Blainie

Blizzard Removing Alpha Access As Punishment

Sign in to follow this  

13 posts in this topic

20034-blizzard-removing-alpha-access-as-

After a feedback thread escalated last night, it seems Blizzard have punished those that acted out on the forums. Both Legion and Overwatch access has been removed for many of those that took part in the "memestorm"!


The thread in question popped up after there were a number of stability issues with the Alpha servers. Players couldn't log in to test the raids that were scheduled, namely the first Mythic bosses to open for testing.

It quickly escalated into personal insults and threats, a barrage of memes and "jokes" spanning topics such as 9/11 and terrorism. It seems Blizzard have since revoked the access of these players to the Legion Alpha and Overwatch Beta for an undisclosed period of time. 

While it's understandable that people take time out to prepare for these events, access to the Alpha is still a privilege. One of the MVPs on the US realms summed it up perfectly:
 

Alpha access is a privilege not a right. Alphas by nature are NOT stable and will have issues. Sure, it sucks to set apart time to test and have it not work out. However, resorting to the trolling and nonsense that happened there is not ok. It was not harmless and demonstrated that some people really don't understand what the purpose of an Alpha is or how to provide polite and constructive feedback. Sure, you are free to act like that, but others don't have to put up with you. Sometimes people simply need to deal with the consequences of their actions.
 
(source)

 

We also saw a blue post from Watcher apologising for the problems over the raid testing night.

 

Blizzard Icon Watcher on the Raid Tests

 

Obviously we've been experiencing significant technical issues. We've been trying to diagnose them, but they're beyond the scope of anything that can be addressed in the short-term (infrastructure/back-end issues, as opposed to just a simple code bug that can be fixed). As such, we're canceling today's tests. They'll be rescheduled.
 
I realize it's frustrating to carve time out of your schedule and then be unable to actually play. If there were anything we could do to prevent this, we would, but an alpha/beta environment is inherently less stable and polished because of how things are changing constantly, both in obvious player-facing ways but also in terms of behind-the-scenes tech. I apologize, but I honestly can't say that it won't happen again - it might. The disclaimers that accompany each raid testing announcement aren't just empty words.
 
 

So, what do you think? Was the punishment fair? Should it have been more, or less, severe?

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I believe Blizzard did the right thing, but honestly, I had fun reading those meme comments. 

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think they went a little too far here, honestly.  Blizzards own ToC states that trolling is punishable by a forum ban based on severity.

 

 


Spamming or Trolling

This category includes:

  • Excessively communicating the same phrase, similar phrases, or pure gibberish

  • Creating threads for the sole purpose of causing unrest on the forums

  • Causing disturbances in forum threads, such as picking fights, making off topic posts that ruin the thread, insulting other posters

  • Making non-constructive posts

  • Abusing the Reported Post feature by sending false alarms or nonsensical messages

  • Numbering a thread, IBTL, TLDR, or any other fad statements


If a player is found to have participated in such actions, he/she will:

  • Be given a temporary or permanent ban from the forums, depending upon severity

 

 

Removal of access goes way beyond a forum ban.  Not only that, but the way WatcherDev responded on twitter was not very, err, appropriate for his position.  

 

 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think they went a little too far here, honestly.  Blizzards own ToC states that trolling is punishable by a forum ban based on severity.

 

 

Spamming or Trolling

This category includes:

  •  
  • Excessively communicating the same phrase, similar phrases, or pure gibberish
  •  
  • Creating threads for the sole purpose of causing unrest on the forums
  •  
  • Causing disturbances in forum threads, such as picking fights, making off topic posts that ruin the thread, insulting other posters
  •  
  • Making non-constructive posts
  •  
  • Abusing the Reported Post feature by sending false alarms or nonsensical messages
  •  
  • Numbering a thread, IBTL, TLDR, or any other fad statements
  •  

If a player is found to have participated in such actions, he/she will:

  •  
  • Be given a temporary or permanent ban from the forums, depending upon severity
  •  

 

 

Removal of access goes way beyond a forum ban.  Not only that, but the way WatcherDev responded on twitter was not very, err, appropriate for his position.  

 

Do you think a forum ban would work in this situation? The whole point of having Alpha access is to test and give feedback. Without access to the forums to give feedback, what's the point of them testing?

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think they went a little too far here, honestly.  Blizzards own ToC states that trolling is punishable by a forum ban based on severity.

 

 

Spamming or Trolling

This category includes:

  •  
  • Excessively communicating the same phrase, similar phrases, or pure gibberish
  •  
  • Creating threads for the sole purpose of causing unrest on the forums
  •  
  • Causing disturbances in forum threads, such as picking fights, making off topic posts that ruin the thread, insulting other posters
  •  
  • Making non-constructive posts
  •  
  • Abusing the Reported Post feature by sending false alarms or nonsensical messages
  •  
  • Numbering a thread, IBTL, TLDR, or any other fad statements
  •  

If a player is found to have participated in such actions, he/she will:

  •  
  • Be given a temporary or permanent ban from the forums, depending upon severity
  •  

 

 

Removal of access goes way beyond a forum ban.  Not only that, but the way WatcherDev responded on twitter was not very, err, appropriate for his position.  

They're not paying for alpha or beta access. If they'd been banned from WoW altogether I could see your point. But they were granted a privilege, and showed they had no real grasp of what they were supposed to be doing with it. Therefore, they lost it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

They could give me an alpha key. They know I would appreciate it, and enjoy helping them out anyway I can. But oh well ill be good and wait for the beta. Blizzard love...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

They could give me an alpha key. They know I would appreciate it, and enjoy helping them out anyway I can. But oh well ill be good and wait for the beta. Blizzard love...

I second this motion.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Bans were justified. You should see it as an honor that a company trusts you to provide feedback on whatever you think that needs to be changed or improved. But then again blizzard stop using the alpha as a promotion tool, get players in that are willing to test the content properly and won't act like adhd kiddies when something bothers them.

 

I think Blizzard should take a page out of Microsoft testing, and add a questionnaire with the beta testing signup where you can motivate yourself and them, on why you should get early testing access.

I'll gladly test 10 hours per day and provide feedback so the issues do not present on live and improve my own and everyone else's gaming experience.

Edited by Hikashuri

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think the way these players have behaved is disgusting. Talking about 9/11 amongst other topics is despicable. Innocent people lost their lives in that tragedy and to this day the pain is still raw.

I honestly think Blizzard have been too soft with said players, If it was up to me they would have been given a lifetime ban. In my honest opinion even that really isn't enough. They should be prosecuted for what they have written. It wouldn't be the first time someone has been prosecuted for trolling!!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Stan

      Our returing player guide is stuffed with relevant information for players that haven't played WoW for a  while and they'd like to give it a go in 7.3.
      If you haven't played WoW for a while, we have a guide for you with all relevant information.
      The main goal of the guide is to keep it short and simple.
      General Tips
      In Patch 7.3, the 3rd relic slot will be unlocked immediately once you reach 110 and there's no need to complete individual campaigns all over again. (Source) You can forget about the Broken Shore content. Artifact Knowledge is now shared. All player start at AK Level 41 and will automatically gain 1 AK Level per week. Only one new Legendary item is added in 7.3. Any player that defeats Argus the Unmaker can get Insignia of the Grand Army. It's rewarded from the quest called The Death of a Titan. More details about the Netherlight Crucible can be found here. Two new factions are added in Patch 7.3: Argussian Reach & Army of the Light, both having new emissary quests. A new Heirloom with an interesting affix was added to the game.  Man'ari Training Amulet. Sacrifice 10% HP to gain 40% increased movement speed for 10 seconds. There are no plans to enable Draenor flying for those that haven't unlocked Draenor Pathfinder. Patch 7.3 Content Rollout
      Not all 7.3 content will be available on day 1.From the latest developer Q/A, the content rollout should look like this:
      Week 1
      Krokuun and the first two chapters of the Argus story will unlock.   Players will be able to unlock Krokuun World Quests. Week 2
      The second Argus zone Mac'Aree will become available and with it the third and fourth chapter of the Argus story. Once you progress through those chapters, you will gain access to Mac'aree World Quests, Kil'jaeden's Terrace World Quests and Western Mac'Aree World Quests. Invasion Points will also open. Week 3
      The last week marks the opening of Argus's last zone, Antoran Wastes. Players will gain access to Antoran Wastes World Quests, the Netherlight Crucible and the new dungeon - Seat of the Triumvirate. All you need to know at this point is that Argus has three zones and once you finish the story in each zone, you will gain access to world quests.
      Reputation Catch-up
      We datamined two Bind-to-Account items related to reputation catch-up with Broken Isles & Argus factions. Sources remain unknown for now. Nathrezim Tome of Manipulation increases rep gains with Broken Isles factions by 200% for 2 hours. The item's intended for alts and doesn't work past level 109. Demon's Soulstone can only be used on Argus and the item increases your reputation standing by 1,000 with all factions. It's good for catching up reputation with the Nightfallen. Gear Catch-up
      New Relinquished items are being added in 7.3 with a base item level of 910. (Source) All items can be purchased for 650 Veiled Argunite (a new currency from Argus World Quests). Crafted 7.3 gear is of ilvl 885 and can be upgraded with Primal Sargerite via Primal Obliterum up to item level 935. Old crafted gear can't be upgraded past 900. You can disenchant it into Chaos Crystal. There's a new shoulder enchant on Argus that will help you farm Primal Sargerite. More information can be found here. Dungeons have had their ilvl increased by 20 item levels on every difficulty. Normal: ilvl 845 (was 825) Heroic: ilvl 865 (was 845) Mythic: ilvl 885 (was 865) World Quest rewards scale up to item level 895. (Source) With the introduction of the Netherlight Crucible, you can now target specific relic types. Antorus the Burning Throne
      The raid won't open immediately with 7.3, but at a later point (probably in Patch 7.3.5). Once Antorus opens, Legendary items will have a base item level of 1,000. (Source) For more information about Patch 7.3, check out our Argus hub.
    • By Stan

      Season 4 isn't ending this week and during Hallow's End, you'll be able to queue up for Headless Horseman at a lower level for a chance to get The Horseman's Reins mount.
      Season 4 Cutoffs
      Blizzard's periodically updating cutoffs for Season 4 and you can find them here.
      Placeholder for tweet 897976866178334720 Season 4 End Date
      PvP Season 4 isn't ending this week.
      Placeholder for tweet 899704462972919808 Hallow's End Queue @ Level 23
      Blizzard has been updating world events to allow lower level players to queue up for bosses like Ahune and Headless Horseman will be no exception. When the event is next up, you can queue up at Level 23. The latest update to Hallow's End introduces a new battle pet Naxxy, purchasable for 150 Tricky Treats.
      Placeholder for tweet 898581888222101504 Patch 7.3: Crafted Items Upgrading
      Pre-7.3 items can be upgraded only to item level 900 using Obliterum. New 7.3 crafted items (base ilvl 885) can be only upgraded with Primal Obliterum up to ilvl 935. More information can be found here.
      Placeholder for tweet 897964671298265088
    • By Stan

      Many players are still waiting for Patch 7.3 to go live, before they complete the Mage Tower Challenge for their Artifact weapon appearance, because with increasing item level, the challenge becomes more trivial. If you have your appearance unlocked and think how good you are, you probably haven't heard of Muddymonk!
      The player wrote on reddit that he finished Mage Tower Challenges for each class / specialization - that's a total of 36 challenges. Congratulations! We're posting some screenshots and the rest can be found by visiting the link at the bottom of the article.

      You can find more screenshots here.
    • By Stan

      Patch 7.3 adds entirely new crafted items for professions and a new obliterum to increase their item level up to a max of 935. We datamined all new recipes that were added in Build 24473. Most of them are tied to new Profession quests.
      Instead of bumping crafted items that existed since Legion launch, Blizzard decided to add an entirely new tier of items, available on Argus (no-fly zone).
      Professions
      Crafed gear can be upgraded through Primal Obliterum by +5 ilvls (up to a maximum level of 935). Requires 1 Primal Sargerite and the target item must be soulbound New Items
      Astral Glory - new Argus herb Empyrium - new Argus ore Fiendish Leather - new Argus leather Lightweave Cloth - new Argus cloth Primal Sargerite - new reagent from Transmuting (requires 25 Bloods of Sargeras) New Gems Argulite Chemirine Labradorite Lightsphene Alchemy
      Lightblood Elixir - Use: Increases damage by 100,000 against demons. Only usable outdoors on Argus and the Broken Isles. Lasts 30 min.
      Lightblood Elixir (Rank 1) Lightblood Elixir (Rank 2) - more efficient craft Lightblood Elixir (Rank 3) - chance to create multiple elixirs Astral Alchemist Stone - new ilvl 885 trinket
      Astral Alchemist Stone (Rank 1) Astral Alchemist Stone (Rank 2) - more efficient craft Astral Alchemist Stone (Rank 3) - chance to create multiple stones Tears of the Naaru - Use: Shows the location of all nearby demons on the minimap for 30 min.
      Tears of the Naaru (Rank 1) Tears of the Naaru (Rank 2) - more efficient craft Tears of the Naaru (Rank 3) - chance to create multiple Tears of the Naaru New Transmutation - Transmute: Primal Sargerite > Primal Sargerite
      Blacksmithing
      Empyrial Breastplate - new ilvl 885 Plate Chest
      Empyrial Rivets are needed to craft the Chest Empyrial Breastplate (Rank 1) Empyrial Breastplate (Rank 2) - more efficient craft Empyrial Breastplate (Rank 3) - even more efficient craft Felslate Anchor (Felslate Anchor) - Use: Attach an anchor to your legs which sends you plummeting towards the ocean floor. Only usable in water.
      Cooking
      Feast of the Fishes (Recipe: Feast of the Fishes) - Use: Set out a Feast of the Fishes to feed up to 50 people in your raid or party! Restores 2,400,000 health and 1,200,000 mana over 20 sec. Must remain seated while eating. If you spend at least 10 seconds eating you will obtain all of the powers of a fish.
      Fishing Artifact
      Underlight Emerald (Deep Green) new green appearance for Underlight Angler Herbalism
      Astral Glory - Restores 1% health every 5 sec for 15 min
      Astral Glory - Gather Astral Glory more effectively Astral Glory - Find rare materials when gathering Astral Glory Astral Glory - Receive a chance to gain a small heal over time when gathering Astral Glory Engineering
      Gravitational Reduction Slippers (Schematic: Gravitational Reduction Slippers) - Use: Affix the Gravitational Reduction Slippers to your current footwear allowing you to jump higher and fall farther. Wormhole Generator: Argus (Schematic: Wormhole Generator: Argus) - Use: Teleports the player to a random location on Argus. Inscription
      Mass Mill Astral Glory - Mill multiple Astral Glory at once Jewelcrafting
      Design List: Argus Crowns - Jewelcrafters can now craft ilvl 885 crowns
      Empyrial Crown of the Cosmos - new ilvl 885 Cloth Helm
      Empyrial Crown of the Cosmos (Rank 1) Empyrial Crown of the Cosmos (Rank 2) - more efficient craft Empyrial Crown of the Cosmos (Rank 3) - even more efficient craft Empyrial Crown of the Depths - new ilvl 885 Leather Helm
      Empyrial Crown of the Depths (Rank 1) Empyrial Crown of the Depths (Rank 2) - more efficient craft Empyrial Crown of the Depths (Rank 3) - even more efficient craft Empyrial Crown of the Elements - new ilvl 885 Mail Helm
      Empyrial Crown of the Elements (Rank 1) Empyrial Crown of the Elements (Rank 2) - more efficient craft Empyrial Crown of the Elements (Rank 3) - even more efficient craft Empyrial Crown of the Titans - new ilvl 885 Plate Helm
      Empyrial Crown of the Titans (Rank 1) Empyrial Crown of the Titans (Rank 2) Empyrial Crown of the Titans (Rank 3) Design List: Argus Gemcutting - epic Gems have been added to the game
      Deadly Deep Chemirine - +250 Primary Stat and +188 Critical Strike Masterful Argulite - +250 Primary Stat and +188 Mastery Quick Lightsphene - +250 Primary Stat and +188 Haste Versatile Labradorite - +250 Primary Stat and +188 Versatility Mass Prospect Empyrium - Prospect multiple batches of Empyrium at once
      Leatherworking
      Fiendish Shoulderguards - new ilvl 885 Leather Shoulders
      Fiendish Shoulderguards (Rank 1) Fiendish Shoulderguards (Rank 2) - more efficient craft Fiendish Shoulderguards (Rank 3) - even more efficient craft Fiendish Spaulders - new ilvl 885 Mail Shoulders
      Fiendish Spaulders (Rank 1) Fiendish Spaulders (Rank 2) - more efficient craft Fiendish Spaulders (Rank 3) - even more efficient craft Mining
      New Mining Techniques have been added to the game
      Empyrium Deposit (Rank 1) - Increase the amount of material found in Empyrium Deposits Empyrium Deposit (Rank 2) - Chance to find rare materials in Empyrium Deposits Empyrium Deposit (Rank 3) - Increase the amount of material found in Empyrium Deposits Empyrium Seam (Rank 1) - Increase the amount of material found in Empyrium Seams Empyrium Seam (Rank 2) - Chance to find rare materials in Empyrium Seams Empyrium Seam (Rank 3) - Increase the amount of material found in Empyrium Seams Skinning
      New Skinning Techniques have been added to the game
      Fiendish Leather (Skinning Technique: Fiendish Leather (Rank 1)) - Gather Fiendish Leather more effectively Fiendish Leather (Skinning Technique: Fiendish Leather (Rank 2)) - Find rare metarials when gathering Fiendish Leather Fiendish Leather (Skinning Technique: Fiendish Leather (Rank 3)) - Gather Fiendish Leather more effectively Tailoring
      Lightweave Breeches - new ilvl 885 Cloth Legs (Design: Lightweave Breeches (Rank 1))
      Lightweave Breeches (Rank 1) Lightweave Breeches (Rank 2) - more efficient craft Lightweave Breeches (Rank 3) - even more efficient craft
    • By Stan

      Primal Obliterum can only upgrade new Patch 7.3 crafted items to item level 935. Pre-7.3 items can only be upgraded to 900 with Obliterum.
      To upgrade Obliterum into Primal Obliterum, you will need 1 Obliterum & 1 Primal Sargerite. Another Primal Sargerite will be consumed when you upgrade an item with Primal Obliterum by 5 ilvls.

      New 7.3 Crafted Gear
      Only the following items can be upgraded to 935. It doesn't matter if you craft older items after 7.3 goes live, they won't go beyond 900.
      Astral Alchemist Stone Empyrial Breastplate Design List: Argus Crowns Fiendish Shoulderguards Fiendish Spaulders Lightweave Breeches Placeholder for tweet 897964671298265088