Jump to content
FORUMS
Starym

Dev Watercooler: BfA Class Design Overview

Recommended Posts

bxSDzET.png
 

Battle for Azeroth is getting closer and closer, with early testing imminent and Blizzard have chosen to talk to the community about classes in the upcoming expansion. The plan is to continue Legion's design principles of iteration and focus on each classes uniqueness, improve the graphical presentation of abilities and focus on specs that don't match this criteria yet.

Here's the full thing and it's well worth a read:

Blizzard LogoDev Watercooler (source)

The development of World of Warcraft: Battle for Azeroth is well underway, and we want to share some insights into our philosophies and approach to class design for the expansion. While the launch of Legion brought lots of change to all of Warcraft’s classes, Battle for Azeroth will more closely resemble the example set by Legion’s patch content: targeted iteration based on player feedback and data.

The intro cinematic of Battle for Azeroth revealed at BlizzCon 2017 has an underlying theme that resonates deeply with the class design team: “Remember what makes us strong.” With that in mind, our goals for the next expansion are to promote what makes each class unique, focus on making group gameplay the best that it can be, and continue our efforts to improve combat visuals and effects. While we believe some specializations will need substantial iteration to achieve these goals, others will not, and our target is greater stability across the board.

Class Uniqueness and Utility

One area we’re trying to focus on across all classes is to better emphasize what makes each class unique and provide greater distinction among their various capabilities, especially when it comes to utility—tools that fall outside of core role functions like damage, healing, or mitigation. Part of what makes you feel excitement and pride in your class is pulling off a heroic moment and feeling the appreciation of your group when individually contributing to a shared success. That feeling is eroded when so many classes bring similar abilities, and you feel you’re rarely providing something distinctive. More differentiation in this area will create situations where another class can do something that you can’t, but you will similarly bring tools to the table that your allies lack.

 That contrast causes members of a team to be more dependent on each other to succeed, and encourages different group compositions to approach encounters in different ways.

Pursuing this goal will likely involve adding some new abilities (or re-adding previously removed abilities) to give classes a more unique signature where needed. It will also likely involve reining in the availability of certain utility types, especially those that are so widespread that they rarely provide meaningful contrast between classes. As a notable example, Area of Effect (AoE) stuns, some of most powerful utility that exists, are so abundant that most groups have at least one or two. As a result, decision-making around that tool is often less about when it would be best used, and more about avoiding overlap with other AoE stuns. Not only does this sometimes drown out the importance of other crowd control in dungeons, but it means that a class bringing an AoE stun to a group is not the major strategy-defining asset that it should be. Our goal is that whatever powerful kind of utility a class brings, it’s something that group will be happy to have added to their toolbox as they approach a challenge.

The goal of contrast between the abilities of different specializations is not limited to utility. We’re also looking at different specializations’ strengths and weaknesses in their “main role”—damage dealing (or DPS), healing, or tanking—and making sure everyone has something to get excited about and an opportunity to shine. Some DPS specializations are “bursty,” doing fast damage; some live for attrition, wearing away their target. Some specializations prefer to isolate and drill into a single threat, while others revel in blowing up huge packs of monsters. Much of this plays out naturally due to the varying sets of damaging abilities, but we are working more intently than in the past to ensure an appropriate variety and spread of DPS strengths and weaknesses. Likewise, healers and tanks should have a bit more identity through their unique healing and mitigation profiles.

Another part of this approach involves working with our content design teams to collaborate on a world where quests, dungeons, and raids create opportunities for all different types of class strengths to shine. If we’re arming classes with distinct tools that provide powerful answers to different situations, it’s important that the game’s content provides a broad array of challenges that play into those different tools.

Talent System Refinements

The overall talent system will remain largely unchanged, but we will be refining our approach. One of the major challenges in setting up talent rows is that they serve two conflicting desires: choices within a row should be meaningfully varied, but also should not feel like they are simply a test of which is best in a particular setting. 

If a row has three similar area-damage talents, your decision can feel like it boils down to a complex math problem. If a row mixes area-damage and single-target talents, you’ll likely feel you should change talents to suit the content you’re doing, which also rarely feels like a choice. The most successful talent rows are those with options that have a generally consistent role in your toolkit, but have very different delivery and mechanics, allowing players to thoughtfully customize their identity and complexity.

One other lesson we’ve already begun implementing in Legion patches is being careful with the effect that talents have on “pacing”—how frequently you get to press your buttons, and how often you generate resources and cooldowns. Of course, many talents affect the pacing of a rotation, and this will continue to be the case, as these are some of the talents with the most noticeable and fun feel to them. But if you have access to multiple talents that slow down or speed up your rotation, players can end up outside the bounds of what feels good to play (for example, by being resource starved or flooded). As we review talents going forward, we will try to avoid this by having strong resource-generating talents compete with each other, and better limiting the pacing change allowable from any single talent.

Artifacts Here and Gone

One particular challenge for the class design team throughout Legion was handling the introduction and eventual removal of Artifacts. The idea was exciting: design a large set of bonuses with the intention that they would be contained within an expansion, allowing us to make them flashier, more complex, and more numerous than we’d been able to in a specialization’s permanent set of core abilities. But the process of parting with Artifacts produces a complex set of decisions about how to adjust the base classes to play well in their absence.

The largest issue is where the pacing of a spec’s rotation was heavily affected by Artifacts. In that case, removing the Artifact may result in a rotation that’s too slow, or has too much open time where the core buttons aren’t available. In the process of reviewing and updating each specialization for Battle for Azeroth, we want to make sure all of them are paced appropriately after the removal of Artifacts. In some cases, we may do things like increase resource generation or reduce cooldowns to fill in some of the newly opened space.

For traits that go beyond simple numerical changes and have their own identity—such as active abilities or the powerful and noticeable procs—we are on the lookout across all specs for a small selection of traits that are worth turning into permanent parts of a class. The bar is high for a trait to become permanent. It’s an intended part of the experience of a system like Artifacts that the bonuses are layered on top of the core functionality of your class. You get to explore those bonuses thoroughly, but eventually move on from them. That leaves space in the permanent classes for new special bonuses from other systems in the future, as we’ll soon be exploring with Azerite Armor. That said, various specs will likely see one or two familiar traits from Artifacts showing up in their talent trees in Battle for Azeroth.


These are the broad philosophies that are guiding our design in Battle for Azeroth, and we were deliberately light on sharing specific examples of change, which are still in a state of flux at this stage. We welcome a community discussion on the principles we’ve outlined, and look forward to delving into detailed and specific changes as we move forward with our beta testing in the near future.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, Xaethron said:

They mentioned everything except how players really feel about the classes.

And how do they really feel about them? By now everything Blizzard or any other game developer / publisher does ends exactly the same way: A majority of the people rage no matter what and people that dare to say they like a change are accused of fanboyism (what a nice word) or naivety or _______________ (fill in blank here) :-)

For me it is always nice to get to know the reasoning behind decisions Blizz makes. But I might be one of a thousand because I do not rage and blame and so on.

For me Legion brought some of the best class identy changes ever. They made a lot of specalizations viable and enjoyable to play and carved out some real nice class fantasies. I like to give things a try and to find joy in stuff even if they seem to be changes for the worse at first sight. If things (take old raid scaling for example) are really messed up the developers immediately hotfix them.

Often people do not realize what dimensions companies like Blizz work in and with when they claim that this or that problem should be easy to fix. Companies of such scale have to prioritize problems. Sometimes things are important but time consuming or they are easy to fix but not really neccessary right now and so on. And games like WoW have code that is in some parts over a decade old which naturally leads into some unexpected outcome when you change stuff.

Edited by Caeren
  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 1/24/2018 at 12:13 PM, Starym said:

 That feeling is eroded when so many classes bring similar abilities, and you feel you’re rarely providing something distinctive. More differentiation in this area will create situations where another class can do something that you can’t, but you will similarly bring tools to the table that your allies lack.

This.  

There are some classes that just... really provide nothing other than numbers.  Even IV's own guide for frost DK notes they really bring nothing to the table.  

Whereas my Ret paladin has immunities, reductions, movement retainers, cleansing and healing...  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 hours ago, PatrickHenry said:

This.  

There are some classes that just... really provide nothing other than numbers.  Even IV's own guide for frost DK notes they really bring nothing to the table.  

Whereas my Ret paladin has immunities, reductions, movement retainers, cleansing and healing...  

It would be amazing if frost DK's had a repositioning tool, something that can prevent even stun immune trash in m+ from getting their cast through, somthing that would help timing aggramar adds. Sadly, they only have dps.

Some classes might be more versatile than others, but every class has something they bring to the table. Interesting tho that you picked out the class that provides the grip mechanic as useless.

  • Haha 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have heard rumors, that they want to change tanking to be more reliant on armor and get rid of active mitigation, what is up with that ?

Also why can't they just incorporate the essential traits into the classes like they used to do with tier sets ? If they say they won't change too much I'd be disagreeing, because the trais are something the classes now and their playstyle depend on. I just wanna play my class in the same reliable fashion I could in Legion, if they claim it is not gonna change too much.

As a blood dk I wouldn't really want them messing around with the tanking specs too much, I heard they wanted to "even out the viability of tank classes", but I mean the tanks and their different playstyles make out their identity and you play them for exactly that. I hope Blizz knows that and doesn't turn the gold they currently have into ashes.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
14 hours ago, Ilummini said:

It would be amazing if frost DK's had a repositioning tool, something that can prevent even stun immune trash in m+ from getting their cast through, somthing that would help timing aggramar adds. Sadly, they only have dps.

Some classes might be more versatile than others, but every class has something they bring to the table. Interesting tho that you picked out the class that provides the grip mechanic as useless.

Interesting I noted it was this very website with guides provided by top raiders that noted its virtual lack of utility, minus DG that works on ..... how many raid fights again?  MAYBE half?  Whereas I can BOP on cooldown and at least have SOME usefulness throughout most any encounter.  

I'm not saying they're USELESS.  Find that word in my paragraph please.  I B waiting.

Interesting tho you picked an argument I didn't even make to argue against.

Edited by PatrickHenry

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 26/01/2018 at 4:25 AM, Ilummini said:

It would be amazing if frost DK's had a repositioning tool, something that can prevent even stun immune trash in m+ from getting their cast through, somthing that would help timing aggramar adds. Sadly, they only have dps.

Some classes might be more versatile than others, but every class has something they bring to the table. Interesting tho that you picked out the class that provides the grip mechanic as useless.

This isn't unique to the DK, though. A grip mechanic can be mimicked by any class by just using LoS or out-ranging mobs, which many people do in M+ anyway (see BRH mini-boss with archers), or just silencing/interrupting a caster. Also, having a single target grip is hardly game changing compared to being able to completely avoid mechanics with multiple tools. The blood one or the Demon Hunter one is far superior. Look at CoS first boss, for example. Doing it at +20 or higher without a Paladin just sucks. Freedom completely avoids the damage you receive over the course of jumping, you can BoP debuffs away and this isn't even as a healer.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Starym
      The massive February 24th hotfixes are here, featuring both the class and Horrific Vision tuning, as well as Explosive Orb M+ affix changes, Ny'alotha tuning, and even more Horrific Visions changes. In WoW Classic we have Razorgore only save raids to the instance if he was killed after all the eggs were destroyed.
      February 24 (source)
      February 24, 2020
      Classes
      Druid Restoration [With regional restarts] Rejuvenation now costs 10% base mana (was 10.5%). [With regional restarts] Efflorescence now costs 17% base mana (was 21.6%). [With regional restarts] Tranquility direct healing increased 11%. Developers’ note: These changes should improve Restoration Druid’s raid healing output, without much impact to their already strong capabilities in dungeons and Arena. Hunter Marksmanship [With regional restarts] Damage of all abilities increased by 5%. Mage Frost [With regional restarts] Damage of all abilities increased by 5%. Monk Windwalker [With regional restarts] Damage of all abilities increased by 5%. Damage unchanged in PvP. Rogue Outlaw Resolved an issue that could prevent Blade Flurry from damaging some types of creatures in Uldum and Vale of Eternal Blossoms. Shaman Enhancement Damage of all abilities increased by 3%. Warlock Demonology [With regional restarts] Damage of all abilities increased by 5%. Dungeons and Raids
      Mythic Keystone Dungeons Explosive Affix Explosive Orbs again immediately put players into combat. Explosive Orbs can again be tab-targeted. Developers’ note: When testing the Awakened affix, we found that Explosive Orbs could sometimes prevent players from entering or exiting Ny'alotha Spires and Rifts if their party was in combat inside the instance. To solve this issue, we changed them to not place players in combat immediately. However, this had the unintended side effect of breaking player expectations around tab-targeting Explosive Orbs, so we're reverting their threat-generation behavior and trying an alternate solution. Ny’alotha, the Waking City Azeroth's Radiance now properly restores Sanity to players who are under the effects of an Immunity spell on all difficulties. Vexiona Cultists now have their health adjusted based on raid size, up to a maximum 10% reduction for 10-player raids on Normal and Heroic difficulties. Ra-den the Despoiled Resolved an issue that allowed Re-origination Anchors to be attackable with area of effect spells. Horrific Visions
      Research into Synchronized Mind Stabilizer has improved, now always reviving the player with at least half their Sanity. Horrific Vision of Stormwind Magister Umbric now casts Frozen Storm twice during the encounter (was 3 times). Items and Rewards
      Torn Pages of “Fear and Flesh” The number of Torn Page of "Fear and Flesh" quest items required for the rank 13-15 cloak quests has been reduced. Rank 13 now requires 4 Torn Pages (down from 6). Rank 14 now requires 6 Torn Pages (down from 12). Rank 15 now requires 8 Torn Pages (down from 18). Developers’ note: This change should make all the quests completable by most players in the week and not require players to feel the need to save as many keys week to week. Along with our other quality-of-life changes, this should help newer characters catch up with their peers. [With regional restarts] Up to 4 Torn Page of "Fear and Flesh" quest items can now drop in Horrific Visions from objectives on the rank 7-11 legendary cloak upgrade quests (max of 2). Developers’ note: Players will need to clear more than two side areas in one run to get more than two pages. The rank 13-15 quests will still drop a max of 2 pages, only from Lost Area objectives. Coalescing Visions Coalescing Visions now drop in higher numbers from Assaults and Daily Quests. [With regional restarts] Visions of N’Zoth daily quests now reward 50% more Coalescing Visions. [With regional restarts] The N’Zoth Assault now rewards 2500 Coalescing Visions (in addition to a Vessel of Horrific Visions). [With regional restarts] Lesser Threats will now reward 6500 Coalescing Visions (was 5500). Heart of Azeroth Reaping Flames (Essence) will no longer have its cooldown reduced to 5 seconds and deal additional damage when killing Twisted Appendages. Player versus Player
      Tank-specialization characters take an additional 50% damage from enemy players (was 40%). Death Knight Blood Death Strike now heals for 12.5% of damage taken when engaged in combat with enemy players (was 25%). Death Strike now heals for a minimum of 3.5% of maximum health when engaged in combat with enemy players (was 7%). Frost, Unholy [With regional restarts] Death Strike now heals for 30% of damage taken when engaged in combat with enemy players (was 40%). [With regional restarts] Death Strikee now heals for a minimum of 5% of maximum health when engaged in combat with enemy players, down from 10%. Mage Arcane [With regional restarts] Prismatic Barrier now absorbs 40% less damage when engaged in combat with enemy players. Fire [With regional restarts] Blazing Barrier absorbs 40% less damage when engaged in combat with enemy players. Frost [With regional restarts] Ice Barrier absorbs 40% less damage when engaged in combat with enemy players. Warlock Affliction, Destruction [With regional restarts] Demon Armor now increases Stamina by 5%, (was 10%). [With regional restarts] Demon Armor now increases Armor by 90% (was 150%). WoW Classic
      Razorgore the Untamed now only saves players to the raid instance if defeated after the eggs have been destroyed.
      Previous Hotfixes
      February 20th February 19th February 18th
    • By Starym
      We have further updates on the Horrific Visions tuning coming tomorrow/Wednesday to go with the class changes, as we have some specifics to check out - from the exact numbers on the Coalescing Visions rewards increases to the Torn Pages required for cloak upgrades.
      Horrific Visions Changes (source)
      I’ve updated the OP here with further information.
      UPDATED 2:45 p.m. PST Monday, February 24
      We’re working on a set of hotfixes to the game that should streamline upgrading your Legendary cloak via Horrific Visions.
      We now have some specifics to outline. Once again, these changes will come into effect with scheduled weekly maintenance:
      Coalescing Visions
      Visions of N’Zoth Daily Quests now reward 50% more Coalescing Visions. The main N’Zoth Threat now rewards 2500 Coalescing Visions (in addition to a Vessel of Horrific Visions ). Lesser Threats now reward 6500 Coalescing Visions. Quests to Increase Cloak Rank
      For Rank 13, the Quest now requires 4 Torn Pages (was 6). For Rank 14, the Quest now requires 6 Torn Pages (was 12). For Rank 15, the Quest now requires 8 Torn Pages (was 18). Posted previously–
      Coalescing Visions now drop in higher numbers from Assaults and Daily Quests. The Unique(5) inventory cap on Vessel of Horrific Visions has been removed, allowing you to carry as many Vessels as you like. Up to 4 Torn Pages of “Fear and Flesh” quest items can now drop in Horrific Visions from objectives on the rank 7-11 Legendary cloak upgrade quests (was a max of 2). You’ll need to clear more than two sides areas in one run to get more than two pages. The rank 13-15 quests will still drop a max of 2 pages, only from Lost Area objectives. These updates will go into effect with weekly maintenance (Tuesday, February 25 in this region).
    • By Starym
      We have some changes to the class balancing coming tomorrow and Wednesday, with Windwalkers and Death Knights having some changes reverted and some of the nerfs lessened for PvP:
      Class Balance (source)
      I’ve updated the OP above with three further adjustments:
      Windwalkers will not have their damage increased in PvP situations. For Unholy and Frost DKs, Death Strike healing is being taken down to 30% in PvP. For Blood DKs, Death Strike healing is being taken down to 19% in PvP. And here are the original class balance changes that were already announced, without the modifications from above:
      Class Balancing Feb 25th (source)
      We’re working on a series of hotfixes to adjust class balance. We currently plan to implement the following changes with weekly maintenance (the morning of February 25 in this region):
      Classes
      Druid
      Restoration
      Rejuvenation now costs 10% base mana (from 10.5%).
      Efflorescence now costs 17% base mana (from 21.6%).
      Tranquility direct healing increased 11%.
      Developers’ notes: These changes should improve Restoration Druid’s raid healing output, without much impact to their already strong capabilities in dungeons and Arenas. Hunter
      Marksmanship
      Damage of all abilities increased by 5%. Monk
      Windwalker
      Damage of all abilities increased by 5%. Mage
      Frost
      Damage of all abilities increased by 5%. Shaman
      Enhancement
      Damage of all abilities increased by 3%. Warlock
      Demonology
      Damage of all abilities increased by 5%. Player vs. Player
      Tank Specializations
      Tank specialization player characters now take an additional 50% damage from enemy players (was 40%). Death Knight
      Unholy, Frost
      Death Strike now heals for 20% of damage taken when engaged in combat with enemy players (was 40%). Death Strike now heals for a minimum of 5% of maximum health when engaged in combat with enemy players (was 10%). Blood
      Death Strike now heals for 12.5% of damage taken when engaged in combat with enemy players (was 25%). Death Strike now heals for a minimum of 3.5% of maximum health when engaged in combat with enemy players (was 7%). Mage
      Frost
      Ice Barrier now absorbs 40% less damage when engaged in combat with enemy players. Fire
      Blazing Barrier now absorbs 40% less damage when engaged in combat with enemy players. Arcane
      Prismatic Barrier now absorbs 40% less damage when engaged in combat with enemy players. Warlock
      Affliction, Destruction
      Demon Armor now increases Stamina by 5% (was 10%). Demon Armor now increases Armor by 90% (was 150%).
    • By Starym
      We have another remastered WoW cinematic on our hands, this time hand-made and not AI upscaled to boot! The end cinematic of the Icecrown Citadel raid is particularly relevant today, as it not only sets up Bolvar as the new Lich King, but also takes place in the Sylvannas vs. Bolvar arena that sets off Shadowlands.
      And here's the description from the creator, Pivotal:
      And here's the intro cinematic for the patch, remastered a long time ago by Hurricane:
       
    • By Starym
      The biggest ongoing discussion in a large part of the WoW raiding player base has been whether raids are harder now than they were in the past, with Vanilla and Classic especially coming under fire for seemingly "easy" bosses. Now it's obvious today's boss fights are infinitely more complex, but there's a huge mitigating factor to consider, and that's addons. If you needed more proof for just how important mods are to raiding, the recent World First race win by Complexity Limit came just as they got their own dedicated addon coder, in their partnership with Deadly Boss Mods. Regardless of where you come out on the "raids were harder in era X" discussion, it's very clear addons have completely changed the way raids work, and we now have a look inside how exactly that evolved in a PC Gamer interview with lead game designer Morgan Day.

      We start in Warlords of Draenor and Hellfire Citadel, where Archimonde sat waiting. The boss had been the hardest in a long time, surviving for 16 days and was only surpassed by his fellow Burning Legion bigwig Kil'jaeden, 2 years later to the day. So why was Archimonde so important? Well, a new addon was developed by the top raiders at the time that could actually draw lines on the minimap, making the Wrought Chaos mechanic easier to deal with. As Morgan Day explains:
      This particular addon was deemed too powerful and the API was changed so it didn't work anymore, and this wasn't the first time Blizzard had to step in and curb a mod's functionality, as Blackwing Lair (and Chromaggus in paticular) had shown that the Decursive addon was too powerful and needed to be toned down.
      The biggest new piece of info from the interview would have to be that while Blizzard don't actually design bosses with addons in mind from the ground up, they very much do pay attention to them when it comes to implementing the boss designs. They don't always catch everything, however. Day mentions that the Prophet Skitra's main mechanic in Ny'alotha was actually completely ignored by mods - the boss would split into many mirror images and players were supposed to communicate and find out which one was real, except Blizzard didn't quite foresee a method mods could mark the real one, and so that part of the fight was completely trivialized.
      And finally, Day talks about how some addons, while deemed too powerful and were shut down, lead to actual improvements in the game itself, like bosses using similar tech to telegraph their attacks better (like the Augmented Virtual Reality one from WotLK which allowed you to draw whatever you wanted on the game screen).

      The interview covers a lot more ground and goes into detail on some of the above examples and is a great read if you're a raider or interested in the World First race, so definitely go check it out!
×
×
  • Create New...