Stan

Ghostcrawler on Death Knight Design

Sign in to follow this  

5 posts in this topic

mQxrftC.jpg

Even though Ghostcrawler no longer works for Blizzard, he still occasionally talks about World of Warcraft. He gives us a developer insight behind WoW's first Hero class, the Death Knight.

You may remember Greg "Ghostcrawler" Street. He was Lead Systems Designer at Blizzard, before he joined Riot Games. He has been really active on Twitter even after leaving Blizzard answering various user-submitted questions about World of Warcraft. This time, he talks about designing the Death Knight class back in Wrath of the Lich King.

Blizzard LogoGhostcrawler

If it’s not problematic for you to do so, would you mind talking to us a bit about the original WoW Death Knight that you were part of designing in Wrath of the Lich King? I’m very curious about how it was built from the ground up, what sorts of challenges you faced and what it ended up becoming. -Magdalena

Ah, one of the original DKs. :)

I could talk about this for days, probably. At the high level, there were a few goals:

1) Create another plate-using class with different abilities and feel than the warrior or paladin. Runes were already conceived before I joined the team as a way to avoid rage or mana (or energy). We hit upon diseases as the primary driver of the rotation: apply a disease, do damage, remove the disease with a finisher. Obviously the rotations have evolved enormously since then.  

2) Experiment with having spec not strictly tied to role. We tried letting Blood, Frost and Unholy all tank and all DPS or PvP (with slightly different builds). This meant coming up with separate but ideally equal tanking cooldowns for example, and ideas such as Bladed Armor to let DKs benefit from the natural defenses on their DPs-oriented gear.

3) Deliver on expectations from Arthas and the Warcraft RTS about how a death knight would play. Example: Death and Decay was an iconic DK ability that WoW had given to the Warlocks. Pets felt like something we needed to deal with. Healing had to be really kit-appropriate. 

4) Make a viable class. This may seem like a no-brainer, but it was a challenge back in the BC era. Early on, some of the hardcore raiders at Blizzard said they couldn’t fit a DK into their raid roster because the parties were so static (e.g. you need a shaman with the rouges for WF, so where was the DK going to fit?). This led to a lot of rethinking about raid buffs, including raid options for who brought what, party vs raid-wide buffs, and whether it was okay to have specs who were only useful for buffing.

5) Because I didn’t know the WoW spell system very well from a technical perspective, I came up with a lot of new ideas. The upside of this was that they were new idea that pushed the team a little to implement new things. The downside was that it caused a lot of bugs (particularly with Shadow of Death, or whatever the talent that let you come back to life). Even with the “hero class” concept, we know we had to present an argument to players over why they should pick the DK as their new main. We knew we had to do something different. Death Grip (which was mostly Xelnath) was key in this regard.

6) I think a lot of the DK success had to do with Acherus and the quest experience, which was mostly Afrasiabi. I helped with that, but I was more focused on abilities and talents. Just wanted to call that out.

7) It was also really important to me to involve the community. The only way I knew how to develop (from my decade working on Age of Empires) was to constantly ask players what was working and what needed work. The early DK community was awesome. They were overall really level-headed, open-minded and defaulted to trust, and I think this experience led to them feeling some level of ownership over the class rather than it strictly being something we passed down to them.

Some issues I am remembering (or misremembering):

There was a point where you could build a DK with something like 16 different diseases, which were all just generic, though there were abilities that scaled with disease count. Somewhere along the way we had the idea to just compress those down to two (Frost Fever and Blood Plague) and try and theme them more strongly. 

We struggled a ton with Chains of Ice, since it was iconic, but also dropping speed so dramatically was really powerful in PvP, especially for a tanky melee class with a lot of ranged spells.

Originally, the intent was that Blood was the more melee focused and easy to play spec. Frost was more for min/maxxers who wanted to obsess over secondary stats, with a bit of casting thrown in. Unholy was originally more of a pet class (which was always super niche) and morphed into being more about spells and debuffing.

We spent way too much effort trying to make the DK-specific enchants a thing, but we never balanced them well, and there was just a right answer most of the time. Go figure. Maybe it was worth it for the flavor, but I am kind of skeptical. (Do these still exist in WoW? Not sure.)

I have mixed feeling about retreating from the idea that there was no dedicated tanking spec. I agreed with the decision (and might have suggested it for all I know), but a lot of that was because we were developing dual-spec at the same time, which made it much easier for someone to say swap to offtanking for just one fight. The class team was starting to feel like we were developing 6 specs of DK (Frost dps, Frost tank, etc.) and that is even ignoring things like DW vs 2H weapons, PvP and so on.

Wow, that was quite the text dump. I hadn’t thought about this in while. If I am misremembering things, I apologize.

(Source)

Note that Ghostcrawler no longer works at Blizzard. He is currently the Design Director on League of Legends.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, PatrickHenry said:

I love hearing those stories. 

Mis-remembered or otherwise ;) 

It's good 'lore' into the game design. 

I agree completely.  I really enjoy hearing from Ghostcrawler too because he was all over the place when I first started WoW.  Every blue post I read seemed to come from him.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As someone that follows folks like Extra Credit and tries to stay up to date with design discussions every now'an'then... these are the types of things that I absolutely love reading about!

Even tho' back during the day and just recently I have gone from prowling forums to becoming more engaged in them, Ghostcrawler is probably one of those folks I will remember for a good long time. And for reasons such as this; very open-minded just retelling of the old creation of what's probably one of my favourite classes to date!

Love'd it! ^^

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Following him on Twitter is awesome, regardless of what he talks about. He is super insightful about so many things and, when WoW does pop up, you really do get a blast from the past. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Stan
       

      A new round of hotfixes was deployed to live servers with adjustments to Tier 21 bonuses from Antorus.
      Antorus, the Burning Throne opens next week and Blizzard continues to adjust Tier 21 set bonuses just before opening of Legion's last raid. For more details about Tier 21 sets, check out our Tier 21 set overview.
      Blizzard (Source)
      Dungeons and Raids
      Siege of Orgrimmar Paragons of the Klaxxi and Siegecrafter Blackfuse are much better hosts and no longer lock their doors if you leave the raid early. Items
      Death Knight: Dreadwake Armor Frost 4-piece bonus (Item - Death Knight T21 Frost 4P Bonus) now deals 210% weapon damage per tick (was 420%). Unholy 2-piece bonus (Item - Death Knight T21 Unholy 2P Bonus) now deals 35% of direct damage (was 25%) from Death Coil over 4 seconds. Demon Hunter: Felreaper Vestments Havoc 4-piece bonus (Item - Demon Hunter T21 Havoc 4P Bonus) now increases haste by 15% (was 40%) for 8 seconds. Druid: Bermantle Battlegear Balance 4-piece bonus (Item - Druid T21 Balance 4P Bonus) now increases the damage of Moonfire and Sunfire by 20% (was 10%) for 4 seconds. Hunter: Serpentstalker Guise Beast Mastery 4-piece bonus (Item - Hunter T21 Beast Mastery 4P Bonus) now reduces the cooldown of Aspect of the Wild by 1.5 seconds (was 2.0 seconds). Survival 2-piece bonus (Item - Hunter T21 Survival 2P Bonus) now increases the critical strike damage of your next Raptor Strike by 100% (was 50%) within the next 20 seconds. Mage: Runebound Regalia Arcane 2-piece bonus (Item - Mage T21 Arcane 2P Bonus) now increases your damage by 2% (was 4%) for 8 seconds per Arcane Charge spent. 4-piece bonus (Item - Mage T21 Arcane 4P Bonus) now has a 10% chance (was 8%) to increase your haste by 15% (was 20%) for 6 seconds. Fire 4-piece bonus (Item - Mage T21 Fire 4P Bonus) now increases your critical strike damage by 10% (was 12%) while Combustion is active. Frost 2-piece bonus (Item - Mage T21 Frost 2P Bonus) now increases the damage of Flurry by 15% (was 25%) for each successive ice bolt. 4-piece bonus (Item - Mage T21 Frost 4P Bonus) now increases the damage of your next Ice Lance by 20% (was 25%). Monk: Chi’Ji’s Battlegear Brewmaster 4-piece bonus (Item - Monk T21 Brewmaster 4P Bonus) now reads, “Every time you dodge an attack, the remaining cooldown of Breath of Fire is reduced by 1.0 sec.” Windwalker The 4-piece bonus (Item - Monk T21 Windwalker 4P Bonus) is now the 2-piece bonus, and still has a 10% chance to generate 1 Chi when you consume Blackout Kick! The 2-piece bonus (Item - Monk T21 Windwalker 2P Bonus) is now the 4-piece bonus, and now it increases the damage of your next Blackout Kick by 175% (was 150%). Paladin: Light’s Vanguard Battleplate Retribution 2-piece bonus (Item - Paladin T21 Retribution 2P Bonus) now increases the damage of Judgment by 40% (was 60%). Priest: Gilded Seraph’s Raiment Shadow 4-piece bonus (Item - Priest T21 Shadow 4P Bonus) now increases the critical strike chance of Mind Flay, Void Bolt, and Mind Blast by 0.5% (was 1%) per stack of Void Form. Rogue: Regalia of the Dashing Scoundrel Assassination 2-piece bonus (Item - Rogue T21 Assassination 2P Bonus) now increases the critical strike chance of Deadly Poison and Wound Poison by 60% (was 15%) for 6 seconds. 4-piece bonus (Item - Rogue T21 Assassination 4P Bonus) now has a chance to grant 2 Energy (was 4 Energy) when your Deadly Poison or Wound Poison critically strikes. Outlaw 2-piece bonus (Item - Rogue T21 Outlaw 2P Bonus) now increases the damage of your next Run Through by 15% (was 5%), stacking up to four times. 4-piece bonus (Item - Rogue T21 Outlaw 4P Bonus) now has a 16% chance (was 12%) to grant you a random Roll the Bones effect, that is not already active, for 10 seconds. Subtlety 4-piece bonus (Item - Rogue T21 Subtlety 4P Bonus) now has a 3% chance (was 5%) to grant Shadow Gestures when using Gloomblade, Backstab, and Shadowstrike. Shaman: Garb of Venerated Spirits Enhancement 2-piece bonus (Item - Shaman T21 Enhancement 2P Bonus) now has a 30% chance (was 15%) to increase the damage of your next Rockbiter by 100%. 4-piece bonus (Item - Shaman T21 Enhancement 4P Bonus) now causes the target to take 15% (was 10%) increased Fire and Nature damage from your attacks for 4.50 seconds after using Rockbiter. Warlock: Grim Inquisitor’s Regalia Affliction 4-piece bonus (Item - Warlock T21 Affliction 4P Bonus) now increases Corruption, Siphon Life, and Agony damage by 10% for 8 seconds (was 6 seconds). Destruction 2-piece bonus (Item - Warlock T21 Destruction 2P Bonus) now increases the critical strike chance of Incinerate by 40% (was 20%). Warrior: Juggernaut Battlegear Arms 2-piece bonus (Item - Warrior T21 Arms 2P Bonus) now increases your critical strike damage by 7% (was 10%) after using Colossus Smash. 4-piece bonus (Item - Warrior T21 Arms 4P Bonus) now increases the damage and critical strike chance of your next Whirlwind or Slam by 12% (was 15%), stacking up to three times. Fury 2-piece bonus (Item - Warrior T21 Fury 2P Bonus) now causes the target to bleed for an additional 18% (was 30%) of the direct damage dealt by Rampage, over 4 seconds. 4-piece bonus (Item - Warrior T21 Fury 4P Bonus) now increases the damage of your Rampage by 25% (was 75%) for 8 seconds. Events
      WoW’s 13th Anniversary Anniversary boss bonus rolls now reward Artifact Power instead of gold if you do not receive an item.
    • By Stan

      The latest information about Patch 7.3.2 and beyond!
      Patch 7.3.2 went live this week and we compiled a hub with all important information.
      Welcome to our latest Patch 7.3.2 hub. We will keep it updated with latest news and hotfixes, so that you won't miss out on any important information! Our class guides have been updated for the latest patch.
      Patch 7.3.2
      Instead of releasing Patch 7.3.5, Blizzard went with the odd numbering and released Patch 7.3.2. Main goal of the patch are bug fixes and tuning in preparation for Legion's last raid Antorus, the Burning Throne. In addition to that, the patch introduced a new Primal Sargerite vendor and some exiciting lore details have been entirely omitted from the official patch notes for obvious reasons.
      Official Patch Notes Legion Live Developer Q/A with Ion Hazzikostas (October 5) Primal Sargerite Vendor Patch 7.3.2 Hotfixes
      The following hotfixes have been applied to live servers so far:
      Patch 7.3.2 Hotfixes (November 21) Patch 7.3.2 Hotfixes (November 14) Patch 7.3.2 Hotfixes (November 6) Patch 7.3.2 Hotfixes (October 26) Patch 7.3.2 Hotfixes (October 24) Antorus, the Burning Throne Raid
      Legion's last raid tier will open at a later time, probably after BlizzCon 2017. Here's a collection of all articles about the raid that we covered thus far:
      A Comprehensive Guide to Antorus Relics Antorus Raid Zone Preview Part 1 Antorus Raid Zone Preview Part 2 Antorus Raid Zone Preview Part 3 Argus the Unmaker Encounter Preview & Secret Mythic Phase Argus the Unmaker Rewards (Mounts, Transmog) Argus the Unmaker Video Preview (26% best pull) Antorus Raid Rewards Antorus Raid Trinkets Guide Loot Information Path of the Titans Trinkets Explained Tier 21 Sets
      Players will be able to obtain Tier 21 sets when Antorus opens.
      Overview of All Tier 21 Sets from Antorus, the Burning Throne Legendary Items
      In Patch 7.3.2, Legendary items can be upgraded to item level 1,000.
      Legendary Items Guide for Patch 7.3.2 Lore & Spoilers
      Learn more about what happens after Argus has been defeated. The articles below contain major spoilers. More information will be added after BlizzCon.
      Before the Storm Warcraft Novel by Christie Golden Legion Ending & Next Expansion Leaks Silithus - The Wound The Fate of Azeroth
    • By Starym

       
      Antorus is coming next week and Blizzard have put an official raid preview together, featuring some lore, some developer insights and more!

      You can also check out our own boss and raid previews in the patch 7.3.2 hub!
      Antorus (source)
      At the core of Argus lies Antorus, the Burning Throne. From this seat of power, Sargeras drives his Burning Crusade to ravage the cosmos.
      Within the Throne’s nigh-impenetrable depths, primordial powers are being forged into weapons of utter annihilation. Should these voices rise to serve their master, the final hour will fall upon all of creation.
      The time has come for the forces of the Alliance and Horde to confront the Burning Legion within Sargeras’ seat of power. Antorus, the Burning Throne, awaits—along with the formidable dangers within.
       
      Location: Argus
      Difficulties: Raid Finder, Normal, Heroic, Mythic
      Level: 110
      Bosses: 11
      Raid Unlock Schedule (EU)
      November 29 — Normal and Heroic difficulties
      December 6 — Mythic difficulty and Raid Finder Wing 1: Light’s Breach
      December 20 — Raid Finder Wing 2: Forbidden Descent
      January 3 — Raid Finder Wing 3: Hope’s End
      January 17 — Raid Finder Wing 4: Seat of the Pantheon
       
      Light’s Breach
      Garothi Worldbreaker
      Constructed deep within the core of Argus and outfitted with an arsenal to decimate worlds, this war machine has been designed for a single purpose: to bring the mortals’ invasion to its knees.
      Felhounds of Sargeras
      Infused with fire and shadow, F’harg and Shatug are the prized pets of Sargeras. Bred for carnage, these hounds delight in eviscerating their master’s enemies.
      With the Army of Light and their allies advancing upon Antorus, the Legion prepares to unleash these vicious creatures onto the battlefield and put an end to the mortals’ invasion.
      Gaze of the Legion
      Antoran High Command
      Long ago, in the golden age of eredar civilization, a council was formed to oversee the defense of Argus and maintain peace. But after their dark bargain was struck with Sargeras, these master tacticians used their military expertise to help orchestrate a Burning Crusade that ravaged countless worlds.
      Now the full might of the Legion’s army is theirs to command, and they wield this terrible power to annihilate all who oppose the Dark Titan’s will.
      Halls of the Boundless Reach
      Portal Keeper Hasabel
      Portal Keeper Hasabel maintains the nexus through which the Legion has unleashed its insidious armies upon countless worlds. With portals that open to myriad strategic locations throughout the Great Dark Beyond. Hasabel is capable of bringing the might of the Legion’s arsenal to bear upon any who oppose her.
      Elarian Sanctuary
      Eonar Lifebinder
      Though she was felled by the blade of Sargeras, the Life-Binder’s essence escaped the grasp of the Dark Titan. After millennia spent hiding in isolation, Eonar’s sanctuary has been discovered by the Legion.
      Should her soul fall into the enemy’s hands, Eonar’s powers of nature growth will be perverted to make the Burning Crusade unstoppable.
      The Exhaust
      Imonar the Soulhunter The infamous Imonar serves as the Legion’s bloodhound, capable of tracking prey across the cosmos. With a vast array of gadgets and traps at his disposal, Imonar has yet to lose a bounty…and he certainly doesn’t intend to sully his perfect record by failing to fulfill his latest contract.
      Kin’garoth
      The design of every Legion war machine stems from the depraved mind of Kin’garoth. Obsessed with crafting implements of death, Kin’garoth infused his very body into the production machinery so he could more efficiently churn out a never-ending supply of destruction.
      At the behest of the Legion’s dark master, Kin’garoth’s fevered brilliance has developed a new super-weapon which he plans to unleash upon the Army of Light.
      The Burning Throne
      The Coven of Shivarra
      Having proven themselves to be the most depraved and fanatical of all his followers, Sargeras entrusted the Coven with the unholy task of twisting the minds of the fallen titans into an unstoppable Dark Pantheon.
      Each sister employs her own signature brand of torture, eliciting screams which echo throughout the halls of Antorus. It is said that neither mortal nor demon can refuse their whispers, making it only a matter of time before the will of the titans is broken.
      Chamber of Anguish
      Varimathras
      As one of the dreadlords overseeing the Legion’s forces during the Third War, Varimathras failed to stop the rebellious Lich King. He submitted to an ill-fated alliance with Sylvanas Windrunner, then made one last bid for power before facing a humiliating defeat.
      In payment for his blunders, Varimathras has been tortured by the Coven of Shivarra. The vindictive sisters stripped away both flesh and sanity, leaving only a singular desire to inflict suffering upon the mortals who cost him everything.
      The World Soul
      Aggramar
      Once the noble Avenger of the Pantheon, Aggramar was struck down by Sargeras and reborn as a titan of destruction. He now stands at the core of Argus, guarding a power that would unmake the universe.
      Not even demons are permitted to tread within the titan’s halls, and any mortals bold enough to trespass will be reduced to cinders by Aggramar’s burning blade, Taeshalach.
      Seat of the Pantheon
      Argus the Unmaker
      Bound. Broken.
      Eons of existence, knowing only pain.
      A shattered soul, fueling infinite evil.
      The master beckons. Rise… Rise!
      Begin the end of all things.
    • By Stan

      Find out what's happening in World of Warcraft during the week of November 21.
      Antorus the Burning Throne
      Antorus will open November 28. Mythic difficulty and the first LFR wing will be available starting December 5.
      Artifact Knowledge Level 53
      All players have access to AK level 53. Legion's max AK cap is 55. There's no reason to worry about catching up on Artifact traits or the Netherlight Crucible relic slots, because AP tokens from world quest and/or bosses will unlock all traits and Concordance of the Legionfall.
      Mythic Keystone Rewards & Affixes
      The ceiling on Mythic Keystone rewards will go up to 15 the week of December 5, when the Mythic difficulty of Antorus opens. If you do a Mythic Keystone 11-15 this week, that effort will be reflected in your weekly chest on December 5. More information can be found here.
      Bolstering Explosive Tyrannical Argus Weekly Quests
      Fuel of a Doomed World: Collect 50 Pristine Argunite from Invasion Points, Rare encounters, or treasure chests on Argus to receive 300 Veiled Argunite. Invasion Onslaught: Complete 3 Invasion Points to get 200 Veiled Argunite. Argus World Boss Occularus

      Occularus is this week's Greater Invasion Point world boss. The portal can be found in Antoran Wastes (55, 50). Don't forget to bring a Seal of Broken Fate for a bonus roll. All Argus world bosses drop ilvl 930 loot. Loot tables and Dungeon Journal entries can be found here. World Boss The Soultakers
      Search for the epic world quest The Soultakers in Stormheim. Death Knights can unlock the Dark Runeblade appearance for the Blades of the Fallen Prince via Runes of the Darkening.
      World Boss Loot Tables
      Barnacled Mistcaller Orb Cord of Kept Souls Hel-Cursed Belt Helchain Waistguard Sea-Reaver's Girdle Soultrapper's Pendant Thrice-Accursed Compass Legion Dungeon Event (Nov 21 - 28)
      While this event is active, the final boss of each Legion dungeon awards an extra item when defeated (Sign of the Warrior). Don't forget to complete the weekly dungeon quest "Emissary of War" to get Cache of Fel Treasures that contains a piece of Heroic Tomb of Sargeras gear. WoW's 13 Anniversary (Nov 16 - 30)
      World of Warcraft's 13th anniversary continues until November 30. Don't forget to make use of Celebration Package and read more details here.
      Pilgrim's Bounty (Nov 20 - 27)
      Not much has changed in 2017. Cosmetic Pilgrim's Bounty gear can be transmogrified during the event. More information can be found in our Pilgrim's Bounty guide.
    • By Stan

      Pilgrim’s Bounty is a time to reflect upon one’s good fortune and share with all around you. What's new in 2017?
      Pilgrim's Bounty is back and there's only one update to the event this year.
      New in 2017
      Cosmetic Pilgrim's Bounty items can be transmogrified for the duration of the event. The change applies to all world events, not just this one. Below are screenshots of said items.

      Pilgrim's Attire, Pilgrim's Hat, Pilgrim's Boots

      Pilgrim's Dress

      Pilgrim's Robe
      For more details check out our Pilgrim's Bounty guide.