Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  

Warlords of Draenor Interview with Tom Chilton

Recommended Posts


Our World of Warcraft / Warlords of Draenor interview with Tom Chilton, Game Director

Finding good questions for a WoW interview is always tricky, because Blizzard communicates just so much about this game. Also, with so many other media having interviews with Tom Chilton at GamesCom, we had to find these few questions that we would be the only ones to ask. Here are the results of our brainstorming. We hope that you enjoy the answers we received.

Below, you will find the whole transcript of the interview, but first we would like to present you with the main things that we have learnt. Note that we only had 20 minutes of interview, to share with other fansites, so we did not get to ask a lot of questions.
  • The delay in the release of Warlords of Draenor caused by massive recruitment on Blizzard side to increase the size of the WoW development team. New employees had to get up to speed first, which slowed things down. Also, Garrisons ended up being much more involved than originally planned.
  • Zones for the next expansion already in production.
  • No plans for new subscription methods, like free-to-play or partial content.
  • The annual pass for Mists of Pandaria was questionable and it is not likely that we will see another promotional offer like that again.
  • Challenge modes for raids would only be considered if more people engaged in dungeon challenge modes.
  • Northrend and Outland could one day be made into level 60 to 80 zones, offering a choice to leveling players.
  • It is unclear what is going to be improved next, after the character models. Physics could be introduced in the game or combat could be made to look better.
  • The progress race is balanced enough, no need to tweak anything.

Blizzard Icon Transcript from Interview with Tom Chilton

Q. You announced repeatedly that you would release content faster: "every 6 months", "no more ICC". Obviously, that did not really work out, so we were just wondering what caused it.

A. That is definitely fair criticism. We did a good job earlier in Mists of Pandaria, having the content come at a more frequent intervals, and certainly we had hoped to have Warlords of Draenor out a couple of months ago. The reality is that scaling up the number of people that we have, to work on multiple projects at once has slowed us down. Honestly, it should have not come as a surprise to us. We increased the size of the team by 50% and the majority of those people had never worked on World of Warcraft before or any other MMO, so it is really difficult for them to create content right away, without getting up to speed. So we ended up redoing a lot of the content that we were doing for Warlords to make sure that we would get it at the quality level that we would expect. Also, the garrison feature turned into a bigger thing than we expected it to be. Quality is the most important thing, so if we have to make a choice between getting you something two months ago or getting you a great expansion in November, the choice is obvious. I think we are in a better position now for the future, we already have zones in production for our next expansion. So, if things go well, there will be less of a gap.

Q. Right now, there are a lot of things you can do in the game: pet battles, raids, dungeons, garrisons soon, etc. Do you have any kind of plans whatsoever to have different subscription plans? Maybe for people who do not want to raid or who only want to do dungeons.

A. We do not have any plans for that. It is something that has been talked about along with free to play and things like that. I do not know if this is really the right thing for World of Warcraft. You can never say never. If our players really want something like that, we would consider it more, but this is not something that we hear a lot about. Usually, when people play, they want to experience, or at least the option to experience, pretty much everything or a lot of it.

Q. Another kind-of-businessy question. Any plans to have another annual kind of thing, like you did for Mists of Pandaria and Diablo III?

A. It really depends on whether there is a good opportunity. With the annual pass, at the time, we felt like we had this awesome game coming out and we wanted World of Warcraft players to feel that they got some kind of benefit for a continued subscription, like they would get a really good value and feel like they saved money. We had kind of a mixed reaction to the annual pass. People were very enthusiastic when we first launched it, but after it was all set and done, we looked back on it and asked ourselves "are our players clearly happier about Blizzard, because the annual pass exists". It felt like it was questionable, so if that is questionable, it does not seem like something that our players want to see us do lot more often.

Q. Do you think we could have challenge modes for raids?

A. We will see. We feel kind of like our Mythic difficulty raid are already kind of challenge modes for raids, although it is a bit different for challenge modes, because of the leaderboard, which is pretty cool. It is something that we talked about. I think that if we get to the point where more people are using the challenge modes and want to see more of it, then we are more likely to do it. Challenge modes are definitely a very hardcore activity, and so are our Mythic raids. We have to be careful on how much time we spend on just that kind of content.

Q. The leveling experience is a little bit strange. It is definitely good, but the experience requirements for Burning Crusade or Wrath of the Lich King are such that you just fly through the zones, without even finishing the quest lines, and you jump to the next zone. Are there any plans to homogenize that?

A. We have ideas for how we would like to address it, but it would take us a significant amount of time to fix, though. So, it is the kind of things where it is like "We could have the expansion take longer to come out, but we could fix that!". For example, we talked about having both Outland and Northrend go from level 60 to level 80. So, you pick if you want to do Outland or Northrend, and each of them would go at half the speed they do now. That way, you would not run into that kind of problems and it would feel that you have more different content options for what to do. It would probably make leveling different characters a little bit more interesting. So, we like that, but it takes so much of our designers' time to go through and fix it and our system designers' time to go through and make that actually work, because it is really very non trivial, changing the rewards and all that kind of stuff. So, it is one of those cool ideas, but when do we spend the time to do that versus trying to finish the expansion faster.

Q. Now that the new character models are finished (or almost finished), do you have idea what is going to be next, in this direction?

A. There are a lot of different things that could be next. Certainly, I do imagine that we are going to continue improving the look of the game, one element or piece at a time. Our environment looks much better now, our character models are about to look much better. I think that other things we could tackle next would be integrating physics in some way, it is also possible that we could take a crack at making combat look better, just like the way we synchronize animations, spell effects, sounds, and stuff like that. We could make things feel cooler without actually changing things mechanically. So, there are a lot of different ways that we could explore that and we just have to see what works within the resources that we have and the features that we are trying to do in the future.

Q. Are you happy with the way the progress race is happening right now? Like, for example the drops that the top guilds get in the first lockout really influences the rest of the race. Any thoughts about balancing the loot drops, at least in the very beginning?

A. To be honest, I am pretty happy with the way it is. You can always identify things that would theoretically make things a little bit more fair. The reality is that in general, the best guilds always find a way to win. Granted, that is not always the case for every single boss or every single raid, but I think the level of competition and how closely the guilds are matched is actually pretty impressive, for something as large and complex as raid balance. I think that this is dangerous to go too far in terms of spending a lot of time to make that race just this much more balanced, when literally nobody else in the world is affected by that. You know what I mean!
  • Like 1

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Starym
      World of Warcraft Design Manager Craig Morrison has left Blizzard today, and his departure has been planned since before the recent lawsuit was filed. Morrison has been with Blizzard since Warlords of Draenor in the Design Manager role, coming in from Anarchy Online, Age of Conan and Secret World MMOs, and also acted as Principal Designer for both Shadowlands and Burning Crusade Classic.
    • By Starym
      While this one can't really be considered a blast from the past, as the style actually goes even further back than its source material, it can definitely be considered a truly awesome piece of fan art! It's time to go back to where all this Jailer trouble really started (well, for Azeroth anyway), as we take a look at that fateful moment when Arthas takes up Frostmourne, damns his soul, and consequently also damns us to 2 expansions of Sylvanas' Shenanigans much later on.
      Agi Hammerthief has created a new video rendition of the Warcraft 3 cutscene in which Arthas acquires Frostmourne in Northrend, in their own pixel art style and really nailed it. While this was never how the game or cutscene looked, it just feels right somehow:
      And here's the original (non-reforged) version with a bit of an intro as well:
    • By Staff
      Blizzard is buffing two Shard of Domination set bonuses with the weekly maintenance in each region.
      Shards of Domination [With weekly maintenance in each region] Blood Link – The damage and healing amount has been increased at all ranks by 20%. [With weekly maintenance in each region] Winds of Winter – The amount of damage and healing stored by the Winds has been increased at all ranks by ~45%. Developers’ note: The difference between the three Rune Words for the Shards of Domination system is bigger than we want it to be. We have identified and fixed a bug in Winds of Winter which was preventing some damaging and healing abilities from counting towards its total, and we have retuned Winds of Winter and Blood Link so that the relative power between Rune Word bonuses is more balanced.
    • By Starym
      Here come the week's first hotfixes, with a fix for the unintended and trapped locations teleport power in Torghast and more.
      August 2 (Source)
      Priest Fixed an issue that caused the Courageous Ascension conduit to grant a low amount of damage while it was at 252 item level. Dungeons and Raids
      Sanctum of Domination Fixed an issue that caused Hollowsoul's Gaoler's Chains to hit targets not inside the area-of-effect. Items and Rewards
      Shards of Domination [With weekly maintenance in each region] Shard of Rev now also has a chance to drop from Sylvanas Windrunner. Torghast, Tower of the Damned
      Anima Powers Sweet Dreams should no longer teleport players to unintended locations.
    • By Starym
      This week we're changing things up a little, and we'll be taking a look at a few specific bosses on Mythic, as the overall Sanctum Mythic numbers still aren't quite there for a really solid look at the real situation. We'll still check out both the Mythic and Heroic overall rankings as well though.
      Heroic Rankings
      Starting with the stable ones, where many, many guilds have actually cleared the Sanctum all the way through, we see the top 5 keep the same specs, with Subtlety jumping into 2nd and Arcane falling to 4th. The biggest mover here is Shadow, rising 6 spots to just outside the top 5, as Havoc and Assassination drop a couple of places.

      95th percentile Heroic data by Warcraft Logs.
      In the all percentiles bracket we see Balance rising up as well, pushing its fellow Feral down a few spots. Unholy and Destruction are actually doing a lot better here compared to the past few weeks as well.

      All percentiles Heroic data by Warcraft Logs.
      Mythic Rankings
      We'll only be taking a look at the all percentiles bracket here, since the numbers aren't quite there yet and to make some room for the bosses. While Affliction may still be at the top, it's a VERY deceiving stat, as only 235 logs were recorded, so only a handful of very good players would (and did) affect it. Windwalkers have some better numbers here, however, with over 2800 logs, but Survival is even worse than Affliction in this case, with its 79 players bringing the spec up into 3rd place. Arms is VERY well represented, second only to Balance with its 10,000+ logs, followed by Destruction, Frost and Marksmanship.

      All percentiles Mythic data by Warcraft Logs.
      Mythic Bosses
      And now we're on to the fun part, as we take a look at a few specific bosses. Do note that since these are individual bosses, there will be MUCH fewer logs present, especially as we climb towards the end of the Sanctum. We'll start with the Eye of the Jailer and The Nine, as they actually have a pretty solid amount of logs, with over 1000 guilds having downed them.

      Eye of the Jailer All percentiles Mythic data by Warcraft Logs.

      The Nine All percentiles Mythic data by Warcraft Logs.
      The we're on to the more difficult bosses, where the log numbers drop off a cliff right after the first three bosses. Comparatively, for The Nine we had a peak of 2250 logs for once spec, while for the Remnant of Ner'zhul, the peak is at 1150 and the overall numbers are incredibly smaller as well.

      Remnant of Ner'zhul All percentiles Mythic data by Warcraft Logs.
      And now it's time for some real pain, as Painsmith Raznal caps out at 217 logs, with a couple of specs having around 1-2 entries to represent them! This boss is going to be a pretty huge wall for most Mythic guilds for a long time still it seems.

      Painsmith Raznal All percentiles Mythic data by Warcraft Logs.
      As always, if you want even more info on a spec, you can check out our class guides here, or for even more data, head on over to Warcraft Logs.
  • Create New...