin Incarnation Form Heritage Armor (Official Preview) Azerite Reforging Blue Posts Island Rewards Update Pet Battle Dungeon: Gnomeregan (Official Preview) Patch 8.1 Build #28440
      G.M.O.D. Mount Preview Ivus (New Darkshore World Boss) Darkshore Introduction Questline (Horde PoV) Patch 8.1: Dungeon Difficulty & Rewards Increase Patch 8.1 Heritage Armor (Official Preview) Tabards Account-Wide in Patch 8.1 Patch 8.1 Build #28366
      Patch 8.1 Build 28366 Highlights Mythic Jaina Mount Preview XP Per Level Nerfs & Leveling Improvements Patch 8.1 Build #28294
      Patch 8.1 Build 28294 Highlights Patch 8.1 Build 28294: Mechanical Parrot Mount Patch 8.1 Build #28202
      Patch 8.1 Build 28202: Tyrande's Ascension Scenario (Alliance PoV) Patch 8.1 Build 28202: New Horde War Campaign Overview Patch 8.1 Build 28202: Warfront Vendors & Commendations Patch 8.1 Build 28202: Frog Mounts Purchasable for 333,333 Gold Each Battle of Dazar'alor Sets Preview Patch 8.1 Build 28202: New Azerite Traits Patch 8.1 Build 28202: New Dubloon Trader (Island Expeditions Vendor) Hunters Can Tame Blood Beasts in Patch 8.1 Glory of the Dazar'alor Raider Reward Mythic+ Season 2 Affix: Reaping Azerite Armor Acqusition in Patch 8.1: New Mythic+ Currency The Fate of Saurfang Story: Alternative Ending Added in Build 28202 Battle of Dazar'alor: Unique Raid Flashback Mechanic Patch 8.1 Build #28151
      Patch 8.1 Build 28151: Overview Patch 8.1 Build 28151: Blood Elf Heritage Armor Patch 8.1 Build 28151: Marksmanship Hunter Changes Patch 8.1 Build 28151: Restoration Shaman Changes Patch 8.1 Build 28151: Marsh Hopper Mounts Upcoming Shadow Priest Changes The Story of Varok Saurfang in Patch 8.1 Orc Running Animation Updated Patch 8.1 Build #28048
      Patch 8.1 Build 28048 Overview Patch 8.1 Build #27985
      Patch 8.1 Build 27985 Overview Patch 8.1 Build 27985: New Creature Models Patch 8.1 Build 27985: New Paladin Animations Patch 8.1 Build 27985: Solo Queue for Legion Raids Enabled Patch 8.1 Build 27985: Dwarf Heritage Armor Preview Patch 8.1 Build 27985: Siege of Zuldazar Weapons Patch 8.1 Build #27826
      Patch 8.1 Build 27826 Overview (Datamined Broadcast Text, Zones, Strings, Scenarios) *Spoilers* Patch 8.1 Build 27286: Vol'jin's Story Continues (Datamined Broadcast Text Analysis) *Spoilers* Patch 8.1 Build 27826: New Creature Models Patch 8.1 Build 27286: New Night Elf Warrior Customization Options Patch 8.1 Build 27286: New Druid Forms (Highmountain Tauren/Kul Tiran Moonkin Forms, Zandalari Aquatic Form) Patch 8.1 Build 27286: Kul Tiran Horse Racial Mount Patch 8.1 Build 27286: Nightsaber Mounts Patch 8.1 Build 27286: The Hivemind Mount Returns Patch 8.1 Build 27286: Vicious PvP Mounts Patch 8.1 Content
      Blizzard recently announced improvements to Azerite Armor acquisition from Mythic+. You can find more details here. Heritage Armor will be added for non-Allied Races; Blood Elves & Dwarves are first on the list. There's no reputation grind behind this. If you're at max level and Exalted with Ironforge/Blood Elves, you can start the quest and complete a scenario to get your Heritage Armor. Reputation Paragon for BfA factions is coming. Champions of Azeroth reputation will be made account-wide. Incursions are a new feature similar to Legion assaults. Darkshore Warfront (Night Elves vs Forsaken theme) The outdoor zone will be updated just like Arathi Highlands with new quests, rares, etc. War Campaign continues with the Alliance leading a direct strike at the Zandalari Fleet. We can expect two new raids in 8.1: Siege of Zuldazar is a nine-boss raid where the foe is the opposing faction. Alliance players will join Jaina and her forces to fight their way up to the pyramid to confront Rastakhan. Horde players will try to defend the pyramid, fighting Jaina in the High Seas as the final boss. Crucible of Storms is a two-boss raid located under Shrine of the Storm that hints at Queen Azshara. It's Battle for Azeroth's "Trial of Valor" raid. Allied Races: Kul Tirans and Zandalari Trolls will become available for gameplay after the Siege of Zuldazar raid. You can find more details about how to unlock them here. Two New Islands: Jorundall (Vrykul-themed Island) & Havenswood (Gilnean-themed Island) Gnomeregan Pet Battle Dungeon Profession Changes New Scenarios Tyrande's Ascension - players will unlok new Night Elf Warrior customization options with dark eyes. Cooking Scenario with Nomi Unknown Tol Dagor Scenario Heritage Armor Scenarios Vol'jin's Story Continues - The Shadow Hunter is looking for answers in 8.1 as he tries to figure out why he appointed Sylvanas for Warchief. Allied Races
      You will be able to unlock Legion Allied Races faster in Patch 8.1.
      Class Changes
      Multiple Classes are subject to changes in Patch 8.1. These include Elemental Shamans, Shadow Priests, and Protection Warriors. So far, Blizzard outlined plans for Elemental Shamans. They haven't decided what to do with Protection Warriors just yet.
      Elemental Shaman Changes Model Updates
      Draenei totems received new models with a higher polygon count in 8.1.
      Draenei Shaman Totems Model Update Interviews/Livestreams
      Game Director Ion Hazzikostas unveiled Patch 8.1 on September 18.
      Tides of Vengeance Livestream with Game Director Ion Hazzikostas Tides of Vengeance Live Developer Q&A with Game Director Ion Hazzikostas Tides of Vengeance is Battle for Azeroth's first major content patch and we created a hub to keep track of everything.
    • By Stan
      An overview of new food added in Tides of Vengeance.
      Visit your faction's Cooking trainers  "Cap'n" Byron Mehlsack in Boralus or T'sarah the Royal Chef in Dazar'alor to learn new Cooking recipes added in Patch 8.1:
      Rank 1&2 Recipes
      Boralus Blood Sausage (Rank 1) - Increases your primary stat by 85 for 1 hour. Creates 5x Boralus Blood Sausage. Honey Potpie - Slow melee attackers' movement speed by 30% for 1 hour. Creates 5x Honey Potpie. Sanguinated Feast (Rank 1) - Increases your primary stat by 100 for 1 hour. Seasoned Steak and Potatoes (Rank 1) - Increases Stamina by 150 for 1 hour. Creates 5x Seasoned Steak and Potatoes. Seasoned Steak and Potatoes (Rank 2) - Available at Cooking Trainers. Creates 7x Seasoned Steak and Potatoes. Wild Berry Bread (Rank 1) - Increases Stamina by 112 for 1 hour. Creates 5x Wild Berry Bread. Wild Berry Bread (Rank 2) - Available at Cooking Trainers. Creates 7x Wild Berry Bread. Rank 2 Recipes
      The following patters can be purchased at Exalted with Tortollan Seekers.
      Boralus Blood Sausage (Rank 2) - Requires Exalted with Tortollan Seekers. Creates 7x Boralus Blood Sausage. Sanguinated Feast (Rank 2) - Requires Exalted with Tortollan Seekers. Rank 3 Recipes
      The new Sanguicell feast and other Rank 3 recipes can be looted from the Tortollan Seekers Reputation Paragon cache. Some are available at Exalted with Tortollan Seekers.
      Boralus Blood Sausage (Rank 3) - The pattern can be looted from Tortollan Seekers Supplies (Reputation Paragon Cache). Creates 10x Boralus Blood Sausage. Sanguinated Feast (Rank 3) - Can be looted from Tortollan Seekers Supplies (Reputation Paragon Cache). Drastically reduces the amount of ingredients needed to create the feast. Seasoned Steak and Potatoes (Rank 3) - Requires Exalted with Tortollan Seekers. Creates 10x Seasoned Steak and Potatoes. Wild Berry Bread (Rank 3) - Requires Exalted with Tortollan Seekers. Creates 10x Wild Berry Bread.
    • By Stan
      At Battle of Azeroth launch, Blizzard introduced an Artifact Power catchup mechanism that reduced the amount of Artifact Power required to level up the Heart of Azeroth. The catchup mechanism has been disabled on 8.1 launch and will be re-enabled when the new raid opens on January 22.
      Intent of the catchup was to help players with unlocking Season 1 Azerite powers. It will resume doing so when the new Azerite Armor with the fifth ring and new traits becomes available on January 22. Placeholder for tweet 1072914797392359424