Stan

D.Va & Xul Hero Discussions

Sign in to follow this  

7 posts in this topic

p2z97Nt.jpg

Discussions continue about D.Va and her post-nerf win rate and Xul's nerfs from yesterday.

D.Va

  • At the time of nerfs, D.Va had the sixth highest win rate in Hero League for players that leveled her to 10 (Blizzard's standard metric).
  • After nerfs she's at 48%  and it's very likely that some of her underperforming talents will be buffed.

Blizzard LogoBlizzard (Source)

Hey guys, I'm Alex from the Live/Balance Team and I wanted to chime in here.

At the time of the nerfs to D.Va, she had the 6th highest winrate in Hero League (~54%) for players that had leveled her to 10 or higher (our standard metric). She was behind only Malthael, Uther, Ragnaros, Probius, and Tassadar. A lot of those Heroes have also received nerfs since that point in time.

We also find that newer Heroes continue to trend up for a while, and our personal experience told us that players were still learning to be really effective with D.Va, so we believed that nerfs were correct.

She's now at 48%, and anecdotally I've never been upset to see a D.Va in my games (nor felt like I shouldn't play her when the team composition made sense).

It's very likely that we'll do more Talent tuning as we progress, which will likely result in buffs to some of the under-performing Talents. Overall, we won't always hit it perfectly the first time, as each Hero reacts differently to tuning, but we're always watching and will continue to make adjustments to get it right eventually. We care deeply for each Hero that is released, and want to see them have a nice place in the Nexus.

GG WP!

Xul

  • The intention of yesterday's changes was to nerf Xul, but at the same time, improve his W-oriented (Cursed StrikesCursed Strikes) build.
  • Devs want to make his three builds on par and they're closely monitoring his win rate.

Blizzard LogoBlizzard (Source)

Just pointing facts here. At the time i post this, Xul has a win rate of 55.8% or ~56% in hero league. I am waiting for the deserved nerf. Honestly, that champion is a beast, both in qm and hero league.

We're watching. The intention of the changes yesterday were to nerf Xul, but make the Cursed StrikesCursed Strikes (W) build a little better in the process (since it was about 5% lower winrate).

It's still too soon to make any conclusions, but an interesting observation is people are taking Grim ScytheGrim Scythe oriented builds less often, which is leading to a rise in his winrate (since the build isn't performing as well on average).

Obviously that's not ideal, we want to make all 3 builds on par, but its one of the things that leads to a fluctuation in a Hero's overall winrate that we need to keep in mind.

I love your posts. Feed us more hero data!!!
Thanks again.

I am glad you are watching the situation closely. I just want to say something, though i doubt it is necessary. Please, don't try to balance the game only on 1 gamemode. Balance the game around every gamemode - QM, HL, Bot games.

In general, we we aim to balance Hero League primarily, as that style of play usually trickles down into the other modes. If things are balanced there, we're usually in a pretty good spot in other game modes.

We do watch Quick Match especially to make sure nothing gets out of hand though. Certain Heroes thrive in the more chaotic Quick Match (and with less structured team compositions), so we expect some deviation from Hero League's results because of it. But if it makes for a degenerative experience, we'll make some changes trying to address just Quick Match problems when we need to.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't know where of a sudden did all those discussions about concrete heroes come, but I like it.

Btw, any chance of some of the oldest and/or less successful heroes getting a rework soon? Anybody knows/can answer?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
21 minutes ago, MvonTzeskagrad said:

I don't know where of a sudden did all those discussions about concrete heroes come, but I like it.

Btw, any chance of some of the oldest and/or less successful heroes getting a rework soon? Anybody knows/can answer?

Dev communication for Heroes of the Storm is really good these days. I can't think of many Heroes off the top of my head. They'd like to rework most of the outdated heroes "in the future", no ETA. I remember they mentioned Medivh & Samuro lately. Keep an eye out here for specific threads that received a blue response.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So, my biggest concern on all this is two things. 

A) They act like 48% win rate is bad on D.Va, like if she isn't about 50% she isn't good. In a balanced world half of the heroes in the game would have a lower than 50% win rate. 48% is perfectly acceptable and still likely to rise a bit with no changes.

B) As predicted, D.Va is a champ that is going to be impossibly hard to balance. She has similar issues to Kled in League of Legends with the added bonus of being able to summon Skarl (or in this case her mech) back immediately after jumping out in some cases. You can't give a hero two health bars, an invulnerability and naturally high tankiness and then wonder why they take every single damage focused trait available to them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 28/07/2017 at 7:50 AM, Thorosofbeer said:

A) They act like 48% win rate is bad on D.Va, like if she isn't about 50% she isn't good. In a balanced world half of the heroes in the game would have a lower than 50% win rate. 48% is perfectly acceptable and still likely to rise a bit with no changes.

But this is only true in a perfect meta that includes every hero - depending on the sway of the meta, certain heroes will have a very low winrate, not because they are bad but because the meta has shifted. For example, if every game sees 3 tanks picked, Nova will have a much lower winrate. This isn't due to her being a bad hero, per say, but simply because it's not the right environment for her. 

On that note, the meta has shifted with D.Va's nerf. The only thing that actually changed was her, which means that she is playing in the exact same meta, but has dropped a huge amount of win %. I hope I'm kind of making sense. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There are a lot of factors that can change the overall win rates of any particular hero, but I don't think some small and targeted buffs typical of the HotS team are going to hurt, especially if they encourage some talent diversity. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 hours ago, Plergoth said:

There are a lot of factors that can change the overall win rates of any particular hero, but I don't think some small and targeted buffs typical of the HotS team are going to hurt, especially if they encourage some talent diversity. 

I think that, after talent changes and revamps, you do also sometimes see people picking the hero up again and possibly not playing her as well as you can - I know that I have heroes above level 15 and I sometimes jump back on to them and feel incredibly rusty on them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Stan
      Alan Dabiri announced today that he's leaving his current position as Game Director for Heroes of the Storm and he's moving on to another project at Blizzard.
      Alan Dabiri has been Game Director ever since Dustin Browder stepped down in December 2016. He thinks the game is in the right hands right now, as developers continue to deliver interesting new Heroes and events. He's transitioning to a new team within the company. We wish him success in all his future endeavors.
      Here's the message he left on the official forums:
      Blizzard (Source)
      In my 20-plus years at Blizzard, I’ve had the privilege of working on many awesome Blizzard games in roles ranging from software engineer to technical director to game director. Across my many roles and games, my experience working on Heroes of the Storm ranks among the best of my development career. I’ve witnessed Heroes’ evolution from a StarCraft II mod to the amazing game you see today. Heroes’ development has been fueled by the shared excitement of our team and all of you in the community, and the game we’ve built together is the game I play almost every night.
      One of the best things about developing Heroes is the fact that this team is not afraid to try new things while always striving to learn and grow. It’s been part of our DNA from the very beginning, and it’s through years of experimentation that we’ve hit our stride both as a development team, and as a game. This is possible because Heroes has an exceptional development team of both Blizzard veterans and fresh faces who are all highly engaged with the game we’re making, and the players we’re making it for.
      It’s in this spirit of trying new things that I want to let everyone know that a few months ago, I accepted an opportunity to transition off my role as Heroes’ game director to heed Blizzard’s call and begin a new adventure elsewhere within the company. The game director has always been one part of the overall leadership team that drives Heroes forward and it’s been a privilege to work among some of the best game developers at every level on the team all the way up to our production director, Kaéo Milker. Leaving a team and game that I love is incredibly difficult, but seeing the steady strength, creativity, and commitment that Kaéo and the design, engineering, and art leadership teams consistently bring to Heroes has given me more than enough confidence to make this decision. I trust that the game is in the very best hands and their work these past few months has only reinforced my belief.
      They’ve released awesome new heroes like Yrel, Whitemane, Mephisto, and now Mal’Ganis, while building on the themed content drops that let the team do fun things that only Heroes can do. They brought the smackdown (plus my favorite mount, the Luchihuahua!) with Nexomania, finally brought an epic slice of Azeroth into the Nexus with the Alterac Pass Battleground, and joined the Raven Lord’s forces with the Fall of King’s Crest. On top of that, the team has also released awesome reworks like Raynor and Brightwing while adding exciting updates like third ban and Team League improvements. With so many awesome content and feature updates, you can see why I believe that the team has brought us the best year of Heroes of the Storm so far.
      And they’re not done yet. Heroes has one of the most passionate and dedicated development teams I’ve had the pleasure of working with, and they have a ton of exciting new content in development. I can’t wait for you all to see what they have in store for the rest of this year and beyond. You can bet that I’ll be right there enjoying it with you as it’s released, too. I’m sure you’ll agree when I say that Heroes is in a great place and I promise that it’s in the hands of the best possible people to continue driving it forward. Kaéo and the Heroes team are people who play almost every night who also happen to get to work on making the game what it is today. With our continued input and support, they’ll keep doing what they do best by making Heroes of the Storm the most awesome game it can possibly be.
      I just want to sign off by saying thank you to all of you. I’ve had an incredible time working on this game and seeing you bring the battlegrounds to life every day. I’m so grateful for the enthusiasm you’ve brought to Heroes and all the changes you’ve encouraged us to make. I know the team deeply appreciates the feedback you share, so please keep it coming—and as always, I’ll see you in the Nexus!
    • By Stan
      Free Hero rotation has been updated for the week of October 16 and features Yrel, Chromie, Chen, and more.
      Free-to-Play Hero Rotation: October 16, 2018
      Malfurion Valla Gazlowe Johanna Thrall Dehaka Lúcio Falstad Li-Ming Alarak Yrel (Slot unlocked at Player Level 5) Tassadar (Slot unlocked at Player Level 10) Chen (Slot unlocked at Player Level 15) Chromie (Slot unlocked at Player Level 20) (Source)
    • By Stan
      Heroes of the Storm Highlights are back with a brand new episode of WTF Moments!
      Episode 114 starts with Sgt. Hammer catching an escaping Sylvanas with her Concussion Mine, Alarak absorbing Kaelthas' Pyroblast for Blaze, killing him with Discord Strike, and more.
      Let us know your favorite moment in the comments below and don't forget to submit your replays here for a chance to be featured in an upcoming episode! of WTF Moments.
      Previous Episodes
      WTF Moments Episode 113 WTF Moments Episode 112 WTF Moments Episode 111
    • By Stan
      Hero sales for next week include Rexxar and Zul'jin. Various skins will also become purchasable with gems starting October 16.
      Blizzard (Source)
      Heroic Deals: October 16 – October 23, 2018
      Our next set of Heroic Deals will begin on Tuesday, October16! Check out the list of upcoming featured items and Hero discounts below.
      Upcoming Hero Sales
      Zul’jin— Sale Price: 375 gems Rexxar — Sale Price: 250 Gems The following skins and mounts will be added to the featured item rotation and will become purchasable with gems until this round of Heroic Deals comes to an end:
      Upcoming Featured Skins
      Emberlord Zul’jin Covert Raider Rexxar Dark Nexus Alarak Toxic Love Doctor Morales Golden Cyberdemon Zarya Violet Roller Derby Nova Upcoming Featured Mounts
      Shadowmoon Hellboar Copper Cloud Serpent
    • By Stan
      This week's brawl is Industrial District! A single-lane Overwatch-themed battleground with shuffle pick and standard play. The objective is to take down the enemy core and you'll receive a Fall of King's Crest Chest when you complete three matches.
      Blizzard
      This week’s Heroes Brawl is Industrial District! Slide around and slug it out in the heart of Volskaya in this Overwatch-themed, single-lane Battleground featuring lots of conveyor belts and tons of action.
      Rules:
      Shuffle pick - Choose from one of three Heroes before entering the battle. Standard play - no talent or level restrictions. The first team to destroy the enemy Core wins! Rewards:
      Complete three matches of the Industrial District Brawl to earn a Loot Chest! Find out more about the Heroes Brawl game mode on our Heroes Brawl site; and as always, you can find more information on this week’s Brawl by clicking the Brawl Info button at the bottom of the play screen when preparing to queue for the Brawl game mode.