Stan

How Devs React to Unsubscribing?

Sign in to follow this  

3 posts in this topic

TbytCT6.jpg

Did you know that unsubscribing because of a design change is quite rare and developers don't take any actionable feedback? Ghostcrawler talks about subscribers, how the developers maintain the game fresh and more!

Greg "Ghostcrawler" Street was the Lead Systems Designer for World of Warcraft before he joined Riot Games and now he's the design director on League of Legends. Even though he no longer speaks for Blizzard, he often gives insightful responses related to game design and this time it's no different.

The subject today is how (and if) developers react to players' unsubscribing as this is the only way to share displeasure with the game. Do they make any changes? Does unsubbing have any direct impact on developers' choices?

  • The devs care why you stop playing their game, but for games like WoW and LoL the reasons can be narrowed down into two:
    • Players have less time to play the game.
    • Players stop playing, because their friends don't play anymore.
  • Dropping a game because of a design change is rare, so for developers it's hard to take actionable feedback.
  • The best way to express your concerns is to discuss an issue on the official forums to make yourself heard.
  • In games that have lasted for so many years (Age of Empires, World of Warcraft, League of Legends) there are times when you gain and lose subscribers over the course of months or years.
  • If you lose to many players the main reasons why they quit is because they are getting bored and the developers need to be bold and innovate, but at the same time, they can't change the game too much to make it confusing for returning players.

Many similarities can be seen between Legion development and Greg's statement. Legion has a lot of TBC nostalgia (Illidan, Tier 20 Sets, Kil'jaeden, Isle of Quel'danas aka the Broken Shore) and many catch-up mechanisms to help returning players (Artifact Knowledge catch-up, increase of item level drops across dungeons etc.). One of the best things of Legion is you always have something to do, players aren't getting bored that quick and patches add a lot of content. For example, Patch 7.2 is the biggest content patch ever introduced to the game. The developers are successfully avoiding content drought in this expansion.

Blizzard LogoGreg "Ghostcrawler" Street (Source)

“Unsubbing is often seen as the only ‘real’ way by players to express their displeasure in a way that affects the devs. However, one thing I’ve never known is how devs themselves react to this. Do you double down? Scrap plans? Abandon the game?”

There are a couple of different ways to answer this.

Developers do care if you stop playing their game and they want to know why. However, for games like WoW and LoL, the answers are almost always “I have less time to play now (job/school/family” and “My friends don’t play anymore.” (I’m basing that on having seen a lot of data - it’s not super open to debate.)

Dropping a game because of a specific design change (despite what you might read on forums / Reddit) is actually pretty rare. I know it happens, but if you’re stack ranking the reasons why people quit, those specific responses end up being so far down the list that it is hard for a development team to take actionable feedback. It’s really rare you see “Wow, that change we made cost us 10,000 players. Let’s revert it!” So overall, I would not advocate boycotting a game as a way to make a statement, especially if deep down you still love the game. You’re just not likely to drive change as a result.

(As an aside, the best way to drive change is still to try and clearly articulate your concerns in some public forum and hope that the developers take it seriously. I have talked to plenty of players to know how frustrating that answer might be, because at the end of the day, there just isn’t some kind of magic key that you can use to 100% guarantee that you will unlock that lock. Nevertheless, it’s still the best hope you have.)

Now, there are long term trends in the lifespan of a game. At the end of the day, I have really only worked on three games (Age of Empires, World of Warcraft, and League of Legends). All three are games that have lasted for many years, but there are macro trends of engagement, meaning sometimes you’re gaining players and sometimes you’re losing players over the course of a few months or a few years.

And it’s interesting. When you see a lot of players leave over the course of say half a year, it usually spurs two diametrically opposed views on the development team. You will get one faction of “Players are getting bored - we must be bold and innovate!” You get another faction of “We are changing the game so much that we’re losing our soul! We need to get back to basics!”

Like with so many things, it’s rarely so cut and dried that you must pick one of those directions over the other. Often the answer ends up being that you need to innovate in one direction, while still making sure the game is easy to return to, and perhaps even getting back to something familiar or even nostalgic in yet other designs.

My perception has been that the players and developers in the “We’ve changed too much!” camp tend to be those who are less engaged with the game than they once were. Losing track of change usually happens to players who once played every day and are now playing once a week or once a month. They remember being super engaged with the game and knowing everything that was going on, and so the dissonance of that no longer being the case for them is really striking, perhaps even alienating. On the other hand, players who are still really engaged are the ones most likely to need something fresh and new so that they don’t run out of stuff to do. 

Overall as a developer, I tend to advocate being bold and innovating. This depends a lot on your business model. Some games really want to create new players as a fast as they can because they can’t hold on to current players for very long. (That’s not a holistic criticism - it’s just a different model.) But a game like League tends to be more reliant on keeping current players than it is on attracting new ones. (Example: if you’re a young man in Korea, chances are you either play LoL or have decided it’s not for you. There probably isn’t a young man in Korea who has just heard of this new LoL thing and wants to try it out.) For League, we weigh most of our decisions on resonance with active players. Yes, it is entirely possible to change so much that you drive players away, but we think the risk of stagnation is greater. So for League, the answer is usually double down. YMMV

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

" The developers are successfully avoiding content drought in this expansion. "

 

So far, at least. As has been traditionally for expansion packs. The drought always starts once teams are shifted into making the next expansion:

 

During WotLK: Drought after ICC is finished.

During Cataclysm: Drought after DS is finished.

During MoP: Drought after SoO is finished.

During WoD: Drought after HFC is finished.

(expected) During Legion: Drought after N'zoth raid is finished.

 

There have been "mild" droughts as well in some expansions in between raids, but that's definitely more polished in this xpac.

But stating "The developers are successfully avoiding content drought in this expansion." 100% remains to be seen. It's more of a "until now." which they have been successful in in the past as well (With some big dips such as the selfie patch and the voice comm patch)

 

Very bold statement by the moderator :P

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Rather than simply quitting the game for good, I just take a small (1-2 Months) break from the game. When I get back I have the entire Suramar (part 2) questline & Nighthold to go through.

What many people are currently facing is to not get burned out from the constant AP/WQ farm and progression raiding. 

What mostly got me this expansion was my desire to switch mains from mage to druid, in the end I played both of them which burned me out even faster.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Starym
      Here come today's hotfixes, reminding us of the Feral and Frost buffs coming this reset, as well as a few extra fixes for Reckless Flurry, Siege of Boralus and Way of the Crane.
      December 17 (source)
      Classes
      Note: These changes will be applied with weekly restarts in each region. Druid Feral Damage of all abilities increased by 7% Mage Frost Damage of all abilities increased by 3%  
      Items
      Heart of Azeroth (Fury Warrior) Reverted an unintended reduction to the damage of Reckless Flurry .  
      Dungeons
      Siege of Boralus Viq’Goth Call of the Deep should no longer damage players who are currently mounted in the cannon.
      Player versus Player
      Monk Mistweaver Fixed a bug that caused Way of the Crane to heal for more than intended on a critical strike.  
      Quests
      The Alliance War Campaign quest “The Big Boom ” can now be completed while the world quest “Zem'lan Rescue ” is active. Previous hotfixes.
    • By Stan
      The Feast of Winter Veil has begun and you can work toward the Merrymaker achievement for the Reins of the Violet Proto-Drake mount through January 2.
      2018 Updates to Winter Veil
      At Least You're Being Careful is a new achievement for opening this year's gift. Toy Armor Set (Alliance) & Toy Armor Set (Horde) can be found in the 2018 gift. The Alliance set contains Alliance Toy Cape & Wooden Toy Helm. The Horde set contains Horde Toy Cape & Wooden Toy Helm. Miniature Winter Veil Tree's item level is 335 this year. Blizzard also updated the Stag & Sleigh models in Battle for Azeroth. Check out our Winter Veil guide to learn more about the event!
      Stag & Sleigh Model Updates

    • By Stan
      Celestalon clarified in a series of tweets how the secret The Hivemind mount works.
      The multi-person capability is a special perk for the Hivemind group (the 5 people you last completed it with) and the final ritual is what establishes the link. Each player in a said group increases the mount's speed by 10% (Joined Hivemind). If you completed the final puzzle with a random group, you will need to complete it again with a different group for the speed bonus.
      Placeholder for tweet 1074489992548765696 Placeholder for tweet 1074492861976965120 Placeholder for tweet 1074543686430543872 Placeholder for tweet 1074493194040049664 Check out the guide over at Warcraft Secrets if you still haven't obtained the mount.
    • By Starym
      Well, that didn't take long! It seems you can't keep the WoW secret finders in the dark for too long, as they've already broken through and managed to obtain the mount! Warcraft Secrets and the secrets discord were hard at work the past few days and today finally bore fruit as they pushed through all the colored crystal monocles and found their way to the Court of Stars.

      From there it's a whole lot of petting kittens and purring, followed by phase-shifting platforms to navigate, and then the goal itself:

      While the very end of the guide hasn't been updated yet, it will be very soon so head on over to Warcraft Secrets and check out the full guide, and you might be riding this crazy thing soon as well.
      And, of course, congratulations to everyone that helped out in the endeavor, it was an amazing performance by all involved!
    • By Starym
      New hotfixes and this time around there's a whooole lot of dungeon changes to non-boss enemies as well as a tragic modification to Fetid Devourer's classic walk. M+ affixes were also tuned, with a Grievous nerf and a Bursting buff. The Elixir of Tongues has also made an appearance, allowing you to understand the opposing faction, and you can buy it from Lizzi Liverzapper. There's also Island Expedition fixes and a few PvP changes as well.
      December 14 (source)
      Classes
      Hunter Marksmanship Double Tap will no longer be immediately consumed for no benefit if it is activated while channeling Rapid Fire . Dungeons and Raids
      Grievous should no longer stack to 2 on the first periodic. Increasing damage of Bursting to 7% per tick (was 5%). Atal’Dazar Removed Infested from several stationary enemies in the instance. Kings’ Rest Adjusted spawns of Teeming in the instance immediately before and after the Golden Serpent. Animated Guardian’s Released Inhibitors only increases Melee haste. Lowered duration of King A’akul’s Hidden Blade to 4 seconds (was 8 seconds. Lowered Embalming Fluid DoT duration to 6 seconds (was 10 seconds). Lowered Golden Serpent’s Animated Gold health by 75%. Lowered Guard Captain Atu’s Axe Barrage to 6 seconds (was 10 seconds). Queen Patlaa’s Dark Shot changed. It now takes 1.5 seconds to land. Reduced Spectral Berserker Severing Blade damage by 25%. Seneschal M’bara is now level 120 and is susceptible to crowd control. Spectral Berserker is now level 120 and is susceptible to crowd control. Motherlode Adjusted spawns of Teeming in the instance. Reduced Venture Co. Mastermind Leech Globule healing by 50% Increased Feckless Assistant Transfiguration Serum recast to 20 seconds (was 10 seconds). Reduced Weapon Testers Echo Blade damage by 50%. Reduced damage of Venture Co. Earthshaper’s Rock Lance by 25%. Reduced Recast of Earthshaper’s Earth Shield to 20 seconds (was 10 seconds). Wanton Sapper casts Final Blast at 10% health (was at 20%). Sethrallis Increased recast of Healing Wave cast by Charged Dust Devil to 16 seconds (was 10 seconds). Reduced duration of Sandswept Marksman Neurotoxin to 4 seconds (was 8 seconds). Faithless Tender’s Greater Heal is now single target. Reduced melee damage of Faithless Conscript by 70%. Increased respawn of Faithless Conscripts to 50 seconds (was 60 seconds). Shrine of the Storm Lowered damage of Temple Attendant’s Wash Away by 25%. Wash Away no longer hits pets and guardians. Runecarver Sorn’s Carve Flesh initial damage reduced by 75%, but is now increased by 70% per tick. Increased recast on Drowned Depthbringer’s Rip Mind to 16 seconds (was 8 seconds). Removed Infested from the Living Current before Aqu’sirr. Siege of Boralus Reduced damage of Blacktar Bomber’s Burning Tar initial damage by 50% and Fire Bomb by 25%. Adjusted spawns of Teeming and Infested in the instance. Increased cast time of Ashvane Commander’s Bolstering Shout to 5 seconds (was 3 seconds). Reduced Hadal Darkfathom’s Break Water unavoidable damage by 25%. Reduced range on Bilge Rat Demolisher Terrifying Roar to 10 yards (was 30 yards), and added a precast visual. Tol Dagor The Sand Queen’s Buzzing Drone no longer melees, but casts Itchy Bite much more frequently. Ashvane Marine’s Suppression Fire initial damage removed, but periodic damage immediately deals damage. Overseer Korgus Incendariy Rounds no longer stacks. Heavy Cannon’s Cannon Blast damage should now scale with the Keystone Level of the dungeon. The Underrot Increased recast on Devout Blood Priest abilities. Reduced Fanatical Headhunter Barbed Spear duration to 4 seconds (was 8 seconds). Reduced duration of Warcry to 8 seconds (was 30 seconds). Elder Leaxa will now only spawn one Blood Mirror clone. Waycrest Manor Deathtouched Slaver is now susceptible to Stun. Maddened Survivalist Freezing Trap is now Magic. Uldir Fixed a bug with the way Fetid Devourer uses his walk. No time to talk. Island Expeditions
      Resolved an issue in Jorundall that could cause the Southsea Pirate invasion to spawn a pirate ship in Fatigue waters. Items
      Players are now able to purchase Elixir of Tongues from Lizzi Liverzapper. Using and applying the potion will allow players to be able to understand the opposite faction. Captain's Signet of Command is now item level 395 (was 380) to match its Horde counterpart. Scouting Maps should again show up on the Honorbound and 7th Legion vendors and display the Pathfinder requirement to buy it if you do not have that achievement yet. Fixed an issue where Cloak of the Restless Tribes was not scaling properly after exiting a Timewalking dungeon. Player versus Player
      Monk Wind Waker will put a spell visual on the Monk when an ally triggers it. Paladin Ultimate Retribution will now cancel when Divine Shield or Blessing of Protection is applied. World Quests
      It is now raining additional mana for the Nazmir Assault World Quests "It's Raining Mana " and "Untapped Potential ". Previous hotfixes.