demonardvark

Overwatch: Is The Brawl Mode a Hit or Miss?

Sign in to follow this  

5 posts in this topic

JJNWmIW.jpg

To all agents of Overwatch, we are fast approaching the one month anniversary of Overwatch. Overwatch was launched initially with four modes, namely Quick Play, Play vs. AI. Custom Game, and a Weekly Brawl. The weekly brawl implements a specific set of rules and potential character restrictions to each match. So far we have seen five different brawls, including Arcade, Super Shamida Bros, Mystery Heroes, We're All Soldiers Now, and Overly Defensive.

I went out to the internet to ask the community what their opinion of each brawl was. Both polls and interviews were made and conducted on various outlets, including Icy Veins, Gamefaqs, Twitter, and Reddit. The results were collected and analyzed, however I do not possess hard numbers on how many matches were played (that info is hard to obtain).

The results were actually rather surprising. The two most popular brawls were "Arcade" and "Mystery Heroes". Arcade was applauded for its reduced cooldowns and Mystery Heroes was favoured for the spontaneity of it. The other brawls however, were frowned upon in general. "We're all Heroes now" was rated the worst and referred to as "Call of Duty: Overwatch". Truth be told, although "Arcade" and "Mystery Heroes" scored the highest of the brawls, they still scored very low. 

People in general don't seem to like the brawl mode, but why?

The Brawls are viewed as pointless and wastes of time. They are also considered poorly balanced, as is in the case of Arcade, where some heroes become flat out broken. The brawls are criticized as being restrictive or just stupid. Lastly, there is reduced experience gained in brawl mode. Why bother brawling under restrictive measures and getting reduced rewards for it? There needs to be some incentive for actually playing these brawls.

Is there something that can raise the opinion of brawls? Something that would make the players want to do them? Well, the community in fact, had an answer for that. Again the results were almost unanimous as to what people wanted. So, what is this magic fix for brawls? What can make people rush home to queue up for them? The answer is this magic little box, known as the loot box.

This is the incentive players want for Brawl mode. The biggest comparison made was with another blizzard franchise, Hearthstone. In their weekly mode, you get rewarded for participating, and people want to see that from the Brawl mode in Overwatch. Ideas have ranged from rewarding for first brawl win of the week, for playing X games, or for playing simply one game. People hesitate for it to require a win amount because trolls could try to make the process miserable for people. Having it after only one game wouldn't help in the long run, since everyone would play the one match and stop. Regardless, many agree that Blizzard should change it so that in some way, you are rewarded loot boxes for playing Brawl mode. 

So, will Blizzard listen to the community? Will Brawl mode ever get loot box rewards, or will the mode slowly fade into obscurity? Especially with "Competitive Mode" looming, brawl mode may be struggling to stay afloat. It's very likely that people will go for either Competitive or Quick Play and forsake all other modes. 

Tell us what you think. Would you play brawl mode if there were loot box rewards? Do you think they need rewards, or do you think brawl mode will develop its own niche following? Let us know in the comments below.

Happy Brawling!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Either give a loot box for your first win each day/week or some currency.  Right now there's now reward or incentive to play te brawls besides curiosity and the want for a bit of a change.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think in its current incarnation that the weekly brawl is a miss.  While it may be fun once it does not offer the same creativeness as the Hearthstone brawl.  Also it has no incentive to try the mode.  The easy way to fix this is eliminate the worst brawls and reward players for playing outside the box (A.k.a Loot box).  I suggest maybe a contest or something to allow the community to invent new weekly brawls they would like to see.  As in Hearthstone, give a loot crate for first win that week. 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think most people who would play 1 brawl a week for a lootbox will play a brawl a week just to see how it plays, even without any rewards at all.

The easy way to make brawl mode played more would be to make it also competitive, with each week having it's own ranking.

Then you could also give rewards for position, some formula like  roundUp(1000/position) gold. (obviously a better formula, but that gives the idea) Whatever gives "you won a single match and that's it" people ~10 gold, and the best player of the week 1000 gold, second 995 gold, etc...

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 hours ago, DashivaDan said:

I think most people who would play 1 brawl a week for a lootbox will play a brawl a week just to see how it plays, even without any rewards at all.

The easy way to make brawl mode played more would be to make it also competitive, with each week having it's own ranking.

Then you could also give rewards for position, some formula like  roundUp(1000/position) gold. (obviously a better formula, but that gives the idea) Whatever gives "you won a single match and that's it" people ~10 gold, and the best player of the week 1000 gold, second 995 gold, etc...

That is actually a really good idea I don't think I've heard yet. Doing competitive brawl mode. If you add a ladder there will be people who want to climb it :D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Starym
      Yesterday on the Overwatch League stream we had a big reveal for Twitch All Access Pass holders, with Lúcio receiving his first legenday emote, and it's a doozy too! Coming out on July 24th, the emote joins the 15 league skins, twitch emotes, a global twitch chat badge, a lot of various insider content as well as an in-game spray and player icon. The Lúcio emote looks like one of the most complex ones to date and is probably the most worth-while item in the whole package, so make sure to check it out.
      All Access Pass (source)
      Every match day, the Overwatch League Twitch chat morphs into a virtual arena, where fans from across the globe gather to cheer on their favorite teams. Now, the time has come to stand out. The Overwatch League All-Access Pass on Twitch is for our superfans: an evolving VIP badge that you can wear in game and in Twitch chat, and that offers a premium viewing experience and behind-the scenes access.
      Let’s look at some of the features.
      LÚCIO LEGENDARY EMOTE
      Get ready to break it down with a new legendary Lúcio emote! This limited-time exclusive is available starting Tuesday, July 24, to all Twitch All-Access passholders. If you’re not already an All-Access member, go here to join. Read on to learn more about the great content you’ll get as an All-Access member.
      PLAYERS PACK
      As announced on Twitch Day on April 14, All-Access passholders will receive 12 Overwatch League team away skins in May. The skins, which will represent one fan-favorite hero for each team, will be automatically deposited into the game accounts linked with All-Access passholders.
      Insider Content
      To allow super fans to dive deeper into the league they love, the All-Access Pass grants access to the Overwatch League Command Center: a second-screen match-day livestream, featuring alternate in-game camera angles, backstage cameras, player POVs, and real-time stats. Your pass also provides access to exclusive behind-the-scenes VODs. In Stage 3, this will be in the form of a weekly series called Behind the Screens, in which an Overwatch League player will give their own analysis of a recent game.
      We know Overwatch League fans love interacting with their favorite players, so All-Access Passholders will be able to view and contribute to Match Day AMAs. Passholders can participate by submitting questions in chat during a special player livestream following the conclusion of Overwatch League broadcasts.
      To celebrate the launch of the program—and to give all Overwatch League fans a taste of what the All-Access Pass experience will offer—the Command Center, Behind the Screens and Match Day AMAs will be free through May 15th!
      Twitch Content
      Overwatch League All-Access Pass will offer 23 global emotes, including gold team emotes and character ability emotes:
      To further show off in chat, All-Access grants you a global chat badge, so you can rep the Overwatch League on Twitch no matter where you are. And in Overwatch League chat itself, you’ll have the global badge and a subscription icon (if you have Twitch Prime, we’ve made it look a little extra-special).
      You’ll be able to show off your badges and try out these new emotes in the subscriber-only Twitch chat room, where super fans from around the world can enjoy in-depth conversations.
      All-Access also will grant an ad-free Overwatch League experience on Twitch.
      In-Game Content
      All-Access passholders to be able to proudly declare their fandom within the game itself, and here’s how:
      Overwatch League in-game skins.  
      In-game spray and player icon. The Overwatch League All-Access Pass is available for USD $29.99 for the inaugural season.  All Access Pass benefits will last up to the start of the 2019 OWL Season—Twitch emotes, badges, and in-game content are yours to keep! A Blizzard account link is required to redeem in-game rewards. For more information or to purchase, head to https://www.twitch.tv/p/overwatchleague.
    • By Starym
      More feedback on the LFG and Endorsement systems and it seems they've had a massive positive effect on toxicity of players and are making the game much more enjoyable! So far we only got stats for KR and the Americas with EU coming later, but the numbers are very impressive nonetheless:
      Jeff Kaplan (source)
      Our Global Insights group just finished parsing some stats as it relates to LFG and Endorsements.
      Post release of Endorsements and LFG:
      The % of Competitive Matches that Contain Abusive Chat is down:
      26.4% in the Americas
      16.4% in KR
      The % of Daily Players being Abusive is down:
      28.8% in the Americas
      21.6% in KR
      We’re really pleased with the community’s efforts to make OW a better place! Thank you all!
      And we’ll keep working on iterating on these features to make them better as well as exploring other systems to improve the gameplay environment.
      ...
      We don’t have all the stats reported yet… sorry… I was just sharing what progress we had…
      ...
      Yes, some quality of life changes are coming very soon. For example, in an upcoming patch the LFG system will persist your filters across logins.
      So the new social systems greatly improved quality of life in the game, but even if they hadn't, it's great to see Blizzard trying new things to improve community interaction, especially since it working in one game can easily be transferred to other games as well. Imagine if your acceptance into a M+ or raid group was based off of recommendations and endorsements instead of raw ilevel and achievements alone...
    • By Starym
      Activision Blizzard signed a historic deal for the broadcast rights to the Overwatch League on US television. For the next 2 years ESPN, Disney XD and ABC will be covering the league events, both live and as summaries. This marks the first time esports will be shown in prime time on a major network, with the quarter and semifinals aired live on DisneyXD and ESPN 2 and 3, while the finals will be shown on both ESPN, ESPN 2 and Disney XD. The package also includes the very first airing of competitive gaming on ABC, one of the big four broadcast networks in the US, with the highlights recap of the finals airing on July 29th. This marks a huge step forward for esports and its presence in the mainstream media, and it seems appropriate for Overwatch to make this first step, as it's already pushed into the pop culture realm.

      The playoffs have already started, so check out the schedule below, as well as comments from both ESPN, DisneyXD and Activision Blizzard themselves:
      Overwatch League (source)
      ESPN, Disney XD and Blizzard Entertainment Announce Multiyear Exclusive Telecast Agreement for Overwatch League™
       
      Jul 11, 2018   Comprehensive 2018 coverage including Overwatch League playoffs and Grand Finals across ESPN and Disney television networks Telecast schedules for 2019 Overwatch League content to be announced IRVINE, Calif--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Jul. 11, 2018-- Today ESPN, Disney XD and Blizzard Entertainment announced an exclusive multiyear agreement for live television coverage of the Overwatch League™, the world’s first major global city-based esports league.
      Beginning with Overwatch League playoff coverage on Wednesday, July 11, across both networks, the 2017–2018 Overwatch League inaugural season concludes with the Grand Finals live from Barclays Center in Brooklyn, New York, on ESPN and Disney XD July 27–28. All coverage also will be available for ESPN and Disney network subscribers to stream live on the ESPN App and DisneyNOW. To round out the 2018 Grand Finals coverage, a recap show highlighting the biggest moments will air July 29 on ABC. The Grand Finals telecast on ESPN marks the first time live competitive gaming has aired on the flagship network in primetime, and will be the first broadcast of an esports championship on ABC.
      “The Overwatch League Grand Finals is by far our most comprehensive television distribution for an esports event over a single weekend: 10 total hours over four networks and three days,” said Justin Connolly, Executive Vice President, Affiliate Sales and Marketing, Disney and ESPN Media Networks. “This overall collaboration with Disney/ABC, ESPN and Blizzard represents our continued commitment to esports, and we look forward to providing marquee Overwatch League coverage across our television platforms for fans.”
      “We are pleased to partner with Activision Blizzard to bring Overwatch esports to our audience. The Blizzard team has created a genre-leading esport and a premium professional franchise system in the Overwatch League,” said Marc Buhaj, Senior Vice President, Programming and General Manager, Disney XD. “We are kicking off the agreement by showcasing the inaugural season playoffs and Grand Finals live across our linear footprint. Together with our telecast partners at ESPN, we look forward to growing a legion of new Overwatch fans across the next two years.”
      “We’re excited to be working with ESPN and DisneyXD to bring Overwatch esports to an even wider audience,” said Pete Vlastelica, President and CEO of Activision Blizzard Esports Leagues. “We’ve seen incredible passion and support from fans during the inaugural season of the Overwatch League, and we’re looking forward to capping it off for them with an epic Grand Finals at Barclays Center later this month.”
      The inaugural season of the Overwatch League will culminate in the Grand Finals, the ultimate showdown for the championship: the first team to win two best-of-five matches at Barclays Center will take home the Overwatch League trophy and the lion’s share of the $1.4 million Grand Finals prize pool. Play begins Friday, July 27, at 7 p.m. EDT with the first best-of-five match on ESPN, and continues Saturday, July 28, at 4:30 p.m. EDT with the second and potential third series on Disney XD. This broadcast will air alongside the primary digital viewing experience on Twitch, with the Overwatch League also available via MLG.com. A re-air of day two Grand Finals play will be available on ESPN2 at 9 p.m. EDT. In addition, a recap show of highlights from the Grand Finals will air Sunday, July 29, at 3 p.m. EDT on ABC. The full telecast schedule, from the playoffs through the Grand Finals, is below.
      Overwatch League 2017–2018 Playoffs and Grand Finals Telecast Schedule (all times Eastern)
                                Date       Time (EDT)       Event       Network(s) Wed, July 11       8 p.m.       Day 1 of Quarterfinals       Disney XD, ESPN3 Fri, July 13       8 p.m.       Day 2 of Quarterfinals       Disney XD, ESPN3 Sat, July 14       4 p.m.       Day 3 of Quarterfinals       Disney XD, ESPN3 Wed, July 18       8 p.m.       Day 1 of Semifinals       Disney XD, ESPN3 Fri, July 20       7 p.m.       Day 2 of Semifinals       ESPNEWS Sat, July 21       7 p.m.       Day 3 of Semifinals       ESPN2 Fri, July 27       7 p.m.       Day 1 of Finals       ESPN Sat, July 28       4:30 p.m.       Day 2 of Finals       Disney XD, ESPN3 Sat, July 28       9 p.m.       Day 2 of Finals       ESPN2 (re-air) Sun, July 29       3 p.m.       Highlights Recap       ABC, ESPN3                           About the Overwatch League™
      The Overwatch League™ is the first major global professional esports league with city-based teams across Asia, Europe, and North America. Overwatch® was created by globally acclaimed publisher Blizzard Entertainment (a division of Activision Blizzard—Nasdaq: ATVI), whose iconic franchises have helped lay the foundations and push the boundaries of professional esports over the last 15 years. The latest addition to Blizzard’s stable of twenty-one #1 games, Overwatch was built from the ground up for online competition, with memorable characters and fast-paced action designed for the most engaging gameplay and spectator experiences. To learn more about the Overwatch League, visit www.overwatchleague.com.
      Cautionary Note Regarding Forward-looking Statements: Information in this press release that involves Blizzard Entertainment’s expectations, plans, intentions or strategies regarding the future, including statements about the exclusive multiyear agreement for live television coverage of the Overwatch League with ESPN and Disney XD, and the dates, events and features of the Overwatch League, are forward-looking statements that are not facts and involve a number of risks and uncertainties. Factors that could cause Blizzard Entertainment’s actual future results to differ materially from those expressed in the forward-looking statements set forth in this release include unanticipated product delays and other factors identified in the risk factors sections of Activision Blizzard’s most recent annual report on Form 10-K and any subsequent quarterly reports on Form 10-Q. The forward-looking statements in this release are based upon information available to Blizzard Entertainment and Activision Blizzard as of the date of this release, and neither Blizzard Entertainment nor Activision Blizzard assumes any obligation to update any such forward-looking statements. Forward-looking statements believed to be true when made may ultimately prove to be incorrect. These statements are not guarantees of the future performance of Blizzard Entertainment or Activision Blizzard and are subject to risks, uncertainties and other factors, some of which are beyond its control and may cause actual results to differ materially from current expectations.
    • By Starym
      The 86th Floor and Hype Creations teamed up to bring us this massive Overwatch cosplay music video, set to Shibuya Sunrise’s original track “Know my place” and featuring so many Heroes and skins in action. Opening with 3 reapers on one team and a McCree that let his bear go a little, the video goes through a few rounds of face-offs and ends with everyone figuring out who the real threat is. Enjoy:
       
    • By Starym
      The Overwatch cosplay community is very active, imaginative and talented, and as a result we've seen plenty of both accurate and impressive Hero looks so far, but today's adds a little bit of exo-suit crafting as well! Gryphon's Gears constructed a great (and functional/usable) version of D.Va's White Rabbit mech skin:

        
      Hopefully it doesn't have the self destruct ult so it stays around a long time.
      Also, let's look forward to/hope for a working Wrecking Ball one with rolling included!