Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  

Covenant Abilities Might Still Become Free to Swap, Exclusion Based on Covenant, Covenant Ability Testing, Classes Being Homogenous: Preach Watcher Interview

Recommended Posts


Preach interviewed Ion Hazzikostas, mostly focusing on the community reaction and issues around choosing a Covenant and the relevance of the abilities each class gets with that choice, as well as feeling shackled in their choice because of that. The interview is very detailed in the discussion and analysis of player choice, its permanence and similar, but the biggest messages we got from it were:

There is still a possibility they call off the whole Covenant abilities being un-changeable!

Beta invites will go out each week until the end of the Beta.

There's a possibility we get a "mode" or similar where we can test another Covenant's abilities while still in our current Covenant, as the access to those abilities probably won't be enough during leveling, where we will get to test them before choosing a Covenant.

Destructible Conduits will not go live as they are now.

Ion doesn't think having the "wrong" Covenant will get players excluded from groups as much, comparing it to Legion and players not getting excluded (that much) if someone had the wrong legendary. Preach argues that adding any additional exclusion parameters is always bad and most players will simply check guide sites to see which are best for which class and discriminate players based on that. Ion still focuses that it will not play out that way, Covenant abilities won't be as impactful and will just be options, top players might use different ones for the same class and spec.

The choice of picking a Covenant is equivalent to picking a spec back in Legion, due to the artifacts related to that, and players didn't seem to have a big issue with that.


Part of the reason the Covenants are available so early in the Alpha/Beta testing process is so they can get player feedback earlier than for Azerite powers etc. There will be significant changes to a lot of the 48 abilities, even redesigns.

Ion's focus is on getting the balance right on the Covenant powers, so they don't feel as mandatory, but Preach responds by saying that that's not really possible even theoretically, especially considering spec switching, as some abilities are just only good for certain specs of a class.

The probably most interesting part of the interview wasn't really new information, but rather the lengthy discussion between the two on class identity and player choice. The elimination of RNG within class specs, aka the dependence on RNG that (usually DPS) players have, even after they get all the gear they want - you can get everything you want and need, and your performance will not be consistent throughout fights at all. Ion mentions passive abilities should not be as impactful as active ones. They talk about this issue across multiple questions and it's a really fascinating discussion, as Ion focuses on player choice, so different players' warriors are different due to those choices, whereas in a game like Overwatch, all Tracers are the same. Obviously currently RNG is too much of a factor due to Corruptions etc, but in general, Ion feels it's an important part of the game due to player identity. If you're even remotely interested in this discussion, you should definitely check out the full interview, as it presents tow fascinating perspectives.



Other Shadowlands interviews:

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Once again Blizzard sticks to its position, doesn't listen to player, and will create a new system that will get people to be meta or be left out of groups. Very horrible decision.

Also, comparing it to legendary is stupid, since legendary were random loots, here it's about a choice you make at the beginning of the expansion. Completely stupid.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Yup, what we will lack here either way is meaningful choice.
Either the abilities will be balanced, which essentialy makes the choice irrelevant. We will just get three different colored boom buttons pushed to the edge of irrelevance.
Or the abilities will be specialized for a kind of content and swapped up freely, which again, no real choice, just pick what's best atm.

Sure we can go with "eh, you got locked into that? Well, time to make an alt until next patch, cause this is 10% subpar".
But that is not exactly winning either. 

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

No matter what blizzard do, there will always be a 'meta'. Since now we have so much access to sims and websites showing you the 'correct' build. I am choosing to remain hopeful that the systems in Shadowlands are more along the lines of racials - sure there might be a 'best', but if you put in the time and learn the intricacies of your class, you can make any covenant work for what you need to. There is always the likelihood of one being far superior for a certain class/spec/type of content, but chances are that will get nerfed. And Ion has said, if you decide you don't like the covenant you've chosen, it will be easy to swap. What is hard will be going back to a covenant you have left. I'm looking forward to the chance be something a little different and not just the same cookie cutter class build as everyone else, because the top 1% tell us it's the meta.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
14 hours ago, Mugendai said:

Once again Blizzard sticks to its position, doesn't listen to player, and will create a new system that will get people to be meta or be left out of groups. Very horrible decision.

Also, comparing it to legendary is stupid, since legendary were random loots, here it's about a choice you make at the beginning of the expansion. Completely stupid.

You aren't thinking of the reality of the situation. More flexibility in choice leads to less freedom and MORE people being kicked out of groups. Let's say Fire is 50% better than Frost. Changing specializations can be done at any time and a Frost mage applies to your group. You instantly assume this guy is an idiot because he isn't playing Fire when he can be at no cost, so why isn't he? Now let's reverse the situation and say that Night Elf groups are 50% better than Human groups. A human applies to your group, you don't assume this guy is an idiot, because Races cannot be changed just like that. The lack of flexibility is what creates more freedom, not less.

If you are playing at the extreme high end where you are min-maxing absolutely everything, you cannot have freedom. You have zero room to complain and no game ever has allowed you to be a meta-slave AND have freedom of choice. This is not just exclusive to WoW, the scales are mutually exclusive.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Starym
      We have more hotfixes this Thursday, focusing on Shrouded affix tuning and some item fixes.
      August 18 (Source)
      Dungeons and Raids Mythic+ Affixes Shrouded Adjusted the health, melee damage, and ability damage of Nathrezim Infiltrators. Vampiric Claws cooldown increased to 12 seconds (was 8 seconds). Developers’ note: We discovered an issue that caused Nathrezim Infiltrators to have inconsistent health and damage, and as part of resolving the issue we had to adjust their health and damage values. The net result is that Nathrezim Infiltrators should feel slightly less powerful than they did previously. Items and Rewards
      Fixed an issue where items purchased with Puzzling Cartel Dinar could not be refunded. Fixed an issue where Enforcer's Stun Grenade, Kihra's Adrenaline Injector, and Fleshrender's Meathook did not reset their cooldowns upon ending an encounter.  
    • By Stan
      Here are the Dracthyr Evoker changes that went live in the latest Dragonflight Alpha build.
      Cycle of Life - Every 3 Emerald Blossoms leaves behind a tiny sprout which gathers 5% 10% of your healing over 10 sec. The sprout then heals allies within 25 yards, divided evenly among targets. Temporal Anomaly - Send forward a vortex of temporal energy, healing 3 injured allies within 10 yards every 2 sec for [ 130% 173% of Spell Power ]. Lasts 8 6 sec. Dream Flight cooldown increased to 2 mins (was 1 min). New Talents
      Divide and Conquer (PvP Talent) - Deep Breath sunders the ground, causing molten barriers to form on either side of you, preventing line of sight for 8 sec.
    • By Stan
      The latest Dragonflight Alpha Build 45141 adds two new Demon Hunter talents and other changes ahead of next week's talent revamp!
      Demon Hunter
      Metamorphosis - Upon landing, you are transformed into a hellish demon for 30 sec, immediately resetting the cooldown of your Eye Beam and Blade Dance abilities, greatly empowering your Chaos Strike and Blade Dance abilities and gaining 25% 20% Haste. Havoc
      Eye Beam - Blasts all enemies in front of you, dealing guaranteed critical strikes for up to ${({?a320,415[{${( 12.38% of Attack Power )*10*2}}][{${( 12.38% of Attack Power )*10}}])} Chaos damage over 2 sec. Deals reduced damage to secondary beyond 5 targets. When Eye Beam finishes fully channeling, your Haste is increased by an additional 15% 10% for 12 9 sec. Eye Beam (Rank 2) renamed to Furious Gaze and changed.  When Eye Beam finishes fully channeling, your Haste is increased by an additional 15% 10% for 12 9 sec. Demon Blades - Your auto attacks have a 60% chance to deal additional Shadow damage and generate 7-12 Fury. Cycle of Hatred - When Chaos Strike refunds Fury, it also reduces the cooldown of Eye Beam by 3 sec. Chaos Strike also reduces the cooldown of Eye Beam by 1 sec, and an additional 1 sec when it critically strikes. Momentum - Fel Rush increases your damage done by 15% for 6 sec. Vengeful Retreat's cooldown is reduced by 5 sec, and it generates 80 Fury over 10 sec if it damages at least one enemy. Fel Rush, Felblade, The Hunt, and Vengeful Retreat increase your damage done by 15% for 6 sec. PvP Talents
      Mortal Dance - Blade Dance now reduces targets' healing received by 25% 50% for 5 sec. Demonic Origins - The cooldown of Metamorphosis is reduced by 2 min, but its duration is reduced by 10 12 sec. New Talents
      Demon Hunter's received 2 new talents ahead of their next week's rework.
      Isolated Prey - Chaos Nova, Eye Beam, and Fel Rush gain bonuses when striking 1 target. Chaos Nova: Stun duration increased by 1 sec. Eye Beam: Deals 30% increased damage. Fel Rush: Generates 40-40 Fury. Chaotic Transformation - When you activate Metamorphosis, the cooldowns of Blade Dance and Eye Beam are immediately reset.
    • By Staff
      Blizzard posted details on the Wrath Classic-pre expansion event that will begin on live servers on September 5.
      On September 5, shipments of Conspicuous Crates will start arriving in Booty Bay and other ports. During the week of September 13, the Scourge Invasion will begin in major cities. At this point, invasion points will start spawning. There, you'll defeat rare undead lieutenants for items that you can exchange outside of Light's Hope Chapel in Eastern Plaguelands for various goods. You'll be able to defeat additional enemies in Dire Maul, Razorfen Downs, Scarlet Monastery, Scholomance, Shadowfang Keep, and Stratholme. Level 70 players can obtain a new raid quest in any capital city called Chamber of Secrets to kill Level 70 players can obtain a raid quest in any capital city in Azeroth (Chamber of Secrets) to kill Prince Tenris Murkblood in Karazhan. The prince can drop the Vampiric Batling pet and the coveted Arcanite Ripper. (Source)
      You know the score. The Lich King, perhaps Azeroth’s most infamous villain, is returning. The last time he set his eyes on a goal, it didn’t end well for anyone involved—just ask Illidan Stormrage. But before you can take the fight to Northrend, first you must deal with more pressing matters. The Lich King is already making his first move, eager to stop Azeroth’s greatest heroes dead in their tracks—quite literally—with a fresh variant of the Scourge plague. It is up to you to survive it if you hope to journey to the frozen wastes of Northrend to stop him.
      The Zombie Infestation
      Starting the week of September 6, astute observers will notice shipments of Conspicuous Crates arriving at less than reputable ports like Booty Bay. These highly contagious containers will infect anyone who touches them with a deadly variant of the Scourge plague. If you need assistance to avoid a grisly death, look for a nearby Argent Healer to cleanse yourself. Player characters capable of dispelling diseases can also help you recover… for now.
      If you’re unable to get rid of the disease, you’ll become a Plague Zombie. While you’ll still have control of your character, you will no longer have access to any abilities you had while living (or unliving, if you were Forsaken). Instead, you’ll gain new abilities that will help you accomplish your new goal as a servant of the Lich King: to infect as many people as possible! As a zombie, you can use the following skills against players and NPCs alike:
      Melee: Infects the target with the plague and heals you. Mangle!: An instant attack that shortens the time the infection takes to zombify the victim. Retch!: Retches on the ground, creating a gas cloud that heals zombies and slows living targets, infecting them after a certain period. Beckoning Groan: Calls up to 4 non-player zombies to aid you. Lurch!: Increases the speed of nearby zombies (including yourself). Zombie Explosion!: Burst into pieces, destroying yourself but infecting those around you. Any targets you infect will eventually become Plague Zombies if not treated. In time large populated areas will become too dangerous to dwell in. If you’re looking to avoid infection, it is best to avoid these places *ahem* like the plague.
      If you get killed as a zombie, you can be resurrected by another player, by the spirit healer, or by running back to your corpse. Once you return to life, you’ll be back to normal, but you can still be re-infected, so be on your toes!

      It gets worse…
      As the week progresses, more Conspicuous Crates will be delivered to every capital city in the Eastern Kingdoms and Kalimdor. Beware of vermin like Plagued Roaches as they can spread the plague, even when dealt with from a safe distance. The infection’s incubation time will become shorter and shorter, and harder to overcome. Plagued Residents, former common citizens unable to fight off the plague, will also terrorize starting areas, bringing additional challenges for fledgling heroes to overcome.
      Over time, the once plentiful Argent Healers will see their forces spread too thin to contain the infestation, and the plague will become more and more resistant to magic. And this seemingly unstoppable disease is just the beginning….
      The Scourge Invasion
      Starting the week of September 13, the Scourge Invasion will begin. Having survived the assault on Naxxramas (you wouldn’t know anything about that, would you?) Kel’Thuzad is ready to once more advance the Lich King’s efforts by striking at strategic locations all over Azeroth. The dread citadel Naxxramas has left the Eastern Plaguelands for good, absconding to the icy continent of Northrend.
      In addition to dealing with the ever-growing Zombie Infestation, you’ll be tasked with investigating the Scourge activity within the major cities and thwarting invasions throughout Azeroth. Keep your eye on your map (M) to locate activity hotspots and put a stop to them.
      In each invasion point, you’ll engage with rare undead who each have a chance to drop various helpful items. Find the Argent Quartermaster, located outside of Light's Hope Chapel in Eastern Plaguelands to exchange items obtained from invasion points for various goods, including parts of the epic Undead Slaying and Undead Cleansing sets.
      Additional foes can be found in the Dire Maul, Razorfen Downs, Scarlet Monastery, Scholomance, Shadowfang Keep, and Stratholme dungeons:
      Revanchion inside Dire Maul Lady Falther'ess inside Razorfen Downs Scorn in Scarlet Monastery Lord Blackwood in Scholomance Sever in Shadowfang Keep Balzaphon in Stratholme
      Level 70 players can obtain a raid quest in any capital city in Azeroth (Chamber of Secrets) to hunt down and destroy Prince Tenris Murkblood in Karazhan. The prince can drop the Vampiric Batling pet and the coveted Arcanite Ripper. This two-handed axe is guaranteed to rock the casbah.

      The Aftermath
      All good(?) things must come to an end. Eventually, the Alliance and the Horde will work together to find a cure for the Zombie Infestation and push the Scourge back to where they came from. The Lich King’s plans will be temporarily halted as the pre-expansion events end and Wrath of the Lich King Classic launches—just in time for you to hop on the nearest long skip to Northrend. Savor your victory, hero… while you still can.
    • By Stan
      Orc Shoulders appear to have been fixed in Dragonflight Alpha. On retail, there's a visible gap between shoulders and arms which has been removed on the Alpha.
      Reddit user TehWurrior posted a side-by-side comparison of the fix. Notice the removed gap between the fur and shoulders in the second to last image.

      Source: Reddit
  • Create New...