Vapir

stuck at Garrosh 10m reg

Sign in to follow this  

8 posts in this topic

Hello all, my team has been having some difficulty with Garrosh on 10man normal. I've supplied our WoL in the link below.

 

http://www.worldoflogs.com/reports/5fzuix7kklmo4xrl/

 

I don't have too much experience with World of Logs, so I'm hoping someone or a few of you can spot any possible things to clean up with our attempts. We've been stuck for a couple of weeks now, and our progression within the fight is varied. Sometimes we wipe in the second phase and other times in the third, so there is not a consistent mechanic we are failing with that I can see. It seems like it's spike damage that's getting the best of us, but idk. This is also the first time i've requested help on a forum for a specific boss, so please ask any questions that would help you make a hypothesis.

 

-Vapir

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Here is a log I found that was a kill and very similar to your raids setup (Both numbers wise and comp):

http://worldoflogs.com/reports/hpvhevit6439l8if/sum/damageDone/?s=7819&e=8556

Your right in that deaths seem to be happening all over the place throughout your attempts. Some on Annihilate's, some on Whirling Corruptions, Add's overtaking, etc.

Obviously everyone needs to get the damage reduction buff in transition phases for Annihilates...Looks like after the first two attempts everyone was getting it.

A few sporadic Desecration deaths so either people need to be more aware when its coming out for proper placement's or those were just "wipe it up, go stand in shit deaths".

After that, it looks like it just might boil down to dps numbers. Most common deaths on longer attempts seem to come from Add/MC damage. I would strongly think about two healing this fight. I think even with a healer going dps, the raid will still have enough CD's from tanks and dps (Rallying, AMZ, Barrier, VE, Tranq, etc...Also for example, if the your shaman can go dps you would still have a HTT and an Ancestral Guidance to help heal) to withstand Annihilate phases and whirling corruption phases.

Obviously phase 3 will just be hectic regardless, but with a lust/potion/execute phase + a few CD's I think you guys can make it. Just one opinion but I would give two healing a shot.

Best of luck.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hard to always determine mechanic issues from logs alone, but...

 

-People can't die to annihilate in realm.

-Have to rotate raid CDs to ensure people survive whirling -- you're three healing which means these should be easily rotated (shaman totem/spirit link, disc priest bubble for non-empowered/spirit shell for others, druid tranq/maybe genesis to burst rejuvs, and keep healing rain stacked on mushroom).

-Are people picking up 1 of the empowered whirling minions and then nuking away from others?

-Don't use dots on the MCs (though this mostly seems to be people dotting up MCs after it's pretty much GG).

 

The varied issues you mentioned earlier would help more with feedback.

 

EDIT: and yeah, now that I see another response, maybe drop a healer -- if your balance set is decent then shaman/priest should have no problems healing that fight.

Edited by Brown

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You have a fair number of unnecassary deaths from people standing in one-shots like rolling Iron stars and the transition phase frontal cones. really doesn't need to happen.

 

Your prot warrior's shield Block uptime is appalling, 17 times in 45 minutes of combat; he should be casting it more or less every 9 seconds. No matter what build  Prot uses it still relies heavily on Shield Block. his Berserker Rage usage is also less than stellar, with no fears, charms, he doesn't need to save it and should just pop it on CD for extra rage.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Raid leader and tank for this group reporting. I thought I'd add a little bit of info regarding how we are approaching this fight in order to hopefully give you guys a little better idea of what is going on other than what you can see from data. Thank you all for your prompt replies thus far; they are most appreciated. We've only worked on this fight for one dedicated evening, but from what I can tell, it is a significant jump up in difficulty from the previous encounters.

 

Regarding composition/setup:

 

These logs do not cover all of our attempts. Our strategy has flopped around a bit, alternating between two and three heals to see if we could make two work. Our strongest healer is our druid, but unfortunately, he is also probably our strongest off-spec DPS. We were a bit concerned with two-heal throughput numbers without him. We tried two healing with dpriest/druid and having our rshaman go elemental, but her DPS isn't exactly terrific. It almost felt like we were bringing more to the table with her staying resto, but since we haven't seen a clean version of the final phase, we don't know if being short that extra DPS is going to pose an insurmountable obstacle.

 

Regarding strategy:

 

When we two-heal, we send our shaman (our lowest DPS) to kill the engineer in P1. When we three-heal, that duty is on the mage. As for tanking, I (death knight) was on add-duty in P1 when we first tried this fight, but that forced our warrior to stop any AoE DPS. I simply could not compete with the massive amount of single-target vengeance he was receiving from Garrosh, plus TC, deep wounds, and Dragon Roar hit like trucks. All the adds would just go to him. So I decided that I'd just let him go nuts with his vengeance bomb, grab all the adds that I wrangled, and when they were on him, I'd simply grab Garrosh. Seems to work pretty well.

 

With the mention of shield block, he has said that he has become a bit barrier-happy lately, and he'll focus on using block more. He uses an avoidance-riposte build instead of a mastery build, so he said that the value of block was lessened, but I'm pretty sure that it's still the go-to for pure physical damage, particularly on fights with lots of mobs or quick swing timers. Then again, I know very little about warriors nowadays, so this is somewhat speculative, and I may just be talking out of a certain dorsal orifice.

 

Regarding a lot of the deaths:

 

I think there may be a good bit of false information that was collected in the midst of wipe-it-up moments. I certainly stood in my fair share of annihilates and desecrates in order to hopefully get a vanish, feign, or invis off when things became unsalvageable. I think the only real issues with those types of deaths came from our hunter who was not very well informed on the fight and had not seen a previous pull. From what I can tell, other than a few corner cases of derp moments, most of our deaths came from whirling corruption damage + adds. This is not so much from combing the data, but rather from just being in this raid and seeing it unfold firsthand.

 

There were a few times when we had a tank spike or a moment of inexplicable stupid, but the majority of our problem seems to come from those empowered whirls. I'm not sure if it is more from people standing in the void zones that spawn the adds or from the adds themselves. I do know that we had a bit of an issue with our DPS not being able to single-target peel adds from others, particularly healers. I have heard of tanks having issues with getting all of their aggro, but this has not been a problem or ours. The instances you see where the whirl adds killed me were usually a result of me taunting extra adds when I would see two or more chewing on a non-tank. I generally have to taunt these or actively hit them to get them on myself, so there is no issue there. We just have trouble spacing them out and peeling them off of players who have 2+.

 

As you can see here, Whirling Corruption is definitely a problem of ours. Any insight would be appreciated.

 

In Closing

 

I've been raiding in WoW for a very long time, and I have found that most speedbumps that occur in progression can be remedied by increasing every individual players' DPS or by switching a healer to DPS. It works almost every time. This fight, though our experience with it is a tad limited, seems to be a bit of a mysterious balancing act to the point that I'm not 100% certain that is the instant fix. There seems to be a considerable amount of damage, and most of our deaths (on attempts where we aren't just trying to wipe because of an errant, goofy death or two) seem to come from one or more or the damage components to the empowered whirl. I don't know how much dropping to two healers would help with this, but more importantly, I don't know how imperative it will be to have 6 DPS in the final phase. I'd really hate to master the first two phases with 3 healers only to find that we have to redo it with 2 because the final phase is impossible. Two heals certainly seems to be the consensus thus far, not only here but also in most of the sources I've seen.

 

I hope that I've given a tiny bit of insight as to what we've been doing/thinking so far, and again, I appreciate everyone's effort to throw advice or critique our way. We may be a bit premature/antsy by posting for WoL analyses after only having one night dedicated to the fight, but it seems like this is a fight that may give us some headaches for a bit if we don't figure out exactly what our problems are and what we need to do to improve them.

 

Thanks again, and cheers!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi there,

 

Just a few insights to the way my team attacked this boss.

 

We tried 3 healing and yes it makes the first phases rather trivial and easy but at the end it makes that final phase so much longer. All of our kills have been 2 healed by either disc/pally or disc/monk.

 

This fight is very much avoid "goofy" deaths. The timers for the mechanics are actually very forgiving. there is enough time between the phases for all 3 min healer cds to be up.

We use a triangle stack method where the raid moves between 2 markers for desecrate and then stack on boss for mc's in the final phase.

Make sure for the empowered whilings u set up any hybrid cd's on your longest attempt there was no VE from your priest. Also ToF talent is very powerful on this fight for shadow as u can dot the desecrated weapon but not kill it and have a massive uptime. (shamans, priest VE/symbiosis tranq, boomkin tranq)

Avoiding the swirlies is very much a personal task of not standing in the mechanic you know is coming and is more than likey called over vent/mumble. Single target your own add then help others with as much cc as u can (void tendrils etc)

If you are 2 healing the aim is to have Garrosh dead after 2 empowered whirling corruptions. Kill the first lot of adds and ignore the 2nd set and just burn the boss as they dont hit much harder than the dark animus adds anyway provided they dont get empowered..

 

We found the MC's were the biggest annoyance and that having the raid stack on the boss for them in the final phase for aoe cc/silences was the way to go.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Our team did it more or less similarly to Brew's team, with the exception of not killing any of the adds in the last phase. Usually when I'm picking up the 2nd set the boss is more or less dead.

 

@Seidus

First off, my team also runs with me (dk tank) and a warrior tank. The way we do P1 is pretty much identical to yours, except we always 2heal and send one of the healers to kill the other Engineer and never have any problms with anyone's survival. This goes as more DPS uptime on boss.

The first add set goes down pretty much with just the warrior's aoe/cleave thansk to the vengeance, and we use the Star to finish the second group. It helps if you have a monk in your team to put a Statue in its path so you can Gorefiends Grasp the adds somewhat safely to the ironstar. Any pushback will do too, ofc.

 

As for Whirling Corruption, our warrior tank usually pulls the boss further away to reduce the raid dmg and I spam glyphed Death Coils on the raid fueled by AMS. It is up for each Whirl so you can do this every time. Adds up to quite a nice amount of healing.

 

I hope I was of some help. :)

Edited by Ceraius

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

for empowered whirl, my group fans out in about 1/5 of the room. garrosh is being tanked somewhere along the wall on the side with his throne and we are about 40-60 yards from him during whirl.

 

everyone is responsible for agroing the add that spawns from the one shot at them and as soon as melee get aggro, they are supposed to kite in towards the boss. the ranged turret theirs down and then get to garrosh to stack for mc. tanks just take whatever mistakes we have and bring them along for the rest of the ride.

 

the goal is to be perfect but favor speed over clean execution, the fight is finished despite your mistakes, you just cant make too many. before p3 no one should be near the middle. the p3 transition is key. it's going to be good if most adds are dead just as he hits 10%.

 

everyone needs to be running with him as he goes to the center. the second he gets to the center we hero and everyone pots. we usually get him to about 4% before he goes up above 20.

 

the first mc is easy because you can be stacked and everyone aoe's as the timer hits so they are almost instantly freed. the first whirl is also easy. tanks pick up all adds and everyone is on boss.

 

second mc is rough. extra adds can get in the way and mc is top priority even though he can be very low and get ppl excited. if everyone is stacked just cleave/aoe and go for broke regardless of how many adds it kills. stop the mcs and kill him before another whirl. if it looks bad mc needs to be close to cast, so ranged can use mit cds and spread way out to try to get the killing blow. rogues can smoke bomb evasion tank too.

 

he is most dangerous below 3%. people can get the impression that their individual dps is what is taking big chunks of his health off, but he is only dying because so many people are hitting him. in p3 every MC is the only priority.

 

once he as at 1% killing him is priority over survival. you're not going to overcome any mistakes youve made that have added up to this point. Don't try to buy time, just kill him or you weren't going to get it anyway.

 

the more sub 3% wipes you get, the more you will see how easy the first phases are. its just part of the fight. it's all about the transition to p3 and having everyone pot and nuke while garrosh powers up, so dont leave adds on caster dps at this point.

Edited by kitsu

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By tanksta1
      [H] Salvation (est.2007) is a progression raiding guild on US-Cenarion Circle/Sisters of Elune.
      Objective
      Salvation is actively searching and recruiting players for current heroic content. What we look to do in the short-term is recruit players and gear them in our farm content. Mythic + will be run as well since it serves as another outlet to gearing up. By doing this we prepare them for our long-term goal, Mythic Mode Progression.
      Recruiting for Tomb of Sargeras
      Tanks- Closed Melee- Rogue x1, Arms/Fury Warrior x1 Ranged- Mages x1, Hunter x2, Warlock x2, Balance Druid x1 Healers- Holy/Disc Priest x1, Resto/Ele Shaman x1

      ***Exceptional applicants can feel free to sign up even if we aren't recruiting your class/spec. Outstanding applications will always be considered.
      We are also accepting players that engage in social aspects of the WoW community such as leveling, PvP, questing, dungeon finding, roleplaying and other challenging activites. We provide monthly guild events. For example, the Tournament of Tiny Champions. It’s a pet battle tournament where guildies compete with each other using 3-6 of their mightiest level 25 tiny champions. We are expanding this extremely fun side of Salvation so that everyone can join in on some action and prizes!
      Raiding Schedule
      Our schedule is as follows. We push content three times a week for 3 hours at a time starting at 6:00pm to 9:00pm PST Tuesdays, Thursdays, and Mondays. 
      Our Raiding Requirements
      You must be able to raid all three nights. Be on time for raid. Lateness will not be tolerated. Be able to play the optimal specialization for Legion raid encounters. (this requirement is more towards the pure dps classes and hybrid classes in some special cases) Come prepared with the knowledge of the Legion raid bosses and mechanics. Have Discord app installed and a working microphone to communicate. Discord browser and phone app is also acceptable. (Note: Some of these requirements will change as time goes on.)
      How to Join
      Please sign up on our guild website at:
      www.salvationcc.guildlaunch.com Want to reach me in game? On Discord? Questions or concerns? Hit me up at:
      Battletag: Zanngetsu#1255 Discord: Tankstâ2329  
    • By Sidonis

      AEQUITAS
      „Als persönliche Tugend bezeichnete Aequitas in der Geschichte die Gelassenheit, vermöge derer ein Römer auch in äußerst kritischen oder aufwühlenden Situationen die Würde (Dignitas) zu bewahren wusste.“
      Wer oder was ist Aequitas?

      Eine Gesellschaft aus Spielern verschiedenster Art und Alters, die sich das Ziel gesetzt hat, Raids mit Effizienz, Erfolg und Freude zu bestreiten. Gleichzeitig werden dem Anspruch Grenzen gesetzt. Grenzen die nicht überschritten werden dürfen, um den letzten Schritt in eine dekadente und abgehobene Gilde zu verhindern, in der Freude am Spiel nur noch dann gelebt wird, wenn jeder Aspekt in die Perfektion abdriftet. 

      Diese Grenzen sind flexibel, beinhalten aber stets dieselben Wert- und Normvorstellungen, den Contentinhalt niemals auf Biegen und Brechen zu bewältigen, niemals zu erzwingen und die Wünsche des einzelnen Mitglieds nach Möglichkeit zu berücksichtigen. 
      Dieses Gleichgewicht wird gewährleistet, jede Woche aufs Neue auf die Probe gestellt und intern geregelt. 
       
      Gleichmut und Gleichberechtigung eines jeden Mitglieds sind und bleiben das oberste Ziel.
      Unsere Gilde bietet ihren Mitgliedern sehr viel:
      Aktiver Raid- und Mythisch+ - Content mit kostenlosem Buff-food und Fläschchen/Trankzubehör, engagierte Offiziere, ein stets selbst-reflektierender Raid-Lead, Klassenberatung und ein kameradschaftliches internes Klima. Wer jetzt eine absolut harmonische Gilde, wie in einem Bilderbuch vor Auge hat, der irrt. Auch wir haben raidbedingte Stresssituationen, in denen der ein oder andere Unmut entsteht. Aber keine dieser Situationen konnte oder wird uns aus der Bahn werfen.

      Unser kurzfristiges Ziel war die Gründung einer funktionierenden und effizienten Gildengruppe. Diese sollte intern die ersten Raids der Erweiterung Legion aktiv bestreiten und erfolgreich abschließen. Dieses Ziel haben wir erreicht und wir sind dabei als Gilde zusammengewachsen. 

      Durch private Lebenssituationen ist unsere kleine eingespielte Gruppe aber immer wieder gezwungen, die Raid-Spielergröße am unteren Limit zu absolvieren. Um eine stabilere Gruppengröße von 14+ zu gewährleisten sind wir jetzt auf aktiver Mitspielersuche.

      Unsere Ziele:

      - Den aktuellen Content auf normalem und heroischem Schwierigkeitsgrad zu bestreiten, außerhalb von Zufallsgruppen.(Mythischer Content ist für unsere kleine Gilde zu zeitintensiv)

      - Ein Gilden- und Raidklima, in dem Berufliches und Privates koexistieren können.

      - Eine offene und demokratische Gildenleitung auf dem Prinzip der Parlamentarischen Demokratie.

      Was wir von neuen Mitgliedsanwärtern erwarten:

      - Ein Mindestalter (20+), auch geistige Reife, Eigenverantwortung und Selbstreflexion sollen gelebt werden.

      - Einen Item-Stand, der etwa dem letzten heroischen Raid-Content entspricht. 

      - Team- und Kritikfähigkeit und Akzeptanz Gegenüber der Meinung anderer.

      - Gefühl und Verständnis der eigenen Klasse (z.B. das Ausüben eurer 
      Klassenfähigkeiten sollten kein Problem darstellen, auch wenn ihr auf eine unerwartete Situation stoßt.).

      Eine Bewerbung oder ähnliche abwegige Formalitäten verlangen wir ironischerweise nicht. Das einzige, was wir von euch verlangen, ist ein formloses Gespräch im Teamspeak und eine 3-wöchige Probezeit, in der ihr euch in die Gilde als auch in die Raid-Gruppe eingliedern könnt. 
      Während dieser Zeit werdet ihr nicht ins kalte Wasser geworfen oder mit eurem Spielcharakter alleine gelassen. Genauso wie ihr möchten auch wir, dass ein weiteres Mitglied in Aequitas aufblühen kann.

      Wir haben zurzeit zwei feste Raid-Tage, zum einen Mittwoch und zum anderen Freitag, jeweils ab 20:00. Die Raiddauer ist flexibel, wird aber die Dauer von 5 Stunden nie überschreiten. Besonders mittwochs wird nie länger als bis 22:30 geraidet.
      Besonders freuen wir uns über:

      Heiler: Paladin oder Schamane
      MeleeDD: Paladin, Schurke, Krieger, Feral(Wildheitsdruide)
      RangeDD: Disziplin, Elementarschamane, Hexer, Magier

      Ansprechpartner:

      Portz#2918
      Saltras#2334
       
    • By Kittykyla
      AU/NZ based guild currently 7/9H ToS built from a core of experienced raiders who have been raiding together since the game came out. We are aiming for progression on a semi-casual schedule with two raid nights -
      Raids are Thursday 6-9pm and Sunday 5-9pm Server Time . Great for NZ players or Aussie players who want to start raids Early and awesome for Players in Europe and America who work Nights.
      We're looking for a few players at the moment to fill out our mythic group and replace those looking to take a break from the game. Will consider a guild that would like to talk about merging.
      We're a light-hearted group but serious about getting content done, so while we won't bite your head off if you make mistakes, we also won't hesitate to point them out, and help you improve.
      If that sounds like a bit of you, and our raid times fit your schedule, send a message to our GM; Swordblazer (Swordblazer#1431), or our Recruitment officer; Darkkon (Pocketbacon#1282), or even me; Kittykyla (Michyla#1119) for a chat and potentially an invite to our raid group.
      We love to talk !@#$ and our Discord is not for the faint of heart, must have a strong sense of humor.
    • By DrSwilly
       

      <Brood Theory> (10/10 H, 8/9 N) is a progression-focused raiding guild looking for exceptional DPS for Tomb of Sargeras and eventually, mythic progression. We raid Tuesdays and Thursdays (10pm-1am EST). We are hoping to come back to mythic NH and eventually push mythic Tomb. Typically, the guild adds Wednesday (10pm-1am EST) as a farm night for gearing alts and hosting carry runs in order to stock up the guild bank for our raiders. We allow 750g in repairs a day for our raiders, and we provide you with free flasks, feasts, gems, enchants, and potions if needed.
       
      Requirements:
      Voice:
      Discord
       
      Add-ons:
      RC Loot Council
      Exorsus Raid Tools
      Deadly Boss Mods
      Skada/Recount
       
      Other:
      895+ ilvl with at least 41 traits and 30 artifact knowledge (room for leniency if needed).
      At least a 4-piece set bonus from NH.
      Be familiar with class itemization and DPS SIMS.
      Watch videos of fights before coming to raid and follow mechanics (Will be posted in our Discord).
      Be on time and ready to enter a mature, but friendly raiding environment.
       
      Casuals also welcome and encouraged to help build the guild community and atmosphere. We are looking for more like-minded and friendly individuals to join us for different guild events, contests, and etc. Our Discord server is a place where gamers of many different games (WoW, LoL, Overwatch, FF14, etc.) can come together, meet new people, and have a great time.
       
      So, if you are looking to progress through mythic content or just relax and be a part of a friendly atmosphere, Brood Theory may be for you!
       
      We are looking forward to hearing from you!
       
      If you are interested, add my Battle.Net DrSwilly#1198 and send me a message.
       
    • By Roghalochan
      Hi all,
      I am new to healing and playing a shaman. I pretty much only ever played a rogue Wrath-Cata, and have recently come back as a Resto Shaman in Legion. I am doing my best to configure everything correctly but I think that I am missing some stuff. My logs show that I am under preforming (bottom 35% of resto shams in my ilvl range). I am looking for any sort of constructive criticism and advice that anyone may have.
      I currently sit at 45 artifact traits, 46.2k intel, 35% crit, 12% haste, and 86% mastery.
      Talents: 
      If possible I would love to not have to use CBT. If it's the best though, it's the best. 
       
      Armory link: https://worldofwarcraft.com/en-us/character/dalaran/roghalochan
      Logs: https://www.warcraftlogs.com/rankings/character/23608431/11#difficulty=5&class=Shaman&spec=Restoration&metric=hps&boss=1849(not sure if above link works)
      Mythic NH: https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/4zmRdkrFnvtQYwjq
      Heroic NH: https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/q7Ab3CFnYacQP4d8
       
      I am stressing over not being able to keep up with my guilds progression, if you see anything that I need to correct or work on please comment.
      Thanks in advance,
      Rog