Stan

Senior Game Designer on Warriors

17 posts in this topic

4LQQRTTGEPVI1458750284105.jpg

The development team sought to establish a more clear definition of tanks around the time frame between D.Va and Garrosh. With a predefined list of Warrior qualities they found out that Warriors who lack peel are used as bruisers to harass the enemy backline.

Blizzard LogoBlizzard (Source)

From a Hero Design perspective, this is something we've talked about a lot on the team. In years past the conventional wisdom was that a "tank" had to be hard to kill, and do things that are sufficiently disruptive (damage/CC) that you can't simply ignore them - which in turn allows them to soak damage for their team.

However, around the time frame between D.Va and Garrosh, we sought to establish a more clear definition of what's required to "tank" for your team and what tools a Warrior needs to do that effectively.

This isn't a comprehensive list, but I believe we landed on something like the following:

  • Durability/Mitigation (so they're not easy to blow up)
  • Self-sustain (so they can stay in a fight)
  • Peel (so they can protect vulnerable allies)
  • Interrupt (so they can disrupt cast/channeled abilities)

We've found that Warriors who don't have enough of one or more of these qualities end up being used as bruisers to harass the enemy backline. Most of the time it's "peel" that's lacking, as this is the aspect that wasn't as clearly defined in the past. Even now I'd say it's hard to say precisely where that line is, and that it's subjective based on what other heroes are capable of. 

If you look at someone like Sonya with 2 stuns, you'd think she could be a tank - and indeed to some extent she can, but other aspects of her kit push her to be more aggressive and limit how effective she can be at protecting a squishy backline (compared to someone like Muradin or Arthas). I think this is something we're trying to be much more aware of earlier on in the development and playtesting process for new Warriors. Do we want them to be able to tank? If so, do they have all the necessary tools? Are there aspects of their kit that make it unintentionally more difficult for them to do so?

This is something I'd encourage all of you to think about (and feel free to disagree with us on!) when discussing whether a Hero can tank for their team, and what they need to be doing to tank effectively.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

E.T.C. may be a tank by these standards, but Tyrael sure as hell isn't. Have you ever been in a game where Tyrael was able to out-tank anyone while being the second tank on his team? I doubt anyone ever has.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
18 minutes ago, Fliits said:

E.T.C. may be a tank by these standards, but Tyrael sure as hell isn't. Have you ever been in a game where Tyrael was able to out-tank anyone while being the second tank on his team? I doubt anyone ever has.

Tyrael was never a tank. He is a Bruiser with a supportive kit.

I think Blizzard needs to start sorting better their classes with sub-classes (i.e.: Bruiser). Not only that would help with matchmaking, but also prevent people from saying stuff like "Tassadar is a healer" or "D.Va is a tank". Just like they need to further emphasize that Specialists are not exclusively siegers; heck, they even changed the icon and description of the Specialist class since the Chromie / Medivh patch.

Edited by Valhalen

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I actually believe that since the opening of the game and the addition of SO many new heroes throughout the few years, that it has become impossible to label something a "warrior", even if just for QM matching. I think there should be a clear cut TANK and a WARRIOR separation. I.E.

 

Tank:

Muradin, Johanna, Garrosh, ETC

 

Warrior:

Sonya, Tyrael, Rexxar (which at this point is a glorified SPEC), Dehaka

 

Now I guess the question becomes, what about the stuff that's kit COULD become TANK rather than warrior - Varian comes to mind, as well as Anub. Well what's wrong with pruning based on 2 different labels rather than try to fit things under 1? As your game grows I think you'll find you're going to run into this more and more. Obviously this is mostly about QM and how matchmaking searches (getting a game with sonya as your only "warrior" vs a team that has johanna as theirs). Also, for new players completely to the game - or even the genre in general, it's a bit confusing that "Hey, Muradin is a warrior, but I want to "tank" on Sonya, it says she's a warrior too!" I believe you're setting them, and the veteran players they come into contact with, for failure, whether that be abusive chat or just never really giving the game a chance because of the obvious difference in the actual "warrior" roles.

 

TLDR: Why can we not split the Warrior role into Tank and Warrior (Bruiser), would that not better service the design team in fitting certain things into certain roles based on kits?

 

-- Obviously this would open the door to the way healers are combined when you could make a case about having a Healer role and a Support role, but the above would also apply to all of that as well.

Edited by Savagefaction

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 minutes ago, Savagefaction said:

getting a game with sonya as your only "warrior" vs a team that has johanna as theirs

Actually, the new algorithm Blizzard introduced prevents you from getting in a group of a true Tank VS a group without a Tank (it can happen, but it is very very rare).

Sonya and D.Va are classified in the game's data as Bruisers, so at least there is that. I've ran countless Quick Matches with Sonya as the sole Warrior and never got in a match against a Tank Warrior like Johanna or Muradin.

Edited by Valhalen

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
52 minutes ago, Valhalen said:

Tyrael was never a tank. He is a Bruiser with a supportive kit.

He was taken as a tank earlier on in HotS life, but now he's a Sanc bot ): I still view him as a tank, but more along the lines of a Support / Tank hybrid, similar to Uther. 

Losing uncapped Regen Master on him hurt his frontline before they removed the level 13 talent and turned his niche into a dive and utility driven "bruiser" who couldn't put a dent in a house of cards, but, unlike Johanna, he still has access to it, so that's a bonus, I guess? Or maybe just a symptom of the weird design decisions going into these reworks and the inconsistency as they address generic talents at an agonisingly slow rate? 

One of the key things about Warriors that tank and those that either suck at it or aren't considered main tanks is bodyblocking. Both Dehaka and Sonya are classic case examples where they have a lot of tanky attributes and talents, but besides both being too unreliable (how many Warriors have a way to shut down Whirlwind, Sonya's main sustain?) to be a front line and initiator, enemy players can ghost through them when they use certain abilities. Compare this to, let's say, Anub, who has one of the biggest collision circles in the game bar Cho'gall, and can win fights or get picks for his team purely down to a Burrow cutting an enemy hero from retreating past their own gate because Anub is so wide, not to mention that it innately helps to soak skill shots for your team. 

There is a lot of things that make a tank... a tank, besides just being tanky and some hard cc. 
 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So let me get that straight... hots dev team first make a huge basket called "warriors" and puts there so many different chars (some of them are not even close to each other) and then they come and say "Oh wait, we thought a lot about it and we think that good "tank" should have this and this and this... but we will call him warrior anyways and throw him into the warrior's basket to confuse players! Yeah, that is a great idea!"

-__-'

Srsly all we need is just make much more diversity in naming. So many good players and streamers suggested it years ago and still nothing. I can't understand why tye have such problem with that.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's been a long time coming. If blizz is too busy to sit down then they can just use the sub roles from hotslog. I very rarely disagree with their designations. 

Edited by Orshova
Auto correct is a douche

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, Orshova said:

It's been a long time coming. If blizz is too busy to sit down then they can just use the sub roles from hotslog. I very rarely disagree with their designations. 

that would leave the support category with only tassadar and medivh, so I'm thinking their not going to do that, at least not exactly like hotslogs.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Fliits said:

that would leave the support category with only tassadar and medivh, so I'm thinking their not going to do that, at least not exactly like hotslogs.

And maybe lets think for a minute here why is that ?
Maybe it means that there are to little SUPPORT chars in game ??
Maybe blizz should make more support chars instead of warriors and assasins ???
Nah, that couldn't be it... or maybe ? ;)

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
13 hours ago, Plergoth said:

He was taken as a tank earlier on in HotS life, but now he's a Sanc bot ): I still view him as a tank, but more along the lines of a Support / Tank hybrid, similar to Uther. 

Losing uncapped Regen Master on him hurt his frontline before they removed the level 13 talent and turned his niche into a dive and utility driven "bruiser" who couldn't put a dent in a house of cards, but, unlike Johanna, he still has access to it, so that's a bonus, I guess? Or maybe just a symptom of the weird design decisions going into these reworks and the inconsistency as they address generic talents at an agonisingly slow rate? 

One of the key things about Warriors that tank and those that either suck at it or aren't considered main tanks is bodyblocking. Both Dehaka and Sonya are classic case examples where they have a lot of tanky attributes and talents, but besides both being too unreliable (how many Warriors have a way to shut down Whirlwind, Sonya's main sustain?) to be a front line and initiator, enemy players can ghost through them when they use certain abilities. Compare this to, let's say, Anub, who has one of the biggest collision circles in the game bar Cho'gall, and can win fights or get picks for his team purely down to a Burrow cutting an enemy hero from retreating past their own gate because Anub is so wide, not to mention that it innately helps to soak skill shots for your team. 

There is a lot of things that make a tank... a tank, besides just being tanky and some hard cc.

Even in his Alpha days I considered him more of a Bruiser with Support skills. He can do a surprisingly amount of peel and interrupts, though. I really hope they give him a deserved rework to define better his role/niche.

Your points regarding the tanks are very valid. I think despite all nuisances and inconsistences here and there, Blizzard made a great job by adding very different types of tanks. They're polishing the edges really well.

2 hours ago, Godeyes said:

And maybe lets think for a minute here why is that ?
Maybe it means that there are to little SUPPORT chars in game ??
Maybe blizz should make more support chars instead of warriors and assasins ???
Nah, that couldn't be it... or maybe ? ;)

Blizzard has been hearing the community on more Supports. And we've got plenty of really meta-changing Supports this year (Ana herself makes the Double Support meta even more powerful).

Don't get me wrong, I'm all for more Supports in this game.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
19 hours ago, Stan said:

This isn't a comprehensive list, but I believe we landed on something like the following:

  • Durability/Mitigation (so they're not easy to blow up)
  • Self-sustain (so they can stay in a fight)
  • Peel (so they can protect vulnerable allies)
  • Interrupt (so they can disrupt cast/channeled abilities)

We've found that Warriors who don't have enough of one or more of these qualities end up being used as bruisers to harass the enemy backline.

This is really scary to read 3 years after the game's release. What the hell did they think tanks were meant to do?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, Oxygen said:

This is really scary to read 3 years after the game's release. What the hell did they think tanks were meant to do?

But isn't E.T.C. pretty much all of that combined in one Hero?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
12 minutes ago, Valhalen said:

But isn't E.T.C. pretty much all of that combined in one Hero?

It is; I'm just wondering why they're even bothering stating it. It makes it sound like it's some kind of deep discovery.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
10 minutes ago, Oxygen said:

It is; I'm just wondering why they're even bothering stating it. It makes it sound like it's some kind of deep discovery.

Well, to the newbs and noobs, maybe? There are still people who claim that Tassadar is a Healer.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Inb4 Tyrael screams "REWORK ME!" "UPDATE ME!" in a corner...

They could also make a Mage class and put the appropriate people/elves/liches/fire elementals/idk what else there to make the Assassin class less crowded (Mage Wars hello?) since game could be called Assassins Creed right now.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, SteveFrost said:

Inb4 Tyrael screams "REWORK ME!" "UPDATE ME!" in a corner...

They could also make a Mage class and put the appropriate people/elves/liches/fire elementals/idk what else there to make the Assassin class less crowded (Mage Wars hello?) since game could be called Assassins Creed right now.

Maybe divide the Assassin Class in two sub-ranks: Physical Damage and Ability Damage.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Stan

      Kel'Thuzad & Tassadar are on sale next week along with a fresh set of cosmetics that can be purchased with Gems until January 30.
      Blizzard (Source)
      Weekly Collection Update: Jan 23 – 30, 2018
      Our next Collection Update will begin on Tuesday, January 23! Check out the list of featured items and Hero discounts below.  Upcoming Hero Sales
      Kel’Thuzad — Sale Price: 375 Gems Tassadar — Sale Price: 250 Gems The following Skins and Mounts will enter the Featured Item Rotation, and will be unlockable using Gems until next week's Collection Update:
      Upcoming Featured Skins
      Frost Star Lich Kel’Thuzad Emerald Tassadar Beastmaster Rexxar Hunter First Lt. Morales Betrayer Illidan Luminescent Lurkablo Pearl Shadowpaw Li Li Prototype Mecha Dehaka Upcoming Featured Mounts
      Ringmaster’s Pride Orange Rainbow Unicorn
    • By Stan

      This week's brawl is the Temple Arena. Harness the power of the temples to destroy the enemy Core. Choose one from three randomly selected Heroes and pick your Heroic ability. No other talents are available. Complete three matches to earn a Loot Chest.
      Blizzard (Source)
      This week’s brawl is the Temple Arena! Harness the power of the Alligator, Cobra, and Jackal Temples to destroy the enemy Core!

      Rules:
      Choose from one of three randomly selected Heroes before entering the Arena. Be quick about it though, you only have 30 seconds to choose! Everyone will begin the round at level 10 and will be asked to choose a Heroic Ability. No other talents will be available. During each round, slay the enemy team’s Heroes and capture the Temple Shrines to take shots at their Core! The Core for each team will have set amounts of health based on the number of active Shrines. Each round can have 1-3 active Shrines. The first team whose Core reaches 0 health will lose the round. Be the first team to win 2 rounds and claim victory! Rewards:
      Complete three matches of the Temple Arena to earn a Loot Chest!  
      Find out more about the Heroes Brawl game mode on our Heroes Brawl site; and as always, you can find more information on this week’s Brawl by clicking the Brawl Info button at the bottom of the play screen when preparing to queue for the Brawl game mode.
    • By Stan

      Learn more about new Mecha skins and bundles that went live with today's patch in the official preview!
      Now onto things that were not mentioned in the latest patch notes:
      In addition to Mecha skins, a new legendary Mecha Tyrael announcer has been added to the game, together with sprays and emojis! Blizzard also released a new video titled MechaStorm. Check it out below!
      Blizzard (Source)
      Arm your Heroes with the latest and greatest technological advancements the Nexus has to offer by picking up new Mecha Skins for Tyrael, Rehgar, and Abathur! These Mechas are built tough, with durability ratings so high they’re guaranteed to be combat-ready whenever you enter the queue, and come back swinging every time you put them through the ringer on the battlefield.
      If it’s style you’re after, our Mechas are crafted using only the finest, artisanal techniques and the rarest materials. With upgraded visual effects on their abilities and altered voiceover kits, you’ll be so sleek, sophisticated, and intimidating during hostile engagements that even D.Va will be jealous—Hell, we’ve even installed custom Hearthstone animations for Tyrael and Rehgar so you can show off even more flair when you need to make an exit.
      Now, why don’t we step over to the show floor so you can check out what we’ve got in stock.
      New Skins
      We just received a shipment containing 10 top-of-the-line models that will be sure to keep up with your every move on the battlefield! The new legendary skins listed below can be forged using shards, or opened in Loot Chests.
      Abathur
      Xenotech Abathur Saboteur Xenotech Abathur Sinister Xenotech Abathur Dehaka
      V.haka Rehgar
      Mecha Rehgar Custom Mecha Rehgar Death's Head Mecha Rehgar Tyrael
      Mecha Tyrael Deathreaper Mecha Tyrael Strike Mecha Tyrael New Bundles
      We’ve put together several Heroic Mecha Bundles so discerning pilots can acquire a range of models for their Hero of choice. If you’d rather amass a stockpile of firepower in one fell swoop, then you might prefer the MechaStorm Bundle, instead. Each of our Mecha Bundles below can be purchased using gems, but they’ll only be available until January 29, so be sure to build your arsenal before they blast off!
      MechaStorm Bundle
      Heroes
      Abathur Rehgar Tyrael Legendary Skins
      Xenotech Abathur Saboteur Xenotech Abathur Sinister Xenotech Abathur Mecha Rehgar Custom Mecha Rehgar Death's Head Mecha Rehgar Mecha Tyrael Deathreaper Mecha Tyrael Strike Mecha Tyrael Heroic Mecha Bundles
      Abathur Bundle
      Hero
      Abathur Skins
      Xenotech Abathur Saboteur Xenotech Abathur Sinister Xenotech Abathur Rehgar Bundle
      Hero
      Rehgar Skins
      Mecha Rehgar Custom Mecha Rehgar Death's Head Mecha Rehgar Tyrael Bundle
      Hero
      Tyrael Skins
      Mecha Tyrael Deathreaper Mecha Tyrael Strike Mecha Tyrael Don't forget to customize! We've added a legendary Mecha Tyrael announcer, as well as a barrage of Mecha-themed sprays and emojis to the collection that you can use to make your loadouts really sing.
      Now that you’ve had a look around, how about a test drive? Head to the featured tab in the collection to give these skins a spin in Try Mode, and we’ll see you in the Nexus.
    • By Stan

      A new patch just hit live servers and Tyrael received a rework. The previously teased Mecha skins are now available for purchase separately, or as a bundle.
      Blizzard (Source)
      Heroes
      Warrior
      Tyrael

      General
      Tyrael will now face the target of his Basic Attack after attacking.  This is a visual change, and does not directly affect gameplay Passive Spell Armor has been removed Stats
      Base Maximum Health increased from 2296 to 2468 Health Regeneration increased from 4.78 to 5.14 Abilities
      El’druin’s Might (Q) Mana cost reduced from 50 to 45 Righteousness (W) Mana cost reduced from 60 to 50 Allied Shield amount changed from a flat value to 40% of the Tyrael-only Shield value. This is the same amount of Shields, but it makes it easier to understand new Talent interactions Smite (E) Can now be cast while moving Damage increased from 144 to 150 Talents
      Level 1 Salvation (W) Moved from level 16 New functionality: Increase Righteousness’ Tyrael-only Shield amount by 25%. If the Shield is destroyed, heal Tyrael for 125 Health. (New) Justice for All (W) Increases Righteousness’ allied shield value to 100% of the Tyrael-only Shield amount. (New) Ardent Restoration (Passive) Damaging an enemy Hero grants 2.5 Health per Second to Tyrael for 5 seconds.  Stacks up to 10 times. Protection in Death (Trait) Removed Even in Death (Trait) Removed Regeneration Master (Passive) Removed Level 4 (New) Stalwart Angel (Q) Tyrael gains 25 Armor while El'druin's Might is out, and for 3 seconds after teleporting. (New) Bound by Law (Q) Increases El’druin’s Might’s slow amount from 25 to 35%. Tyrael’s Basic Attacks increase the duration of the slow by 1 second, up to 4 seconds. (New) Divine Vigor (Passive) Damaging an enemy with Smite causes Tyrael's Basic Attacks to heal him for 50% of their damage for 4 seconds. Vigorous Strike (Passive) Removed Level 7 Purge Evil (E) Moved from level 1 New functionality: Every enemy Hero hit by Smite increases Tyrael's Basic Attack damage by 30% for 4 seconds Swift Retribution (E) Movement Speed bonus increased from 10 to 20% No longer increases the duration of Smite’s Movement Speed bonus Added functionality: Now also causes Smite’s friendly effect to increase Attack Speed by 25% Angel’s Grace (Q) Removed Zealotry (W) Removed Follow Through (Passive) Removed Level 13 Sword of Justice (Q) Moved from level 16 New functionality: Can teleport with El'druin's Might twice, returning to Tyrael’s original position. Holy Ground (Q) Moved from level 16 Duration reduced from 4 to 3 seconds (New) Law and Order (W) Reduce the cooldown of Righteousness by 1 second for each enemy Hero hit by Smite.  Righteousness increases the damage of your next Smite by 25% for each ally affected. Burning Rage (Passive) Removed Angelic Absorption (W) Removed Angelic Might (E) Removed Level 16 (New) Burning Halo (Q) El'druin and Tyrael deal 15 damage per second to nearby enemies. This damage is increased by 100% for Tyrael for 3 seconds after teleporting to El’Druin. Horadric Reforging (Q) Moved from level 4 New functionality: Basic Attacks reduce the cooldown of El'druin's Might by 1.5 seconds (New) Smite the Wicked (E) Smite’s cooldown recharges 100% faster while El'druin is out and for 3 seconds after teleporting to El’Druin Blood for Blood (Active) Removed Level 20 (New) Defense of the Angels (Active) Activate to reduce all incoming damage by 40% for 5 seconds.  Any time Tyrael or an ally shielded by Righteousness take damage, reduce the cooldown by 3 seconds. 120 second cooldown (New) Seal of El’druin (Passive) Every time Tyrael casts a Basic Ability, increase his Attack Speed by 50% for 3 seconds Nullification Shield (Active) Removed Nexus Blades (Passive) Removed Bug Fixes
      Heroes, Abilities, and Talents
      Blaze: Fixed an issue allowing players to cast Flame Stream while dead if they entered a Bunker while dying. Blaze: Fixed an issue that could cause Heroes to enter permanent Stasis if they were killed just as they entered a Bunker. Hanzo & Leoric: Fixed an issue causing Towers to spawn if Leoric was directly impacted by Sonic Arrow. Malfurion & Stitches:  Fixed an issue that could cause Heroes to become unplayable if Nature’s Cure was cast while they were affected by Stitches’ Gorge. Malfurion & Zagara: Nature’s Cure can no longer cleanse Heroes of the Devouring Maw effect. Uther:  The Well Met talent will no longer affect non-Heroic units. Valeera: The Strangle talent will no longer affect non-Heroic units.
    • By Stan

      Free Hero rotation has been updated for the week of January 16 and it's the first free week for Hanzo!
      Free-to-Play Hero Rotation: January 16, 2018
      Malfurion Valla Gazlowe Johanna Thrall Dehaka Leoric Auriel Greymane Stukov Garrosh (Slot unlocked at Player Level 5) Probius (Slot unlocked at Player Level 10) Valeera (Slot unlocked at Player Level 15) Hanzo (Slot unlocked at Player Level 20) (Source)