Stan

Heroes Balance Q/A Summary

Sign in to follow this  

8 posts in this topic

DR8p9lT.jpg

The recap features highlights of the latest Balance Q/A from reddit. Balance Designers have been answering your questions.

Hero-related News

Anub'arak

V0TGBEY50T4F1417483333676.png

  • Anub'arak is a great tank who can counter mages and there are no changes planned for him right now.

Arthas

Q00N5QG4L4441417483333667.png

  • Arthas has some talents in the works that are internally tested that might help him.

Azmodan

MPC0MT16C6I91417483333902.png

  • There are plans to allow Azmodan to walk with basic movement speed while casting his laser.

Dehaka

S5T04ROESNVH1466787135735.png

  • The team wants to change the "D" overwrite.
  • The infamous Level 1 agility talent is on the radar.

Diablo

W74UW0BVVWY41417483334083.png

  • Diablo being able to activate his "D" was tested, but lead to weird behavior (players not resurrecting, because of losing power from stacks), so it wasn't implemented.

Falstad

XZ4PPH8K5IF51417483334088.png

  • Hinterland Blast will be revisited in the future to make it a more desirable pick.

Greymane

3N30E9ZS7S2D1452704274681.png

  • Drastic changes are coming to "Marked for the Kill" to make it an opening skillshot.
  • Damage reduction in Worgen Form is considered.

Li-Ming

Q9YVJXM1128C1455326823654.png

  • She will get some buffs to compensate for the "Calamity" nerf if needed.

Lunara

K666Z00DJIK21452704274692.png

  • A change for Skybound to reveal Stealth is planned.

Medivh

6WFFUF574HLT1463704053340.png

  • The team is satisfied how Medivh turned out, but they don't want to design Heroes that are useless to most of the audience.

Murky

ALZFYULQAD0J1417483334906.png

  • He's being tested internally and we should expect a rework in the next 2 or 3 months.

Nova

1P2JN07X4Q121417483335002.png

  • No Nova changes are planned for now.

Raynor

L1FZEBIMXPLI1417483335075.png

  • The team is happy with Raynor's simplicity and don't want to change him, but at some point in the future they'd like to update his talent tree.

Tassadar

2J5UMQ9U8Y951417483335330.png

  • There are plans to rework "Archon" to its former glory.

Thrall

FJ7AAFOTWHJ31417483335508.png

  • They're satisfied with Thrall's current spot, but he lacks talent diversity that will be looked into in the middle of next year.

Uther

5W8VDU5725O81417483335719.png

  • The rework is on the radar (around March). He will be reworked to fit the "tanky support fantasy".

Valla

RHUC14VVAAUN1417483335722.png

  • She's fine now, both her "Q" and "W" builds are doing fine. If the "Q" build isn't doing well, they consider buffing it or nerfing the "W" build.

Miscellaneous

  • The mount speed nerf is doing well, but it made globals more popular, which is why they are changing their effectiveness.
  • The team doesn't want to spend time redesigning Heroes that are fine for 99% of the player base, but aren't picked in Competitive.
  • There are no current plans to rework existing Heroes to be "multiclass".
  • There are discussions to expand the Hero role system, but far more important things to do for now. 
  • The team is not a fan of hard counters, e.g. Murky vs Tracer.
  • Health Globe talents are being looked into. The team wants to make them more interesting. One idea is split quest rewards, Part for gathering 20 globes and the rest for gathering 40.
  • Patches released two weeks after a Hero release are the best and they want to continue this trend.
  • Four-lane maps are hard to balance, but they want to make a brawl with one for testing.
  • Three talent picks per Tier are best for Heroes in terms of win rate and it allows to focus on more powerful options.

(Source)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

"In recent times, we have positioned Anub'arak to be a tank who counters mage characters pretty well (he has strong dive and can reduce damage from abilities.)" sounds a lot more like "Anub'arak is doing ok as a niche mage counter" than "Anub'arak is a great tank."

Also for Lunara " Good point. No guarantees but I'll see what we can do. :)" does not = "A change for Skybound to reveal Stealth is planned."

Edited by WhatDothLife

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
19 hours ago, Valhalen said:

Nothing to Cho'gall. =(

What would you change for him, just out of interest? Always like hearing new ideas :D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 hours ago, Blainie said:

What would you change for him, just out of interest? Always like hearing new ideas :D

I'd change so much... The problem is that Cho'gall pretty much has that one bread and butter build with a few variations here and there, but nothing that makes them either a fantastic tank or a deadly killer. Yeah, sure, they are a bit of both, but don't excel at any even with the right talents. Either you make a tanky Cho'gall or get hard countered by other Heroes. Since they count as two heroes, they should be as threatening as two, but I don't feel they really are all that.

I think they needs a major rework much like Stitches and Anub'arak had a while ago, so players can have more options for builds and increase the setups and synergies, which is what Cho'gall is all about. Maybe throw some Quest Talents or what not, or give Cho's trait a natural reduction on CCs so he is a bit more intimidating while in battle.

Another issue is that Dread Orb is too slow and easy to avoid, so it's only use is to damage structures. One of the Gall's best talent combination are Dread Shield + Twilight Nova, but even with that it is quite easy to avoid the orbs. Sure, making it too fast would be a bit too powerful, but a slightly increase in its bounce speed wouldn't hurt.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 12/12/2016 at 9:14 PM, Valhalen said:

I'd change so much... The problem is that Cho'gall pretty much has that one bread and butter build with a few variations here and there, but nothing that makes them either a fantastic tank or a deadly killer. Yeah, sure, they are a bit of both, but don't excel at any even with the right talents. Either you make a tanky Cho'gall or get hard countered by other Heroes. Since they count as two heroes, they should be as threatening as two, but I don't feel they really are all that.

Would you say the hero was in a good place when it first released, at least in regards to power? Or do you think it was too OP?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, Blainie said:

Would you say the hero was in a good place when it first released, at least in regards to power? Or do you think it was too OP?

I was MIA back when Cho'gall was released.  Did Blizzard nerf him?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 12/14/2016 at 4:30 PM, Valhalen said:

I was MIA back when Cho'gall was released.  Did Blizzard nerf him?

It might just have been that people weren't sure how to play against him, but I'm fairly certain that Gall in particular was better back then.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Stan

      Braxis Outpost has been chosen as this week's brawl. Complete three games on the single-lane map to earn a Loot Chest.
      Blizzard (Source)
      Rules:
      Shuffle Pick Choose from one of three randomly selected Heroes before entering the battle on Braxis Outpost. Be quick about it though, you only have 30 seconds to choose! ARAM Rules Players cannot use Hearthstone Players do not heal at their starting location. (Hall of Storms) Cores have no shields Mercenary Camps Braxis Outpost features two mirrored Goliath & Raven mercenary camps. Be the first team to take down the enemy Core to claim victory! Rewards:
      Complete three matches of Braxis Outpost to earn a Loot Chest.
    • By Stan

      Discussions continue about D.Va and her post-nerf win rate and Xul's nerfs from yesterday.
      D.Va
      At the time of nerfs, D.Va had the sixth highest win rate in Hero League for players that leveled her to 10 (Blizzard's standard metric). After nerfs she's at 48%  and it's very likely that some of her underperforming talents will be buffed. Blizzard (Source)
      Hey guys, I'm Alex from the Live/Balance Team and I wanted to chime in here.

      At the time of the nerfs to D.Va, she had the 6th highest winrate in Hero League (~54%) for players that had leveled her to 10 or higher (our standard metric). She was behind only Malthael, Uther, Ragnaros, Probius, and Tassadar. A lot of those Heroes have also received nerfs since that point in time.

      We also find that newer Heroes continue to trend up for a while, and our personal experience told us that players were still learning to be really effective with D.Va, so we believed that nerfs were correct.

      She's now at 48%, and anecdotally I've never been upset to see a D.Va in my games (nor felt like I shouldn't play her when the team composition made sense).

      It's very likely that we'll do more Talent tuning as we progress, which will likely result in buffs to some of the under-performing Talents. Overall, we won't always hit it perfectly the first time, as each Hero reacts differently to tuning, but we're always watching and will continue to make adjustments to get it right eventually. We care deeply for each Hero that is released, and want to see them have a nice place in the Nexus.

      GG WP! Xul
      The intention of yesterday's changes was to nerf Xul, but at the same time, improve his W-oriented (Cursed Strikes) build. Devs want to make his three builds on par and they're closely monitoring his win rate. Blizzard (Source)
      Just pointing facts here. At the time i post this, Xul has a win rate of 55.8% or ~56% in hero league. I am waiting for the deserved nerf. Honestly, that champion is a beast, both in qm and hero league.
      We're watching. The intention of the changes yesterday were to nerf Xul, but make the Cursed Strikes (W) build a little better in the process (since it was about 5% lower winrate).

      It's still too soon to make any conclusions, but an interesting observation is people are taking Grim Scythe oriented builds less often, which is leading to a rise in his winrate (since the build isn't performing as well on average).

      Obviously that's not ideal, we want to make all 3 builds on par, but its one of the things that leads to a fluctuation in a Hero's overall winrate that we need to keep in mind.
      I love your posts. Feed us more hero data!!!
      Thanks again.

      I am glad you are watching the situation closely. I just want to say something, though i doubt it is necessary. Please, don't try to balance the game only on 1 gamemode. Balance the game around every gamemode - QM, HL, Bot games.
      In general, we we aim to balance Hero League primarily, as that style of play usually trickles down into the other modes. If things are balanced there, we're usually in a pretty good spot in other game modes.

      We do watch Quick Match especially to make sure nothing gets out of hand though. Certain Heroes thrive in the more chaotic Quick Match (and with less structured team compositions), so we expect some deviation from Hero League's results because of it. But if it makes for a degenerative experience, we'll make some changes trying to address just Quick Match problems when we need to.
    • By Stan

      Senior Game Designer Matt Cooper talks about Brightwing, her current state and future changes. 
      The devs think Brightwing is in a healthy spot right now balance-wise and has good talent diversity. One exception to this are her Q talents. Her niche is a support with global mobility and there aren't any plans to change her Z. The fact that it has a long cooldown and can be interrupted with CC make it balanced. Her shield build was problematic when it was the only "correct" way to play her and invalidated her Z. On the other hand, the build was fun and had a strong sense of idenity and Blizzard would like to explore whether they can reintroduce some aspect of what made this build unique and fun. The community brought up that currently, there's no skill differentiation on Brightwing aka there's no difference between a good and a great Brightwing. The problem with Arcane Flare and its talents is their balance of effectiveness vs reliability. You don't get enough value from taking them compared to other options on the same tier and the team will be addressing it at some point when time allows. (Source)
    • By Stan

      For the True Horde! Learn more about Garrosh in our Hero preview.
      Victory or Death! Garrosh, Son of Hellscream has been added to the official website and Blizzard released a Hero spotlight with his abilities. Check out our preview for full talents!
      As the new warchief of the Horde, Garrosh is a proud and vicious warrior who rules with an iron fist. His hatred for the Alliance burns like wildfire, and he will stop at nothing to destroy them. By his axe, the orcs will reclaim their rightful glory.
      Skin Variation - Mad Axe Garrosh
      Of all the biker gangs marauding the wastelands, none are as feared as the Warsong Outriders. Led by the mutant warlord Garrosh, the roar of their engines is the sound of death on wheels.

      Trait - Armor Up
      Garrosh gains 1 Armor for every 2% of maximum Health missing,
      Primary Abilities
      [Q] GROUNDBREAKER Deal 81 damage to enemies in an area. Heroes hit on the outer edge are pulled toward Garrosh. [W] BLOODTHIRST Deal 156 damage to an enemy and heal for 10% of Garrosh's missing Health. Healing is increased by 100% against Heroes. [E] WRECKING BALL Throw a nearby enemy Hero, Minion, or Mercenary to the target location, dealing 91 damage to enemies near the impact and Slowing them by 30% for 2.5 seconds. Heroic Abilities
      [R1] WARLORD'S CHALLENGE Silence nearby Heroes and force them to attack Garrosh for 1.5 seconds. [R2] DECIMATE Deal 50 damage to nearby enemies and Slow them by 30% for 1.5 seconds. Deals 100% more damage to Heroes, and each Hero hit reduces the cooldown by 1 second. Stores up to 3 charges. Talents (Source - Credits go to redditor WarHamsterQueek)
      Level 1
      1 [Q] Warbreaker Quest: Pull Heroes with Groundbreaker Reward: After pulling 5 Heroes, Groundbreaker deal san additional 150 damage over 3 seconds to Heroes. After pulling 15 Heroes, reduce Groundbreaker’s cooldown by 3 seconds. 1 [E] Unrivaled Strength Increase Wrecking Ball’s throw range by 20% and its damage by 100% 1 [Active] Body Check Activate to deal 111 damage to a target enemy and Slow them by 30% for 3 seconds. Damage is increased by 200% of Armor Up’s current bonus, and the Slow amount is increased by 30% if Armor Up’s bonus is above 25. Level 4
      4 [W] In for the Kill Increase Bloodthirst’s damage against non-Heroes by 60% Killing enemies with Bloodthirst resets its cooldown and refunds its Mana cost. 4 [Passive] Thirst for Battle Basic Attacks against Heroes reduce the cooldown of Bloodthirst by 2 seconds. 4 [Active] Indomitable Activate to become Unstoppable for 1.5 seconds. Level 7
      7 [Q] Intimidation Groundbreaker reduces the Attack Speed of Heroes hit by 40% for 4 seconds. 7 [Active] Brute Force Enemies hit by Body Check receive 50% reduced healing for 4 seconds. 7 [Passive] Oppressor Basic Attacks against Heroes reduce the target’s Spell Power by 40% for 2.5 seconds. 7 [Active] Into the Fray Activate to throw a nearby ally and grant them 25 Armor for 3 seconds. Deals 91 damage to nearby enemies upon impact and Slows them by 30% for 2.5 seconds. While in flight, allied Heroes are Unstoppable. Level 10
      10 Warlord’s Challenge Silence nearby Heroes and force them to attack Garrosh 1.5 seconds. 10 Decimate Deal 50 damage to nearby enemies and Slow them by 30% for 1.5 seconds. Deals 100% more damage to Heroes, and each Hero hit reduces the cooldown by 1 second. Stores up to 3 charges. Level 13
      13 [Q] Defensive Measures Pulling a Hero with Groundbreaker grants Garrosh a 350 Shield for 6 seconds. 13 [W] Bloodcraze When hitting a Hero, Bloodthirst heals for an additional 10% of Garrosh’s maximum Health over 3 seconds. 13 [Trait - D] Double Up Armor Up can be activated to increase its Armor bonus by 100% for 3 seconds. Level 16
      16 [Q] Rough Landing Heroes pulled by Groundbreaker are Slowed by 50% for 3 seconds. 16 [Q] Mortal Combo If Wrecking Ball is used on a Hero within 2 seconds of pulling them with Groundbreaker, Wrecking Ball’s cooldown is reduced by 10 seconds. 16 [E] Earthshaker Wrecking Ball Stuns enemies near the impact area for 0.75 seconds. Level 20
      20 [R1] Death Wish Increase the duration of Warlord’s Challenge by 0.5 seconds. If an enemy Hero is killed while affected by Warlord’s challenge, its cooldown is reduced by 45 seconds. 20 [R2] Deadly Calm Heroes hit by Decimate deal 20% less damage for 3 seconds. 20 [E] Titanic Might Wrecking Ball now throws the 2 closest enemies. 20 [Active] Inner Rage Body Check gains an additional charge, and its cooldown recharges 100% faster while Armor Up’s bonus is at or above 25. Hero Spotlight
      Garrosh will be playable on PTR starting July 31.
    • By Stan

      Blizzard just released a balance update with plenty of Hero changes and bug fixes.
      Blizzard (Source)
      Assassin
      Genji

      Stats
      Health reduced from 1600 to 1550 Health Regen reduced from 3.3 to 3.2 Abilities
      Shuriken (Q) Mana cost increased from 15 to 20 Dragonblade (R) Cooldown increased from 80 to 100 seconds Mana cost increased from 50 to 75 Talents
      Level 7 Dodge (Passive) Charges reduced from 3 to 1 Cooldown reduced from 12 to 8 seconds Greymane

      Abilities
      Cursed Bullet (R) Damage reduced from 40 to 35% of enemy Heroes’ current Health Tychus

      Talents
      Level 4 Fully Loaded (Q) Cooldown reduction increased from 33% (4 seconds) to ~41% (5 seconds) Specialist
      Xul

      Abilities
      Raise Skeleton (Trait) Health reduced from 300 to 270 Cursed Strikes (W) Cooldown increased from 15 to 16 seconds Talents
      Level 1 Backlash (Trait) Damage reduced from 15 to 12% of enemy Heroes’ maximum Health Level 4 Grim Scythe (W) Cooldown reduction per attack increased from .5 to .75 seconds Maximum cooldown reduction increased from 10 to 12 seconds Support
      Stukov

      Abilities
      Healing Pathogen (Q) Mana cost increased from 30 to 40 Flailing Swipe (R) Pushback distance increased by 50% Talents
      Level 1 Spine Launcher (Passive) Slow duration increased from 1 to 1.5 seconds (now matches his attack speed) Fetid Touch (W) Quest requirements reduced from 20 and 40 Heroes hit to 15 and 30 Growing Infestation (E) Added functionality: Now increases the Cooldown of Lurking Arm by 4 seconds Level 4 One Good Spread… (Q) Spreading requirement reduced from 4 to 3 Heroes Mana refund increased from 30 to 40 Vigorous Reuptake (D) Healing bonus reduced from 50 to 40% Level 16 Pox Populi (D) Adjusted functionality: Detonating Bio-Kill Switch no longer refreshes heal duration, but instead extends it by 3 seconds Level 20 Controlled Chaos (R) Cooldown between casts reduced from 3 to 1 second Cooldown for each charge reduced from 40 to 30 seconds Push Comes to Shove (R) Duration requirement reduced from 1.5 to 1.25 seconds Uther

      Abilities
      Holy Light (Q) Healing reduced from 380 to 360 Self-healing reduced from 190 to 180 Holy Radiance (W) Mana cost increased from 60 to 70 Warriors
      Chen

      Abilities
      Fortifying Brew (Trait) Brew per second reduced from 40 to 30 Chen will now instantly gain 25 Brew upon activation Talents
      Level 1 Elusive Brawler (Active) Cooldown increased from 20 to 25 seconds Cooldown reduction from Basic Attacks reduced from 3 to 2 seconds Muradin

      Stats
      Health increased from 2633 to 2765 Health regen increased from 5.5 to 5.8 Rexxar

      Talents
      Level 1 Flare (Active) Cooldown reduced from 25 to 20 seconds Stitches

      Abilities
      Vile Gas (Trait) Damage reduced from 18 to 17 Talents
      Level 1 Heavy Slam (W) Bonus damage reduced from 50 to 40% Bug Fixes
      Heroes, Abilities, and Talents
      Diablo: Casting Shadow Charge on Sgt. Hammer while she is in Siege Mode will no longer cause Diablo to pass through her. Malfurion: The Moonburn Talent will no longer cause Moonfire to deal bonus damage to Mercenaries and Monsters prior to reaching 25% bonus damage against Minions. Malfurion: Casting Astral Communion now properly consumes 100 Mana. Nazeebo:  Fixed an issue that could prevent Voodoo Ritual from gaining stacks after scoring the killing blow on a Minion. Stukov: Fixed a typo in the tooltip for Fetid Touch. Stukov: Stop, Hold Fire, Taunt, and Dance commands can no longer be issued while casting or channeling Lurking Arm. Stukov: Fixed an issue that could cause FPS to drop to 30 when targeting Lurking Arm. Stukov: Massive Shove will no longer be cancelled when used on Sgt. Hammer while she is in Siege Mode. Tyrande: After learning Huntress’ Fury, Basic Attacks against targets with Hunter’s Mark will now correctly splash to nearby enemy Mercenaries. Tyrande: Fixed an issue causing Sentinel to benefit from increased width prior to learning the Ranger Talent.