DZN

PvE Frost, Fire or Arcane?

Sign in to follow this  

12 posts in this topic

Hey Icy Veins,

First off I'd like to say Hi! I've played a lot of WoW in my days, but I havent played since the days of ICC 25, some of my friends started playing again and I decided to join them a few weeks back. Now that my mage is about to hit 90, we're all getting serious for raiding, I've been doing tons of research, I've also noticed that WoWhead and EJ are kind of dead (how come?). Anyway, that brings me here, this community is very promising. I've looked into it, Noxxic tells me that Arcane is the way to go, Frost and Fire are decent too, but for some reason the website doesn't feel like it's made for the hardcore End-game raiding.
My question is: What mage spec yields to most DPS? My personal preference is frost, is it a big deal in the late-late 530+ iLvl raids when you play frost? Any website that properly tracks top DPS specs?

Thanks in advance

Edited by DZN

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hey Icy Veins,

First off I'd like to say Hi! I've played a lot of WoW in my days, but I havent played since the days of ICC 25, some of my friends started playing again and I decided to join them a few weeks back. Now that my mage is about to hit 90, we're all getting serious for raiding, I've been doing tons of research, I've also noticed that WoWhead and EJ are kind of dead (how come?). Anyway, that brings me here, this community is very promising. I've looked into it, Noxxic tells me that Arcane is the way to go, Frost and Fire are decent too, but for some reason the website doesn't feel like it's made for the hardcore End-game raiding.

My question is: What mage spec yields to most DPS? My personal preference is frost, is it a big deal in the late-late 530+ iLvl raids when you play frost? Any website that properly tracks top DPS specs?

Thanks in advance

Welcome back to the game and thanks for asking for our advice. I'm afraid I don't know what happened to EJ and Wowhead. :

Well, what the highest DPS is, really depends.. Theoretically if you don't have to do anything else, then just DPS yes arcane is a way to go. However, in the current tears the fights are not like this, so I will summerize the specs for you.

Arcane

Pros

Very good DPS if you can stand in your Rune of Power (Which is the only viable talent choice for arcane)

The overall gear scaling is good. You can do decent DPS with lower ilevel as well as with higher one

Very easy rotation

Cons

YOU HAVE TO STAND IN A RUNE! You are very very immobile. If you get a fire underneath you, you have to move, and recast your rune... Then, if you get another fire after 5 seconds, you have to move again and AGAIN cast the rune. This can get very annoying.

While the rotation is easy, it is rather boring.

Fire

Pros

Very-very good DPS at higher ilevels (around 40% crit) Like, even OP atm. and will be more OP in 5.4 if Critical Mass doesn't get nerfed.

Very mobile spec. This is the only spec atm with Scorch, taht you can cast on move.

Very-very good AoE damage. (possible 2 million burst DPS on council with spread combustion.)

Cons

Very RNG dependant on lower item levels that mostly result in bad DPS.

You need good reflexes with procs and you have to decide quickly when it's worth casting Combustion.

Frost

Pros

Very easy rotation

Very-very good DPS on lower item levels.

Very stable DPS. (Not big damage spikes, but no low damage spikes as well)

strong Aoe burst thanks to frozen orb with Ice lance spam.

Cons

Not the most mobile caster spec ever, but still better than arcane

Very bad gear scaling. After you reached about 520-530 item level, the other 2 specs clearly perform better. (Our best secondary stat, Haste, goes to waste after 50%)

All in all, I would suggest you to stick to frost for now at lower item level. Once you can reach 35-40% crit rating, switch to fire. Although, you could also try out arcane with higher itemlevels. You might love the playstyle, but I'd prefer fire more, personally.

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Any website that properly tracks top DPS specs?

I use Raidbots to see the damage output of different specs. If you look at the top 100 25H damage dealers, you'll see that fire is clearly on top, but if you look at all logs for 25H, Arcane is better. Fire has the potential to do the most damage, but you have to get lucky to get that much damage output. Arcane will do steady, good, dependable high damage.

But listen to Oltier, go Frost in the beginning, and then switch to either Arcane when you have the tier 15 4-set bonus, or to Fire when you can get at least 10,000 crit from gear and gems.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Welcome back to the game and thanks for asking for our advice. I'm afraid I don't know what happened to EJ and Wowhead. :

Well, what the highest DPS is, really depends.. Theoretically if you don't have to do anything else, then just DPS yes arcane is a way to go. However, in the current tears the fights are not like this, so I will summerize the specs for you.

Arcane

Pros

Very good DPS if you can stand in your Rune of Power (Which is the only viable talent choice for arcane)

The overall gear scaling is good. You can do decent DPS with lower ilevel as well as with higher one

Very easy rotation

Cons

YOU HAVE TO STAND IN A RUNE! You are very very immobile. If you get a fire underneath you, you have to move, and recast your rune... Then, if you get another fire after 5 seconds, you have to move again and AGAIN cast the rune. This can get very annoying.

While the rotation is easy, it is rather boring.

Fire

Pros

Very-very good DPS at higher ilevels (around 40% crit) Like, even OP atm. and will be more OP in 5.4 if Critical Mass doesn't get nerfed.

Very mobile spec. This is the only spec atm with Scorch, taht you can cast on move.

Very-very good AoE damage. (possible 2 million burst DPS on council with spread combustion.)

Cons

Very RNG dependant on lower item levels that mostly result in bad DPS.

You need good reflexes with procs and you have to decide quickly when it's worth casting Combustion.

Frost

Pros

Very easy rotation

Very-very good DPS on lower item levels.

Very stable DPS. (Not big damage spikes, but no low damage spikes as well)

strong Aoe burst thanks to frozen orb with Ice lance spam.

Cons

Not the most mobile caster spec ever, but still better than arcane

Very bad gear scaling. After you reached about 520-530 item level, the other 2 specs clearly perform better. (Our best secondary stat, Haste, goes to waste after 50%)

All in all, I would suggest you to stick to frost for now at lower item level. Once you can reach 35-40% crit rating, switch to fire. Although, you could also try out arcane with higher itemlevels. You might love the playstyle, but I'd prefer fire more, personally.

I want to thank you for taking your time to read my post and then type such an elaborate answer, it really restores my faith in the WoW community (I was afraid it was a dead one). I have to agree that Arcane looks incredibly boring, I only needed like half the keybinding I need for frost and it was just boring! I'll stick to frost indeed and switch the fire later, that's a great idea Posted Image Frost is still the way to go in PVP right?

Thanks again!

Edited by DZN
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You are always welcome. ;)

If you have any more questions, don't hold yourself back!

Yes, Frost is currently the most PvPish spec. :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Frost is still the go-to spec for PvP, however fire can still be tons of fun and provide great damage. When I get bored of frost in arenas and rbgs I'll switch to fire and queue up for normal bg's. It's quite amusing to find a suitable target and hit you're one shot macro, combusting them and standing back to watch them burn!

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

 

Thank you for the best summary on mage specs I've seen in a long long time.

 

-------------------------------------------------------------

 

I played WoW on and off but I've always played a mage. Fire from beta to WoTLK, arcane through out Cata, and now frost in Pandaria.

 

Imo, arcane mage is hardest to master, but once you do you will excel in dps. Fire mage can deal great damage easily, and in many situations are superior to arcane mage, so there really is no point sticking to fire or arcane all the way, you can always switch between the two according to your need (or how you want to play on that day).

 

People always say frost is the best in PVP and they are absolutely right. But one can not think other mages can't pvp well. I have great success in all kinds of world pvp, battlegrounds, and even arena fights as arcane and fire mage; and I have also seen enough frost mage out-DPS fire/arcane mages in raids. In the end I think it comes down to how you want to play and which style would give you the most joy in game.

 

So keep an open mind. Keep trying out new rotations and specs on dummies and them bosses and maybe you can agree that while dishing out high dps is important, the journey you take to achieve such goal is equally fun and rewarding.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thank you for the best summary on mage specs I've seen in a long long time.

 

-------------------------------------------------------------

 

I played WoW on and off but I've always played a mage. Fire from beta to WoTLK, arcane through out Cata, and now frost in Pandaria.

 

Imo, arcane mage is hardest to master, but once you do you will excel in dps. Fire mage can deal great damage easily, and in many situations are superior to arcane mage, so there really is no point sticking to fire or arcane all the way, you can always switch between the two according to your need (or how you want to play on that day).

 

People always say frost is the best in PVP and they are absolutely right. But one can not think other mages can't pvp well. I have great success in all kinds of world pvp, battlegrounds, and even arena fights as arcane and fire mage; and I have also seen enough frost mage out-DPS fire/arcane mages in raids. In the end I think it comes down to how you want to play and which style would give you the most joy in game.

 

So keep an open mind. Keep trying out new rotations and specs on dummies and them bosses and maybe you can agree that while dishing out high dps is important, the journey you take to achieve such goal is equally fun and rewarding.

Please note that, the post you have quoted from me is outdated, and things changed. :)

 

That being said, I aggree with you partly, but I would definitely argue that

 

Frost is only PvP. It is very good in pve as well competing with the other 2 specs.

 

You are right tho about other specs in PvP :) I really enjoyed combustion spread on players in BGs.. :D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Heh the information in this thread frustrates me greatly tongue.png

You know I was right before the mastery change. more-or-less! :D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Cons

 

YOU HAVE TO STAND IN A RUNE! You are very very immobile. If you get a fire underneath you, you have to move, and recast your rune... Then, if you get another fire after 5 seconds, you have to move again and AGAIN cast the rune. This can get very annoying.

 

Cons
YOU HAVE TO STAND IN A RUNE! You are very very immobile. If you get a fire underneath you, you have to move, and recast your rune... Then, if you get another fire after 5 seconds, you have to move again and AGAIN cast the rune. This can get very annoying.

With the increase in rune diameter, I can move 8 times without recasting (on Immersius at least). And while the Invoker bubble is a bit of a dps decrease, it keeps you mobile and has a bonus of adding some mitigation to IB. Between that and rotating from AT and LB depending on the fight, I got through at least half a stack of tomes on a successful run. Very happy with the tomes.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am closing this thread, because it is out of date and it misleads new players visiting the forum. Please do not refer to what I have written above, as those circumstances have changed signifficantly in 5.4.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Darksickness
      About Us:
      Two Strike Policy is a weekday Mythic hardcore progression guild on US-Sargeras. In our spare time, we run various high Mythic keystones/carries, Heroic Uldir carries and optional Mythic Uldir pug runs. Currently we are recruiting for our BFA Mythic Team. Most of our members were 3-4k+ Raider.io and retained top 10 spots on Sargeras Alliance side in Legion. We value camaraderie, communication, preparedness and excellence in each other. Discord is used to communicate during raids.
      Although BFA brings changes to the loot system, we will still be using the updated RCLootCouncil to help distribute loot if it is tradeable or a sidegrade. We expect raiders to be aware of their BIS and ideal gearing setup, and willing to trade where possible to best equip the raid team. The type of people we want would almost JUMP at giving gear to their fellow raid member/team if it is a sidegrade for themselves. Guild repairs, flasks and food are provided to all raiders, including trials.
      Current Progression:
      1/8M Uldir                                                                                                                                                                                                  11/11M Antorus 
      7/9M ToS
      7/10M NH - (Started tier late as a guild most are 9/10M & 10/10M)
      7/7M EN
      Raid Times:
      Tuesday - 7pm-10pm CST
      Wednesday - 7pm-10pm CST
      Optional Tuesday Morning On Reset - 10am-12pm CST (depends on server restart) - Heroic Uldir on mains 
      Optional Thursday 7pm-10pm CST - Alt Heroic Uldir 
      Optional Saturday 7pm-10pm CST - Mythic Alt Uldir                                                                                                                 
      Invitations start 30 minutes before raid time.
      Recruitment:
      We are currently recruiting strong applicants of all classes and roles, with the ability to handle calls and criticism like an adult. 
      High Priority Recruitment:
      Melee DPS: Rogue
      Ranged DPS: Warlock and Balance Druid 
      Healer: Discipline Priest and Holy Paladin
      ALL exceptional applicants will be considered. Please visit us at twostrikepolicy.com for more information. 
      Guild Master/Raid Leader: Darksickness/Zahedd - Ghostdragon#19918
      Recruitment Officer: Alandran - TheKiserSoze#1742
    • By Chumani
      Inevitable Destiny   (H)Corrupted Destiny guild Skywall/Drak'thul US realm😎 JOIN US!
      We are currently 8/8 Normal Uldir and 2/8 Heroic Uldir  -- Kickin' ass and hell with their names!
      1st  raid - Sun/Tues/Thurs 600-830pst
      2nd raid - Fri/Mon 530-800pst
      We ARE one of Skywall's largest and oldest standing guilds! Very active with a large player base. ALWAYS something going on, mythic dungeon runs, normal runs for alts, Island Expeditions, Arathi Highlands Warfront, PVP events.... always something!!!
      Come experience the reason a guild as old as CD continues to stand and stand strong year after year after year! Come...... and get.... CORRUPTED!!!
      Chu#12466 or Deni#1743
    • By Xantten
      <exceL> is a recently-established raiding team based on the Tarren Mill server, Horde [EU].   Supported by one of the UK’s leading esports organisations, exceL Esports, we are building a raiding team in advance of Battle for Azeroth with the sole intention of progressing to and clearing mythic end-game content in the new expansion. For more information on exceL Esports please see our website and check out our social media pages:   Guild: https://www.guilded.gg/exceL/ 
      Esports: https://www.excelesports.com Twitter: https://twitter.com/exceL Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/excelesportsltd Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/excelesports YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/excelesportstv Discord: http://rebrand.ly/xLDscrd   Background   exceL Esports was established in 2014 and is a professional competitive gaming organisation that serves to enable its playing staff to compete at the highest level in global esports. We value honesty, professionalism and integrity and look to combine our expertise with our passion for esports to create a stable, profitable and successful organisation.   exceL’s co-founders, Joel and Kieran, were hardcore Vanilla raiders and have remained fans of the World of Warcraft franchise ever since. exceL’s ambitions to recruit a raiding team are part of a wider strategy to explore opportunities in World of Warcraft esports.   Despite being a newly-established guild, our core members achieved Ahead of the Curve (11/11HC) in Antorus, the Burning Throne and would have progressed to mythic given more time. It remains our sole ambition to ensure this team is progressing through, and ultimately completing, BfA end-game content - up to and including Cutting Edge.   Expectations   What you can expect from us: A fun and friendly raiding team with an overt focus on raid progression combined with an understanding of life’s priorities Fair treatment when making the raid team selection - in the event that we are over-subscribed for raids, rotation decisions will be made to offer all capable individuals the opportunity to contribute to raid progression The opportunity to contribute to discussions regarding the guild’s strategies and decision-making Utilisation of the Personal Loot system   We are looking for players who: Can display relevant raid experience from Legion and/or previous expansions (at least 11/11HC in Antorus, the Burning Throne, is preferred) Can provide evidence (i.e. logs) of strong previous raid performance Take responsibility for their own raid attendance and performance Are open to constructive criticism and are prepared to be given advice on how to improve their performance in raids Will make every effort to educate themselves on developing raid strategies Will make every effort to maximise the performance of their character, including the studying of relevant logs Are prepared to take the initiative and make creative strategic suggestions to aid raid progression Enjoy being part of a team Are patient and understand that progression requires a positive and productive mindset   Recruitment and Requirements   Recruitment is currently open for the following classes/specs: Tanks - All (except Blood DK) Healers - Priest (Holy/Disc), Paladin (Holy) Ranged DPS - Mage (Any), Priest (Shadow) Melee DPS - Shaman (Enh), Rogue (Sub), Warrior (Arms) or Monk (WW)   Raid Schedule   Wednesday: 21:00-00:00
      Sunday: 21:00-00:00   All times indicated are server times. You will be expected to be online at least 15 minutes before the raid start time, at which point the final raiding roster will be announced. At least one 10 minute break will be held during every raid.   We will not be doing mandatory split runs, alt raids or PTR tests. However all scheduled raids will be highly organised and focused.   You will not be asked to raid additional days. However we do expect members to be active outside of raid times to continue progressing their main characters. We are also likely to be regularly running Mythic+ dungeons, especially early on in the expansion.   How to Apply   If you are interested in applying please complete our application form -> http://www.guilded.gg/r/AdwlVrMK8l <- and if you have any questions, please contact our Guild Master Xanten#2717   Successful applicants will be invited to join our Discord server, used as the main VOIP platform whilst we are raiding as well as the guild’s main text-based communication platform.   Thank you and we look forward to hearing from interested parties soon.
    • By Orb
      <Banana Hammock> is a BFA social raiding & M+ guild for late night weekend raiders.
      Hours: 11pm-2am (Pacific) Saturday & Sunday  for progression raids
      Progression: 8/8 N 2/8 H
      Raiding Goal:  To reach AOTC each tier and to do mythic raiding if we can. 
      Looking for:  
      Ranged DPS  If interested in raiding or hanging out with us just message
      B.net:  Nox#1474, Anubismerc#1882, or Radjehuty#1804
      Discord: nox#2686