Stan

Senior Game Designer on Warriors

17 posts in this topic

4LQQRTTGEPVI1458750284105.jpg

The development team sought to establish a more clear definition of tanks around the time frame between D.Va and Garrosh. With a predefined list of Warrior qualities they found out that Warriors who lack peel are used as bruisers to harass the enemy backline.

Blizzard LogoBlizzard (Source)

From a Hero Design perspective, this is something we've talked about a lot on the team. In years past the conventional wisdom was that a "tank" had to be hard to kill, and do things that are sufficiently disruptive (damage/CC) that you can't simply ignore them - which in turn allows them to soak damage for their team.

However, around the time frame between D.Va and Garrosh, we sought to establish a more clear definition of what's required to "tank" for your team and what tools a Warrior needs to do that effectively.

This isn't a comprehensive list, but I believe we landed on something like the following:

  • Durability/Mitigation (so they're not easy to blow up)
  • Self-sustain (so they can stay in a fight)
  • Peel (so they can protect vulnerable allies)
  • Interrupt (so they can disrupt cast/channeled abilities)

We've found that Warriors who don't have enough of one or more of these qualities end up being used as bruisers to harass the enemy backline. Most of the time it's "peel" that's lacking, as this is the aspect that wasn't as clearly defined in the past. Even now I'd say it's hard to say precisely where that line is, and that it's subjective based on what other heroes are capable of. 

If you look at someone like Sonya with 2 stuns, you'd think she could be a tank - and indeed to some extent she can, but other aspects of her kit push her to be more aggressive and limit how effective she can be at protecting a squishy backline (compared to someone like Muradin or Arthas). I think this is something we're trying to be much more aware of earlier on in the development and playtesting process for new Warriors. Do we want them to be able to tank? If so, do they have all the necessary tools? Are there aspects of their kit that make it unintentionally more difficult for them to do so?

This is something I'd encourage all of you to think about (and feel free to disagree with us on!) when discussing whether a Hero can tank for their team, and what they need to be doing to tank effectively.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

E.T.C. may be a tank by these standards, but Tyrael sure as hell isn't. Have you ever been in a game where Tyrael was able to out-tank anyone while being the second tank on his team? I doubt anyone ever has.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
18 minutes ago, Fliits said:

E.T.C. may be a tank by these standards, but Tyrael sure as hell isn't. Have you ever been in a game where Tyrael was able to out-tank anyone while being the second tank on his team? I doubt anyone ever has.

Tyrael was never a tank. He is a Bruiser with a supportive kit.

I think Blizzard needs to start sorting better their classes with sub-classes (i.e.: Bruiser). Not only that would help with matchmaking, but also prevent people from saying stuff like "Tassadar is a healer" or "D.Va is a tank". Just like they need to further emphasize that Specialists are not exclusively siegers; heck, they even changed the icon and description of the Specialist class since the Chromie / Medivh patch.

Edited by Valhalen

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I actually believe that since the opening of the game and the addition of SO many new heroes throughout the few years, that it has become impossible to label something a "warrior", even if just for QM matching. I think there should be a clear cut TANK and a WARRIOR separation. I.E.

 

Tank:

Muradin, Johanna, Garrosh, ETC

 

Warrior:

Sonya, Tyrael, Rexxar (which at this point is a glorified SPEC), Dehaka

 

Now I guess the question becomes, what about the stuff that's kit COULD become TANK rather than warrior - Varian comes to mind, as well as Anub. Well what's wrong with pruning based on 2 different labels rather than try to fit things under 1? As your game grows I think you'll find you're going to run into this more and more. Obviously this is mostly about QM and how matchmaking searches (getting a game with sonya as your only "warrior" vs a team that has johanna as theirs). Also, for new players completely to the game - or even the genre in general, it's a bit confusing that "Hey, Muradin is a warrior, but I want to "tank" on Sonya, it says she's a warrior too!" I believe you're setting them, and the veteran players they come into contact with, for failure, whether that be abusive chat or just never really giving the game a chance because of the obvious difference in the actual "warrior" roles.

 

TLDR: Why can we not split the Warrior role into Tank and Warrior (Bruiser), would that not better service the design team in fitting certain things into certain roles based on kits?

 

-- Obviously this would open the door to the way healers are combined when you could make a case about having a Healer role and a Support role, but the above would also apply to all of that as well.

Edited by Savagefaction

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 minutes ago, Savagefaction said:

getting a game with sonya as your only "warrior" vs a team that has johanna as theirs

Actually, the new algorithm Blizzard introduced prevents you from getting in a group of a true Tank VS a group without a Tank (it can happen, but it is very very rare).

Sonya and D.Va are classified in the game's data as Bruisers, so at least there is that. I've ran countless Quick Matches with Sonya as the sole Warrior and never got in a match against a Tank Warrior like Johanna or Muradin.

Edited by Valhalen

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
52 minutes ago, Valhalen said:

Tyrael was never a tank. He is a Bruiser with a supportive kit.

He was taken as a tank earlier on in HotS life, but now he's a Sanc bot ): I still view him as a tank, but more along the lines of a Support / Tank hybrid, similar to Uther. 

Losing uncapped Regen Master on him hurt his frontline before they removed the level 13 talent and turned his niche into a dive and utility driven "bruiser" who couldn't put a dent in a house of cards, but, unlike Johanna, he still has access to it, so that's a bonus, I guess? Or maybe just a symptom of the weird design decisions going into these reworks and the inconsistency as they address generic talents at an agonisingly slow rate? 

One of the key things about Warriors that tank and those that either suck at it or aren't considered main tanks is bodyblocking. Both Dehaka and Sonya are classic case examples where they have a lot of tanky attributes and talents, but besides both being too unreliable (how many Warriors have a way to shut down Whirlwind, Sonya's main sustain?) to be a front line and initiator, enemy players can ghost through them when they use certain abilities. Compare this to, let's say, Anub, who has one of the biggest collision circles in the game bar Cho'gall, and can win fights or get picks for his team purely down to a Burrow cutting an enemy hero from retreating past their own gate because Anub is so wide, not to mention that it innately helps to soak skill shots for your team. 

There is a lot of things that make a tank... a tank, besides just being tanky and some hard cc. 
 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So let me get that straight... hots dev team first make a huge basket called "warriors" and puts there so many different chars (some of them are not even close to each other) and then they come and say "Oh wait, we thought a lot about it and we think that good "tank" should have this and this and this... but we will call him warrior anyways and throw him into the warrior's basket to confuse players! Yeah, that is a great idea!"

-__-'

Srsly all we need is just make much more diversity in naming. So many good players and streamers suggested it years ago and still nothing. I can't understand why tye have such problem with that.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's been a long time coming. If blizz is too busy to sit down then they can just use the sub roles from hotslog. I very rarely disagree with their designations. 

Edited by Orshova
Auto correct is a douche

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, Orshova said:

It's been a long time coming. If blizz is too busy to sit down then they can just use the sub roles from hotslog. I very rarely disagree with their designations. 

that would leave the support category with only tassadar and medivh, so I'm thinking their not going to do that, at least not exactly like hotslogs.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Fliits said:

that would leave the support category with only tassadar and medivh, so I'm thinking their not going to do that, at least not exactly like hotslogs.

And maybe lets think for a minute here why is that ?
Maybe it means that there are to little SUPPORT chars in game ??
Maybe blizz should make more support chars instead of warriors and assasins ???
Nah, that couldn't be it... or maybe ? ;)

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
13 hours ago, Plergoth said:

He was taken as a tank earlier on in HotS life, but now he's a Sanc bot ): I still view him as a tank, but more along the lines of a Support / Tank hybrid, similar to Uther. 

Losing uncapped Regen Master on him hurt his frontline before they removed the level 13 talent and turned his niche into a dive and utility driven "bruiser" who couldn't put a dent in a house of cards, but, unlike Johanna, he still has access to it, so that's a bonus, I guess? Or maybe just a symptom of the weird design decisions going into these reworks and the inconsistency as they address generic talents at an agonisingly slow rate? 

One of the key things about Warriors that tank and those that either suck at it or aren't considered main tanks is bodyblocking. Both Dehaka and Sonya are classic case examples where they have a lot of tanky attributes and talents, but besides both being too unreliable (how many Warriors have a way to shut down Whirlwind, Sonya's main sustain?) to be a front line and initiator, enemy players can ghost through them when they use certain abilities. Compare this to, let's say, Anub, who has one of the biggest collision circles in the game bar Cho'gall, and can win fights or get picks for his team purely down to a Burrow cutting an enemy hero from retreating past their own gate because Anub is so wide, not to mention that it innately helps to soak skill shots for your team. 

There is a lot of things that make a tank... a tank, besides just being tanky and some hard cc.

Even in his Alpha days I considered him more of a Bruiser with Support skills. He can do a surprisingly amount of peel and interrupts, though. I really hope they give him a deserved rework to define better his role/niche.

Your points regarding the tanks are very valid. I think despite all nuisances and inconsistences here and there, Blizzard made a great job by adding very different types of tanks. They're polishing the edges really well.

2 hours ago, Godeyes said:

And maybe lets think for a minute here why is that ?
Maybe it means that there are to little SUPPORT chars in game ??
Maybe blizz should make more support chars instead of warriors and assasins ???
Nah, that couldn't be it... or maybe ? ;)

Blizzard has been hearing the community on more Supports. And we've got plenty of really meta-changing Supports this year (Ana herself makes the Double Support meta even more powerful).

Don't get me wrong, I'm all for more Supports in this game.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
19 hours ago, Stan said:

This isn't a comprehensive list, but I believe we landed on something like the following:

  • Durability/Mitigation (so they're not easy to blow up)
  • Self-sustain (so they can stay in a fight)
  • Peel (so they can protect vulnerable allies)
  • Interrupt (so they can disrupt cast/channeled abilities)

We've found that Warriors who don't have enough of one or more of these qualities end up being used as bruisers to harass the enemy backline.

This is really scary to read 3 years after the game's release. What the hell did they think tanks were meant to do?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, Oxygen said:

This is really scary to read 3 years after the game's release. What the hell did they think tanks were meant to do?

But isn't E.T.C. pretty much all of that combined in one Hero?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
12 minutes ago, Valhalen said:

But isn't E.T.C. pretty much all of that combined in one Hero?

It is; I'm just wondering why they're even bothering stating it. It makes it sound like it's some kind of deep discovery.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
10 minutes ago, Oxygen said:

It is; I'm just wondering why they're even bothering stating it. It makes it sound like it's some kind of deep discovery.

Well, to the newbs and noobs, maybe? There are still people who claim that Tassadar is a Healer.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Inb4 Tyrael screams "REWORK ME!" "UPDATE ME!" in a corner...

They could also make a Mage class and put the appropriate people/elves/liches/fire elementals/idk what else there to make the Assassin class less crowded (Mage Wars hello?) since game could be called Assassins Creed right now.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, SteveFrost said:

Inb4 Tyrael screams "REWORK ME!" "UPDATE ME!" in a corner...

They could also make a Mage class and put the appropriate people/elves/liches/fire elementals/idk what else there to make the Assassin class less crowded (Mage Wars hello?) since game could be called Assassins Creed right now.

Maybe divide the Assassin Class in two sub-ranks: Physical Damage and Ability Damage.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Stan
      Production Director Kaéo Milker talks about improvements coming to the game in the near future. All skins will be purchasable individually with Gems and Lunar Festival has been reimagined as the Spring Event.
      Highlights
      The next Hero release is around the corner, but it seems Anduin is planned for later. Spring Event is coming soon and it will be very similar to other events like Nexomania, The Fall of King's Crest in Fall, and the Toys. The team would like to explore more of these events and universes. Reddit AMAs focusing on Quick Match and the Role Overhaul will be announced soon. Beginning with the latest patch that hits next week, all skins in the Collection will be purchasable individually with Gems and Gold can be converted to Shards starting with the Spring Event patch. Blizzard (Source)
      Hi, Heroes!
      I know we’ve been more quiet than usual the past few weeks, but it’s not because we’ve lost focus on the game. In fact, we’ve been working very hard behind the scenes to regroup as a team and align on our goals for 2019 and beyond. As I mentioned before, this process involved revisiting not only our existing plans, but also rethinking some of our approaches to core areas of the game and its development with our focus solely on creating the best experience possible for our players. It’s been a bunch of work and there’s still much more work ahead, but we’re finally ready to get back to talking about our plans and sharing some insight as to what our players can expect next.
      We can’t talk about Heroes without talking about our awesome content. As you’ve seen so far this year, we released Imperius along with a flurry of impactful hero balance changes across the game. We also announced our Resistance themed event before bringing it to PTR this week, and we’re excited to deliver those fun skins for Hanzo, Deckard, and my BFF, Blaze, next week! While we have more balance changes coming at regular intervals, our next new hero is also right around the corner. There are some theories floating around as to who’s next, but we have a few more releases before they’ll be ready to see the light of day.
      Speaking of our next few releases, you probably noticed that our Lunar New Year seasonal event hasn’t hit yet, but fear not – that’s just because we’ve reimagined it as our Spring Event. Last year we had a ton of fun with our unique seasonal events like Nexomania in Summer, The Fall of King’s Crest in Fall, and Toys in Winter, and we’d like to continue exploring fun new universes and themes to coincide with each season moving forward. Stay tuned for all the details on our Spring Event next month, and know that we’ll not only be bringing back our previous limited-time Lunar New Year content, but we’ll also unveil an exciting, all-new skin theme to round out this year’s event.
      Let’s talk about features and systems. There’s been a lot of discussion both on the Heroes dev team and amongst our community regarding the state of Ranked Play, Quick Match, and matchmaking. The team’s made some decisions as a continuation of the plans we shared at BlizzCon and we have a schedule for a series of improvements we’ll be making across the next few patches and Ranked Seasons. Much like we did in our AMA’s last year, we’d like to have the developers responsible for those changes discuss these plans with you at our next Reddit AMA, tentatively planned for later this month. As part of that AMA, we’ll also dive into some thoughts surrounding our continued evolution of Quick Match and our upcoming completion of the Hero Role overhaul, so please join us for that discussion. We’ll share the upcoming Reddit AMA schedule soon!
      Another thing I mentioned in my last post was that we’d be reevaluating not only our content and feature plans, but also taking another look at how players unlock the Collection. As part of looking back, we took stock of where we’ve been across the game’s lifespan. We recognized that Heroes 2.0 was an important step in our game’s evolution and brought a lot of very positive changes. It grew our audience, got more players earning or buying the stuff we loved creating, and most importantly – it uncapped progression and gave all Heroes players a chance to unlock content in the Collection for free by simply playing the game and earning Loot Chests. While we saw a lot of benefits from our Heroes 2.0 changes, they did come at the cost of taking away the ability to purchase most skins directly. I’m excited to say that we’ve decided to make some changes here based on player feedback.
      Beginning with the Resistance patch that hits next week, all skins in the Collection will be purchasable individually with Gems. This is a change that many of our players have asked for, and we’re really happy to finally bring it to the game. Note that this goes beyond what we offered pre-Heroes 2.0, as every skin in the Collection will now have a Gem and Shard price individually, whereas before Heroes 2.0 skins were only available in bundles that included every color variation. Be sure to check out the patch notes next week for all the details and know that we have plans down the road to expand these offerings to the rest of the Collection. We hope this change helps give players the best option yet to get the exact content they’re most excited about.
      We didn’t want to stop there, so we also looked deeper at ways we could provide more value and utility with Gold. As a result, we’re going to start allowing players to convert their earned Gold to Shards alongside the release of our Spring Event next month. This change combined with the Gem changes is intended to give all players maximum flexibility in how they unlock their favorite content, and the team is excited to provide these options.
      So that’s a lot of stuff summarized at once here, and the team will be elaborating on it all as it unfolds across the next few patches. The past few months have been challenging for us, but the Heroes team is united with a passion for this game and all of you in our community. It’s been difficult to remain so silent while we unpacked all these changes, but we’re eager to get back to communicating regularly with you and talking about the game we all love. To that end, be on the lookout for our next few AMAs across February, March, and April and we’ll be striving to find more ways to get our developers involved in discussing the game with you.
      Thank you for bearing with us as we adapt to these changes, and we can’t wait to share more of the awesome things we’re working on with you in the coming weeks and months! In the meantime, please keep that feedback coming!
      Kaéo
    • By Stan
      Lunara, Probius, and Stitches are on sale this week along with the Flirty Cloud mount.
      Blizzard (Source)
      Our latest round of Heroic Deals and Limited-Time Offers brings 50% off of a limited selection of Heroes and a fresh set of limited-availability skins and mounts into the collection for purchase or crafting. Check out the Hero sales and featured items listed below, and then head in-game to add them to your collection before these offers expire!
      Heroic Deals: February 19 - 26

      Heroes Discount Price Lunara 625 312 Gems Stitches 625 312 Gems Probius 750 375 Gems Limited-Time Offers: February 12 
      The skins and mounts that we’ve added to the Limited-Time Offers are available for Gem purchase and Shard crafting for a period of a few weeks, starting on February 12. Be sure to grab these items now, because once the offer expires they will leave the collection until the next time they’re featured here!
      Skins Mounts Paramour Pajamathur Abathur Flirty Cloud We hope you enjoy your new Heroes, skins, and mounts as you conquer your next challenge in the Nexus! Be sure to head to the Heroes of the Storm website every week to check out our latest round of Heroic Deals and Limited-Time Offers.
    • By Stan
      Free Hero rotation has been updated for the week of February 19.
      Free-to-Play Hero Rotation: February 19, 2019
      Malfurion Valla Gazlowe Johanna Thrall Dehaka Tyrael Lunara Kharazim Kerrigan D.Va (Slot unlocked at Player Level 5) Maiev (Slot unlocked at Player Level 10) Medivh (Slot unlocked at Player Level 15) Nova (Slot unlocked at Player Level 20) (Source)
    • By Stan
      The Nexus Forces have taken over a Volskaya Industries Factory - fight to the death to obtain its manufactured power! Two teams enter, one team leaves.
      Blizzard (Source)
      Rules:
      Battle it out on a single-lane Overwatch-themed Battleground known only as… the Trial Grounds. Shuffle Pick Choose from one of three Heroes at the beginning of the match. Choose carefully though, you won’t have the opportunity to choose again after rounds. Elimination A round is won when all Heroes on the enemy team are slain. Best of Three The first team to win two rounds will win the Brawl! Round Events  Starting at 60 seconds, an elevator will rise in the center of the Battleground, presenting one of the following challenges to both teams: Tribute Capture the Tribute to reduce the health of all enemy Heroes to 1! Capture Point  Capture the point to spawn a Triglav Protector for your team! Artifact Artifact spawns in the center of the Battleground. The first Hero to walk over it gains its power! The Hero that kills the artifact carrier will claim it for themselves. Dueling Immortals Immortals spawn for each team in the center of the Battleground. Once an immortal has been slain, the winning team’s Immortal will take to the sky, revealing the map and raining destruction onto the enemy Heroes. Safe Zone  A Safe Zone is created at the center of the Battleground. Every 15 seconds the entire map is electrified, and only those in the Safe Zone will be protected. There’s also a chance for no event at all. You’ll just have to rely on your own ruthless skills to take down the enemy Heroes and be the last team standing! Rewards:
      Complete three matches of Trial Grounds to earn a Loot Chest!
    • By Stan
      This week's sales include Abathur, Artanis, Butcher, and the Flirty Cloud mount!
      Blizzard (Source)
      Our latest round of Heroic Deals and Limited-Time Offers brings 50% off of a limited selection of Heroes and a fresh set of limited-availability skins and mounts into the collection for purchase or crafting. Check out the Hero sales and featured items listed below, and then head in-game to add them to your collection before these offers expire!
      Heroic Deals: February 12 - 19

      Heroes Discount Price Butcher 625 312 Gems Artanis 625 312 Gems Abathur 750 375 Gems Limited-Time Offers: February 12 
      The skins and mounts that we’ve added to the Limited-Time Offers are available for Gem purchase and Shard crafting for a period of a few weeks. Be sure to grab these items now, because once the offer expires they will leave the collection until the next time they’re featured here!
      Skins Mounts Paramour Pajamathur Abathur Flirty Cloud We hope you enjoy your new Heroes, skins, and mounts as you conquer your next challenge in the Nexus! Be sure to head to the Heroes of the Storm website every week to check out our latest round of Heroic Deals and Limited-Time Offers.
      Head to the official Heroes of the Storm forums to discuss this post with other players.