Jump to content
FORUMS
Sign in to follow this  
Starym

Parry, Dodge, Miss, Block and Crit Issues in Classic Beta

Recommended Posts

Y5PdZCx.jpg
 

After all the "not a bug" issues that have been reported on the Classic beta, we thought it would be nice to take a look at a more serious report that actually takes some time to take a look at the issues discussed and present some proper evidence and data. Mirayne over on the official forums took time to detail some possible major discrepancies for parry, dodge, block, miss and crit values when facing higher level enemies.

Quote

Conventional wisdom about vanilla hit table mechanics includes the following:

  1. Mobs and players of equal level (more precisely, equal weapon skill and defense) have a base 5% chance to dodge, parry, block, miss (non- dual wielding).

  2. Mobs have (5 * Level) weapon skill and defense values.

  3. Each point of difference between defense and weapon skill changes those percentages by 0.04% per point (except miss, see below). For example, a player hitting a +3 mob (such as a raid boss) from the front without dual wielding will experience 5.6% chance for their attacks to be dodged, parried, and blocked by the mob. For the purposes of this discussion let’s stick to white attacks.

A guide on the old Evil Empire site claimed the source of the knowledge about 0.04% per point of difference between weapon skill and defense, and other information, came from the following three blue posts:

https://web.archive.org/web/20070105001622/http://forums-en.wow-europe.com/thread.aspx?fn=wow-blizzard-archive-en&t=7

https://web.archive.org/web/20070105001622/http://forums-en.wow-europe.com/thread.aspx?fn=wow-blizzard-archive-en&t=15

https://web.archive.org/web/20070105001622/http://forums.worldofwarcraft.com/thread.aspx?ForumName=wow-bugs&ThreadID=62388

Unfortunately these are no longer accessible, at least not that I could find so I can’t see the wording.

A few of us from one of the classic warrior discords have been doing some testing on beta to verify the hit tables and other mechanics work the way we think. The testing is slow going but we have some preliminary results. Good news is certain things like glancing blow chance and penalties seem to be consistent with previous understanding, at least for +5 wep skill and +0 wep skill. Some testing will need to wait until later beta stages (presuming level cap is raised).

However we have found some strange results for other parts of the hit tables. For each result we also report 95% confidence intervals. Admittedly sample size is lower than we would like but testing is tedious and time consuming to do manually. However, even at these sample sizes some important information can be gleaned.

  1. Parry appears to be much too high (13.61% +/- 1.18%) for +3 mobs (no extra weapon skill) and is more consistent with parry values from later expansions. This conflicts with the 0.04% from old blue posts.

  2. Dodge (6.73% +/- 0.86%) appears to match later expansion values (wrath, see below). This conflicts with the 0.04% from old blue posts.

  3. Block (4.52% +/- 0.71%) appears slightly lower than expected. This conflicts with the 0.04% from old blue posts.

  4. Miss (8.41% +/- 0.95%) unfortunately isn’t enough samples to resolve between three prevailing theories on base miss chance for +3 mobs (8%, 8.6%, and 9%), but it’s encouraging that there isn’t a huge surprise here.

  5. Based on the base crit (4.49%) for the “Antlered Courser” test, there appears to be an additional crit suppression happening for +3 mobs beyond the expected 0.04% factor. For that test we are seeing a crit of 1.34% +/- 0.6%. Similar results were obtained for the Giant Yeti test, though slightly different due to different paper doll crit. ~3% crit suppression for +3 I believe was a feature of later expansions but was apparently not seen in vanilla according to any old sources.

Combat logs and summaries can be found here:

https://github.com/magey/classic-warrior/issues/5

Additional references:

This site claimed parry was changed to 14% for +3 in cata pre-patch:

https://wowwiki.fandom.com/wiki/Attack_table?diff=2413116&oldid=2412483

This site claimed dodge of 6.5% for +3 mobs (wrath):

https://wowwiki.fandom.com/wiki/Expertise?diff=1923754&oldid=1918454

This site claimed 5.6% for dodge/parry/block/miss for +3 (5% for +0), perhaps based on the blue posts linked above

http://web.archive.org/web/20061115223930/http://forums.wow-europe.com/thread.html?topicId=14381707&sid=1

All of this leads us to the following questions:

Is it possible that the creation of the 1.13 client led to some accidental setting of parameters from later expansions?

Would it be possible to verify that the beta is behaving as intended, or misbehaving, by devs comparing to their 1.12 reference client?

Blizzard responded, but still don't have a direct answer:

Blizzard Logo Parry, Dodge, Miss, etc. (source)

Hi Mirayne,

First off, the QA team wanted to thank you for the exceptionally detailed report. This is a great example of a professional report that utilizes data to support a hypothesis. Well done!

Regarding the potential issue itself, the team is going to take a look at this tomorrow in the reference client and verify that the current functionality is consistent with 1.12. Thanks again for the diligent, detailed analysis!

So, will this one make it to the "not a bug" list or is there really something fishy going on with those combat stats? Place your bets!

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

well I can definitely say that dodges, parries, misses, blocks, glancing blows, spell resists and partial resists definitely happened hell of a lot more in classic than they do in modern WoW but it is entirely possible that the values are too high pending what the dev team finds.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Uncommon Patron

I think it's amazing that a Classic player is taking the time and putting in the effort to glean these numbers from such tedious work. Someone give that human a medal, or a hug, or a medal with a hug on it. Something. Give them something.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Staff
      Blizzard have update the PTR notes with some Legacy raid content nerfs! 
      PTR Septemner 23 (Source)
      Updated the notes with the following Legacy Raid changes:
      Dungeons and Raids
      Legacy Raids The following encounters have been adjusted to be less challenging for solo play: Antorus, the Burning Throne Antoran High Command Eonar the Life-Binder Varimathras (This change will be available in a later PTR build) Coven of Shivarra Aggramar Tomb of Sargeras The Desolate Host Fallen Avatar Kil’Jaeden The Nighthold Gul’dan Trial of Valor Helya
    • By Starym
      A calm week in Mythic+, where we see Windwalker move up in its weakest bracket and Fire actually see a drop anywhere, while Subtlety has a very good week and might be ready to dethrone the eternal blue king.
      Note: The logs are based on POINTS, and not actual damage or healing, meaning they log the timed completion for the specs, with higher keys getting more points, obviously. The time in which the dungeon is completed is also a factor, but a much, much smaller one, as it grants very few points if you do it significantly faster than just any in-time completion. We're also using the Normalized Aggregate Scores numbers, for clarity, meaning the top spec is marked as 100 and then the rest are ranked in relation to that peak point.
      This past week was Tyrannical, Bolstering, Explosive (and Tormented).
      All Keys
      Windwalkers return to the top 3, correcting their drop from last week while Subtlety actually comes much closer to Fire's eternal throne. Arcane rises two into the top 5, pushing Affliction and Balance down, as Shadow sees the biggest movement in the high percentiles, jumping 4 into 8th. Marksmanship drops one and Havoc gets in-between the Warriors in the middle of the pack , as the bottom 5 remain the same, with Retribution dropping to dead last.

      Mythic+ All Keys 95th Percentile Data by Warcraft Logs.
      The all percentages bracket is starting to look more like the 95th, as Subtlety takes 2nd place here as well, but Affliction is still doing a lot better and keeps its 3rd place at least. Arcane is doing even better here compared to last week, jumping 4 into 6th, while Fury dropped 3 spots seeing Havoc, Unholy and Survival pass it in the middle of the pack.

      Mythic+ All Keys All Percentile Data by Warcraft Logs.
      High Keys
      Fire hasn't managed to take over the +15s quite yet and the standings remain the same in the top 5, but 6th sees a big change as Havoc moves there, rising 2 spots. Survival and Assassination are the next to rise, 3 and 4 spots respectively, as Fury drops 3. All the specs are incredibly close in the 15s still, so even the bottom of the pack is doing really well here.

      Mythic+15 All Percentile Data by Warcraft Logs.
      Windwalker retains its No.1 spot in the 20ies and Fire actually drops a space, as Subtletly had a really good week across all keys it seems. Arms and Arcane both moved up, with the Warrior spec surpassing the Mage along the way. Havoc jumped 3 spots and almost made it to the top 5, while Assassination was the biggest mover, rising a whole 7 spots into 8th!
      Mythic+20 All Percentile Data by Warcraft Logs.
       
      For even more in-depth data for each individual key head on over to Warcraft Logs. And if you're interested in more info on the specs themselves you can always check out our class guides or our extensive Mythic+ guides as well, which have tier lists, dungeon rankings and more.

    • By Stan
      One Rogue Legendary power has been updated in Patch 9.1.5 Build 40290.
      Toxic Onslaught has been redesigned in this week's PTR build.
      Rogue
      Legendary Powers
      Toxic Onslaught - Your stealth ability used while Sepsis is active grants you one of Shadow Blades, Adrenaline Rush, or applies Vendetta to your current target for 12 sec. Assassination: When Sepsis expires on your target you gain Adrenaline Rush and Shadow Blades for 10 sec. Outlaw, Subtlety: When Sepsis expires on your target you gain Adrenaline Rush and apply Vendetta to your current target for 10 sec. You can find the remaining Rogue changes that will go live in the forthcoming patch here.
    • By Staff
      The Arena World Championship 2021 Grand Finals is just around the corner! On September 25 at 10 am PT on Saturday and Sunday, teams from Europe and North America will compete for a $300,000 (USD) prize pool! Who will win?
      You can read more about the Arena World Championship over at Upcomer.
      Arena World Championship Grand Finals
      The Arena World Championship (AWC) Grand Finals kicks off September 25, with teams battling it out to determine the best of the best across Europe and North America. Catch the action live starting at 10 am PT on Saturday and Sunday, only on YouTube!
      This year of AWC has seen some of the most competitive teams in the world rise to the occasion, and some fall in defeat, with the goal to be 2021 Regional Champions. This weekend marks the end of the road to glory as four teams in each region enter the arena for their share of the $300,000 (USD) prize pool and the prestigious title of AWC: Shadowlands 2021 Grand Finals Champions!
      Details
      Venue: Online - YouTube.com/Warcraft Dates: Saturday, September 25 – Sunday, September 26 Broadcast Start Time: 10:00 AM PT  Each day starting with EU series and ending with NA Series All Quarter and Semi-Finals will be completed on Saturday Elimination Rounds and the Finals will occur on Sunday Prize Pool: $300,000 (USD) combined between North America and Europe Format: 3v3, Best of 5 / Best of 7 Finals Casting Talent: Elliott “Venruki” Venczel Sid “Supatease” Compston Gillian “Eiya” Long Mohammed “Ziqo” Beshir Language Streams on YouTube: English German Portuguese (LATAM) Spanish (EU) Teams
      The Season 2 Circuit started with 16 teams, with 12 advancing from the Season 1 Circuit and four from the mid-season Relegation Cup, but after four weeks only eight teams across Europe and North America have secured spots in this weekend’s Grand Finals. Here is all you need to know to follow the teams in their final battles of 2021:
      Europe 
      blob:https://www.icy-veins.com/4be77638-f27a-49c3-a45a-afea30292f04
      Skill Capped is the European team to beat, with a Season 1 EU win already under their belts and a strong 19-7 record across the Season 2 Circuit.
      Skill Capped, Method EU, and Reload Esports each appeared earlier this year in the Season 1 Finals, with Skill Capped taking the win over Method EU (watch the EU Season 1 Finals VOD here). Horizon qualified to Season 2 from being Top 6 in the Season 1 Circuit, but did not appear in the Season 1 Finals. Team
      Alias
      Class
            Reload Esports
      Lontar
      Restoration Shaman
      Reload Esports
      Vilaye
      Shadow Priest
      Reload Esports
      Merce
      Warlock
      Reload Esports
      Mystic
      Retribution Paladin
      Skill Capped
      Maro
      Mage
      Skill Capped
      Asgarath
      Restoration Druid
      Skill Capped
      Blizo
      Warrior
      Skill Capped
      Froffsy
      Mage
      Method EU
      Chas
      Restoration Druid / Discipline Priest
      Method EU
      Zunniyaki
      Shadow Priest
      Method EU
      Whaazz
      Rogue
      Method EU
      Thesia
      Mage
      Horizon
      TonyFeral
      Feral Druid
      Horizon
      Kasuxo
      Hunter
      Horizon
      GeluBaba
      Mage
      Horizon
      Relzah
      Discipline Priest
      North America 
      blob:https://www.icy-veins.com/2fd8be27-b860-41a7-9850-f9bdd486dbd4
      Hot off the heels of a Season 1 NA Finals win, Method NA remain dominant as their 20-5 record is the best across both regions in the Season 2 Circuit.
      Method NA, Cloud 9, and Golden Guardians each appeared earlier this year in the Season 1 Finals, with Method NA taking the win over Cloud 9 (watch the NA Season 1 Finals VOD here). Unitas Blue qualified to Season 2 from being Top 6 in the Season 1 Circuit, but did not appear in the Season 1 Finals. Team
      Alias
      Class
            Cloud9
      Snutz
      Rogue/Warrior
      Cloud9
      Chanimal
      Warlock
      Cloud9
      Wealthyman
      Mage
      Cloud9
      Kubzy
      Restoration Druid
      Golden Guardians
      Pikaboo
      Rogue
      Golden Guardians
      Absterge
      Restoration Shaman
      Golden Guardians
      Wizk
      Shadow Priest
      Golden Guardians
      Jellybeans
      Hunter/Mage
      Method NA
      Ceralium
      Mage
      Method NA
      Brain
      Holy Paladin
      Method NA
      Drake
      Windwalker Monk / Warrior / Rogue
      Method NA
      Prev
      Balance Druid
      Unitas Blue
      Smexxin
      Warrior
      Unitas Blue
      Borngood
      Holy Paladin
      Unitas Blue
      Aiden
      Rogue
      Unitas Blue
      Nuked
      Mage
      Stay Connected
      Stay connected and on top of the latest World of Warcraft Esports news and content on the AWC and MDIwebsites, YouTube, and don’t forget to follow the WoW Esports Twitter account!
    • By Stan
      Here are all Priest class changes that went live this week on the 9.1.5 PTR.
      Priest
      Discipline / Holy
      Halo (Level 45 Talent) - Creates a ring of Holy energy around you that quickly expands to a 30 yd radius, healing allies for [ 144% 115% of Spell Power ] and dealing [ 103% of Spell Power ] Holy damage to enemies. The spell now deals reduced healing beyond 6 targets. Divine Star now deals reduced healing beyond 6 targets. The spell cap is now independent on the outgoing/return trips.
×
×
  • Create New...