Starym

Jeff Kaplan on "Troll Picks" and Hero Balance

Sign in to follow this  

8 posts in this topic

LjvfPjh.jpg

OW's Game Director gives a really good answer to the everlasting balance question.

 

Balance is one of those basically unattainable goals in all games (except for maybe SC1), and Overwatch is no exception. At any point in the game's lifetime some Hero was OP while another was considered a "troll pick" (ok, so it's Hanzo, it's always been Hanzo, it'll always be Hanzo, but you get the idea). Over on the official forums Game Director Jeff Kaplan addressed this ever persisting issue with a very well thought out response to the question "Will the current effort toward hero balance will completely erase or dissipate those "troll" pick?"

Blizzard LogoJeff Kaplan

It's never our intention to have a hero be perceived as a "troll pick", but that will inevitably happen sometimes. Let's say that we all agreed that all of the heroes were perfectly balanced (just pretend with me), even if we touched nothing, eventually the balance would shift over time due to evolving playstyles, strategies and meta-trends. A lot of us like pro sports and tend to think of those games (soccer, football, hockey, basketball) as "timeless". But if you follow those games closely, the leagues have had to make minor tweaks to the games to keep them fun and balanced over time. It's a weird analogy, but it is very similar to hero balance in a game like Overwatch. In those pro sports, players and coaches evolved their ways of thinking about the game that required the game itself to change at times.

We will absolutely do our best to make sure all of our heroes our viable. With so many heroes, I do believe the playerbase will (at times) decide that certain heroes are out of fashion and therefore deem them as "troll picks". Sometimes this will be very valid. And sometimes it will be perception.

Both Torb and Symmetra are being looked at right now. We want to try to improve them in ways that makes them more fun to play, more enjoyable to have on your team and try to make sure they are not infuriating to play against.

We wrestle with the issue that players get very upset at us when they perceive "the meta is stale" and certain heroes are not viable. Yet it's also very disruptive to the playerbase for us to make changes. It's a bit of a Catch-22 but we do our best to responsibly look at all heroes all the time and make sure nothing is terribly unbalanced or worse, un-fun.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So they say "We will try to do this and that about troll picks" everytime, everywhere and it's their answer to any question.

But will this happen? never in my opinion. Dota2 couldn't do it, LoL couldn't do it, even Blizzard couldn't do it in heroes of the storm (Looking at you Murky)

Instead of balancing heroes (which is impossible) they should try to balance the matchmaking, Trolls with Trolls. You wanna pick a hero regardless of the team comp? and you don't even want to communicate? Then you should be at the Troll League playing with your troll friends, go there pick hanzo + bastion + symmetra + torb on attack!! No one cares.

When you see someone pick Hanzo or Bastion or even Torb on attack in plat! and no matter what, the guy doesn't even talk or chat and never changes accordingly, that's where the problem starts. You try to convince your teammates to change heroes but you end up being the A-Hole who's flaming the team and should stfu and just accept the defeat.

 

Edited by mnime

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 hours ago, mnime said:

So they say "We will try to do this and that about troll picks" everytime, everywhere and it's their answer to any question.

But will this happen? never in my opinion. Dota2 couldn't do it, LoL couldn't do it, even Blizzard couldn't do it in heroes of the storm (Looking at you Murky)

Instead of balancing heroes (which is impossible) they should try to balance the matchmaking, Trolls with Trolls. You wanna pick a hero regardless of the team comp? and you don't even want to communicate? Then you should be at the Troll League playing with your troll friends, go there pick hanzo + bastion + symmetra + torb on attack!! No one cares.

When you see someone pick Hanzo or Bastion or even Torb on attack in plat! and no matter what, the guy doesn't even talk or chat and never changes accordingly, that's where the problem starts. You try to convince your teammates to change heroes but you end up being the A-Hole who's flaming the team and should stfu and just accept the defeat.

Problem is, some picks that are considering trolling can be absolutely superb. It will always depend on the player, as well as the enemy team. I have more problem with people troll picking things such as Winston or Roadhog, for example. When playing KoTH, players will refuse to change from Winston, despite there being a Reaper, Zenyatta, Mei, McCree. 

I don't mind what hero the person picks, as long as it fits the comp and isn't countered hard. I've won games at high Diamond comfortably with a Bastion sitting on the payload, simply because the enemy team won't swap. At the same time, I've lost games miserably with a perfect team setup, if the team was in a vacuum. Instead, my team refuse to swap heroes because "the game is already over, who cares" and our tanks get farmed by Reaper and a Zenyatta. 

I never bother arguing if someone first picks a Torb anymore because I have been proven wrong too many times. I argue when they refuse to swap if it doesn't work.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
11 hours ago, mnime said:

Instead of balancing heroes (which is impossible) they should try to balance the matchmaking, Trolls with Trolls. You wanna pick a hero regardless of the team comp? and you don't even want to communicate? Then you should be at the Troll League playing with your troll friends, go there pick hanzo + bastion + symmetra + torb on attack!! No one cares.

The problem with this is that in OW you can't "balance matchmaking" in the sense that you're talking of.  You pick your hero after the matchmaking is done, and also even if you don't agree with it that player might not be picking a "troll pick" in their mind.  To them the hero might be completely viable.  I also don't think that in OW there are any straight up "troll picks".  I have seen way too many people do amazing things with heroes that I didn't think they could do.

3 hours ago, Blainie said:

Problem is, some picks that are considering trolling can be absolutely superb. It will always depend on the player, as well as the enemy team. I have more problem with people troll picking things such as Winston or Roadhog, for example. When playing KoTH, players will refuse to change from Winston, despite there being a Reaper, Zenyatta, Mei, McCree. 

I don't mind what hero the person picks, as long as it fits the comp and isn't countered hard. I've won games at high Diamond comfortably with a Bastion sitting on the payload, simply because the enemy team won't swap. At the same time, I've lost games miserably with a perfect team setup, if the team was in a vacuum. Instead, my team refuse to swap heroes because "the game is already over, who cares" and our tanks get farmed by Reaper and a Zenyatta. 

I never bother arguing if someone first picks a Torb anymore because I have been proven wrong too many times. I argue when they refuse to swap if it doesn't work.

^ This is the truth of it!  It always comes down to player and team comp.  Symmetra and Torbjorn can both do amazing on attack when they are trying to back enemy teams off of a point or escorting the payload.  Sure they aren't typical for that use, but in the right hands from a strategic player.....they are AMAZING.  I personally LOVE Hanzo, and I use him on attack frequently.  He's one of my main heroes and you would be surprised what I can do with him.  However, if my team comp isn't solid enough to sustain while I do my thing then I don't pick him.  Point being: it's all situational.  People have to be fluid which means changing heroes when they aren't working, but also NOT jumping on someone's case immediately because they don't agree with the pick at match start.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, Blainie said:

I've won games at high Diamond comfortably with a Bastion sitting on the payload, simply because the enemy team won't swap. At the same time, I've lost games miserably with a perfect team setup, if the team was in a vacuum. Instead, my team refuse to swap heroes because "the game is already over, who cares" and our tanks get farmed by Reaper and a Zenyatta. 

When the comp is not working, change it! that's what makes a team great. But if they don't communicate, you're like "OMG WHY GOD! WHY", maybe they are not troll picking, maybe there isn't a thing called "Troll Pick", but as you said when someone picks Winston when they have reaper and he dies too many times and he refuses to change hero, that's exactly trolling.

 

1 hour ago, ghostdeini said:

However, if my team comp isn't solid enough to sustain while I do my thing then I don't pick him.  Point being: it's all situational.  People have to be fluid which means changing heroes when they aren't working

Now that's true, my main point is when it's not working, change it! I always criticize those who don't communicate at all. 

Winston might work vs a reaper, who knows? maybe the reaper is bad, but when it doesn't, you should change! If you don't listen to your teammates and keep dying, you're trolling.

 

Now I've seen this porblem in all the competitive games that blizzard made so far, people with no basic game knowledge reach high ranks, like in heroes of the storm, ranked games in diamond 1!! I cannot remember how many times I tried to convince someone they should help the objective! Why should someone who don't know the basics reach this level of play? Someone who doesn't change Winston vs a Reaper who's raping him should stay in bronze and keeping this guy in the bronze until he learns things is the matchmaking system's job.

The problem with the matchmaking system is that very few things affect the mmr, we should have a button to report ppl for not cooperating, and many other reports that I see in league of legends but not here, atleast in LoL when you reach diamond you see people who know what they are doing, and this is exactly why, unskilled players lose mmr. This should be the case in any game. But this 50% win rate rule blizzard created is screwing everything, if you're unskilled then you shouldn't have a 50% win rate!

 

Edited by mnime

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, mnime said:

we should have a button to report ppl for not cooperating

Things like this are always interesting to me because I'd love to have them, but they are always open to abuse. I imagine with high enough thresholds (so that a small number of reports can't ruin someone's game), it could work nicely to have different styles and reasons for reporting.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, Blainie said:

Things like this are always interesting to me because I'd love to have them, but they are always open to abuse. I imagine with high enough thresholds (so that a small number of reports can't ruin someone's game), it could work nicely to have different styles and reasons for reporting.

Blizzard has like over 4000 employees, they are making billions of dollars every year, they should dedicate a full time team to overcome this. Kinda like what riot games did, there might be ppl who abuse this or get carried away, but there are still Game Masters who check the reports and decide what to do.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 10/23/2016 at 10:59 AM, mnime said:

Blizzard has like over 4000 employees, they are making billions of dollars every year, they should dedicate a full time team to overcome this. Kinda like what riot games did, there might be ppl who abuse this or get carried away, but there are still Game Masters who check the reports and decide what to do.

Ah, but there's always that big defining factor here! Money spent vs. money gained. Let's be honest, it's just not worth it for them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Starym

       
      It seems while trying to improve Moira's Biotic Grasp targeting the team actually made it worse in some cases, as Lead Engineer for Gameplay Systems Tim Ford explains.
      A fix will be coming late this week or early next week.
       
      Tim Ford (source)
      Hi everyone! We wanted to give you a heads up on what’s happening with the targeting on Moira’s Biotic Grasp.
      On the PTR, we made a number of improvements to the mechanism that Moira uses to select a target. Now players can more accurately select a target when multiple targets are in the field of view (which resolves issues like this: https://streamable.com/rosvo), and the new system can better discern which target is closest to the player's reticle when multiple targets are valid.
      When we made this change, we did our best to make the everything feel as close to her original system as possible, but since the new mechanism uses a different functionality, it didn’t convert perfectly for a number of heroes. Generally, the larger heroes are a little harder to target, while the smaller heroes are much closer to her original behavior. The training bots also need to be adjusted, as they are by far the worst offender in the new system.
      Since it wasn't our intention to do anything but improve Moira's targeting, we’re hoping to test a new configuration on the PTR either late this week or early next. Thank you so much for surfacing the issue for us; these reports are incredibly useful for us when it comes to tracking down bugs.
      The change also had nothing to do with upcoming Symmetra changes:
      Tim Ford (source)
      The inconsistencies with Moira are unrelated to Symmetra's increased lock on range. That is a separate defect that is also affecting Mercy Rez and a few other AoE abilities. We'll get a fix for those up on PTR next week.
      Again, thank you all for your help. Hopefully a thorough dose of tryptophan over the weekend will improve our math skills.
      And, just to keep everything Moira updated, she will be unlocking in competitive mode today, Thursday 23rd, at 11AM PST.
    • By Zadina

      The much anticipated map, that was first shown at BlizzCon, is now available on the Public Test Realm!
      Most Blizzard fans have dreamed of a theme park dedicated to our beloved games. Now, this theme park will be partly realised into Overwatch! The developers poured all their creativity into celebrating World of Warcraft, Diablo, StarCraft, Hearthstone and Heroes of the Storm in... Overwatch. Thus, the new hybrid map, Blizzard World, was presented at BlizzCon:
      Now, you can finally try Blizzard World out on the PTR. Feel free to go nuts and share your experience on the comments below! PTR Patch 1.18 also contains various bug fixes. Here are the patch notes:
      Blizzard Entertainment
      PATCH HIGHLIGHTS
      New Hybrid Map: Blizzard World
      An amusement park celebrating the universes of Warcraft, StarCraft, and Diablo, Blizzard World is a brand-new hybrid Assault/Escort map. Charge the gates of Stormwind, sneak through the Nexus Experience, and guide the payload through areas filled with high ground, flanking routes, and environmental hazards. Grab some Blizzard-inspired snacks at the concession stand along the way! GENERAL
      A.I.
      An option to “Remove All A.I.” in the custom game lobby can be accessed by Right Click > Remove All Bots BUG FIXES
      General
      Fixed an issue that caused the arcade card for Limited Duel and Mystery Duel to not list all currently disabled characters Fixed an issue that prevented certain sound effects from playing when navigating the Options menu with a controller Heroes
      Fixed a visual bug that caused Ana’s Biotic Rifle ammo clip to detach when her Captain Amari skin was equipped Fixed a bug that caused Doomfist’s Seismic Slam to create performance drops when repeatedly used with no cooldown Fixed a bug that prevented Mei’s Cryo-freeze from clearing the healing debuff caused by Ana’s Biotic Grenade Fixed a visual bug with Moira’s Biotic Orb that sometimes caused Biotic Grasp’s healing spray effects to display instead Fixed a bug that prevented Moira from being able to pass through enemies when using Fade Fixed a bug that caused Moira’s eyelashes to detach from her face during her Heroic highlight intro Fixed a visual issue with Moira’s Oasis skin that caused her knees to clip through her knee guards while crouched Fixed a bug that caused Reaper’s shotguns to animate incorrectly when discarded on the ground Fixed an issue that prevented highlights captured by Zenyatta players from recording correctly when the Cultist skin was equipped Maps
      Fixed a bug that caused a performance drop when players shot at the gold coin piles in the last Defender spawn of Junkertown (source)
    • By Stan

      Blackheart's Tavern return with another interview with the voice of Zenyatta!
      If you have not been following their series, Blackheart's Tavern previously talked to Senior Art Director Samwise Didier and Anjali Bhimani (Symmetra). Feodor Chin is the voice actor for Zenyatta from Overwatch! Jay also told us they've got Sombra and Roadhog coming!
    • By Zadina

      Black Friday starts early this year: both versions of Overwatch have had their price reduced by half.
      The free weekend, that is currently underway, is a great way to try out Overwatch. The added bonus is that if you like the game, you can currently buy it on a 50% discount from the Blizzard Shop!
      The simple Overwatch edition is now at 19.99 USD/EUR and the Overwatch: Game of the Year edition is at 29.99 USD/EUR (PC only).
      If you already have Overwatch and you want to upgrade to the Game of the Year edition, you can also do it at the reduced price of 10.00 USD/EUR. The discount on the upgrade is available on both PC and consoles.
      The offer will last until November 27 at 11.59 p.m PST in the Americas and November 28 at 09;00 a.m. CET in Europe. Happy Black Friday!
    • By Starym

       
      Moira is here! The new patch also brings the PTR Ana damage boost, significant Mercy Resurrect and Valkyrie changes as well as some visual improvements for several heroes. These are all in addition to the usual bug fixes, this time focusing on bots, spectator mode as well as a bunch of hero and map fixes. 
      You can also check out or BlizzCon coverage for more details on the new hero here and here.
      November 16 (source)
      PATCH HIGHLIGHTS

      New Hero: Moira (Support):

      Wielding both regenerative and degenerative technologies at her fingertips, Moira O’Deorain is Talon’s ambitious geneticist who seeks the knowledge to rewrite the building blocks of human life by any means necessary.

      Moira’s cutting-edge capabilities make her a mobile healer and damage dealer capable of adapting to any situation. Her main attack is Biotic Grasp, which she can use to either heal allies or sap an enemy’s life force. Biotic Grasp’s primary fire sprays a cone of energy that heals all teammates within range, draining biotic energy while active, which will replenish slowly over time. Her alternate fire is a beam that tethers to enemies, dealing damage and siphoning health. Draining her foes’ health regenerates Moira’s biotic energy even faster, allowing more healing for her allies.

      Her Biotic Orb ability launches a sphere of energy that bounces around the battlefield, healing nearby allies or damaging enemies until it dissipates. Fade enables Moira to disappear out of sight and sprint through the shadows, and makes her invulnerable for its duration. When Moira’s ultimate is ready to be unleashed, she can cast Coalescence—a powerful, long-range beam of chaotic energy that pierces through barriers to heal allies or damage enemies in its path.

      To learn more about Moira, click here.

      As with all new heroes, please note that Moira’s release in Competitive Play will be delayed by 1 week.  
      GENERAL UPDATES

      General Clicking the "leave game as group" checkbox will now remember your selection for future matches
      Arcade One of the arcade slots will now change on a daily basis to include a variety of game modes such as Limited Duel, Low Gravity, and Capture the Flag
      HERO UPDATES

      General

      Ana
      Biotic Rifle Damage increased from 60 to 70
      Developer Comments: Ana has been outshined by other supports lately. Boosting her damage will help her defend herself and make her more threatening to the enemy team.

      Lúcio
      Lúcio now has an effect above his head to indicate which song he's playing in spectator mode
      Mercy
      Caduceus Staff Increased visual readability of Mercy’s healing and damage boosting beams  
      Resurrect Cast time increased from 0 seconds to 1.75 seconds Mercy’s movement speed is now reduced by 75% while casting Can now be interrupted when Mercy is knocked back, stunned, or hacked Valkyrie While active, Resurrect no longer has a cast time While active, casting Resurrect does not reduce Mercy's movement speed
      Developer Comments: We feel that Mercy’s recent rework has been successful, but her Resurrect ability still feels too strong and frustrating to play against. Now that it has a cast time, enemies are more able to counter the ability. However, Resurrect will cast instantly when Valkyrie is active. This should make her feel powerful when she transforms on the battlefield.

      Winston
      Barrier Projector Now displays a health bar
      Developer Comments: This change will help both Winston’s allies and enemies know how much more damage his shield can absorb from oncoming attacks. USER INTERFACE

      General
      Made several visual adjustments to revamp the spectator mode HUD including an improved spectator mode UI, a new unit frame style, and an animated ultimate indicator BUG FIXES

      General
      Made several visual adjustments to revamp the spectator mode HUD including an improved spectator mode UI, a new unit frame style, and an animated ultimate indicator Fixed a bug that prevented players from adding spectators to a Deathmatch game from within the Custom Game lobby
      A.I.
      Fixed a bug that prevented bots from respawning when they were moved to a different slot or team within the Custom Game lobby Fixed a bug that prevented the Sombra bot from hacking health packs Fixed an issue that affected the Bastion bot’s movement when defending Point A on Eichenwalde Fixed a bug that prevented bots from defending Point A on certain maps
      Heroes
      Fixed a bug that caused Ana’s sidearm to emit a bright light when viewed in the Hero Gallery Fixed an issue that prevented Ganymede from making appropriate roadrunner noises when Bastion’s Dune Buggy skin was equipped Fixed a bug that prevented Mercy’s ultimate icon from displaying correctly when hacked by Sombra Fixed an issue causing Roadhog’s Chain Hook to latch on to enemy players for longer than intended Fixed an animation bug that caused Widowmaker’s knees to snap together when jumping Fixed an issue that caused the toy robot in Zarya’s Mystery Gift emote to inflate when she tore it apart Fixed an issue that prevented Junkrat’s RIP-Tire from casting properly while jumping
      Maps
      Fixed a bug that caused the incorrect stage of the map (e.g. Sanctum on Nepal) to be displayed during the hero selection phase when playing on Nepal and Lijiang Tower Fixed a bug that prevented the progress bar from displaying briefly when players reached checkpoints on Escort and Escort/Assault maps Fixed an issue that prevented the targeting UI on Doomfist’s Seismic Slam from functioning correctly when aiming at the spinning turbine blade near the last point of Junkertown Fixed a bug that caused some objects to uncharacteristically fly across the room when shot on Horizon Lunar Colony Previous patch notes.