Stan

Duncan Jones: Warcraft Movie Sequel Unlikely

40 posts in this topic

LfSpeRl.jpg

According Director Duncan Jones, a Warcraft movie sequel is unlikely to happen.

Director Duncan Jones responded to a tweet regarding a sequel to the Warcraft (2016) movie yesterday. According to him, it's not looking likely, because too many companies are involved to thread that needle.

Placeholder for tweet 1018553145889189889

An ongoing reddit discussion brings up some valid points about the Warcraft movie, namely the lore inconsistency and the fact that we possibly won't see an Arthas movie. Let us know in the comments if you liked the Warcraft movie!

Credit to redditor SHdude for bringing this up!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

WoW fans are rabid about lore and inconsistency, and non-fans have no interest in Warcraft lore.  They tried to play both sides in the first movie and it didn't go over well enough to take that gamble a second time, at increased risk.  If you can't tap into the existing fanbase, there's no reason to use the IP; you can just make the exact same movie, but with different names, call it unrelated to Warcraft, and it's much lower risk.

That said, the ideal viewer is the former wow player - like me - I saw the movie and it made me want to play the game again, so I came back to it.  Unfortunately, the former wow player community is *ahem* legion.

I think Hollywood is starting to understand this, and finally seeing the downside of remaking and sequel/prequeling every successful film in history.

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, thurk said:

WoW fans are rabid about lore and inconsistency, and non-fans have no interest in Warcraft lore.  They tried to play both sides in the first movie and it didn't go over well enough to take that gamble a second time, at increased risk.

I agree on this but at the same time I wonder why they did that in the first place. Wouldnt it be enough for a Warcraft-Movie if the fanbase of WoW would watch the movie?
I consider the average WoW-Player as someone whos a bit of a nerd and is partially into fantasystuff. That kinda person who'd watch the Marvelmovies in the cinema and thoroughly enjoys said movies.

So why not produce a movie that appeals to those fans? Just make a movie that, if you want to understand it you have to know a certain bit of warcraftlore to fully enjoy it? Isnt the Warcraft/WoW-Fanbase big enough for such a movie to be a sucess?

Just ignore the avarage Joe who has not connection to this franchise and concentrate on you're already (huge?) fanbase.

Edited by Pauly02

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

just continue with thrall and then arthas and it would be amazing! i wait till Wc3 story comes up in movies ;)))

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, Hypersonic said:

Warcraft movie.. I hope once can forget it.

I liked it.  As a movie it was good.  As a 'warcraft' item, it was... inconsistent obviously, at best.  

But on its own it was a great movie.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well movie was a flop, only China saved it from total financial failure.

31 minutes ago, rush said:

just continue with thrall and then arthas and it would be amazing! i wait till Wc3 story comes up in movies ;)))

Not sure how they could do it, since first movie already changed some stuff.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, thurk said:

WoW fans are rabid about lore and inconsistency, and non-fans have no interest in Warcraft lore.  They tried to play both sides in the first movie and it didn't go over well enough to take that gamble a second time, at increased risk.  If you can't tap into the existing fanbase, there's no reason to use the IP; you can just make the exact same movie, but with different names, call it unrelated to Warcraft, and it's much lower risk.

That said, the ideal viewer is the former wow player - like me - I saw the movie and it made me want to play the game again, so I came back to it.  Unfortunately, the former wow player community is *ahem* legion.

I think Hollywood is starting to understand this, and finally seeing the downside of remaking and sequel/prequeling every successful film in history.

If they want to tell the Warcraft story, it's better to it as an animation. As well as making sure Chris Metzen is at the helm of writing it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, MackDye said:

This is what happens when you cheap out on the first film. 

What exactly was cheap about the movie?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's funny to bring up lore inconsistency - but I think there isn't a single soul out there who loves Blizzard games (and mainly the Warcraft universe) due to it's great lore rather than the gameplay experience. It has terrible lore - nothing comparable to the Warhammer, Lord of the Rings, Witcher or other fantasy worlds out there. We all loved Metzen as a game director, but I think the fanbase also acknowledges that he was an unskilled story writer. Now we have the likes of Christie Golden to fix his mishaps, but it will take some time to gather some blockbuster-quality screenplay material out of Warcraft.
Untill then the best Warcraft videogame movie I can think would be one including Dwayne Johnson and tons of stunts to divert our attention from those little incosistencies. Hey - thats a Hollywood technique proven to be working! The Rock could play like Varian or even Thrall - story doesn't matters as long there's action on the screen and he saves the world in the end.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What we really need is Blizzard creating their own cinematic division and making a 2 hour WoW cinematic, with motion capture, 3D modeled characters and their original voice actors. Now THAT will be a Warcraft movie we all want and deserve.

We all saw how well made the Orcs were in the movie. They were pretty much the highlight of it (and I'm not even a Horde fan). So what if every single character was CGI? Wouldn't that be much better? It's a rhetorical question, by the way.

Edited by Valhalen

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Can't say I'm surprised. The movie was pretty awful. What they should have done with it is either:

A) Rise of the Horde. Show how the orcs conquered Draenor. The CGI was the film's only redeeming factor so having the draenei done the same way as the orcs would have been stellar.

B) The story of Arthas. Let's be real here, far less people played WC1 and 2 than they did WC3. The rise of the Lich King works entirely as a stand-alone tale and is far more intriguing and well written than anything from the other RTS games.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's not about being a warcraft fan or not..it's all about that movie sucked...it starts and it looks like it should be warcraft 2 or mid of the movie but it's not..I think they had to make arthas's movie..it was more interesting for sure and plus that arthas is more popular since more people played warcraft 3 in compare with wow

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

Duncan Jones: Warcraft Movie Sequel Unlikely

 

Well no shit sherlock!   I could have told you that right after I left the theater the day I saw it! 

Hey I had a nerd boner going into see it but it was a bit of a let down! and I knew right then this was a one and done!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, Myke said:

What exactly was cheap about the movie?

perhaps he's referring to the budget?  Warcraft budget was $160 million and to compare lets use Avatar, avatars budget was $237 million!  avatar was a hit and is getting 4 more sequels!   so maybe if Warcraft spent more it would have looked better and we would have at least gotten 1 sequel !

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, multiboxing said:

perhaps he's referring to the budget?  Warcraft budget was $160 million and to compare lets use Avatar, avatars budget was $237 million!  avatar was a hit and is getting 4 more sequels!   so maybe if Warcraft spent more it would have looked better and we would have at least gotten 1 sequel !

The movie looked phenomenal. I don't see where it went cheap.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Myke said:

The movie looked phenomenal. I don't see where it went cheap.

"Phenomenal" is very strong word. Yes, the Orcs where phenomenal, definitely. Now when you compare the Orcs with the other races, such as the High Elves, you can clearly where the majority of the budget went. The special effects for magic don't look impressive either.

It is as I say, if Blizzard decided to make their own animation studio, things would have been very VERY different. Take all the Overwatch shorts, for example. Compiled they are over 1 hour long; enough for a full-lengthy feature. After I saw that Hearthstone "Hearth and Home" they showed at BlizzCon I became certain that Blizzard has the potential to become as good as Disney, Pixar and Dreamworks when it comes to CGI animation.

I mean, JUST. YOU. LOOK. AT. THIS:

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I liked Warcraft as a movie on its own (if it wasnt supposed to be linked to Warcraft RTs nor WoW).They put too much things in a small timeframe and alot of the events in the movie were completly unnecesary( Lothar's son that didnt serve for anything) it also changed alot of the lore so they could show off the CGi (Dalaran flying,thousands of Draenei being killed for the Dark Portal to open etc.).Dont know why Medivh was made so weak that he had to use that mana pool or whatever it was most of the time,Guldan being so obviously having power over Blackhand,changins Garona to be half human and half orc.It really should have been tailored more for a person that played Wow or Warcraft RTS because im sure it would earn way more money and get more positive rewiews.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

wow story is too far and wide it is very very hard to make it in to a movie. first movie happened in middle of wow story with alot happened before and will happen after that. main complain about movie was that people (no wow fans) didnt understand half of things that happened because they didnt know the lore. i dont know why they chose that part of story, i think it is either because it was human vs orc to make it lord of the rings look alike or because it was warcraft 1 story. either way it wasnt good point to start the movies :(.

a wow series would be much better :).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
15 hours ago, Brutalis said:

Can't say I'm surprised. The movie was pretty awful. What they should have done with it is either:

A) Rise of the Horde. Show how the orcs conquered Draenor. The CGI was the film's only redeeming factor so having the draenei done the same way as the orcs would have been stellar.

B) The story of Arthas. Let's be real here, far less people played WC1 and 2 than they did WC3. The rise of the Lich King works entirely as a stand-alone tale and is far more intriguing and well written than anything from the other RTS games.

i agree with the first one but problem with that is it has NO HUMANS in it !!! so it will be a first in cinema history i think (maybe not but still pretty odd) !

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Many follow the hate train without having their own opinions cuz' that's what sheep do, especially if a streamer says their opinion about something, holy banana's everybody follows suit and starts spamming LUL. For the movie I really enjoyed it, my biggest problem though was Garona freakin', flyin' like 20ft. in the air out of nowhere to mount a horse like 2-3 times through out, like wut. Wasn't perfect but was enjoyable, as long as the fan's would stop being picky like most spoiled people are with thing's handed too them. All creator's try to do is create fun thing's for entertainment purposes, only to get unnecessary basement dweller comments and banter cuz' their pretty expectations wasn't glorious and uplifted enough 200 times over FeelsBadMan

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
48 minutes ago, KonadorAuchindoun said:

Many follow the hate train without having their own opinions cuz' that's what sheep do, especially if a streamer says their opinion about something, holy banana's everybody follows suit and starts spamming LUL. For the movie I really enjoyed it, my biggest problem though was Garona freakin', flyin' like 20ft. in the air out of nowhere to mount a horse like 2-3 times through out, like wut. Wasn't perfect but was enjoyable, as long as the fan's would stop being picky like most spoiled people are with thing's handed too them. All creator's try to do is create fun thing's for entertainment purposes, only to get unnecessary basement dweller comments and banter cuz' their pretty expectations wasn't glorious and uplifted enough 200 times over FeelsBadMan

I'm perfectly ok with some changes in the story because let's face it: the Warcraft Lore is severely convoluted, plus it is pretty hard to fit the story of an entire game in a 2 hour movie.

My nitpick lies with the acting of the human characters, and some special effects. They also tried too hard to fit some things that felt really forced, such as the Anduin & Garona hinted romance, or Anduin's son Callan.

I keep repeating myself that they should make the entire movie as CGI (including the human characters) because it opens the possibilities for crazy scenarios and art direction. Warcraft has always had that cartoonish style, which would fit great in a fully animated feature. Overwatch has that kind of artstyle and it works great, specially when you watch all their shorts.

Edited by Valhalen

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
20 hours ago, PatrickHenry said:

But on its own it was a great movie.  

No, it wasn't. It wasn't hilariously bad, like most game-based movies are, but it just wasn't good. I could start by pointing out all the mistakes (like Travis Fimmel as Lothar and not Medivh? wtf?!) and how it could have been done better, but there already is a better version of it, and it's called The Last Guardian. The movie could have worked if it was just that, because the book is already a perfect introduction into the lore. Instead they tried to squeeze in everything, have three stories at the same time, and the result was a hard to follow mess with a forced romance and an inconsistent style (why are the dwarfs CG but not the humans or Garona?!).

And no, this isn't about how it's different from WoW lore, it's about how the story and character changes actually made everything worse.

That being said, I would lie if I said I didn't enjoy it, but that's mostly due to me being a fan of the franchise, going "oh, that looks like the thing from the game!"

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Starym
      We're back from the weekend and that means hotfixes! Today we have more solutions for Warlocks on mountainsides, dungeon issues, including faction-wide attunement to Siege of Boralus and King's Rest, a lot of Darkmoon cards got major buffs (and one got nerfed), the NPC for mercenaries who wish to fight for the opposite faction has moved to the new zones, Legion assaults have returned and a lot more.
      August 20 (source)
      Azerite Powers
      Fixed an issue where Dagger in the Back failed to stack properly when applied by multiple users. Character Services
      Players who faction transfer should now get a more informative message on how to continue the War Campaign on their new faction. Classes
      Warlock Demonology The Summon Vilefiend and Nether Portal talents will no longer sometimes fail to work when cast on steep terrain. Creatures and NPCs
      Fixed a bug that caused some enemies in the Drustvar Crimson Forest to be untargetable by players. Rikati at The Four Stingers will now sell his wares, including his famous Snake on a Stick, to members of the Alliance.  
      Dungeons
      Unlocking Siege of Boralus as a Horde player now unlocks the dungeon for all Horde characters on that account. Unlocking Kings' Rest as an Alliance player now unlocks the dungeon for all Alliance characters on that account. Freehold Irontide Enforcer's Shattering Toss will no longer wipe threat from the tank. Shrine of the Storm Vol’zith the Whisperer Fixed a bug that caused players to sometimes become stuck with Grasp of the Sunken City. Items
      Fixed an issue where Darkmoon Deck: Blockades was providing far less Stamina and Health than intended. Fixed an issue where Darkmoon Deck: Squalls was dealing less damage than intended. Its effective damage has been increased by approximately 300%. Fixed an issue where Darkmoon Deck: Fathoms  would not trigger for Marksmanship or Beast Mastery hunters. Reduced the damage of Darkmoon Deck: Fathoms by 9%. Player versus Player
      Sergeant Wilson has travelled to The Mugambala and will offer Mercenary Contracts to members of the Horde that wish to fight for the Alliance. Nassar has travelled to Hook Point and will offer Mercenary Contracts to members of the Alliance that wish to fight for the Horde. Quests
      Fixed multiple bugs that made it very difficult to bomb targets successfully on “Swab This!”. Fixed a bug causing Third Telemancer Syranel to evade player attacks on “Grand Theft Telemancy”. Players should now reliably get credit for taking the ferry for "The Ashvane Trading Company”. Horde players should now properly be able to see the Stolen Supplies for "Plunder and Provisions". World
      Legion Assaults have returned to the Broken Isles. Previous Patch 8.0.1 Hotfixes
      August 17 August 16 August 15
    • By Starym
      We have the very first developer Q&A session with Ion Hazzikostas coming this Thursday, August 23rd! You can ask your questions over Twitter with the usual #WarcraftQA hashtag, and you can bet there will be plenty of Azerite and Heart of Azeroth questions to be had. With the slightly shaky launch of BfA (at least compared to Legion's) there will probably be a lot of interest in what happened there as well as the usual look at what's ahead and presumably a big PvP focus as well. We'll hopefully also get a discussion on the story aspect of the expansion, with the huge hubbub we had over the Sylvanas short and Saurfang cinematic, as it would be great to hear some in-depth opinions from the Game Director himself.
      Q&A (source)
      Join us live on Twitch.tv/Warcraft Thursday, August 23, at 11:00 a.m. PDT, as we sit down with Game Director Ion Hazzikostas for our next live developer Q&A, where he’ll be answering your World of Warcraft: Battle for Azeroth questions.
      You can submit your questions here in this thread or on Twitter by using the hashtag #WarcraftQA.
      As a reminder, please keep your questions short (40 words or less) so that we can get to as many questions as possible. We look forward to you joining us live on Tuesday!
    • By Starym
      We're 4 for 4 in this first week of Battle for Azeroth and as we head into the weekend we see Azerite armor outer ring requirements reduced on the Heart of Azeroth, Affliction Warlock Deathbolt fixes, Conquest removals until PvP Season 1 starts, Brewmaster PvP fixes/nerfs, the removal of two belt enchant from PvP, and a bit fewer fixes for professions and quests than usual.
      August 17 (source)
      Azerite Gear
      Substantially lowered the Heart of Azeroth level required to activate the outer ring of Azerite armor obtained from World Quests and Mythic dungeons. Classes
      Warlock Affliction Deathbolt will now correctly deal increased damage if cast immediately after casting Unstable Affliction. Creatures and NPCs
      Slickspill should be much easier to loot now. Items
      Fixed an issue where 'Bygone Bee' Almanac's cooldown or duration would be affected too much when hitting multiple enemies. Player versus Player
      Sources of Conquest such as the World PvP Call to Arms quests, PvP Island Expeditions, Skirmish, and Battleground queues will award Honor until Battle for Azeroth: Arena Season 1 starts. Players who currently have Conquest will have the currency converted to Honor once they log in. Miniaturized Plasma Shield and Personal Space Amplifier engineering belt enchants can no longer be used in Arenas and Rated Battlegrounds. Fierce Gladiator is once again available to players who have earned the Fierce Gladiator: Legion Season 5 achievement. The War Mode Air Supply Drops in Tiragarde Sound should no longer fall in unreachable locations. Monk Brewmaster Incendiary Brew now adheres to line of sight restrictions. Double Barrel will no longer stun targets multiple times per Keg Smash cast. Professions
      Cooking Fixed a bug that prevented Pandaria Banquets from granting the intended skill levels to Pandaria Cooking and Way of the Grill. Quests
      Fixed a bug that caused the miners to not respawn as intended for “A Shot at the Dark Iron”. Fixed a bug where missions required to unlock hubs on the other continent were expiring quickly. Riding Macaw is no longer unfriendly to Horde for the world quest "Swab This!". Hexlord Raal is now reliably present to offer “Pa'ku, Master of Winds”. “The Lord Admiral's Lament" and "Bloodied Sentinel's Glaive" can now be turned in to Kayla Mills World
      Flight paths unlocked through missions should now reliably appear as valid destinations on the flight map. Previous Patch 8.0.1 Hotfixes
      August 16 August 15 August 14
    • By Stan
      Game files contain a male character model named "ThinHuman" with various customization options. The model provides a good example of how Kul Tiran Humans would look if they weren't all chubby.
      Blizzard probably uses the character model to generate NPCs for the outdoor world, same thing we've seen with the Lightforged Draenei on Argus before they have been added as an Allied Race. It would be really cool to see this as a customization option for Kul Tiran Humans, what do you think? Here's an overview of all "ThinHuman" customization options:
      Skin Color

      Faces

      Hair Color

      Hair Style

       
      Beard

    • By Starym
      The fall season of 2018's Arena World Championship is bringing two new BfA arenas to the table, Mugambala and Hook Point, set in Zandalar and Boralus, respectively. 6 cups await this season, with each bringing a $10,000 prize pool and a whole bunch of AWC points, so check out the full schedule and requirements to join in the competition:
      Arena Fall Season (source)
      The Arena World Championship is a 3v3 tournament that takes place in the iconic battlegrounds of Azeroth. In this Fall Season, we are introducing Mugambala and Hook Point, two asymmetrical arenas which were released in the Battle for Azeroth expansion.
      Mugambala is set in Zandalar, a region that was once a part of ancient Kalimdor and the birthplace of troll civilization. This arena features an upper level, and a lower level with a large pillar in the middle. Hook Point is an area in Boralus, where only the bravest battle for the right to call themselves true Kul Tirans! It features four pillars for players to dance around—one with a shark hanging from it—and two smaller pillars. This season, there are six Cups up for grabs—three in North American and three in Europe—each with a prize pool of $10,000 and an increased amount of AWC points on offer, more than any season this year!
      No Arena ranking is required for teams of three to four people to sign up. Once you are deemed eligible to compete, you will have access to the Tournament Realm, where you and your teammates will have the ability to create whatever class, talent, and gear combinations you see fit, to practice taking down all who oppose you! If you think you have what it takes, sign up here, and check out the table below for the cutoff times for each of the Fall Season Cups.
      Remember, the top three point-earners of the year from North America and Europe will earn a spot at the Arena World Championship Global Finals at BlizzCon, where they will fight on the biggest WoW esports stage of the year for their share of the $280,000 prize pool.
      If you’re coming back to World of Warcraft for Battle for Azeroth and want to see how the pros handle the new PvP talent system, join us! The Top 8 from each Cup in North America and Europe will be broadcast live on Twitch. Watch as the greatest heroes from across North America and Europe adapt to the changes—it might give you some tips and tricks for your own Arena adventures!
      AWC Fall Season Schedule
      Event Signups Close Play Begins Top 8 Broadcasts EU Cup #1 September 3
      (18:00 CEST) September 12 September 14 & 16
      (19:00 CEST) NA Cup#1 September 3
      (18:00 CEST) September 12 September 15 & 16
      (19:00 CEST) EU Cup #2 September 17
      (18:00 CEST) September 26 September 28 & 30
      (10:00 CEST) NA Cup #2 September 17
      (18:00 CEST) September 26 September 29 & 30
      (19:00 CEST) EU Cup #3 September 24
      (18:00 CEST) October 3 October 5 & 7 
      (19:00 CEST) NA Cup #3 September 24
      (18:00 CEST) October 3 October 6 & 7
      (19:00 CEST) Check out the Warcraft Esports site for current standings, the global broadcast schedule, and the latest news about AWC, and follow @Warcraft for all things Battle for Azeroth!