Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  

The State of Burning Crusade Classic Server Populations

Recommended Posts



The Burning Crusade Classic side of the Community Council has received a lengthy response on the topic of server populations (relating to low pop and faction balance issues), where Blizzard discuss some potential solutions, why they should and shouldn't be implemented, talk about the topic in general, and ask for player ideas for potential solutions.

Blizzard LogoServer Balance (Source)


First off, big thanks to Sixxfury and Basîl for taking the time to write up your thoughts on this. Second, apologies for taking so long to reply. No great reason or excuse other than “I had to think about this post a lot before making it” :stuck_out_tongue:

In any case, this is definitely a top issue for both us and for players, and it’s a topic we are basically always talking about as a team internally. I’d like to preface what I’m about to say with this: player distribution across realms is one of the most complex, if not the most complex issue that WoW Classic faces, and I’m not going to provide a silver bullet answer today. There’s no single-right answer for this issue, because different people want different things, and lots of apparently obvious solutions have non-obvious consequences.

I think to start, it might be appropriate for us to touch on what we’ve done so far and what the actual intent of that is.

In November, we opened a multitude of Free Character Moves (FCMs) between many realms.
The intent of this was to respond to the feedback that some players wanted to play on realms with a higher population. We aren’t trying to stop smaller servers from becoming even smaller, and we aren’t trying to prevent so-called “megaservers” from forming. We are simply trying to give players who want to move an easy option to do so. It’s not perfect or complete, but it’s a relief valve.

I’ll also be the first to acknowledge that we probably should have done this sooner. This isn’t meant to be an excuse, but the main reason we waited as long as we did (and a big driver to being very slow and methodical when making changes that affect server populations in general) is because in our attempts to “fix” things for specific groups, we could unintentionally damage the experience of other groups, and this is something that always gives us pause. Here’s an example:

Imagine a medium-population PvP realm that is 60% Horde and 40% Alliance, and a majority of people on this realm are happy with the state of the realm. However, half of the current Alliance population (20% of the total server population) is unhappy at the feeling of being disadvantaged in world PvP, having a harder time leveling without getting ganked, and having a perceived weaker factional economy. If we open FCMs off this realm, this unhappy 20% of players might be delighted to be able to easily leave for greener pastures. Let’s assume that they all go from unhappy to happy. But now what’s left is a smaller realm that is 75% Horde and 25% Alliance. It’s not hard to imagine that now Alliance players who were previously content with a 60/40 split now become unhappy at being 3:1 underdogs and at having their own economy and community shrink by 50%, and now they’re unhappy. And on the other hand, some % of Horde players who value world PvP and were happy being on a 60/40 PvP realm are now also unhappy because their faction is now so dominant that the only world PvP available feels lopsided and unsporting.

In the above example, doing something well-intentioned to benefit the unhappy 20% would have actually hurt more people than it helped. This is part of the dilemma and what causes us to take a lot of time to analyze things before taking actions that affects realm populations and faction balance. Ultimately, we did end up opening FCMs to and from a variety of destinations, and we will continue to monitor and modify the source and destination realms as time passes. We could have done a lot better here however, or at least been more communicative and I do sincerely apologize for that.

Next I want to drill into a common suggestion we’ve seen that was alluded to in both posts above, as well as talk about how we’ve approached this issue as we’ve debated it internally.

My server is 90% horde, and this other server is 90% alliance. Merge them and make a perfectly balanced server.
This idea is, on its face, a great one, and we can see why such a suggestion could be a quick one to make. There are a few things that have given us pause about this in the past, however.

  • “Merging” servers is actually something that WoW has almost never done, and the reason for this is simple; we don’t like the idea of someone losing their unique name on a realm, and this is doubly true for classic where your identity in the community is a major aspect of the game.

  • We’ve somewhat worked around this in modern versions of World of Warcraft with the concept of “connecting” realms. With this process, we do allow you to keep your name (and guild affiliations), it’s not seamless and is an intrusive change to the players’ chosen gameplay environment. When the connection is completed, players on the new connected realms will then have a realm name appended to the end of their nameplate such as “Aggrend-Grobbulus” or “Kaivax-Pagle”.

  • As a result of this being entirely new territory to WoW Classic, this also leads to more Classic-specific questions and conundrums such as:

    • Is this appropriate for WoW Classic? In doing this, we are essentially overriding your realm identity and forcibly causing you to merge with another, wholly unknown (to you) realm and community.
    • What if you don’t want to be on a balanced realm and at some point, specifically elected to move to a realm where your faction is in the majority? We have years of data that suggests that, on a long enough timeline, the population for most PvP realms will tend to skew towards one faction or the other and that this skew often starts as the result of more incoming players joining the majority faction, rather than players leaving the minority faction.
    • What if merging two realms like this forces layers to be enabled at all times, when they were not enabled previously? Layers are a useful tool and something that we feel most players understand they will have to deal with when choosing to move to a “High” or “Full” population realm, but if your realm has existed without layers for months or years and they are suddenly forced upon you, is that okay?
    • What happens in several months when the population of this new more-balanced realm starts to again (and likely inevitably) skew towards one faction or the other? Do we then connect the already connected realms to yet another realm with the inverse population skew? In such a scenario, you could easily see a never-ending cycle of continuously connecting realms to “chase” that balance, and of course, each time we connect a set of realms, it further dilutes the original realms’ ecosystem and communities.
  • Overall, the data we have suggests that, broadly, players don’t seem to want an even playing field and/or they care more about having their faction be heavily populated and lively than they care about their realm being balanced. Our concern is that the more we try to directly intervene, the more likely we may be to destroy the communities or individual play experiences that players have created organically. Does this mean we won’t ever connect realms in WoW Classic? No, and that is an active discussion we’ve been having for quite some time.

Obviously, there are many, many other proposed solutions that we’ve seen from players as well as from our colleagues, but using just this one example you can likely see how difficult this is to work through, and how even a seemingly simple solution can be fraught with peril if not carefully considered. I mostly provide this to give insight into the types of discussions we have internally and how we arrive at the actions (or inactions) we take.

So, where do we go from here? Well, I think that’s where you come in. What we’d like to see now is some more suggestions from you with your ideas of how we could improve this situation and ideally, we can have some back and forth here to discuss them. One thing I will ask you to keep in mind however is that we generally prefer to avoid any solution that would force players to do anything they don’t want to do, or directly damages or diminishes their ability to log in and play the game, so please try and keep that in mind when suggesting things in this discussion. Obviously, that places a lot of restrictions on the scope of ideas, but that’s kind of the point, and part of the reason for the dilemma we face right now when thinking of ways to address this issue in a way that fits within the WoW Classic design space.

Lastly, we also wanted to float the idea and acknowledge that this issue might just be too big for forum discussion. To that end, we are working on plans to host some form of live chat with you soon, to discuss this and other aspects of WoW Classic. This is still in the planning phase and we hope to have more details about this in the coming weeks, but needless to say, I think we all want to get to the point where we have multiple avenues to have meaningful, conversational discussions about this and other topics affecting our community.

Please stay tuned for details on that. Thank you again for your time, and we hope that you will have a most excellent new year! Thank you!

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Kinda weird seeing them accept the non-aggression principle in this matter when what they did the last few expansions was stuff garbage down the throat of their playerbase and act the exact opposite.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, Andser said:

Kinda weird seeing them accept the non-aggression principle in this matter when what they did the last few expansions was stuff garbage down the throat of their playerbase and act the exact opposite.

On this subject, they're aware that forcing something on us is garbage, and consider all the options. In your aggressive scenario, they believe their garbage is amazing and should be tasted by all, and that it is in fact, not garbage at all. 

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
Uncommon Patron

I wonder if they'd consider the option to clone one of your characters to any realm you please? It's not much different than a transfer, except if it doesn't work out on the new server you can just go back to the one you cloned from.

Edited by Migeru71

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Opening server moves doesn't really change anything, no one wants to remain on a dead server, so very few are willing to risk moving to less populated one.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Allow same name on horde and alliance on same server.

2. Transfer the horde population of a horde dominated realm to a new server.

3. Transfer the alliance population of an alliance dominated realm to that same server.

4. merge the low factions on one server and give them free transfers wherever they please.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Starym
      We have a new hotfix for BCC, as a bug with certain mobs in Serpentshrine Cavern has been fixed.
      January 26 (Source)
      Serpentshrine Cavern Enemies during the Hydross the Unstable and Leotheras the Blind encounters should no longer occasionally become stuck in the environment.
    • By Starym
      A small batch of BCC hotfixes has arrived, fixing tier sets in relation to Incubi.
      January 21 (Source)
      Warlock The Black Book and Felheart tier set now empowers the Incubus.
    • By Staff
      Here come the official patch notes for the phase 3 release! We still have to wait 10 days for the raids, but a lot of the new features are here. You can also check out our Phase 3 guides here.
      2.5.3 Patch Notes (Source)
      Content The Black Temple
      Defeat the Betrayer himself—Illidan Stormrage—atop the Black Temple.
      Raid bosses: 9 (High Warlord Naj’entus, Supremus, Shade of Akama, Teron Gorefiend, Gurtogg Bloodboil, Reliquary of Souls, Mother Shahraz, The Illidari Council, Illidan Stormrage) Level: 70 Location: The Black Temple, Shadowmoon Valley Improve your standing with the Ashtongue Deathsworn to earn rewards from Okuno inside the Black Temple.
      The Battle for Mount Hyjal
      Preserve the outcome of the pivotal Battle for Mount Hyjal and ensure the demon Archimonde meets his fate.
      Raid bosses: 5 (Rage Winterchill, Anetheron, Kaz’rogal, Azgalor, Archimonde) Level: 70 Location: Caverns of Time, Tanaris Improve your standing with the Scale of the Sands to earn rewards from Indormi in the Caverns of time.
      Raid Attunements
      Those who wish to brave the two new raid instances must complete the required attunement quests first. The required quests must be completed once per character. All new raid content will unlock at 3:00 p.m. PST on Thursday, January 27.
      Epic Gems
      Epic gem Jewelcrating Designs will be available from Indormi in the Caverns of Time. Epic gems can be obtained from Battle for Mount Hyjal through mining (requires 375 mining skill), and as rare drops from Black Temple.
      Netherwing Daily Quests
      Earn Netherwing reputation through daily quests in Shadowmoon Valley. Collect Netherwing eggs to speed up reputation gains. Epic Netherdrake mounts will be available to players that reach Exalted reputation (requires Artisan Riding skill).
      Burning Crusade Arena Season 3
      The week of January 18, with the weekly reset in each region, Arena Season 3 has begun. The matchmaker has been adjusted to increase the range of possible opponents. This will help match players of different matchmaking levels more quickly. As before, teams with similar ratings who queue at the same will be prioritized to match against each other.
      Bosses in Serpentshrine Cavern and Tempest Keep now drop one additional class set token for a total of 3. Bosses in Magtheridon’s Lair and Gruul’s Lair now drop an additional loot token for a total of 3. The Lurker Below, Morogrim Tidewalker, A’lar, and High Astromancer Solarian have had their loot tables updated to their final state, which includes additional drops for each boss, and in some cases, new items. All dungeon bosses now have a chance to drop epic gems in Heroic difficulty. New Darkmoon cards now have a chance to drop. Warlocks can now learn to summon an Incubus by completing a new questline: In Undercity, speak to Carendin Halgar. In Orgrimmar, speak to Gan’rul Bloodeye. In Stormwind, speak to Gakin the Darkbinder. The Consortium vendor now sells: Formula: Enchant Weapon - Major Striking. The Honor Hold and Thrallmar vendor now sells: Pattern: Netherscale Ammo Pouch. The Lower City vendor now sells: Enchant Ring - Stats and Pattern: Quiver of a Thousand Feathers. Mind Quickening Gem is no longer usable in Arenas. The trinket is unchanged in all other areas of play. The following items are no longer usable inside Arenas: Nigh-Invulnerability Belt Net-o-Matic Projector Dazzling Longsword Silent Fang Skull of Impending Doom User Interface
      You can now select multiple activities when searching for groups in the Looking for More UI. After listing your group in the Looking for Group UI, the UI will now automatically search for other groups interested in the same activities. In the Looking for Group UI, the entire dropdown body can now be clicked to open the dropdown. You may now report players searched via /who using the right-click menu. Added a more descriptive error message when attempting to transfer a character who is an Arena team captain from one realm to another. Fixed an issue that caused Duels to end after 15 minutes. Added a “have materials” filter in the Profession UI. Fixed an issue that caused interface errors to appear when using the character Unstuck service. Fixed a bug where the player model in the character sheet could get stuck rotating when the player moves the mouse. Bug Fixes
      Made some improvements to player pathing during fear to reduce situations where players end up outside or under terrain. Fixed a bug that caused certain flight paths to incorrectly take players through mountains and other terrain. Fixed an issue where Alliance players who died in Ogri’la were teleported to the incorrect graveyard after releasing. Fixed a bug preventing dialogue options from working correctly in several quests that offer replacement quest items from the quest giver, such as “The Hawk’s Essence”. Fixed an issue that caused mounted footstep/hoof sounds to play at incorrect speeds for certain mounts. Fixed an incorrect tooltip for the Spell Reflection ability that the Coilfang Serpentguard in Serpentshrine Cavern cast on themselves that indicates that it reflects 4 spells when it actually reflects all spells for its duration. Resolved an issue where Renataki of the Thousand Blades’ Thousand Blades ability could register an unintentionally huge number of hits and cause performance issues. It’s meant to be a figurative Thousand Blades, not a literal thousand. Relax, Renataki. Fixed multiple issues with Succubus creature animations. Fixed multiple issues with Worgen creature animations. Fixed an issue that caused belts to sometimes vanish when equipping an unequipping items. Resolved an issue that caused human models to use the incorrect animations when slowed. Some tamable pets, such as Rip-Blade Ravager, will now correctly change colors randomly when they are resummoned by the Hunter. Developers’ note: This will only affect pets tamed after the launch of this patch. Fixed an issue where the Paladin Trainer Noellene in Eversong Woods doesn’t show up when tracking Class Trainers. The Gladiator’s Spellblade now displays the appropriate textures. Fixed an issue that caused Shaman weapon enhancements displayed their visual effects twice on player weapons. The Aurora Cowl item is no longer missing its model. Fixed an issue where Shadow Word: Death could damage the caster when a low-level target is killed by the spell. Fixed an issue where certain channeled auras, such as Mind Flay from Fel Eye Stalks, were not stacking correctly. Effects that increase damage taken from spells by a flat amount, such as Shadow Resonance, will now work correctly with stacking damage-over-time auras. Snakes created by Snake Trap will now correctly not trigger most “On Kill” procs. Developers’ note: Some “On Kill” effects, such as Spirit Tap, will still correctly be triggered by slaying the snakes. Fixed an issue that caused loot sparkles to not properly scale up in size for larger creatures. Now please – loot the hounds.  
    • By Staff
      We're pleased to announce that we've updated our Burning Crusade Classic section with new content for Phase 3 that begins soon.
      Phase 3 begins during the week of January 17 on Burning Crusade Classic servers with raids opening on January 27.
      Updated Class Guides
      Below you will find links to all class guides that have been updated for Phase 3.
      Balance Druid Guide Feral DPS Druid Guide Feral Tank Druid Guide Restoration Druid Guide Hunter
      Beast Mastery Hunter Guide Marksmanship Hunter Guide Survival Hunter Guide Mage
      Arcane Mage Guide Fire Mage Guide Frost Mage Guide Paladin
      Holy Paladin Guide Protection Paladin Guide Retribution Paladin Guide Priest
      Holy Priest Guide Shadow Priest Guide Rogue
       Rogue Guide Shaman
      Elemental Shaman Guide Enhancement Shaman Guide Restoration Shaman Guide Warlock
      Affliction Warlock Guide Demonology Warlock Guide Destruction Warlock Guide Warrior
      Arms Warrior Guide Fury Warrior Guide Protection Warrior Guide Gearing Guides
      With new gear being available in Phase 3, our writers have updated gearing pages with new recommendations.
      Phase 3 Balance Gear Phase 3 Feral DPS Gear Phase 3 Feral Tank Gear Phase 3 Restoration Gear Hunter
      Phase 3 Beast Mastery Gear Phase 3 Marksmanship Gear Phase 3 Survival Gear Mage
      Phase 3 Arcane Gear Phase 3 Fire Gear Phase 3 Frost Gear Paladin
      Phase 3 Holy Gear Phase 3 Protection Gear Phase 3 Retribution Gear Priest
      Phase 3 Holy Gear Phase 3 Shadow Gear Rogue
      Phase 3 Rogue Gear Shaman
      Phase 3 Elemental Gear Phase 3 Enhancement Gear Phase 3 Restoration Gear Warlock
      Phase 3 Affliction Gear Phase 3 Demonology Gear Phase 3 Destruction Gear Warrior
      Phase 3 Arms Gear Phase 3 Fury Gear Phase 3 Protection Gear New Raids
      In Phase 3, we'll see two raids open. The Black Temple is located in Shadowmoon Valley and Mount Hyjal is found in Caverns of Time (Tanaris).
      Black Temple has a long attunement questline that you will find in our guide. Mount Hyjal has a shorter, but more challenging attunement quest chain that we highlight in the Mount Hyjal attunement guide.
    • By Staff
      Blizzard has posted updated development notes for Patch 2.5.3 with new changes coming in the upcoming patch, including additional tier tokens from Darkmoon cards having a chance to drop, and new profession recipes.
      Serpentshrine Caverns and Tempest Keep bosses now drop new and additional items, such as an additional tier token. Magtheridon and Gruul’s Lair now drop an additional tier token. All dungeon bosses now have a chance to drop epic gems in Heroic difficulty. New Darkmoon cards now have a chance to drop. The Consortium vendor now sells: Formula: Enchant Weapon - Major Striking The Honor Hold and Thrallmar vendor now sells: Pattern: Netherscale Ammo Pouch The Lower City vendor now sells: Enchant Ring - Stats and Pattern: Quiver of a Thousand Feathers
  • Create New...