Vlad

What is Overwatch Closed Beta Like?

Sign in to follow this  

3 posts in this topic

13938-what-is-overwatch-closed-beta-like

 

We've been playing Overwatch Closed Beta since October the 27th, and we want to share exactly what it's like.

 

Overwatch's Closed Beta has been going strong for 5 days. Invited to the test so far are just a select few of the many Beta opt-ins, together with a rather large number of streamers, YouTubers and other press writers. Some of our staff, myself included, were extremely fortunate to be invited to the test, so I'm taking this opportunity to tell you just what it's like.

 

For reference, I got to play the game at BlizzCon 2014 (briefly), Gamescom 2015 and Road to Blizzcon 2015 (extensively), and I wrote an article about my impressions of the game shortly after Gamescom.

 

Smooth and Stable Experience

 

We had stated time and time again, ever since we first got a chance to play the game in 2014, that it felt very polished, practically ready for release. This has not changed, of course, and in fact, being able to play the game from the comfort of my home, I can say that I am very impressed by how smoothly the Beta client runs.

 

During the many hours of playtime I have put in since October 27th, I have not noticed a single instance of lag, nor have the severs ever gone down. Players occasionally reported the client crashing, but I never experienced this either.

 

Likewise, the feedback provided on the Closed Beta's forums (both the US and EU ones) indicates that most players are happy with the performance they are getting from their computers, so all in all, it seems like Blizzard have done a tremendous job as far as technical aspects are concerned.

 

The lack of a Mac client (or of 32-bit operating system support) has frustrated some, but given the scope of the release, that is hardly something to hold against Blizzard.

 

Lack of Features

 

If you're disappointed because you haven't received an invitation to the Closed Beta, this section should make you feel a bit better.

 

Despite everything I said above about the game being polished and in a very stable state, there are still many, many features missing from the game. In fact, if you've played any other modern (or even not-so-modern) first person shooters, you might find Overwatch to be quite bare-bones.

 

My greatest gripe with the game is the fact that user interface does not do a good job of conveying enough information to you about what is happening in the game at any given time. This makes it very difficult to stay informed, which in turn reduces the amount of teamwork potential.

 

Even in a competitive environment where all 6 members of a team communicate through voice at all times, the current lack of information would mean that these players would have to talk almost non-stop in order to provide one another with the required relevant information.

 

6SQpm7n.jpg

 

Overwatch's sleek and minimalistic UI leaves a lot to be desired.

 

 

I wrote a thread about this very topic on the Overwatch Feedback forums, which has had a large number of replies (some agreeing, others disagreeing). I will simply summarise my concerns here.

 

  1. The lack of a mini-map makes it practically impossible to keep track of your teammates positions.
  2. The lack of a kill feed (showing a notification on the screen whenever a player is killed by another player) likewise makes it very difficult to keep track of how many enemies and allies are in the fight, and also makes it difficult to tell which heroes of a given team are alive or dead.
  3. The lack of a player status display (showing which players on a team are dead/alive, and for how long) contributes even further to the general confusion. It is possible to see this information by opening up the scoreboard, but this requires a key-press and takes up the entire screen, which is likely to get you killed in the process.
  4. The lack of a detailed scoreboard (the current one only shows which players are dead/alive, and what hero each player is using) makes it very difficult to evaluate the performance of teammates (and yours by comparison).

 

There are a myriad of other features that players have requested on the Feedback forums.

 

Blizzard have agreed to add an option to permanently skip the (sometimes frustrating) kill-cam that you are shown after you die, and they have likewise indicated support for a way to have Widowmaker's sniper rifle remained zoomed in without you having to hold down the right mouse button.

 

Another feature that would make a great addition is a proper console that allows players to tweak settings in a more customized manner (there is currently no way to reduce mouse sensitivity below 1, which is still too high for some people's liking).

 

Other Problems

 

In addition to the above-mentioned missing or incomplete features, there are some other issues with the game that I would like to see Blizzard address before the game's release.

 

For starters, the game feels too fast. It is possible to have balanced, relatively long games, when the teams are perfectly matched, but not only is this rare, even these games do not often feel long enough. Just when you get to enjoy playing against the opposition, the game ends. How much of an impact this will have depends on the format Blizzard choose to adopt for competitive games (how many maps will be played as a part of a single competitive match?), but as of right now, the games definitely feel too short.

 

Moreover, one-sided games are over much, much too quickly. My shortest game, on Volkskaya Industries, lasted just over 1 minute. We were wiped out while defending the first objective, and we respawned just in time to be killed on top of the second objective and lose the game. Not only is this not fun for the losing side, it makes it a terrible experience for a spectator sport. Obviously, it is unlikely that there would be such a discrepancy in skill between teams facing each other at a high competitive level, but the issue is still a real one. Spectators need to have enough time to get into the game and understand what is happening if they are to enjoy watching it.

 

I also have somewhat of a problem with the strength of abilities (especially ultimate abilities) compared with the strength of main weapon damage. This is a clear design choice, which I can respect, but it often feels very disappointing to be killed by an opponent's lackluster use of a strong ability, rather than by them exhibiting some great feat of skill.

 

I mentioned ultimate abilities because it is there that the issue is most obvious. Many ultimate abilities in Overwatch are press-to-kill, requiring little to no further input from the player. McCree, Reaper, Soldier: 76, Pharah, and Hanzo are all guilty of this. Mind you, I am not complaining that these abilities are overpowered or that they cannot be countered. They certainly can be dealt with. My complaint is that they are too strong for just how boring and easy to use they are.

 

With regards to ultimate abilities, I mind how quickly it is possible to recharge them, and how having them recharge by doing damage means that in reality, the team that is dominating at a given time will probably recharge their ultimates very quickly and be able to dominate even more. There is also essentially no way of knowing when the ultimate abilities for the enemy team are available, given their dynamic recharge time.

 

Finally, I feel that the game is too strongly centered around good teamplay. This does not look like a problem on the face of it, and I'm sure Blizzard have had a blast testing their game in-house during development. However, in the real world, most people who play the game will be doing so in public games with strangers, where the heavy reliance on team work can prove to be a great frustration.

 

A large number of the game's heroes are only really playable within the framework of a team that is supporting them. Without that support, they simply do not work (an unsupported Bastion, Widowmaker, or Torbjorn is instant dead meat, or, err... dead scrap). On the other end of the spectrum, some heroes (like Tracer, Pharah, or Reaper) are extremely strong in almost all scenarios, and these will probably see a lot of play during disorganized public games.

 

What Is There To Do Right Now?

 

If you aren't playing the Beta, you may be wondering what there is to do in the game. The answer is... not that much.

 

You can play against AI to test heroes and maps or to improve your skill (the AI is surprisingly good).

 

You can create a private game and invite up to 11 other players to face off in an organized setting (but let us face it, with the low number of players that have access to the Beta, we won't be seeing any tournaments just yet).

 

And, of course, you can queue up for public games, where you will be matched with and against random players. This is a somewhat disjointed experience, where you will sometimes be placed into games already in progress, and other times you will be shifted around from one team to another. There isn't really anything to play for (except, of course, to test the game and improve yourself!), and there doesn't seem to be much (if any) of a matchmaking system in place to find opponents of "appropriate skill".

 

Of course, all of my points so far should be taken as constructive criticism. Despite all of this, I still enjoy playing the game and I think it has great potential. I just wish that Blizzard would address these and many other issues that are reported on the Feedback forums, and improve the game.

 

So far, the developers (including Jeff Kaplan himself) have replied to threads on the forums, indicating that they are taking improving the game very seriously, so there is hope that they will give it the required love and care for the remainder of the development process. Only time (and extensive playing!) will tell.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Really awesome write up Vlad!

 

I've been one of the lucky ones to get a chance to play the game too.  Sadly my uptime has been a little limited with me being away for the weekend but I've managed a few games in so far.

 

As a player of a number of FPS over the years (think old school Doom / Wolfenstein 3D / Quake) and Titanfall more recently my first impressions are positive.

 

I haven't really played too many "recent" games such as CoD or CS:GO and so wanted to try and get a feel for the game for somebody who wouldn't automatically make comparisons with other FPS games that are currently available (on console or PC).  With that said I didn't really have too much expectations either.

 

I have only played Public games so far  (wanting to jump straight in rather than playing against the AI) and the heroes that I have played (mainly Pharah) have been fun.  As Vlad mentions above the current interface feels a bit lacking.  I struggled to get used to seeing when my Ultimate was available and keeping tabs on my other abilities and especially if you are keen on communicating with your team (not that many of my games have got to that stage yet).  Maybe players are "rushing in" a bit more as it is only beta but sometimes the fights are that fast that I struggle to see whats going on (probably just because Im just bad though!)  Games are fast paced and I agree with a lot that Vlad has said regarding one sided games.  There seems to be a problem with snowballing in certain situations and I hope they take feedback on this as no one enjoys games where they feel they getting battered by the other team (even if they are over quickly).

 

I should get plenty of game time over the upcoming weeks and I do plan on streaming a little at some point as well.  But to summarise briefly - its really fun!

 

Hopefully (along with other Blizzard games) it will encourage players who have never previously played a certain type of game to give it a try.

 

So don't fret if you've yet to be invited folks.  It's worth waiting a little longer!

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This honestly worries me. These are such basic features that it leaves me wondering how it is possible for them not to be in the game already. Counter Strike was made by 2 guys and came out with a proper scoreboard and kill feed. After 6 months of beta, we had a proper radar as well and this was 16 years ago.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Zadina

      The team is still experimenting with Mercy's Valkyrie and Resurrection trying to balance them out as best as possible.
      The first iteration of Mercy changes on the Overwatch PTR were considered as huge nerfs for the fan-favourite Support hero. The devs quickly admitted that these changes were experimental and the team is still testing things out with Valkyrie and Resurrection.
      Now, a new change is being tested on the PTR: within Valkyrie's duration Mercy gets a second Resurrection charge, making it possible to resurrect two people at once. Moreover, Resurrect no longer resets the cooldown of Guardian Angel, putting an even bigger target marker on Mercy when she is resurrecting somebody. Lastly, Mercy can now get an unlock boost from her Guardian Angel by using the jump key.
      Geoff Goodman
      We've updated the PTR last night with the following changes to test:

      Mercy can now get an unlock boost from her guardian angel by using the jump key. This unlocks you from your target and lets you fly past them for a little bit, and sort of use your target like a slingshot. This somewhat replicates some of the behavior the recent Mercy zero-air resistance bug caused, but in a way that is more consistent and with less buggy side effects. 

      Valkyrie has also changed a bit, in regards to how it affects Resurrect. It no longer increases the range of res, it now instead gives you one free 'charge' of res that you can use any time during Valkyrie. I do not use this free res, it will be removed when Valkyrie ends. Valkyrie still no longer affects Resurrect's cooldown directly now, but this method preserves some amount of 'burst ressing' when needed, while making it more flexible to use. For example, in the past if you want to res two targets with Valkyrie, you had to first res one target, then ult (causing the cooldown to reset), then res the other target. With this new change you can now hit Valkyrie first, fly in quickly and res two targets instantly. 

      However, overall this still reduces the overall numbers of Resurrects Mercy can provide since Valkyrie no longer reduces its cooldown.

      We have also made some changes to Lucio's speed boost when jumping off a wall to try to compensate for the super-boost bug fix that just went out. He now gets a more significant boost off a wall.

      We're still iterating on these changes, and any feedback you guys have would be great. Thanks. (source)

      There is one more change to Mercy: Resurrect no longer resets the cooldown of Guardian Angel. This makes Resurrect more reasonable to fight against, since Mercy will now be slightly more vulnerable if she chooses to res someone in a bad position. (source)
      As you see, there's an additional change to Lucio's speed boost when jumping off a wall. In the first October PTR patch, there was a bug that caused Lucio to gain a super speed boost after wall-riding. A dedicated Lucio player u/Serenad3 has written up a proper essay on the history of changes to Lucio's wall-riding speed. The conclusion of this write-up is that this last iteration on Lucio's wall-riding will make him feel a bit slower than his current speed on live servers.
    • By Starym

       
      The patch notes accompanying the Halloween Terror event are here and we're getting Ultimate meter changes after an ult gets interrupted, as well as individual Hero Ultimate changes related to that and dev commentary to explain it all. There's also improvements to the objective capture UI and the usual bug fixes!
      October 10 (source)
      PATCH HIGHLIGHTS New Seasonal Event: Overwatch Halloween Terror 2017
      The fright for the future returns!
      For a limited time, explore the haunted streets of Eichenwalde and Hollywood, expand your collection of spooky seasonal cosmetics, and team up to fight evil incarnate once more in not one, but two Junkenstein's Revenge-themed brawls! We're also re-opening our crypt so players can unlock their favorite Halloween-themed items from last year along with over 50 new tantalizing treats, including legendary skins like Corsair Ana, Van Helsing McCree, Dragon Symmetra, Cultist Zenyatta, and more.
      To learn more about Overwatch Halloween Terror, click here.
      New Epic Skin: BlizzCon 2017 Winston
      Through the power of science, Winston has traveled with his trusty jump pack from his base in Gibraltar all the way to Anaheim, California for BlizzCon 2017. We’ve given him a special souvenir to mark the curious occasion and he’d like to share it with you. Starting today, this new skin is available in-game for all BlizzCon Virtual Ticket holders—click here to learn more.
      GENERAL UPDATES
      Overwatch Halloween Terror Victory Pose Updates
      We've made a few changes to this year's selection of seasonal victory poses. To learn more about this change, click here.
      HERO UPDATES
      General
      Ultimate charge is now immediately expended when a hero's ultimate ability is activated, instead of depleting over a short period of time Developer Comments: One of the most common pieces of feedback we receive revolves around the way Overwatch handles ultimate interruptions. Players often feel frustrated when they’re able to prevent an enemy from using an ultimate, only to see that same enemy use it again immediately after respawning
      Until now, many ultimates drained the meter quickly over time, instead of instantly setting the meter to zero when the button was pressed. We originally designed it this way to ensure that players had the chance to use (at the very least) a little of their ultimate every time. However, we now feel that it causes too much frustration without adding many benefits.
      With this patch, ultimate abilities will instantly set a hero’s meter to zero when the button is pressed, which means stopping an enemy ultimate at any point after it’s activated will ensure that it has been spent.
      Another piece of feedback we often hear is that it’s difficult to understand which abilities are interruptible and which are not. For clarity, most of Overwatch’s ultimates fall into three basic categories:
      Transformation Ultimates:

      These add significant passive benefits to your heroes, while allowing the use of weapons and abilities.

      Ultimates in this category: Bastion's Configuration: Tank, Genji's Dragonblade, Mercy's Valkyrie, Soldier: 76's Tactical Visor, Torbjörn's Molten Core, and Widowmaker's Infra-Sight.
        Channeled Ultimates: These force your hero into a new mode and render your other abilities unusable while active. In most cases, these abilities can be interrupted at any point to cancel them.

      Ultimates in this category: Doomfist’s Meteor Strike, McCree's Deadeye, Pharah’s Barrage, Reaper’s Death Blossom, Roadhog’s Whole Hog, and Zenyatta's Transcendence (though, Zenyatta’s ultimate renders him immune to interruptions).
        Cast-Time Ultimates: These abilities require a small window of time to pass before they become effective. If they’re interrupted during this window, they are canceled.

      Ultimates in this category: Ana's Nano Boost, D.Va’s Call Mech and Self-Destruct, Hanzo's Dragonstrike, Junkrat's Rip-Tire, Lúcio’s Sound Barrier, Mei's Blizzard, Orisa's Supercharger, Reinhardt's Earthshatter, Sombra's EMP, Symmetra's Shield Generator and Teleporter, Tracer's Pulse Bomb, and Zarya's Graviton Surge. Most abilities fit neatly within these categories but we did make some changes to outliers such as Genji's Dragonblade and Orisa's Supercharger to make them more consistent. Additionally, any ultimate that can be interrupted by a stun (Channeled ultimates and Cast-Time ultimates) can now be interrupted by Sombra’s Hack as well. Overall these changes should make it much easier to understand the ultimate mechanics and how they interact in combat.
      D.Va
      Boosters An option to manually hold down D.Va’s boosters rather than toggling them has been added under Options > Controls > D.Va Genji
      Dragonblade No longer interrupted when Genji is stunned or hacked Developer Comments: See the above developer comment on ultimate interruptions
      Orisa
      Supercharger Can now be interrupted when Orisa is stunned or hacked Developer Comments: See the above developer comment on ultimate interruptions
      Sombra
      Hack Now interrupts the following ultimate abilities during their cast time: Ana's Nano Boost, Orisa's Supercharger, Mei's Blizzard, Reinhardt's Earthshatter, and D.Va's Call Mech Developer Comments: See the above developer comment on ultimate interruptions
      USER INTERFACE UPDATES
      Assault Maps
      When capturing an objective, the progress bar is now broken into three segments that will fill in with the team’s color that is capturing it (as each segment fills, it will trigger an animation and audio cue) The number of defenders currently on the objective will now be displayed in addition to the number of attackers, just below the progress bar BUG FIXES
      General
      Fixed a bug that allowed muted players to become unmuted after leaving and rejoining the same match A.I.
      Fixed a bug that caused bots to get trapped in a movement loop after taking the tunnel under the capture point in the University section of Oasis Competitive Play
      Fixed an issue that caused matches to end in a draw when both teams won their first attacking rounds in overtime on Hanamura, Horizon Lunar Colony, Temple of Anubis, and Volskaya Industries Custom Games and Game Browser
      Fixed a bug that prevented the Capture Speed Modifier setting from being applied in custom games Fixed a bug that prevented D.Va’s Projectile Speed slider from appearing in Custom Game settings Heroes
      Fixed a bug that prevented D.Va’s Micro Missles from producing rumble feedback when using a controller with vibration enabled Fixed a bug that caused Lúcio’s soccer ball to fly off in the wrong direction when activating his Juggle emote at 30 FPS Fixed a bug that caused Mercy to maintain forward momentum after canceling Guardian Angel mid-flight Fixed a bug that could cause heroes to respawn as a different hero after being resurrected by Mercy Fixed a bug that caused Roadhog’s chest to deflate when his Tuckered Out emote was activated while the Mako or Sharkbait skins were equipped Fixed a bug that prevented the sound effects on Symmetra’s turrets from being heard by teammates Fixed a bug that prevented Torbjörn’s weapon-draw animation from being played when turret placement was canceled Maps
      Fixed a bug on Junkertown that allowed some heroes to get stuck behind a barrel near the final point Fixed a bug on King’s Row that caused a dark box to appear if you stared into the robot city for too long Fixed a bug that allowed Sombra to reach unintended locations on Volskaya Industries Fixed a bug affecting Ilios, Lijang Tower, Nepal, and Oasis that prevented overtime progress from resetting when the point had been flipped after both teams’ progress bars reached 99% UI
      Fixed a bug that could cause Widowmaker’s scoped overlay to appear while spectating her from third person view
    • By Starym

       
      The Halloween event is back and much improved this year, as we not only get the expected new skins, emotes and intros, but also an upgraded Junkenstein's Revenge game mode! This survival flavored version of the PvE game mode sees you trying to...well, not die. Check out the trailer as well as all the new skins and everything else below!
      Halloween Terror (source)
        TERROR RETURNS
      The fright for the future has begun, heroes!
      For the next three weeks, we’re celebrating the spookiest time of the year with a seasonal event. Expand your collection of seasonal-themed items and relive a chilling tale in our PvE brawl: Junkenstein's Revenge.
      This year, we’ve added a new endless mode for Junkenstein’s Revenge, with leaderboards to commemorate those who last the longest in their fight against the evil doctor. Plus, unlock over 50 new seasonal items—including new legendary skins like Dracula Reaper, Van Helsing McCree, Totally 80’s Zarya, and Dragon Symmetra—alongside last year's Halloween Terror gear.
      JUNKENSTEIN'S REVENGE
      Team up with three other players and face off against a host of horrific enemies, including Junkenstein and his Monster, the mysterious Summoner, the Reaper, and the Witch of the Wilds.
      ENDLESS NIGHT
      Prepare for a real challenge! New to the Arcade is Junkenstein’s Revenge: Endless Night. How long can you survive as wave after wave of enemies and bosses assault the castle doors? Play as one of four additional heroes: Genji, Torbjörn, Widowmaker, and Zenyatta. Those who survive the longest will earn a spot on the all-new leaderboard.
      Spooky Eichenwalde
      For a limited time, explore haunted versions of the Hollywood and Eichenwalde maps!
      NEW SKINS!
        
        
        
        
      TRICK OR TREAT
      Celebrate the frightful season with a Halloween Terror Loot Box, filled with new skins, emotes, highlights, avatars, sprays, voice lines, and more. You can also purchase items you missed from last year's event with credits for a discounted price. Over 140 cosmetic items are available, but don’t wait too long—these Loot Boxes will disappear in a puff of smoke before you know it.

    • By Zadina

      Four of the new skins appeared on Facebook ads of Overwatch and some people noticed them!
      We already know that Halloween Terror is returning this year and that there will be some new skins, including one for Reaper. The new Reaper skin and three other skins were "leaked" on Facebook ads and u/Mnemosynaut gathered them in a Reddit thread.
      Reaper

      Zenyatta

      Mei 

      Symmetra

    • By Zadina

      The team is just testing the change to Mercy's Valkyrie, according to Geoff Goodman. Moreover, there is a bug with Lucio on the PTR.
      The nerf to the interaction of Valkyrie with Resurrection in the latest PTR patch stirred a lot of talk from the fans of one of Overwatch's most popular Support heroes. It turns out that the team was merely experimenting with that tweak and it's not going to make it to live servers yet.
      Geoff Goodman
      Let me give some extra context for these changes.

      First off, these changes will not be included with the other changes on the PTR, which will be coming out with the Halloween update. These Mercy changes are purely something that we're experimenting with, and there will likely be more changes coming to try out.

      There was a bug where Mercy's Guardian Angel momentum wasn't slowed correctly sometimes when canceled. This was intensely frustrating for most Mercy players, but some players enjoyed trying to use this bug to gain extra mobility. This bug is important to fix so it doesn't feel like Mercy randomly gets out of your control, but we're looking seeing if there is a way to include some of what people enjoyed about this bug as new functionality for her.

      To reiterate: These changes aren't hitting live any time soon. These are just things we want to try out for now, and they are likely to change. (source) One of the undocumented changes of this PTR patch, that the community noticed, was that Lucio didn't seem to have his wall jump speed boost anymore. Thankfully, this is merely a bug.
      Jeff Kaplan
      It's just a bug on the PTR. (source)