Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

New to Resto Shaman [Help]

5 posts in this topic

Good day,

My name is Shirushi and I am new to the shaman class. I have been healing now since Emerald Nightmare has come out, and I feel that I am missing something with my healing. I know really vague right. I want to be able to maximize my HPS, but according to the logs especially on the Cenarius attempts in Log 2 my healing seems to be lacking. I am attempting to stick to the rotation as much as possible and I know my timing on my totems is a little off. If you require more information please let me know. My artifact weapon has 25 points in it, and my next artifact trait will be Tidal Pools.

I have tried Cloudburst Totem but was having issues working it into rotation properly, our raid group usually stays as spread out as possible which I know hurts my healing a little. I am looking for any advice that can be given on helping me better understand the Resto Shaman and to master the class. Below are my armory link and two logs that I have gathered.

Armory Link

Log 1

Log 2

Edited by Shirushi

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Hello and welcome to the forums :)

Well, let's start from the very start.

Your Artifact weapon: I see you followed the guide.

Well, I personally disagree with the posted there paths order. The standard way for a resto shaman is right down path to Queen's Decree, then left upper path to Tidal Pools, and then you make your way to the 3rd Gold through Ghost in the Mist->Sense of Urgency->Floodwaters. Some people prefer the right side to the 3rd Gold through Caress of Tidemother and Servant of the Queen but this is very minor difference. This way is the fastest to get all three Golds. You spent a lot of time with 5 traits that do almost nothing to your healing (Ghost in the Mistx3, Refreshing Currents, Sense of Urgency is doubtful because in how many fights so far Heroism was paired with some serious healing? Not many, right?) instead of going right away for Empowered Droplets and Tidal Pools that both directly add to your Healing Done.

Anyways, it's not your fault and there's nothing you can do now about it now but it is a part of doing less healing.

Your gear: not even one enchant and a Crit gem? Our best secondary stat is Mastery. There are some arguments what's the next - Haste or Crit, but there's no doubt about Mastery so you gem and enchant Mastery or Intellect. 

Your Haste is very low, so not only you miss additional ticks of Riptide and totems but cast more slowly too. If you do not agree with Haste being second best after Mastery, it still should be somewhere on pair with Crit.

Now the logs:

First thing: 5 healers for 20-man Normal are way too many even with your raid average ilvl. You know that resto shamans Mastery makes us great when the raid is on low HP and awful when the raid HP is higher than 70-80%. You have nothing to heal  - with 5 healers and low damage shamans unfortunately would be the worst.

The talents: the build you are using in raids is a 5-man build. For the raids it's High Tide, CBT and Ancestral Guidance mostly. 

You are extremely conservative with mana hardly casting Chain Healing and Healing Surge even that you sit on full mana most of time according to the logs.


Well, it feels like there are plenty little things all over the place and while every one of them is not that bad, all together they make a difference.

So let me just shortly sum the things:

1. There is no such a thing as 'rotation' for healers. I think that this idea ruins your performance a lot because you try 'push' things to the places they don't belong.^^

There are priorities though:

- always drop HST on CD - no exclusions. Use a Weakaura as a reminder

- always use Riptide on CD - no exclusions. If everyone is on full HP, use it on tanks.

- always keep Healing Rain on melee camp if there's no other specific place to use it.

- try to use major Raid CDs as much as possible, never keep them for some vague future possible damage that most of time never happens.

- if you have 3 or more injured people, use Chain Healing - your goal is to finish a fight with 10% of mana or less. There's no reason to sit on full mana all the time. Use mana pot when going OOM.

- learn to play with CBT - it does 10-14% of overall raid healing, there's no reason to avoid it. Start with just dropping it on CD after casting Healing Rain and then you can easily charge it with a couple of CH and the rest of healing you are normally doing. Get a weakaura that shows how much healing it stored - it will help you to plan your casts.

- grab your Artifact Gold Traits asap - don't get any more utility traits before Golds.


Enough for now I think :) If you have any questions, do not hesitate to ask.

1 person likes this

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Thank you Pandacho, originally I was following the guide which is why I did everything I could to craft the mastery and crit gear. After reading the forums earlier this week I believe that you are absolutely right that it should be Mastery > Haste > Crit, which is why I have started putting on some of the Mastery and Haste gear.

Is there a soft cap for haste for shamans that we should be trying to reach, I have currently switched to Haste food to help bring my haste up and I believe when I am buffed with the food my haste is at about 11%.

We are in the midsts of going through our raid make-up and I do notice that a lot of the time there is nothing to heal or I am just triage healing. I honestly think that with 20 people in a raid group that 3 healers should be sufficient as long as you have the right 3 healers :P.

I am going to be making more crafted gear to replace some of the pieces that I have, just wish I had an endless supply of gold to make it a little quicker as patience is definitely not a strong suit of mine.

135k and I will the 2nd Gold trait.

Will keep you posted.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites


Great that you are figuring out the things :)

3 healers for 20-man Normal are definitely enough. Same would go for HC progression up to Cenarius and Xavius. If you are really struggling, bring 4, but not 5-6. I saw guilds bringing 6 healers to HC progression and it never went very well because every additional healer means less dps -> longer fights-> more bad abilities goes out -> more stuff to heal and it just converts to an endless circle of trying to get a boss down by healing it to the death. 

And frankly, any healers comp would be fine while you are not stacking the same class.

Regarding the amount of secondary stats, i'd suggest you to look at raw numbers rather than percents because having passive 24% of Mastery and 5% of Crit makes the relative percentage a bit awkward. 

I'm trying to keep the difference between secondary stats 2-3K.

For example Mastery=9000, Haste=6500, Crit=4500, Vers=1500 (in percents you'll see a completely different picture for the same numbers as Mastery=101%, Haste=20%, Crit=23.6%, Vers=3.7%). You can see that if you rely on percents ratio, your gearing will pretty much go south because with exactly the same gear looking at numbers gives you Mast>Haste>Crit>Vers with a 'normal' gaps, while percentage changes it to Mast>Crit>Haste>Vers with 80% gap between Mastery and other stats and an awful 3% in Vers.

I would suggest you to run Mythics+ for gear, it doesn't cost gold and you can get really nice pieces. I run up to +8 so far and find a resto shaman completely fine on healing, great on utility and not bad on dps.

1 person likes this

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
15 hours ago, Pandacho said:

- always use Riptide on CD - no exclusions. If everyone is on full HP, use it on tanks.

- always keep Healing Rain on melee camp if there's no other specific place to use it.

Debatable for max healing healing rain isn't even worth it don't take deluge take the raid CD Ancestral Guidance.

Only Riptide when mobile or needing to conserve mana

Cast chain heal

Also really important take high tide over Ascendance


Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By molodirazz
      All applications will be reviewed and considered however if you are playing a class/spec combination we need then your chances of joining will be higher.
      A little bit of info about us:
      We are a group of friends and serious raiders on EU Twisting Nether looking to recruit skilled like-minded players into our roster for Mythic Legion raids and onwards. We will offer a sociable and fun raiding environment while maintaining a strong desire for progression. Our Discord is very active and we encourage all members to chat and play together not only for raids. The guild formed late March 2016 and fully cleared 13/13 Mythic Hellfire Citadel pre nerf shortly after. We've since been improving our world ranking every tier.
      We currently raid 3 days per week on Mythic: Wednesday, Sunday and Tuesday 19:15-22:15 server time. While it is not a lot we try to make the most out of our time. We run optional heroic/normal/alt/previous tier raids during off days in which raiders are welcome to come to. Our members also play other games outside raid times together where anyone is welcome to join(LoL, Dota, HotS, Overwatch etc.).
      Our loot system for Mythic is RC Loot Council.
      What we expect from you:
      - We are a raiding guild with only a 9 hour per week schedule so you are expected to attend and be ON TIME! However we understand things can come up sometimes but please let us know.
      - Be able to speak and understand the English language and not be afraid to communicate with other members during raids.
      - Actively doing dungeons/world quests to improve your gear and artifact weapon.
      - Have a strong understanding of the current raid tier and be able to play your class to it's potential.
      - Always come to raids prepared(i.e. bringing food and potions, etc).
      - Come fully gemmed and enchanted with the correct stats for your class and spec.
      - Access to Discord and a working microphone.
      - Have a computer that can handle 20 man raiding and a good, stable internet connection.
      - Exorsus Raid Tools, Weakauras2 and RC Loot Council addons installed. We may ask you to install others.

      If you have any further questions please contact us at battletags: Vims#21684 Azkey#21565
      To apply please visit our guild website:
      Requirements to be considered into current main raids:
      - 905~ ilvl
      - 40+ traits.
      - 6 or more mythic kills in NH.
      - Exceptions to the requirements may be made.
      We're currently looking for the classes below but may consider other classes as well.
      Druid: Balance and Restoration.
      Hunter: BM and Survival.
      Monk: Mistweaver and Windwalker.
      Shaman: Restoration.
      Priest: Holy.
      Warlock: Affli/Destro.
      Any and all applications be considered.
    • By Rexene
      I am looking for critiques of my custom stat weights.  I want to improve it and get advice if there is a better way of calculating my numbers.  If you see basic errors with my number crunching, please let me know.
      Naked_Normal - 4608
      Naked_Crit - 9216
      Naked_Ticks - 6
      Naked_Extra_Tick - 0
      Naked_Tooltip_Rejuv - 26382
      Naked_Actual_Rejuv_with_4.8%_Mastery - 27648
      Naked_Actual_Rejuv_w/o_4.8%_Mastery - 26381.6 [Calculated by (Naked_Actual_Rejuv_with_4.8%_Mastery / 104.8%) = 27648 / 1.048 = 26,381.6]

      1421_Int_Trinket_Normal - 5502
      1421_Int_Trinket_Crit - 11002
      1421_Int_Trinket_Ticks - 6
      1421_Int_Trinket_Extra_Tick - 0
      I used a 1421 Int Trinket and ignored the crit procs.  We have 4.8% Mastery, which adds 4.8% to our healing even with no gear.  I divided by 1.048 to try to get to the base healing.
      Int_Weight = (6 x (1421_Int_Trinket_Normal - Naked_Normal) / 1.048) / 1421 [1421 in the amount of Intellect on the Trinket]
      Int_Weight = (6 x (5502-4608)/1.048) / 1421
      Int_Weight = 3.602

      1165_Mastery_Ring_Normal - 4685
      1165_Mastery_Ring_Crit - 9369
      1165_Mastery_Ring_Ticks - 6
      1165_Mastery_Ring_Extra_Tick - 0
      I used a 1165 Mastery and crit ring and then ignored the crit procs.
      Mastery_Weight = (6 x ((1165_Mastery_Ring_Normal - Naked_Normal) / 1.048)) / 1165 [1165 is the amount of Mastery on the Ring]
      Mastery_Weight = (6 x ((4685 - 4608) / 1.048)) / 1165
      Mastery_Weight = 0.3784

      406_Leech_Ring_Normal - 83
      406_Leech_Ring_Crit - 165
      406_Leech_Ring_Ticks - 6
      406_Leech_Ring_Extra_Tick - 0
      I used a Ring with 406 Leech, 745 Mastery and 1626 Crit.
      Leech_Weight = ((6 x 406_Leech_Ring_Normal - 745 * Mastery_Weight) / 1.048) / 406 [406 is the amount of Leech on the Ring]
      Leech_Weight = ((6 x 83 - 745 * 0.3784) / 1.048) / 406 [406 is the amount of Leech on the Ring]
      Leech_Weight = 0.5079

      945_Haste_Ring_Normal - 4608
      945_Haste_Ring_Crit - 9216
      945_Haste_Ring_Ticks - 6
      945_Haste_Ring_Extra Tick - 1
      945_Haste_Ring_Extra_Tick_Amount - 583
      I used a Ring with 945 Haste and 1626 Crit and ignored Crit procs.
      Haste_Weight = (945_Haste_Ring_Extra_Tick_Amount / 1.048) / 945 [945 is the amount of Haste on the Ring]
      Haste_Weight = (583 / 1.048) / 945
      Haste_Weight = 0.5887

      1055_Versatility_Trinket_Normal - 4710
      1055_Versatility_Trinket_Crit - 9420
      1055_Versatility_Trinket_Ticks - 6
      1055_Versatility_Trinket_Extra_Tick - 0
      I used a Trinket with 1055 Versatility and no other stats.
      Vers_Weight = (6 x ((1055_Versatility_Trinket_Normal - Naked_Normal) / 1.048)) / 1055 [1055 is the amount of Versatility on the Trinket]
      Vers_Weight = (6 x ((4710 - 4608) / 1.048)) / 1055
      Vers_Weight = 0.5535

      UI tooltip crit percentage increase for a 6518 Critical Strike with my gear before 6% bonus is 16.30%
      Crit_w_Gear - 16.3%
      Crit_Weight = 6 x (Naked_Crit - Naked_Normal) x (16.3% / 6518) [6518 is the total amount of Crit on my gear]
      Crit_Weight = 6 x (9216 - 4608) x (0.1630 / 6518)
      Crit_Weight = 0.6597

      I am going to increase my mastery weight since I primarily use HOTs and you have a 10% Mastery bonus for every HOT you have on a target.  I am going to increase my Mastery weight arbitrarily by 25% to account for this (choose your own weight as you prefer).  
      Int_Weight = 3.602
      Mastery_Weight+25% = 0.3784 * 125% = 0.4730
      Leech_Weight = 0.5079
      Haste_Weight = 0.5887
      Vers_Weight = 0.5535
      Crit_Weight = 0.6597
      Total_Weight = Int_Weight + Mastery_Weight+25% + Leech_Weight + Haste_Weight + Vers_Weight + Crit_Weight
      Total_Weight = 3.602 + 0.4730 + 0.5079 + 0.5887 + 0.5535 + 1.0690
      Total_Weight = 6.3848

      Int = Int_Weight / Total_Weight x 100% = 3.602 / 6.3848 x 100% = 56.41
      Mastery = Mastery_Weight+25%  / Total_Weight x 100% = 0.4730 / 6.3848 x 100% = 7.41
      Leech = Leech_Weight / Total_Weight x 100% = 0.5079 / 6.3848 x 100% = 7.95
      Haste = Haste_Weight / Total_Weight x 100% = 0.5887 / 6.3848 x 100% = 9.22
      Versatility = Vers_Weight / Total_Weight x 100% = 0.5535 / 6.3848 x 100% = 8.67
      Critical = Crit_Weight / Total_Weight x 100% = 0.6597 / 6.3848 x 100% = 10.33
      My weights
      Int= 56.41
      Mastery = 7.41
      Leech = 7.95
      Haste = 9.22
      Versatility = 8.67
      Critical = 10.33
    • By Damien
      This thread is for comments about our Budget Midrange Jade Elemental Shaman Standard deck.
    • By Damien
      This thread is for comments about our Budget Midrange Elemental Shaman Standard deck.