Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Damien

Protection Warrior 7.1

90 posts in this topic

This thread is for comments about our Protection Warrior guide.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

the tier 45 talent, Unyielding Strikes, is misleadingly labeled and severely underrated in your guide. It reduces the rage cost of heroic strike by 5 for 5 secs stacking up to 6 times, therefore at 5 and 6 stacks it is worth it to be spamming heroic strike, allowing 4 heroic strikes for a total rage cost of 20 at 5 stacks, and 4 heroic strikes at zero rage cost at 6 stacks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

the tier 45 talent, Unyielding Strikes, is misleadingly labeled and severely underrated in your guide. It reduces the rage cost of heroic strike by 5 for 5 secs stacking up to 6 times, therefore at 5 and 6 stacks it is worth it to be spamming heroic strike, allowing 4 heroic strikes for a total rage cost of 20 at 5 stacks, and 4 heroic strikes at zero rage cost at 6 stacks.

Thank you, we've amended the section!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Would it just be better to stack mastery on gemming vs having parry/mastery? 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I dont get it...

 

Call me thick but They have removed Parry and Dodge?

 

Now as a tank i have to stack cirt and haste?

 

Stat priority? Stam>Armour>Mastery>Haste>Crit

 

Confused :S

 

I seem to do a fuck ton more damage though, although its hard to gauge as thats about 3-4k damage :0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sorry repeat of the previous post, i have registered

 

 

I dont get it...

 

Call me thick but They have removed Parry and Dodge?

 

Now as a tank i have to stack cirt and haste?

 

Stat priority? Stam>Armour>Mastery>Haste>Crit

 

Confused :S

 

I seem to do a fuck ton more damage though, although its hard to gauge as thats about 3-4k damage :0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have been looking at askmrrobot and for defensive they have for the primary build where crit is the first stat and bonus armor is third. I know that right now alot of stuff is in the air and that it is viable. So i have to ask. Looking at the legendary cloaks, is the melee dps one better for tanking right now. I know you loose the life saving feature of the cloak but on the dps one you gain parry and an AOE agro generator. Was just curious on the thoughts on this.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Guide still includes Recklessness as a cd that is affected by Vial in the trinkets section. 

RIP prot recklessness.

 

Some of the gear isn't included in the list, but it doesn't matter much anyway.

 

Thank you for updating such a well written and thoughtful guide.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Gems for Red slot might need some changes in the guide, since Expertise changed to Haste. I don't know whether Prot Warrior need Haste in new expansion?

Edited by Zvon

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have been looking at askmrrobot and for defensive they have for the primary build where crit is the first stat and bonus armor is third. I know that right now alot of stuff is in the air and that it is viable. So i have to ask. Looking at the legendary cloaks, is the melee dps one better for tanking right now. I know you loose the life saving feature of the cloak but on the dps one you gain parry and an AOE agro generator. Was just curious on the thoughts on this.

 

Bonus Armor is amazing, so I don't really see the DPS cloak coming in handy unless you *really* need the AoE damage, or you're just looking to maximise your DPS at the expense of your survivability.

 

Guide still includes Recklessness as a cd that is affected by Vial in the trinkets section. 

RIP prot recklessness.

 

Some of the gear isn't included in the list, but it doesn't matter much anyway.

 

Thank you for updating such a well written and thoughtful guide.

 

Should be fixed now. Thank you very much for the compliment!

 

Why are stormbolt and shockwave not considered CC while warbringer is?

 

Because in the case of Stormbolt and Shockwave, their impact is so strong that the performance-enhancing element overtakes the (frankly not so important) CC-element. Warbringer is basically just CC and nothing more.

 

Gems for Red slot might need some changes in the guide, since Expertise changed to Haste. I don't know whether Prot Warrior need Haste in new expansion?

 

Haste is good, or at least it's a stat worth getting until we have access to Versatility and Multistrike. Come Warlords of Draenor launch, the gemming will change.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hey, just curious, have you guys considered the weapon enchant Executioner as main hand enchant, seeing as crit is good for tanks now? It's from TBC, it gives 120 crit on proc, don't know the cooldown or proc-rate at all, just stumbled upon it while running around in Outland.

Might be worth checking out!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hey again, after leveling skinning/leatherworking I also stumbled upon the leg enchant Scorched Leg Armor. It gives 28 atk power and 23 crit, surely that must be better than Angerhide Leg Armor (19 str 11 crit)? Maybe I am missing something here..

 

Also, check out the "old" leg enchants for other classes, since the stat crunch alot of old enchants/gems have become much better than the MoP ones. Dont know if this is intentional by Blizz.

 

- Thaseel

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The differences for these old enchants are tiny, and clearly unintentional. It's all going to be irrelevant once Warlords of Draenor is here, so we honestly didn't want to go through the trouble :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Guide still shows best off hand for prot warrior is PARRY??? Also glyph of gag order is gone.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Guide still shows best off hand for prot warrior is PARRY??? Also glyph of gag order is gone.

The guide does not show a best off-hand. Items are listed by item level and alphabetical order. It says just that before the list starts.

The Glyph of Gag Order glitch has been fixed. Thank you.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The last bit in single target rotation is confusing.

 

wow_icon_ability_rogue_ambush.jpgHeroic Strike is not on the same global cooldown as your other abilities, which means you can use it at any point of your rotation. The reason why we put it in the priority is to show its importance in your rotation. You want to avoid spamming Devastate once you already have 6 stacks of Unyielding Strikes, and use them on Heroic Strike.

 

Why not spam both? What would I be "using" on Devastate that is better off used on Heroic Strike? The only thing I could see here would be stacking to 5 then holding off on Devastate to get more cheap HSes out. Even then you'd miss out on Enrage and Sword and Board opportunities as well as higher damage.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm not sure if this has been addressed yet or not. In the protection section under section 8:Tier 7 talents. The abilities listed that are effected by Anger Management are wrong (I think). The ones listed in the guide are Avatar, Bloodbath, Storm bolt, Shockwave, Dragon Roar, Mocking Banner, Heroic Leap, Recklessness, and Die by the Sword. Those are the talents for Arms or Fury specs. They should be (according to the tooltip) Avatar, Bloodbath, BLADESTORM, Storm bolt, Shockwave, Dragon Roar, Mocking Banner, Heroic Leap, SHIELD WALL, DEMO SHOUT, and LAST STAND. 

 

Maybe I'm reading it wrong but just F.Y.I.

 

The site rocks. Very helpful and well written. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes, I'm working on it now, it should be up tomorrow!

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

AskMr Robot says Multistrike is better than Haste.

And you dont mention that Multistrike triggers Blood Craze.

Its a nice self heal which is further increased by Resolve and your Versatility.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hey VLAD, Hey ICYVEINS team.

 

just saying thanks for the great Protection Warrior guide. Keep up the great work. And let me know if there is any cap we can reach in the close future around parry dodge mastery critcal strike etc.

 

a everyday visitor!

 

Vokuhila, Garosh

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There seem to be an error in the Macro section. 
It talks about Hand of Salvation (and hand of protection) but the macro will remove Hand of Protection and Hand of Sacrifice.

Thanks for a good guide! Really love what you guys do

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Your content will need to be approved by a moderator

Guest
You are commenting as a guest. If you have an account, please sign in.
Reply to this topic...

×   You have pasted content with formatting.   Remove formatting

  Only 75 emoticons maximum are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

Loading...
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Stan

      This week's 7.2.5 PTR Build added 27 new Legendary items to the game.
      Here's a list of all new Legendary items added in Build 24163. The second round of new items can be found here and for "Hellfire Amulets" don't forget to check out the first round.
      Death Knight
      Cold Heart Death Screamers Soulflayer's Corruption Demon Hunter
      Chaos Theory Oblivion's Embrace Druid
      Behemoth Headdress Fury of Nature Radiant Moonlight Hunter
      Celerity of the Windrunners Parsel's Tongue Unseen Predator's Cloak Mage
      Contained Infernal Core Mantle of the First Kirin Tor Shattered Fragments of Sindragosa Monk
      The Wind Blows Paladin
      Pillars of Inmost Light Scarlet Inquisitor's Expurgation Priest
      Heart of the Void Rogue
      The Curse of Restlessness The Empty Crown The First of the Dead Shaman
      Primal Ascendant's Stormcallers Smoldering Heart Warlock
      The Master Harvester Warrior
      Ararat's Bloodmirror The Great Storm's Eye Valarjar Berserkers
    • By Stan

      A list of all class changes and Tier Set Bonus adjustments of this week's 7.2.5 build.
      Warriors went through lots of changes in the latest build, Fists of Fury now have an 8yd range & more.
      Concordance of Legionfall (Legion Infinite Trait)
      Concordance of the Legionfall Concordance of the Legionfall Concordance of the Legionfall Concordance of the Legionfall Class Changes
      Death Knight
      Chilled Heart // Chilled Heart Crystalline Swords Unholy Frenzy Vampiric Fangs // Vampiric Fangs // Vampiric Fangs Demon Hunter
      Demon Rage Empower Wards Eternal Hunger // Eternal Hunger First Blood Imprison Druid
      Backlash Soul of the Forest Hunter
      Deathstrike Venom Mok'Nathal Tactics Scatter Shot Sniper Shot The Beast Within T.N.T. Wild Protector Monk
      Fists of Fury Keg Smash Purifying Brew Stormstout's Last Gasp Paladin
      Blessing of the Ashbringer Eye of Tyr Judgment of Blood Seraphim's Blessing Priest
      Call to the Void Lash of Insanity Plea Power Word: Shield The Alabaster Lady Rogue
      Assassination Rogue Flat % increase - Assassination Rogue Toxic Blade Shaman
      Crashing Lightning Earth Shield Ethereal Form Spark of Ra-den Smoldering Heart Warlock
      Affiliction Warlock Flat % increase - Affliction Warlock Haunt Warrior
      Fury Warrior Flat % increase - Fury Warrior Deadly Calm Exploit the Weakness Fervor of Battle Focused Rage Frenzy Opportunity Strikes // Opportunity Strikes Ravager Rend Titanic Might Trauma Whirlwind Tier Set Bonus Update
      Death Knight
      Item - Death Knight T20 Frost 2P Bonus Druid
      Item - Druid T20 Restoration 4P Bonus Paladin
      Item - Paladin T20 Protection 2P Bonus Item - Paladin T20 Protection 4P Bonus Shaman
      Item - Shaman T19 Enhancement 4P Bonus Item - Shaman T20 Elemental 2P Bonus
    • By Starym

       
      Better stats and scaling in PvE, worse scaling in PvP and more changes are live.
      Update 2: Today's hotfixes didn't bring any additional info on the procc rate buff, but did offer some insight from the devs as to why the changes happened in the first place. You can check them out here.

      Update: It seems the procc rate was buffed as well and we'll find out the exact details in the hotfix notes later today.

      After the big announcement about the Artifact Knowledge cap being reduced, today we're getting a bit of an offset (or consolation prize for some) as the "infinity trait" aka Concordance of the Legionfall just got buffed, at least in PvE. The changes are up already on live servers.
      Placeholder for tweet 867444216745439232 It did not get the base buff PvP, however, and the scaling actually got nerfed:
      Placeholder for tweet 867444363655233536 We also got some clarifications on when exactly the PvP tuning comes into effect:
      Placeholder for tweet 867445986959818752 And in the most recent update, we found out the procc rate was buffed as well, but we'll be getting more details later:
      Placeholder for tweet 867452620767600640
    • By Starym

       
      A very short list today, with just 1 item on the agenda: the Concordance changes. Unfortunately we didn't get any more detailed info on the exact proc rate increase, but we did get some insight into the overall changes from the devs.
      May 24 (source)
      Artifacts
      Concordance of the Legionfall Chance to activate slightly increased. Now grants 4,000 Strength, Agility, Intellect, or Versatility at rank 1 (was 2,000). Additional ranks now increase this value by 300 per rank (was 200). Effects are now reduced by 50% in PvP situations. Developers’ Note: While additional ranks of Concordance of Legionfall are intended to have a low impact, the trait was overall weaker than it needed to be. With these changes, it provides a stronger up-front benefit, and very slightly more value for Artifact Power spent past the first rank. These changes also result in an overall nerf in PvP, where we are continuing to monitor its performance. Previous hotfixes (May 22nd).
    • By Starym

       
      Mione is back at it and this time it was the Emerald Nightmare's own Cenarius that went down vs. the lone Vengeance Demon Hunter. Pretty damn impressive since EN is technically still the same tier as the current endgame raid, Nighthold (even though it's waay behind on item levels). The fight itself is pretty exhilarating as well, as the health on the DH keeps flying up and down the whole time!
       
      And here's the armory link for the 918 ilev Demon Hunter.