Jump to content
FORUMS
Sign in to follow this  
Starym

The Not a Bug List Strikes Again - Berserker Stance

Recommended Posts

44305-beta-ends-on-july-12th-final-stres
 

Update: there was an addition blue post that further clarified the situation. It has been added to the bottom of the article.

Here we go again! It seems players keep getting convinced that something's not quite right™ over on the WoW Classic beta, and this time around it's the extra critical strike chance granted by warriors' Berserker Stance.

Blizzard LogoBerserker Stance (source)

Thanks to extensive testing done on the beta by Puffymuffins, Towneh, and Vilius over at the classic warrior discord, we’ve encountered what appears to be a pretty significant bug with Berserker Stance. Against +3 level mobs, Berserker Stance’s +3% crit bonus is not applying to our attacks and as a result our effective crit chance is 3% lower than it should be. We’re aware of the 1% crit reduction per level difference, this is an additional 3% reduction. If we attack mobs of the same level in Berserker Stance, then we are seeing expected crit values. Attacking +3 level mobs while in Defensive or Battle Stance is also giving us expected crit values, after factoring in crit suppression, as can be seen here:

https://github.com/magey/classic-warrior/wiki/Attack-table

In our analysis of 5178 hits, we show that when fighting +3 lvl mobs in Berserker Stance the measured crit chance was ~3% lower than expected on each individual test and also when doing a weighted average of all the tests:

Overall crit chance (weighted average):

  • Spell book: 15.61%
  • Expected: 12.61% (-3% crit suppression)
  • Measured: 9.75% ±0.82%

Additionally, all other attack table results match what what’s expected when fighting +3 level mobs (comparing to our extensive log collection totaling ~15k hits) which further validates these results.

As a control, we also did tests on same level mobs with no weapon skill bonus to see if this bug was caused by some interaction of weapon skill, crit suppression, level difference and the Berserker Stance bonus. In these tests, the measured crit chance was as expected given the tolerances:

Overall crit chance (weighted average):

  • Spell book: 17.19%
  • Expected: 17.19%
  • Measured: 16.93% ±1.22%

The detailed analysis and combat logs of our tests can be found over here:

https://github.com/magey/classic-warrior/issues/17

-magey

 

Hi All,

We looked into this.

Modifiers to Critical Strike chance are reduced against enemies 3 levels higher than the player-character. We tested a variety of modifiers to Critical Strike, such as: Berserker Stance, the Cruelty talent, and critical strike chance on gear. They all behaved the same as they did in 1.12, so we’ve concluded that there’s no bug here.

Thanks for the report!

New:

I’m not going to get too deep into the specific math on this one, but for the sake of clarity, I’ll say that this is not a per-aura modifier and it is separate than the 3% suppression that is baseline against +3 level creatures. There is a single modifier placed on total Critical Strike gained from auras that increase Crit chance such as those I listed in my last post.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The way the blue reply is worded implies that this is the case for all classes and critical strike, rather than just warriors. Which means DPS in Classic WoW should be lower than on private servers, since people will have less crit in general, especially at higher levels of gear if its a % reduction on crit gains against bosses rather than a flat one.

This could make raiding a little bit more interesting / harder, lets see 🙂

  • Haha 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Starym
      The Blackwing Lair speed runs continue unabated, and there's been a few more fastest runs, with Progress claiming the most recent/current record, taking only 20 minutes and 30 seconds to get Nefarian and co. down! Their run was actually a massive jump both from the current second place holders SALAD BAKERS (1 min 10 sec) and from the last one we covered, GUSY (1 min 23 sec), so this one will probably stay up there for a while. To make things even better, they conjured up a little celebration video as well, with some of their... ahem, "fans" "cheering" them on at the start. The video itself is pretty short, with highlights of the kills and a pretty damn good soundtrack as well, so let's take a look.
      This particular speed required over half the raid to be warriors (21, in fact), and also starred 6 priests, 5 rogues, 3 paladins, 2 hunters, a warlock, a mage and a druid. Here are the current standings in the seemingly most prestigious ongoing race in Classic at the moment, with the top 10 being separated by all of 3 minutes:

      Source.
    • By Starym
      We have another South Park Live to Win champion on our hands! DrFive had taken it upon himself to ignore every non-boar mob in Classic and get to max level as close to how the boys from South Park did as possible (but obviously couldn't quite stay in Elwynn Forest only). This isn't the first time someone has taken up and completed this very weird challenge, as it was conquered on retail back in 7.3.5, but that one took a trip to Outland to finish things up.

      This Classic attempt took almost 10 days played, 10,000 boars downed, 30 deaths and 22 million damage, but it was a success in the end, so let's take a look at the final moments, as well as some details on how he got there (including a whole lot of rested XP, help in pre-clearing Razorfen Downs etc):
       
      The entire journey will be uploaded to youtube, and there's already 36 videos up there to check out if you really like to see boars die.

      In case you don't feel like checking days' worth of footage, there's this theorycrafting video from before Classic's release on the very subject, and while DrFive didn't necessarily keep to this exact path, it's still a fun video to check out!

      Congrats to DrFive on this very weird challenge, and to everyone that keeps doing weird things in all of WoW, as we love seeing things like this make the game feel more alive. Also, make sure to re-watch the Make Love, not Warcraft South Park episode that started all of this.
      Source.
    • By Starym
      It seems the crowding has been (somewhat) alleviated, as Blizzard have disabled layering on all US servers, after having enabled it for select servers around a month ago. It remains to be seen when the same will come for EU servers.
      Layers (source)
      At this time, we’re contracting from two layers to one on all realms in this region that were layered.
      As we’ve constantly watched and analyzed realm populations over the last few weeks, we’ve seen enough of a recent trend to justify returning to the intended population arrangement for each realm. At the same time, we’ve unlocked any realms that were locked for new character creation.
      All Paid Character Transfer restrictions have been left in place. We’re going to continue to use our ability to disable that service as a stopgap, and we’ll let you know when we open or close it further.
    • By Starym
      Nefarian and co. are having a really bad month, as APES' previous speed clear record has been taken down! The previous fastest guild had already taken 26 seconds of the time we had previously reported, and the new champions GUSY have taken another 20 seconds off that, which may not sound like much, but when your clear is that fast to begin with, it's still pretty impressive.
      Shockingly, the raid had 18 warriors and 7 rogues, with the rest of the DPS classes fighting it out for 6 slots, and the priests also joined in the DPS fun with a whole lot of smites as well! Congrats to GUSY on the run, and we're sure to see even more extremely close clears, as the guilds now compete in terms of seconds.


      Source.
    • By Starym
      Today's hotfixes focus on Classic and a fix for the recently announced permanent addition to it, War Games.
      May 12 (source)
      WoW Classic
      Fixed a bug that caused some players to be returned to an incorrect location when leaving a War Game.
×
×
  • Create New...