Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Realbookwurm

d3 Wyatt Cheng Addresses Changes to % Bonus Damage Affix in Diablo's Patch 2.4

1 post in this topic

14692-wyatt-cheng-addresses-changes-to-b

Diablo 3 Senior Technical Game Designer Wyatt Cheng is spending a lot of time on the /r/Diablo sub-reddit lately, and he has established the philosophy behind some of the larger item changes that 2.4 will bring.


 
Popular community figures such as Quin69 have come out in opposition to the changes the new patch will bring, arguing that it kills off build diversity. The argument against such a large increase to the % Skill bonus means that if a player uses a particular skill, they will feel like they are being punished for not using the corresponding % Skill bonus item. This would dictate that players only use certain items with certain skills, possibly forcing only cookie-cutter builds to be viable.
 
Cheng wrote a pretty sizable response to the less favorable reactions, which followed up a short tweet Cheng made on December 8th.
 

 
Read the full post below:

Blizzard Icon Wyatt Cheng


I understand Quin's critique and totally get where he's coming from. Putting large skill bonuses means you can't cube the item and reconfigure them around as much.

Design is about tradeoffs, and we wouldn't do it if we there aren't upsides as well.

Furycrab correctly identified some of the issue here: https://www.reddit.com/r/Diablo/comments/3vh11v/quin69_diablo_3_itemisation_rant_24/cxnu16u
What we've done is sacrifice some illusion of choice for real choice. While this is a bad trade-off for some (particularly cutting edge explorers), it is a win for many others.

If we were to increase the damage of base skills and lower legendary item +%s it gets the number where it needs to be for that configuration, but also affects every other configuration. Let's use Fury of the Vanished Peak as an example. Maybe it's at a certain spot in IK builds. Yes, we could shift some numbers out of the item and into the base skill, but how does that affect Might of the Earth builds? Legacy of Nightmares builds (for which there are innumerable configurations)? Pushed far enough what if it was a huge buff to Raekor builds? Now don't get me wrong - having lots of toys to play around with and configure in different ways is GREAT. We love that. But what will inevitably happen is if any one of those builds is 10% better than the others you don't get an increase the variety, you end up with a decrease in variety due to there being a "right answer". There are innumerable ripple effects and if any one of those ripples ends up disrupting the status quo then it becomes the new standard by which every other class/build is judged.

Another downside of simply buffing base skills rather than pushing the power into legendaries is the effect it has on the level up game. How does the game play in all yellow items during the 1-70 experience - new players are entering the Diablo community every day. (and some of them post here in /r/Diablo to talk about what a great time they're having!). We can't have Wave of Light doing 3x as much damage as every other skill during that period.

The reality is that sometimes a +% on a skill is the only way to get a skill where it needs to be competitive at the upper tiers of play without disrupting the existing ecosystem. The choice for us becomes use a +% skill on an item or allow to skill to simply go completely unused for end game players.

Patch 2.4 is looking to have more viable builds than any patch to date. The team is really excited about this and we hope all of you are too. (Source)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Stan
      A new Facebook Live Q/A is scheduled for January 26 and Travis Day and Julian Love will be answering your questions about Necromancers!
      We'll be doing a recap as soon as the Q/A comes to a close.
      Nevalistis
      We have another Facebook Live Q&A coming up, and you’re invited! Join Senior Game Designer Travis Day and Lead VFX Artist Julian Love on Thursday, January 26 to find out more about what we’ve been up to in our development of the Necromancer class.
      Got a question for us? Submit any Diablo question by posting in this forum thread or via Twitter using the hashtag #D3QA.
      We’re hoping to answer as many questions as we can and can’t wait to see you Thursday at 5:00 p.m. PST. See you there!
      (Source)
    • By Damien
      This thread is for comments about our Wizard Manald Channeling Build.
    • By Stan
      Rainbow Portrait is coming to consoles with the patch that brings Seasons, The rest blue posts deal with The Barber, Juggernaut affix and the duration of the Darkening of Tristam event.
      Rainbow Portrait on Consoles
      The rainbow portrait isn't currently available on consoles. The implementation of portraits will come with the patch that brings Seasons to consoles (Season 10 maybe). Until then, you can earn portraits through the Darkening of Tristam event.
      Nevalistis
      So, with the 1.15/1.16 patch, will this portrait drop now on the consoles?
      Sorry for the delay in response, but I had to do some digging on this one. On console, Sir William does not currently drop the Whimsyshire portrait. The reason why is because full portrait integration isn't actually active yet for the Ultimate Evil Edition on PS4/XB1, though a couple of portraits can be earned through the Darkening of Tristram event (see here for more information on that). Full integration will be coming with the patch where Seasons become available on console.

      If this is something you guys would like to see in the future once portrait integration is in, I'll be happy to pass along that feedback to our console development team!
      (Source)
      The Darkening of Tristam Event Duration
      Another posts informs that the Darkening of Tristam event will last until the end of January and will return every January from here on out.
      Nevalistis
      When does the Darkening of Tristram event end?
      Just to confirm, The Darkening of Tristram event will last until the end of this month (January), and will return every January from here on out.
      (Source)
      The Barber Nerfs
      A player has submitted photographic evidence that The Barber has been nerfed. Here's a blue post related to it.
      Tyvalir
      I'm using it with a build I'm working on and I like it even though it's not doing insane amounts of godly damage like on the ptr.
      Glad you're liking the revamped Barber! As more people play with this item, there will doubtless be interesting new builds they create that are worth trying out.

      It's also worth noting that with the changes to certain items in patch 2.4.3, we've seen players talk about how these compare to the most powerful Legendary and Set items available in the game. 

      To clarify, our goal when updating Legendary items is to open up new build opportunities for players to explore. Along with this, it's important to note that not every item is designed to push the current best Greater Rift level. Some will be better for speed farming builds, and others will simply be a means to create fun novelty builds (like Manajuma's Way, for instance).

      There's more than one way to compare an item's relative worth, and more than one way to incorporate it into various builds. Even so, I'm glad to see people trying the new items out and sharing their experiences. It helps, for sure!
      Is it really not guaranteed elemental damage though?
      As for the weapon not rolling the additional damage modifier, that does seem buggy - I will pass this on, and thanks for reporting it!
      (Source)
      Juggernauts in Greater Rifts
      They now have lots of health and resistance to damage, intended? The information below was taken from the latest patch notes.
      2.4.3 Patch Notes - Juggernaut
      Juggernaut New enemy affix Juggernaut monsters are permanently immune to crowd control effects, but move more slowly than normal monsters Along with this change, enemies with this affix take 30% more damage from all sources Only a rare Elite enemy can be a Juggernaut (Source)
      There may even be a visual indicator for affixes on elites in the works!
      Tyvalir
      OK I got it - immunity to cc means a whole bunch of procs that raise damage or debuff won't work.
      Just wanted to clarify for those who haven't seen the new Juggernaut affix in-game or read our recent patch notes that this is correct. As with all enemy affixes, some will be easier for certain builds to handle while the inverse is true for others. 

      One of our goals when adding new enemy affixes is to broaden the types of enemy variety you see in the game and the kinds of challenges you'll face. This helps achieve both of those goals while (hopefully) encouraging you to think more tactically in certain cases as a CC-dependent character.
      Damn! Will have to actually look at affixes now - it would be nice to have a visual indicator on the elite.
      Totally fair feedback! I'm happy to pass this on and thanks for sharing it.
      (Source)
    • By Stan
      On January 10, Blizzard has released the first round of hotfixes related to issues in Patch 2.4.3. Those issues have also been removed from the 2.4.3 Known Issues List.
      Nevalistis
      Below you will find a list of hotfixes recently applied or coming soon that address various bugs or mechanic tweaks.

      These hotfixes should not require you to download a new patch. Some of the hotfixes below will go live the moment they are implemented while others may require restarting the game to go into effect. Please keep in mind that some issues cannot be addressed without a client-side patch. Also note that changes to certain abilities will not be reflected in its tooltip until a patch is issued.

      Last updated January 10. Hotfixes are denoted by the date they were applied to live servers.

      Previous Hotfixes: [2.3.0] [2.4.0] [2.4.1] [2.4.2]

      [LIVE HOTFIXES]

      General A fix has been deployed that should resolve many of the 64-bit client issues since the release of Patch 2.4.3 (1/9) Please note that this fix will require you to download a small patch If you have updated to the latest patch and are still experiencing issues, please detail your experience in our Bug Report or Technical Support forums and be sure to include your dxdiag report
      Items The Barber Addressed an issue where having The Barber equipped on a Follower could repeatedly kill that Follower (1/9) Flail of the Ascended Fixed an issue where Shield Glare would only damage the last enemy hit by Shield Glare (1/9) (Source)
    • By Stan
      Season 9 is underway and it doesn't matter if you're just planning to start playing or you're already in. Deadset has been busy updating our Diablo Guide Section for the latest Patch 2.4.3.
      Patch 2.4.3 & Season 9
      Our guide section has been updated for Season 9, so if you're leveling a new Hero from scratch or need some help with build suggestions or itemization, feel free to visit one of the links below:
      Barbarian Crusader Demon Hunter Monk Witch Doctor Wizard Community Powerleveling
      If you're looking for fast leveling, don't forget to join in-game communities that may help you reach Level 70 in just a few minutes. Search communities with "Powerleveling" or "Seasonal Powerleveling" in their name, join the chat and there you are likely to encounter somebody farming, willing to boost you. The same applies for Hardcore. Don't underestimate how communities may save your time and help you find your niche (players doing split bounties etc.).
      Diablo I Anniversary Event
      Patch 2.4.3 introduced the Darkening of Tristam. Nostalgy, various transmogs and pets are up for grabs. Our full event guide can be found here.