Jump to content
FORUMS
Sign in to follow this  
Stan

The Downsides to Layering in WoW Classic

Recommended Posts

43455-wow-classic-first-impressions.jpg

Layering is a limited form of sharding invented specifically for WoW Classic. It will be implemented to ensure a smooth launch in August, but comes with downsides and recent Closed Beta footage demonstrates just how easy it is to abuse the system in its current iteration.

Layering in WoW Classic

The purpose of layering is to shard entire continents at launch, meaning one server will have multiple layers that will be gone in a few weeks after launch when all layers merge into a single realm.

Redditor Salvage_di_macaroni posted an image which highlights differences between sharding and layering on reddit.

xpz3z1ly1dy21.png?width=960&crop=smart&a

You can find more information about layering in the article below.

The Downsides to Layering

Now comes the fun part. Redditor omegalulreddit posted two clips showing how easy it is to abuse the new system. In the first clip, we have a demonstration of switching between multiple layers. Each character represents a different layer and you can control the layer of your main by logging in with an alt first.

The second clip takes place in Gurubashi Arena and shows how layering can be abused in world PvP.

A player gets invited to the party, phasing into another layer with different players and leaving the party causes him to phase back out, making his enemies disappear. For some odd reason, we're unable to embed the clip, but you can watch it here.

What do you think about layering? The current suggestion is to disable it outside of starter zones.

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I do not think this is a big deal in any way - even if someone does "abuse" it, its simply not a big deal. Classic population will most likely be small anyways

 

Lets focus on being positive for the games we love ? not need to create issues out of total edge cases. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Wait, wait, we don't get the AUTHENTIC VANILLA EXPERIENCE!?    Where every time something was added we'd have realms down for hours, crazylag when they were up, and zonewide disconnects whenever a ZG berserker feared someone?     This is an OUTRAGE.

  • Like 2
  • Haha 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
13 hours ago, PatrickHenry said:

I dont see much practical difference in the issues occurring than there were with Sharding.  

Me neither. We have that kind of "server-hoping" with sharding, don't we? In both situation we joining an other instance of the zone, don't we? Instead of switching shards, we switch the layer. So as far as i understand, this is a technical thing - but for us as a player, where is the difference?

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Keep the layering, but have no interaction between the layers, then merge them after a month. 
So you would select the layer when making a character, a new layer would become available when one fills up.
so you would have mini-servers. i.e frostwhisper 1, 2, 3 etc. you are stuck in that layer till the merge.

Downsides would be a friend coming late and can't get on the same layer as their friend. but if it only lasts a month thats not rly gonna matter, also you're not rly gonna play with your friend you're 60 lvls ahead of.  
 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't really understand how people expect them to accomplish this and not have something like layering.

The technology that exists can't handle the amount of influx it will receive.

At this point, you don't understand what you're trying to deride by making insinuations like "just make it go away".

 

?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
15 hours ago, Migol said:

Wait, wait, we don't get the AUTHENTIC VANILLA EXPERIENCE!?    Where every time something was added we'd have realms down for hours, crazylag when they were up, and zonewide disconnects whenever a ZG berserker feared someone?     This is an OUTRAGE.

Well there goes my plans to play a hunter just for when ZG launches.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, Tucky said:

Keep the layering, but have no interaction between the layers, then merge them after a month. 
So you would select the layer when making a character, a new layer would become available when one fills up.
so you would have mini-servers. i.e frostwhisper 1, 2, 3 etc. you are stuck in that layer till the merge.

Downsides would be a friend coming late and can't get on the same layer as their friend. but if it only lasts a month thats not rly gonna matter, also you're not rly gonna play with your friend you're 60 lvls ahead of.  
 

As far as i understood, Layers will be created much faster than you think. Layering is a good thing, it keeps WoW playable. For me, it's not an abuse what you see in the video. This is how layering works, intentionally. How i already said, at my PoV we have same "issues" with sharding. I often used this behavior in Legion if there was WQ-Ganking on my PvP-Server. I just hoped to an PvE-Server ? . To be said, this layering needs more effort to "abuse". Because you need to have people (lets call them friends) who invite you from one to another layer. As i understood in videos you don't automatically "layer" back after quit a group. You stay on this layer till another person from another layer invite you.

For me: Good system, works as intended, nothing to worry about ?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Allseye said:

This is how layering works, intentionally.

No, it's how it works technically but not intentionally. The intention of layers is not to hop in and out of combat or farm nodes through layer-hopping. Like you said, we had similiar issues with realm-hopping in WoD and Legion, and Blizz tried to minimize that behaviour, meaning that they don't intend for this kind of "clever use of game mechanics".

I think there will be some no-life goblins out there who will abuse the *filtered* out of this system. To say that it's nothing to worry about is very optimistic considering we don't know exactly to what extent it will be abused on live servers. So, it's definitely an issue that they should at least try to solve.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

"phasing" introduced in Wrath, and LFD also introduced in wrath...

 

Decimated server communities. I have friends that haven't logged in since, that I chat with on other platforms.

Toss in LFR and cross realm.   They destroyed what they had.  Ghostroller is the guy who did this, prob others who we aren't sure of.

I'd bet not Tigole.,..  But, maybe Morheim cashed out, not sure.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Staff
      Hunters got some newly added tuning today, as Blizzard detail additional changes added to the already quite significant class tuning! 
      Hunter (Source)
      This morning with scheduled weekly maintenance, in addition to previously-planned adjustments to other classes, we deployed several changes to Hunters in Season of Discovery.
      Hunter
      Rapid Killing now reduces the cooldown of Rapid Fire by 80% (was a reduction of 2 minutes). Chimera Shot weapon damage percent increased to 135% (was 120%). Explosive Shot base damage before attack power increased by 50%. Sniper Training has an additional new effect: while Sniper Training is at 5 stacks, Aimed Shot is instant. Serpent Spread now causes Multi-shot to apply Serpent Sting to its targets for 12 seconds (was 6 seconds). Steady Shot now deals 100% weapon damage (was 75%). As we previously noted, there are more adjustments coming for Hunters and other classes. In general, we intend to improve the ranged playstyle and diminish the melee playstyle so that the two become more equivalent.
      We apologize for the confusion caused by the changes above going live earlier than intended, and we intend to post more about further adjustments soon.
      Thank you for your patience and understanding.
    • By Staff
      This weekend, a global damage reduction aura will be tested in PvP combat in Season of Discovery to balance the increased burst damage observed the latest phase.
      (Source)
      Hello, Classic PvPers!
      This coming weekend, we will test an adjustment to Player versus Player combat in Season of Discovery. We will implement a global damage reduction aura on PvP combat between players (and player controlled pets and other units).
      When we started Season of Discovery, we knew that PvP would become significantly more fast paced and bursty, with each class being capable of significantly more damage output, and this quickly proved to be true. We experimented with a damage reduction aura in battlegrounds during Phase 1, but it didn’t work as well as we hoped, mostly because healing was scaling more aggressively than damage at that point, causing healing classes to become significantly more oppressive in battlegrounds than they normally would be. Now that we’re in Phase 3, we’ve made many changes and added more runes, and burst damage has significantly outpaced healing output, so we feel that it’s a good time to try this again.
      Damage scaling and its impact on PvP has always been a concern in World of Warcraft, even since original WoW. Various systems have been introduced to counteract this to varying levels of success, but ultimately it always comes down to the fact that player damage outscales player health at a base level, and an adjustment is needed for combat between players to continue to feel satisfying as player power increases. We’ve been hesitant to introduce this as a permanent feature, and we prefer to give it a trial run this weekend to get an idea of how it feels before we take further steps. Please note: this aura will affect all areas of the game world, not just battlegrounds.
      We encourage you to get out into the world (or in battlegrounds) and PvP the weekend and let us know how it feels. We’re prepared to do some tuning to make it the most effective, so your feedback will be very helpful.
      We currently plan to enable the aura on all Season of Discovery realms on Friday, April 26 at approximately 19:00 CEST, and it will be disabled four days later, during scheduled weekly maintenance in each region.
      We look forward to your feedback. Thank you!
    • By Staff
      Blizzard have announced that there will be realm transfers coming from PvP to PvE realms over the next few weeks. These free transfers will be open for a short time and on multiple occasions. Blizzard also explain why these are opening now and also talk about faction balance, which is the reason the transfers will work in these short bursts on numerous occasions. 
      Transfers (Source)
      Good evening everyone,
      When we launched Season of Discovery, we made some bold decisions, one of those was the creation of Enforced Faction Balanced PvP Realms. When we did this, we did our best to communicate some caveats that this may not end up being the experience you want from World of Warcraft, as PvP realms can be an intensely challenging experience at times. While we are very happy with how the faction balance system has worked out, we know from player feedback internally and externally that the reality of a balanced presence of both factions on a single realm, and that individual layers will not always have equal factions, means that some folks have now decided they would instead prefer a PvE ruleset, but have characters locked to these PvP realms.
      To that end, we genuinely want everyone to have the best time they can in Season of Discovery, so over the next few weeks, we will be periodically opening Free Character Transfers from PvP realms to PvE realms. These transfer windows will open and close fairly rapidly, and we offer no guarantee that you will be able to transfer. The reasoning for this is simple; we need to ensure that one faction doesn’t disproportionally leave a realm, undoing months of hard work with realm faction balance.
      These transfer options will be periodically available starting Tuesday and will open and close throughout the rest of this week.
      As always, thank for you joining us in Season of Discovery. We’ve experimented a lot and learned much that will ultimately lead to bigger and better things.
    • By Staff
      We have some more class tuning coming to Phase 3 of SoD, as Druids, Paladins, Priests, Rogues and Shamans get some solid changes.
      Class Tuning (Source)
      Tomorrow, during each region’s normal maintenance period, we will apply the following adjustments to classes in Season of Discovery.
      Druid
      The Natural Weapons talents now increases all damage done by druids in Season of Discovery, instead of just physical damage. The Gale Winds rune now reduces the mana cost of Hurricane by 60%. Swiftmend no longer consumes a Rejuvenation or Regrowth effect on the target when used. Developers’ notes: Please note that it does still require Rejuvenation or Regrowth to be on the target to be used. Paladin
      Seal of Righteousness damage can now be critical hits. Sacred Shield’s duration is extended to 60 seconds (was 30 seconds). Crusader Strike has now gained an additional effect: Crusader strike now refreshes all judgement effects active on the target to a 30 second remaining duration. Seal of Martyrdom can now “twist” with other seals, including Seal of Command. Developers’ notes: Seal “twisting” was an interesting emergent effect that became popular during the original Burning Crusade, that utilized the slower server messaging system used in early versions of WoW to slightly extend the duration of the Paladin’s active seal for a short time whenever a second seal was cast. This effectively allowed paladins to momentarily gain the benefit of two seals at once if they timed the application of a new seal to line up perfectly just before their weapon swing. This is something we would have considered a bug at the time, but for many players, it became a popular feature of the class, allowing skilled players to increase their output with precision gameplay.
      We recreated this playstyle in Burning Crusade Classic and since then it’s been a popular request in other versions of original WoW, including Season of Discovery. We had concerns about allowing Martyrdom and Command specifically to be twisted together in Season of Discovery for a variety of reasons, including the fact that the playstyle is highly mana inefficient, it largely requires addons such as a weapon swing timer to function properly, and twisting can be unintuitive for less experienced players. As the game matures and we continue to listen to player feedback however, we recognize that for some, this is part of the charm and uniqueness of playing a paladin during those early eras of WoW’s history. We consider this change to be experimental and we will watch the performance and behavior of Retribution closely after this change. Should it prove problematic, we may revert this change or apply additional adjustments later. We greatly appreciate the feedback we’ve received about this thus far.
      With this change to allow twisting, we do not expect to see a major change in the “optimal” way to play Retribution right away. Due to the interaction between Art of War, Martyrdom, and Exorcism, we’ll likely need a larger redesign and changes to that interaction to truly add more diversity to the Retribution playstyle. We’re evaluating options here for potential changes we can make either via hotfix during Phase 3 or as part of a larger effort for Phase 4. Priest
      Shadowform now increases all shadow damage done by 25% (was 15%). Rogue
      Saber Slash bleed now stacks up to 5 times. Saber Slash bleed now also increases the impact damage done by Sinister Strike and Saber Slash by 15% per stack for the rogue who applied the bleed. Saber Slash bleed now deals 3% of the rogue’s Attack Power in damage per tick (was 5%). Shaman
      Mental Dexterity now only triggers from dealing damage with Stormstrike and Lava Lash, and it now lasts 30 seconds (was 10 seconds). Burn now increases Flame Shock Damage by 100% and flame shock DoT duration by 6 seconds, and causes Flame Shock to strike up to 5 targets (was 3 targets). Developers’ notes: We’ve received a lot of feedback about the overall usability of mental dexterity, particularly for Elemental Shamans. This ability was not intended to be used by elemental, so the adjustments we’ve made are to help ensure its usage is a bit more enhancement-centric. To compensate, we’ve increased the output and usability of the Burn rune, with a slight quality-of-life improvement in the form of a Flame Shock duration increase which allows two Lava Burst casts to be used within a single Flame Shock duration. This is likely not going to be enough to overall bring elemental up to the level we want, so we intend to continue to make other tactical adjustments in future class adjustment updates as needed. In the Weeks to Come
      We’re carefully planning for more adjustments to Hunters, Mages, Shamans, and Warlocks in future updates. We really appreciate the feedback we’ve received since the start of Phase 3 and look forward to sharing more about our next round of adjustments with you soon.
    • By Staff
      Players have been noticing that Righteous Orbs were suddenly no longer dropping, and now Blizzard have confirmed that there was a hotfix, and that they were never intended to drop before Phase 4.
      Righteous Orbs (Source)
      With a hotfix that went live to all realms earlier today, Righteous Orbs no longer drop during Phase 3 of Season of Discovery.
      They’ll become available as intended in Phase 4.
×
×
  • Create New...