Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  

On the Adjustments to Pandaemonium: Abyssos (Savage)

Recommended Posts


Square Enix has released a statement regarding one of the adjustments they made in Patch 6.21 — the reduction of the boss' health values in Abyssos: The Eighth Turn. 

They go on to explain why they made that change, and it appears to be more than just a balance issue on their part. It goes to show significant awareness of the player community, as well as the state of the game in general. With this change, they hope that certain jobs will no longer be excluded from party finder and lessen player frustration.

Lastly, they explain their process for balancing raids and the source of their miscalculation, which may prove to be an enlightening read. While some players may think the corrections are essentially a "nerf" (the P8S clear memes on social media are aplenty), it's understandable why they made the choices they did. Read on more below!

Square Enix LogoAdjustments to Abyssos: The Eighth Circle (Savage) (Source)


Hello, this is Naoki Yoshida, Producer and Director of FINAL FANTASY XIV.

There has been a lot of discussion surrounding our explanation for adjusting the HP of the boss in Abyssos: The Eighth Circle (Savage) in Patch 6.21, as well as the necessity of the adjustment itself.

Firstly, please allow me to apologize for the disruption caused by this balancing issue, and for any offense resulting from the insufficient explanation we initially provided.

In this post, I hope to clear up any misunderstandings as to how and why this adjustment was made.

Reason for the HP Adjustment

As was explained in the Patch 6.21 notes, a miscalculation on our part resulted in the boss's HP being roughly 1% too high in comparison to the difficulty of previous fourth-stage Savage raids.

We do, of course, understand and appreciate that many players nevertheless honed their ability rotations, raised item levels, and repeated the fight over and over in order to claim victory.

Having the HP set to this higher value, however, had other undesirable consequences, including:

  • Certain jobs being excluded from party recruitment
  • A growing dissatisfaction with the overly punishing degree of difficulty

As our miscalculation was the root cause of these issues, we decided that the best course of action was to explain our mistake and correct the inflated HP to the value it should have been in the first place. This type of correction has little precedence in FFXIV's development, and although the decision was made after considerable debate, we once again apologize for the impact it had on player enjoyment.

Source of the Miscalculation

This issue was touched upon in the patch notes, but allow me to explain our balancing process in further detail.

Firstly, the development team bases adjustments on the following premise:

The top percentage of players are overwhelmingly better at the game than we are.

We regret not stating this more clearly in the previous explanation, but said premise is the reason why we do not release content tuned precisely as it was when the battle team’s balance testers cleared it.

We always add a little bit extra to the boss values before rechecking the fight and releasing it live.

The team responsible for balancing boss fights does so without debug commands and at the appropriate item level, employing available materia, foods, and medicines while experimenting with mitigating actions and various job compositions. Yet we recognize that player skill far exceeds our own. If we were to ship content with the same values which challenged our battle team, the top raiders would be deprived of that by-the-skin-of-your-teeth victory in the initial week of release.

Based on the team's skill and our experience, that "little bit extra" usually translates to:

Balance test clear values +1-2% HP

The final values account for other mathematical factors too, of course, such as the estimated damage the party could deal from the moment of victory to the end of the time limit, as well as total burst damage potential based on frequency and amount inflicted. The numbers these various calculations are based on are what we were referencing when we said that our team’s performance was higher than anticipated.

This latest installment features a boss closely tied to the dark past of a major character, and so we were focused on making this battle even more of a challenge than usual. As such, the battle team spent an inordinate amount of time together designing and testing the fight mechanics, which in turn led to them improving party coordination and communication beyond what they might usually achieve for a given boss fight. Final adjustments were, however, still based on the team's victory data, and so the "little bit extra" we added for the release proved to be that little bit too much.

Reasons aside, our adjustments were off by that crucial 1% and we again offer our apologies to those whose gaming experience was adversely affected by the correction and insufficient explanation.

A high-difficulty raid is a special kind of battle. We want players to enjoy a satisfying, hard-won victory, and we keep that ideal in mind when making tweaks and balance adjustments. Although we failed to walk that delicate line this time, the experience will help us to design a more perfectly thrilling battle in the future.

Why Adjust the Duty, Rather than Job Balance?

When balancing jobs, each job’s base damage numbers at the applicable item level are adjusted with respect to the difficulty of playing that particular job and its rotation, as well as its support actions and their effects.

the above factors are also affected by the mechanics and combination thereof at work in each battle─meaning that every job’s numbers will not necessarily be at ideal values during all available battles. In addition to this inherent variance, there are indeed times when our calculations or adjustments are incorrect, producing damage numbers lower than intended and requiring subsequent strengthening of a job.

In this case, when considering job balance more broadly, the jobs that needed emergency adjustment in this fashion were Paladin and Warrior. However, the aforementioned issue with Abyssos: The Eighth Circle (Savage) also caused certain jobs to be better suited to the raid than others, and made the damage check required to clear extremely strict,
 resulting in a situation where players felt obligated to choose jobs with higher damage output when attempting the raid.

Attempting to ameliorate this by buffing certain jobs without making changes to the raid itself would have negatively impacted overall balance within each role, and likely resulted in disappointment for those whose jobs were already dealing sufficient damage for the raid and therefore received no adjustments. Unfortunately, adjusting all jobs in such a short period is also not feasible.


  • The root cause of the issue was a mistake in balancing the duty
  • An immediate fix that maintains role balance was required.

It is a game design fundamental as well as our policy that, rather than adjust the jobs to suit each battle, we balance the jobs independently, and only then set the battle content difficulty. Changing the job balance for one single duty would end up causing more problems than it solves, and so we decided to address the problem in the manner we did─by ameliorating the root cause.

I appreciate that, regardless of our rationale, this issue has been a source of frustration for many, and I apologize for that. I hope, however, that this has helped clarify our approach.

In Conclusion

The adjustment to Abyssos: The Eighth Circle was never intended to be a “nerf,” but merely the correction of values that were set inappropriately for a fourth-stage Savage raid to begin with.

Nevertheless, I understand that it feels like a nerf for those who worked hard and were on the verge of clearing the fight as it was originally implemented, and I regret having caused such disappointment.

As we strongly wish you to continue enjoying fiercely challenging Savage fights, particularly in the early days after release, we will do our utmost to further improve the tuning of these battles. Furthermore, we will strive to better understand what our players think about such issues and improve our operational protocols─perhaps by waiting a week before implementing fixes, in addition to providing details on our perspective─so that if we again find ourselves in a similar situation, we may arrive at a solution that is more satisfying to everyone.

At the risk of sounding like a broken record, I sincerely apologize for any disruption that our error may have caused to your gameplay experience, and appreciate your patience.

Naoki Yoshida

FINAL FANTASY XIV Producer & Director


Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Neviriah
      The Final Fantasy XIV Fan Festival 2024 in Tokyo is a celebration of the game and its community. You can join the fun by attending the event in person or watching it online. Learn how to get a ticket and what to expect from the event.
      The first Fan Festival of 2024 will take place in Tokyo, Japan, on January 7th and 8th, 2024. As always, the event will be live-streamed for everyone to enjoy! However, this time, you can also watch the piano performance and The Primals concert online, but you need to buy a ticket to stream them live. The ticket will let you enjoy the full concerts from anywhere in the world.

      Tickets will cost around 3,500 yen. They will go on sale Tuesday, December 19th, 2023, and end on Monday, February 5th, 2024. 
      The concerts will be streamed on paid video distribution platforms StreamPass/FanStream, but be aware that the broadcasts may not be available in certain regions.
      The broadcast time and URLs will be announced at a later date, and the concerts will be archived and available for viewers who bought a ticket from January 9th, 2024 to February 7th, 2024.

      For more information about the Fan Festival 2024 in Tokyo, you can visit the official website.
      Whether you are attending the event in person or watching it online, you are sure to have a blast with fellow fans and adventurers. The Fan Festival 2024 in Tokyo is an event you won’t want to miss!
    • By Neviriah
      The Final Fantasy XIV Hairstyle Contest came to an end, and the winners have been announced! Check out some of the stunning hairstyles that might be added to the game in the future.
      The Final Fantasy XIV Hairstyle Design contest was held for A Realm Reborn’s 10th anniversary, and it has been filled with lots of wonderful art from players all around the world. In fact, the Final Fantasy team has been so amazed by all the innovative hairstyles, that they increased the number of winning entries from 30 to 40 players. 
      Here are some of the winning entries:

      If you wish to see all 40 winning entries, you can check out the official announcement.
      One of the winning entries might be chosen by Square Enix to be added to the game in a future update. However, this is not guaranteed. Also, your entry might still have a chance to be selected even if you are not among the 40 winners. But please note that the development team might need to modify the hairstyle design to make it suitable for all the characters in the game.
      The 40 winners will be rewarded with Fat Cat Earrings during November 2023. The prize will be sent through Moogle post in game, on the character selected during the submission process.

      Congratulations to the 40 winners of the Final Fantasy XIV Hairstyle Contest! And of course, to all the participants as well! The Hairstyle creations are amazing, and we hope to see some of them in the game soon!
    • By Neviriah
      Don’t miss this chance to upgrade your game to the collector’s editions of each expansion and get exclusive in-game items such as mounts, weapons, and more. The sale ends on December 8, 2023.
      Final Fantasy XIV fans can now enjoy the collector’s editions of each expansion for a 50%-discount. The editions include exclusive in-game items such as weapons, minions, mounts, and more. 
      The sale is available since Friday, 24 November 2023 until Friday, 8 December 2023 at 7:00 (GMT) / 18:00 (AEDT).
      Upgrading your game’s version to the collector’s edition is a way for you to enjoy unique and rare items that are only available through this option. For example, the "Endwalker" collector’s edition includes a majestic paladin mount and a Death Scythe weapon for the Reaper job, while the "A Realm Reborn" edition includes the famous Fat Chocobo.

      You can either purchase the bundle or a specific expansion to upgrade to the collector’s edition, if you only want to get some of the items.
      However, please note that if you already have one of the digital collector’s editions on your service account, you cannot access the bundle purchase, and you have to upgrade each expansion individually.
      To upgrade to the collector’s edition, visit the Final Fantasy XIV: Mog Station, and select the option to upgrade.

      Then, select the bundle or the specific expansion you want to upgrade to the collector edition, and proceed to check-out. Afterward, you will receive a confirmation email, and the collector edition will appear on your service account. It may take some time to receive the items in-game.
      Be aware that this does not including the game expansion. This system is only available for players who already bought the game and the expansions, and simply wish to upgrade their normal versions to the collector editions.
      The Mog Station digital upgrade system is the only way for you to get the items if you already have the game, so don’t miss out on this chance to get them for a very low price.  
    • By Neviriah
      Participate in the upcoming Cloud Data Center Stress Test from 21 to 28 November and assist the Final Fantasy Team in expanding their server infrastructure.
      To cope with the increasing demand for server capacity, Square Enix is working on creating a cloud data center solution that would allow players to access the game from anywhere in the world.
      A cloud data center is a virtual server structure that is hosted on the internet, rather than on physical hardware. This means that anyone can connect to the game without being limited by their real life location. Cloud data centers also offer potential improvements to the game’s performance and stability.
      In order to test how the server will do in a public service environment, players will be able to participate in the Cloud Data Center Stress Test, and give their feedback to the FFXIV team. The test will run from Tuesday, 21 November, to Tuesday, 28 November. For now, the server is located in North America (East Coast), but players from all over the world can participate. Keep in mind, though, that you might experience latency if you are not located in North America. 
      In order to participate, you must create a new character on the Cloud Data Center. The Data Center selection screen can be accessed from the title screen, where you will have to choose the NA Cloud DC (Beta) - CloudTest01 or CloudTest02, and then create a character to start the game!

      Characters created on this server will receive 50 million Gil, as well as a copy of Tales Of Adventures: Shadowbringers, and Tales of Adventure III (level 80), for each job to instantly access as many in-game features as possible. You will be able to explore every content existing in the game, there are no limits!
      Keep in mind, that all characters created on this Cloud Server, will be deleted when the test ends. 
      If you have any feedback regarding the stress test, you can post on the official forum threads.
      For further details, please head over to the official information post.
      The Cloud Data Center Stress test is a unique opportunity for players to experience the game in a different way, and to contribute to the improvement of the server infrastructure. By participating in the test, players will help Square Enix evaluate the feasibility and performance of the cloud data center solution, which could potentially enhance the game’s quality and accessibility for players around the world.
      The test is open to everyone, regardless of region or platform. So don’t miss this chance to join the test and have fun with the FFXIV community!
    • By Neviriah
      Those interested can now pre-order the third round of FFXIV Fan Festival 2023-2024 merchandise. Check out the new items, including team jerseys for Warrior of Light and Warrior of Darkness, plushies of the Scions, keychains of the Endwalker logo, and more.
      Pre-Orders Have Begun for the Third Round of Merchandise to Commemorate the 2023-2024 Fan Festival Events. This new lineup is not the same as the previous ones from North American and European Fan Festivals! Each event has its own unique theme and content, as well as merchandise, so check it out if you're interested in any of the new items:
      You can head directly to the Square Enix Store, and check out the brand-new items, including the amazing team jerseys for both Warrior of Light and Warrior of Darkness, as well as plushies, keychains, and much more!

      The Fan Festival 2023-2024 is a great opportunity for Final Fantasy XIV fans to celebrate their passion and enjoy exclusive content and merchandise.
      If you are interested in the goodies, don't miss your chance to get some of the amazing items, now that the third round of merchandise is available for pre-order through the Square Enix Store, and show your support for your favorite game, so you can get ready for the upcoming Fan Festival events in Japan!
  • Create New...