Blainie

overwatch Is Mercy the Villain of Overwatch?

12 posts in this topic

pZcybTb.jpg

Given her appearance and skillset, who would have thought Mercy might be the true villain of the game?

If you're an Overwatch lore fan, I would definitely recommend checking this theory out. It's very well thought out and alludes to the relationship between Mercy, Genji and Reaper, as well as what her motives might actually be.

Posted by Reddit user OJPaper, their post goes through the following theories:

  • The backstory of Mercy and what her role is in Overwatch
  • Her relationship with Genji, Reaper, and later, Sombra
  • Where is Mercy in present day Overwatch?
  • What was Reaper's motive in Recall?
  • Name and design choices of Mercy

A comment on the post also adds another interaction with Mei, which adds slightly more information to the theory. The comment comes from user phluke-, where they point out that these voice lines exist:

Mercy: Mei, you haven't aged a day. What's your secret?

Mei: Cryostasis. But I'm not sure if I'd recommend it.

This voice line points towards Mercy's interest in staying young and immortality, which then leads to the following exchange between the two.

Mei: Doctor Ziegler, I don't think you've aged a day since I last saw you.

Mercy: And neither have you, Mei.

While this confirms nothing, it definitely points towards Mercy's interest in staying young and her youthful appearance to Mei.

What do you think of all this? Is Mercy truly the villain of Overwatch?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Oh dem Blizzard Conspiracy theories. Classic. I've been chasing The Old Gods since I was 10yo.

WoW is often claimed to be stopped with its 12+ rating - they can't really stick such blurred lines and gray moralities left and right. IDK how exactly they play it out this time with OW, but it's going to be really cool.

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
8 hours ago, Paracel said:

Oh dem Blizzard Conspiracy theories. Classic. I've been chasing The Old Gods since I was 10yo.

WoW is often claimed to be stopped with its 12+ rating - they can't really stick such blurred lines and gray moralities left and right. IDK how exactly they play it out this time with OW, but it's going to be really cool.

I think WoW's lore can be as deep as you want it to be. A lot of the Vanilla based stuff drew a lot from the Lovecraftian themes, as well as certain zone designs. There's definitely a rich adult loreset to be delved into there, once you get past the pop-culture stuff.

Going to start reading a lot more about the Overwatch background with this!

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I do plan to read the Reddit thread, but haven't yet. As far as the Mei/Mercy interaction? Um... that's like, super common IRL. Do the people spinning these theories even KNOW any women IRL? Or even on social media?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
38 minutes ago, solitha said:

I do plan to read the Reddit thread, but haven't yet. As far as the Mei/Mercy interaction? Um... that's like, super common IRL. Do the people spinning these theories even KNOW any women IRL? Or even on social media?

When there are so many pointers all heading towards her being obsessed with immortality and experimenting with life, it becomes a bit more than womanly banter :p

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ehhh i just don't know if deep lore stuff works in games like overwatch. Yes blizz allegedly made this huge backstory and that but as a player you don't experience it. It's sort of like Destiny when it launched. Oh you  want lore? Well go to our website and decipher the letters seen in the alphabet soup. Sure there are audio clips and maybe teaser images in the levels but as far as this big story goes we don't have much. The world needs overwatch again, so we are going to kill each other over and over. In a way it feels battleborn esque, where blizz wanted a single player mode for overwatch but scrapped it in order to work on legion some more.

Don't get me wrong, I love overwatch, just not sure about trying to add in deep lore to it. Someone lock metzen in a closet.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
21 hours ago, Paracel said:

Oh dem Blizzard Conspiracy theories. Classic. I've been chasing The Old Gods since I was 10yo.

WoW is often claimed to be stopped with its 12+ rating - they can't really stick such blurred lines and gray moralities left and right. IDK how exactly they play it out this time with OW, but it's going to be really cool.

Same here on the Old Gods front. I couldn't believe it when I found out N'zoth was going to be unveiled outside of WoW. It was like all my investigative work was for nothing :p

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Any game that implies competition as design value tends to be slightly off the point. 

Remember TF2? (oh boy mentioning this in any OW thread can start a war) Lore was over when we've been told there are two corps - B.L.U.E and R.E.D - fightning. No idea who they are, no idea what for. 

Counter-Strike? Nameless good guys, nameless bad guys, middle of nowhere, still a good game.

MOBA games tend to have lore behind their characters but not behind the conflict. DOTA 1 made sense because it was a WC3 related thing - everybody knew what The Frozen Throne and Tree of Life are, and why are we defending them.  And who the hell are Radiant and Dire? What are those new Ancients and why do we even care?
What are we doing in HOTS and why Arthas fights alongside Diablo and Raynor? Still a mystery for me. Hats off to the old League of Legends lore though - summoners made a ton of sense, shame that they've cut them completely.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Where are the voice lines from?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Damien said:

Where are the voice lines from?

They're interactions when the two heroes are on the same team. They don't always happen, it often picks an interaction for the whole team, rather than everyone having them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We could list them all. That'd be nice.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The main theory behind Mercy (and by correlation, Reaper) starts to unravel when you consider some of their other voice lines. The theory suggests Reaper is not actually hunting Overwatch people, but just Mercy. And yet:

If Reaper kills an Overwatch member: "Another one off the list."

Repear at Watchpoint: Gibraltar: "Overwatch. I'll put an end to your sad story."

Suggesting he went out of his way to avoid killing Winston starts to strain Occam's Razor a bit. There was a basic story to be told, that Reaper is trying to get the location of Overwatch members, and Winston needs to stop him. It wouldn't be much of a story if Reaper killed Winston, nor if Reaper got that list and wiped out Overwatch. The short was exciting and entertaining, and showed off a bit of expected gameplay. It's kind of like that list of things Not to Do if I Become an Evil Overlord. Some "details" are only shown for entertainment purposes.

He does clearly blame Mercy for his current condition, but it's a bit much to suggest she's his sole target.

 

Mercy herself is rather typical of aid-givers throughout history. Few of us like the situations in which we are required, but feel that it's necessary that SOMEone steps in and does his/her best to ease the inevitable hurt. Do you think Doctors Without Borders is performing similar experiments? There they go straight into war zones, just like Mercy.

 

As far as Sombra, I favor the theory that she's actually Alejandra, from the "Hero" short, especially when considering timeline clues.

 

When I shared the Mercy theory with a group, someone pointed out that it's just like the "Jar-Jar is the ultimate Sith" stuff. I really feel a lot of it's being overthought - for instance, I could believe someone at Blizzard reads stuff like this and says, "Wait, I named Mercy's staff after what? I TOTALLY thought it was the healer's symbol! Crap!"

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Starym

       
      Jeff Kaplan took to the forums to talk about plans for new maps this year, and while he did mention at least 6 that are being worked on, 3 fit into the standard Quick Match and Competitive systems and are already in advanced testing stages, with 3 more presumably for the Arcade in earlier stages of development. The post came in reply to a user's question on whether only two maps a year, as we've gotten so far (Oasis and Eichenwalde), was enough to sustain the game in the long term.
      Jeff Kaplan (source)
      We currently have 3 maps in development, all past the initial playtesting phase that are "standard" maps (QP/Comp). While something could always change, all 3 of those are looking likely for a release this year.
      We also have 3 non-standard maps in development (these won't go in QP/Comp).
      We also have a few other experiments going on.
      Hopefully this will satisfy some of what you're looking for. We want to play on these maps as badly as you guys do. We'll work as fast as we can!
    • By Starym

       
      Game director Jeff Kaplan takes to youtube once again to talk about Overwatch's latest update: how they wanted an event that wasn't related to real world events, how they decided to go for a historical OW moment, where exactly the event takes place in the timeline and more! You can check out the specific topic and links to specific times under the video.

      00:19 - Why did the developers create the Overwatch Uprising event?
      01:32 - Jeff explains where the Overwatch Uprising event falls in the lore's timeline.
      02:40 - Jeff briefly details NEW skins, animations, sprays, and voice lines that will be available in this event!
      03:29 - Jeff explains the differences from the two game modes being implemented in the Arcade.
      05:12 - Jeff thanks the community for their feedback which inspired the creation of this event.
    • By Starym

       
      A new co-op mode, a hundred+ cosmetic items, big Lucio changes and more!
      Well, it seems it's called Uprising and not Insurrection as the French trailer leak showed, but the rest was on point. A new co-op brawl, the usual 100+ new cosmetic items, going back to the early days of the Overwatch organization, Tracer's first mission specifically and more await in this new event that's live now and lasts until May 1st. We also get a brand new lore video, featuring Tracer!

      You can also check out the full patch notes, featuring some major Lucio changes, right here, and the comic of the same name as the event, here.
      Blizzard (source)
      Archive declassification complete.
      Overwatch "Uprising" mission file status: OPEN.
      Commencing playback in 3...2...1...
      Get ready for the ultimate recall. Our latest seasonal event turns back the clock, giving you the chance to relive a pivotal moment in Overwatch history. Explore the stories behind some of your favorite heroes, unlock pieces of the past with over 100 declassified Loot Box items, or suit up with your friends and join Tracer on her very first mission in a brand-new cooperative brawl.
      It's time to rewind the future. Welcome to Overwatch Uprising! 
      CELEBRATE THE OVERWATCH LEGACY
      Starting today, all in-game Loot Boxes have been replaced with Uprising Loot Boxes. These special time capsules have been filled to the brim with mementos from the earlier eras of Overwatch—including Mercy’s "Combat Medic Ziegler" and Tracer’s "Cadet Oxton" skins, "Talon Widowmaker," "Blackwatch Genji," "Blackwatch McCree," and more!

      As with our previous events, any Loot Boxes you earn or purchase will contain at least one skin, highlight intro, emote, spray, or player icon from the Overwatch Uprising collection. While the contents of each Uprising Loot Box are random, you can unlock a variety of these cosmetic customization options with credits in the Hero Gallery throughout the event's duration.

      Once you've unlocked an Overwatch Uprising item, it will be yours forever, which means you can use it all-year round. The collection will be re-encrypted on May 1, however, when the event concludes, so be sure to fire up your favorite gaming machine and browse the archives before it's too late!
      WELCOME TO THE TEAM, AGENTS
      From now until May 1, you and three friends must journey seven years into the past, joining forces as Tracer, Torbjörn, Reinhardt, and Mercy to quell an uprising on the streets of King’s Row. A group of omnic separatists known as Null Sector has overwhelmed the area, and you must defeat the robots to liberate the city. The future depends on you.
      To defeat this new threat, you’ll need to work together with your team, developing new strategies and adapting on the fly as the seemingly unstoppable force continues its assault. The robots of Null Sector will stop at nothing—so you and your fellow agents need to be prepared for anything.
      THE OMNIC UPRISING BEGINS
      We're also decrypting more of Overwatch’s history over on our social media channels, so be sure to follow us on Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram for additional intel. And as always, don't forget to keep an eye on playoverwatch.com to stay up to date with the latest game news.

      Overwatch Uprising is live RIGHT NOW on Windows PC, PlayStation 4, and Xbox One—so get out there, soldier, and make Commander Morrison proud.
    • By Starym

       
      The new event brings new patch notes, and aside from all the new stuff added for Uprising, we're finally getting some Hero backstory available in-game in the Hero Gallery, the tie-breaking feature from the PTR, Custom Game Browser improvements, as well as big changes to Lucio, for his healing, wall-riding and gun! Also Orisa was made smaller. Well, her hitbox at least. Would this qualify as fat-shaming, even if she's a robot?
      Blizzard (source)
      PATCH HIGHLIGHTS:
      New Seasonal Event: Overwatch Uprising
      Starting today, we’re rewinding the future, giving you the chance to relive the stories behind some of your favorite Overwatch heroes. Suit up with your friends and travel seven years into the past, joining Tracer on her very first mission in a brand-new cooperative brawl; or collect more than 100 declassified Loot Box items—including skins, highlight intros, emotes, sprays, and player icons!
      For more information, click here.
       
      GENERAL
      General
      Details about each hero’s unique backstory, along with information about some of their lore-inspired skins, have been added to the Hero Gallery [PC] The Player Report system has been redesigned, adding new reporting options and activity examples to better capture the reason for each report In-game voice conversations for the Overwatch Uprising event can now be displayed as subtitles. This can be enabled under the “Sound” tab in the “Options” menu
      Competitive Play
      A tracking system has been added to Assault and Assault/Escort Maps that will allow us to break ties based on the progress that was made toward capturing the objective.
      Developer Comments: To mitigate draws in Competitive Play, we're implementing a system that tracks each team's progress on the objective. This will work similarly to the system that's already in place for Escort and Assault/Escort maps, which grants a win to the team that pushes the payload the furthest. Now, even if neither team successfully captures the objective, a winner can be determined based on which team captured the largest portion.
      Custom Games and Game Browser
      Custom Game settings can now be saved as a preset from the game’s details page. This can be accessed by right-clicking on the map image from the Create Game page, right-clicking a game name from inside the Game Browser, or via the save button on the settings page Players can now change weapon clip and magazine size or grant unlimited ammunition when creating a custom game
      Maps
      A new route has been added to Eichenwalde that connects the attacking team's spawn area to the capture point
        HERO UPDATES
      Lúcio
      Sonic Amplifier Damage increased by 25% Projectile speed increased from 40 to 50 Alternate fire now considers vertical orientation when knocking targets back Crossfade Area of effect radius has been decreased from 30 meters to 10 meters Heal Song Healing-per-second has been increased by 30% (also applies to Lúcio's Amp It Up ability) Self-healing has been reduced by 25% Wall Ride Movement speed increased by 20% when wall riding Lúcio now receives a burst of speed when leaping off a wall Developer Comments: Lúcio has often felt like a must-pick due to his raw healing output and the versatility of providing a speed bonus to your entire team. The goal of these changes is to keep those elements feeling strong, but making them harder to apply to everyone on your team at all times. The end result is that he should feel stronger with teams that he can stay close to but not as strong when on teams with heroes that are often spread out (such as Pharah, Widow, Genji, etc). Much of Lúcio’s character power was tied up in his large passive auras, which caused other elements of his kit to be weakened over time in an attempt to balance him. Now that his auras are more focused it will allow them to be much stronger and allow Lúcio to be more active in his role.
      Orisa
      The size of Orisa’s head hitbox has been decreased by 15%  
      BUG FIXES
      General
      Fixed an issue preventing voice lines from being played on Control maps
      Competitive Play
      Fixed an issue that was preventing Top 500 icons from appearing until after completing a competitive match Fixed a bug preventing achievements from being unlocked during off-season competitive matches Fixed a bug that forced Play of the Game highlights to be drawn from the last round of play
      Custom Games and Game Browser
      Fixed an issue allowing empty player slots to be displayed even when disabled (e.g. in 6v1 games) Fixed a bug preventing the pause feature from working properly after the original host has left the match Fixed a bug that allowed extremely long team names Removed unnecessary customization options (e.g. cooldown options for abilities with no cooldown)
      Heroes
      Ana no longer cocks her rifle after throwing a grenade The brightness on Bastion's golden gun has been toned down when the BlizzCon skin is equipped Fixed a bug causing Mei's pinky to bend awkwardly in some poses when her Chang'e and Luna skins were equipped
      Maps
      Fixed a bug on Eichenwalde that allowed enemy player outlines to be seen through a pile of dirt at the castle gate Fixed an issue on Eichenwalde that allowed players to become trapped in the broken castle doors Fixed a bug that allowed Sombra to reach unintended locations on King's Row Fixed a bug that allowed players to reach unintended areas on the Capture the Flag version of Lijiang Tower Fixed a bug that allowed Symmetra to hide turrets in unintended locations on Oasis Previous patch notes.
    • By Starym

      The new event starts later today and will feature an Omnic takeover, as well as old-school Overwatch uniforms!
       
      The official announcement is still expected to come today, but the French version slipped by a little earlier! it seems we have a bit of time travel and an Insurrection on our hands! Overwatch's next event is going back to the Omnic takeover of King's Row, seemingly and hopefully featuring another PvE game mode similar to the Halloween one. As usual it will bring hundreds of new skins, sprays, and everything else, with the new skins focusing on the old Overwatch organization uniforms, as well as some Blackwatch action for McCree and, more impressively Genji, who gets to show of his physique. The non mech-kind. Well, half of it anyway. There was also a new comic released recently covering this same era and topic, so if you want a bit more lore and backstory on it, check it out.
      The event looks to be starting later today (or tomorrow, depending on where you are), April 11th and will last until May 1st!
      Redditor dewse translated the contents of the trailer:
      Soldier 76: Morrison here. London has been attacked. King's Row has fallen. We are on the edge of an open war.
      News voice: Hundreds are dead. Injured counts themselves by the thounsands.
      Soldier 76: Your time to play, Overwatch.
      Reinhardt: Lieutenant Wilhelm on duty! We're not going to let you down, commander!
      Mercy: We're going to save as many lives as possible!
      Reyes: Blackwatch agents are signaling presense of important fortifications: Null Sector controls the whole zone.
      Bjorn: Leave this to an expert. I've got a little surprise for them!
      Reyes: Intervention team, we're counting on you, and take care of the new recruit!
      Tracer: You can count on me, chief!