Oxygen

Six Aspects of HotS That Need Improvement

49 posts in this topic

An incredibly thorough and well written piece reflecting everything and more the kind of improvements and features HotS players want to see. The reconnect system for me should be a priority, both with the AI control and the catch up after reconnecting makes an otherwise fun game extremely stressful out of nowhere, but things like a gift system wouldn't go amiss either. There are times where I feel like ringing up Blizzard and offering to come and push the HotS engine down to the local garage so it can get jump started. 

They have been fairly consistent with improving the game in many other areas, I just hope they have a lot of goals that they are aware of and are pushing to reach for next year. 

Edited by Plergoth
  • Like 6

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The reason the reconnect system works as it does is simply because of the hots runs on the SC2 engine, which is designed to have both the client and the server on the same page, and record every single action that happened in game. In SC2, this works fine because you simply cannot continue the game when someone dcs simply because those who have the extra time will win period, as every second is precious, so the game pauses when someone DCs. In Hots however, you can't simply "pause the game" when someone leaves when there are 9 other players in the match, so they had to come up with that backwards reconnect system. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 minutes ago, AnotherRussianGamer said:

The reason the reconnect system works as it does is simply because of the hots runs on the SC2 engine, which is designed to have both the client and the server on the same page, and record every single action that happened in game. In SC2, this works fine because you simply cannot continue the game when someone dcs simply because those who have the extra time will win period, as every second is precious, so the game pauses when someone DCs. In Hots however, you can't simply "pause the game" when someone leaves when there are 9 other players in the match, so they had to come up with that backwards reconnect system. 

I played a bit ignorant there, but I know this is the reason. I need to question *why*, however, we must endure this system. Good insight.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 minutes ago, Oxygen said:

I played a bit ignorant there, but I know this is the reason. I need to question *why*, however, we must endure this system. Good insight.

Bad design. As most of us know, Blizzard Dota was originally an SC2 arcade game mode, and as it got bigger they had to make it a standalone title, and were too lazy to develop a new engine, and thought that if Valve can make a moba on a pre-existing engine meant for another genre, why can't we? Unfortunately, unlike Source which Dota 2 was originally built on, the SC2 engine is not versatile at all, and came with more detrimental engine restrictions than Dota 2 originally had, so ultimately, Blizzard needs to do an engine remake.

Edited by AnotherRussianGamer

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is all well and good - But the Class System only needs one change. And that change requests some hero re-design but that is also something that would fix it up.

Time and again I see morons saying that Heroes needs more sub classes to be more like LoL and Dota. No. Heroes just needs Warrior - Healer - Assassin and Specialist.

Have Warriors be Tanky, there is no need nor any reason for them to be DPS'y like Sonya and Artanis.

Healers should be healers, not "supports" - They should heal and focus on keeping members of their team up, not doing damage.

Assassins can keep on doing what they do now.

Specialists should be better rounded so they all can deal with both structure damage and camps as right now a great deal of Warriors are better for camp clearing than most specialists while some Warriors and Assassins are better IN the lane than specialists (But not necessarily on structure damage)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

How about bad behaviour and people that constantly afk/alt tab mid game ( especially on start but even mid game),those that assist enemy ( garrosh throwing you to your death or saving enemy  for example), etc etc?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@Oxygen

You are totally on point with this article.

I couldn't agree more - especially with points 2 and 3.
Lack of transparity + reconection issue are so disappointing in this game. Not to mention you are totally punished if you do not manage to reconnect in time - even if it isn't your fault.

I would add 1 other issue that somewhat corresponds to the first issue - current role system is BAD. We get chars like ETC and Zarya in 1 basket called "warriors" when they are so damn different. New players take those chars like Zarya/Sonya/Rexx and don't understand that they are NOT tanks...

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The reconnect system should be devs highest priority since that garbage is there from so long and make you lose games even if you DC for a short period you take much longer to use the hero again even if you are already online.

Also yeah those stupid talents picked by AI are very annoying since they pick always the same thing for example if you DC with tyrande at 9 AI will take starfall no matter what resulting in rage after you reconnect cursing blizzard.

I wish they add to select all talents at lv 1 so when you reach the level it gets autopicked so AI can't take it in your place.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, Oxygen said:

If Blizzard is bent on keeping its current role system, Quick Match mode simply cannot continue to exist in its current form. The solution is rather simple: Just like the World of Warcraft dungeon system, and, more closely related, League of Legends’ Draft Pick system, players should simply select the role they wish to play before a given match, and not the hero itself. Enforce a basic 1-tank, 1-healer, 3-assassins/specialists rule. If there aren’t enough tank or healer players around to make queue times reasonable, incentivize players to switch to these roles with gold and experience bonuses that scale directly with how many players for roles are necessary to regulate said queue times. This would have the positive side effect of pushing players towards experimenting with new, different roles, potentially increasing hero purchases, and giving players a better understanding of the game as a whole. The same system should certainly be introduced to non-Team-League-Draft modes as well.

This could work, but would completely contradict the concept of Quick Match being a... Well... Quick Match. Where you simply pick a Hero you feel compelled to use.

If anything, I think the system should be a bit more "gentle" in a similar vein to Overwatch, where it displays a warning that there is no "Tank" or "Support". Simply forcing players that they HAVE to follow that Team Composition defeats the purpose of Quick Match.

Don't get me wrong, I hate when I get in 5 Assassin Teams VS Traditional Teams; although the current matchmaking does the best it can to try to queue you with another team filled with the same roles (it's not perfect, however). On the other hand, I have a LOT of fun gathering some buddies and doing stuff like running with 5 Supports.

On the other hand, your points are completely valid. But I think that a solution would be, would be to allow the player to select which roles they want to be filled in the other slots; this would be especially useful when solo queueing.

In my opinion Blizzard should also dissect further the roles, adding in-game the "Bruiser" subrank for Warriors, for example. Adding subranks would be useful to teach players that Heroes in the same class can perform different types of tasks (i.e. Medivh is a Specialist, but he is not made to perform Sieging, or that Tassadar is a Support, but is not suited for solo-healing).

6 hours ago, Oxygen said:
  • I’d like to be able to check out mounts in Try Mode.
  • I wish I could use my Stimpacks whenever I please. As it stands, I don’t open Loot Chests unless I know I’ll be playing for a while, and if I do open a Stimpack by accident, I just ALT+F4 my way out of the game to preserve it.
  • I would love to have an item gifting feature for my teammate’s birthday.
  • I don’t particularly care for the forced MVP cut scene after every single match. I rarely see more than 2 people vote anyway; let’s at least have the option to opt out of it.
  • I’d like to be able to check out anyone’s profile, at any time, if I happen to know their BattleTag.
  • I wish my heroes were available across other regions.
  • Players who opt out of receiving messages from non-friends probably shouldn’t be able to whisper other players.

THIS SO DAMN FUCKING MUCH.

Oxygen, please, send this to Blizzard.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I feel like the AI talent picking could be fixed if you could save talent paths on your profile. The AI would just continue the path based on what you picked.

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As people said before, all actions will be saved in a log. Its a good design for sc and also ok for hots. The cool thing is, you cant have any server laggs. I know this from Battlefield where you killed someone in your client and you die after him because he killed you in his client too and its all because of the client-server connection. And this is impossible in hots due to the system. But so we have to live with this bad reconnctions system. When you try to reconnect all actions have to readjust to the point where your team is and this takes a little bit of time. So hots need a new engine, when they want to change this reconnect/ replay system. Aslong hots isnt more popular i think they wont change it.

 

I only dont understand why sometimes the reconnect button disapears, that i have to restart the game before i can reconnect.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
19 minutes ago, Xaethron said:

I feel like the AI talent picking could be fixed if you could save talent paths on your profile. The AI would just continue the path based on what you picked.

Or do it the simplest way there is - after you reconnect you can pick again talents that were picked by AI.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

just registered to icy veins only to thank you for this awesome article! some stuff i wasnt even aware about, but while reading i was like "hell, yeeah, that's true and i didn't even know better!"

biiiig thumbs up! hope this gets shared and blizzard somehow recognizes it! and yeah, let's see what blizzcon has in stores for heroes!

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, DeadPixel said:

I know this from Battlefield where you killed someone in your client and you die after him because he killed you in his client too and its all because of the client-server connection.

Keep in mind that Battlefield hosts games for up to 64 players, while HotS is a game for 10 people. Some system just don't scale so well and have to be replaced by a different one that can handle larger amounts of players at once.
Additionally, in the case of Battlefield, you have to consider projectile speed, as there is a chance of both bullets being in the air at the same time, especially for long range combat.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
13 hours ago, Valhalen said:

This could work, but would completely contradict the concept of Quick Match being a... Well... Quick Match. Where you simply pick a Hero you feel compelled to use.

If anything, I think the system should be a bit more "gentle" in a similar vein to Overwatch, where it displays a warning that there is no "Tank" or "Support". Simply forcing players that they HAVE to follow that Team Composition defeats the purpose of Quick Match.

Don't get me wrong, I hate when I get in 5 Assassin Teams VS Traditional Teams; although the current matchmaking does the best it can to try to queue you with another team filled with the same roles (it's not perfect, however). On the other hand, I have a LOT of fun gathering some buddies and doing stuff like running with 5 Supports.

On the other hand, your points are completely valid. But I think that a solution would be, would be to allow the player to select which roles they want to be filled in the other slots; this would be especially useful when solo queueing.

In my opinion Blizzard should also dissect further the roles, adding in-game the "Bruiser" subrank for Warriors, for example. Adding subranks would be useful to teach players that Heroes in the same class can perform different types of tasks (i.e. Medivh is a Specialist, but he is not made to perform Sieging, or that Tassadar is a Support, but is not suited for solo-healing).

THIS SO DAMN FUCKING MUCH.

Oxygen, please, send this to Blizzard.

I think for the MVP thing, they should give rewards at the end of the game or season. For example a mount or a nice chunk of gold

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
12 hours ago, DeadPixel said:

As people said before, all actions will be saved in a log. Its a good design for sc and also ok for hots. The cool thing is, you cant have any server laggs. I know this from Battlefield where you killed someone in your client and you die after him because he killed you in his client too and its all because of the client-server connection. And this is impossible in hots due to the system. But so we have to live with this bad reconnctions system. When you try to reconnect all actions have to readjust to the point where your team is and this takes a little bit of time. So hots need a new engine, when they want to change this reconnect/ replay system. Aslong hots isnt more popular i think they wont change it.

 

I only dont understand why sometimes the reconnect button disapears, that i have to restart the game before i can reconnect.

How popular is HotS in comparison to other mobas? I know that LoL is stagnating, and DotA is well DotA

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
16 hours ago, AnotherRussianGamer said:

Bad design. As most of us know, Blizzard Dota was originally an SC2 arcade game mode, and as it got bigger they had to make it a standalone title, and were too lazy to develop a new engine, and thought that if Valve can make a moba on a pre-existing engine meant for another genre, why can't we? Unfortunately, unlike Source which Dota 2 was originally built on, the SC2 engine is not versatile at all, and came with more detrimental engine restrictions than Dota 2 originally had, so ultimately, Blizzard needs to do an engine remake.

Is there a way to upgrade the existing engine, so it's as versatile as the source engine? I mean if it can be upgraded without the need for an entirely new engine

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's been over two years since the release, and Blizzy didn't even try to fix reconnect issue or improve matchmaking.

I had over 2000 matches in the game and finally uninstalled it because I fed up of getting matched with players who have 100-200 games. They have no map awareness, usually ignore objectives and feed instead of getting xp, but are always the first to blame the team.

Moreover, there are many players who don't even try to come back after just one lost team fight or objective.

The game had bad matchmaking and MMR from the start, which led to good players leaving HotS because they don't want to play with idiots. This led to even worse matchmaking and even more players leaving the game.

After all this time and infamous HotS 2.0 patch that added boxes and more skins but completely ignored gameplay issues, I personally don't have any hope for the game.

There's only one thing they ever did right: disabled chat with opposing team.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
15 hours ago, Valhalen said:

THIS SO DAMN FUCKING MUCH.

Oxygen, please, send this to Blizzard.

My hope is that it'll find them organically. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Oxygen said:

My hope is that it'll find them organically. 

Maybe you could post this on the Battle.Net forums too. Although I'm not sure if it is a good idea given how toxic people are there.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, Valhalen said:

Maybe you could post this on the Battle.Net forums too. Although I'm not sure if it is a good idea given how toxic people are there.

Someone did before I could. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 hours ago, Dejo93 said:

Is there a way to upgrade the existing engine, so it's as versatile as the source engine? I mean if it can be upgraded without the need for an entirely new engine

Any time there has been this kind of thing suggested for other games, there has often been hints at the idea that the code just currently doesn't allow it, or that it's old code and so can't be upgraded without being remade.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Oxygen
      Find out more about how the recently-announced 2019 gameplay changes will affect Heroes of the Storm in the long run.
      Just over a year ago, in preparation for BlizzCon 2017, I produced a lengthy article outlining some of Heroes of the Storm's most important issues. Notable among these was that of Quick Match team compositions. To me, Heroes of the Storm had always been clearly designed and balanced with tanks and healers in mind. As such, failing to enforce team compositions that included these classes caused a number of important problems across the game.
      Following disappointing BlizzCon 2017 announcements on the matter (class changes were discussed briefly, but composition changes were not), a reddit post and a blog post published six months later would confirm that changes to Quick match team compositions were indeed in the works, though no ETA was given. BlizzCon 2018 was a pretty safe bet that would turn out to be accurate.
      So, what's the big deal?
      As Heroes of the Storm's introductory - and most popular - game mode, Quick Match must absolutely accomplish two things: Groom its player base for improvement and present Heroes of the Storm in the best light possible.
      Year after year, however, the Quick Match system has continued to fail on both counts completely, discouraging new players and veterans alike with frustrating matches that taught bad habits and ultimately hindered the growth of the player base's skill level. How can players learn to follow up without a tank to initiate? How can they possibly internalize what their reasonable survivability is like against five other assassins? The answer is simple: They can't, because these situations are nonsensical and for the most part subpar in any remotely competent environment. Fortunately, this will soon be a thing of the past.
      Placing players in a tank-healer environment - around which the game was designed - leads me to believe that player base's skill level to improve across all game modes. Drafting skill is likely to improve as well, leading to fewer draft infighting situations. Further, it  will reduce the frustration caused by unreasonable team compositions to ultimately better retain new players, whom will get to experience the game as it was meant to be played as opposed to this rather ridiculous game mode.
      Needless to say, I think this is one of the best BlizzCon announcements to date, though I must still question what took so long. The most educated guess I can produce has to do with fearing longer queue times, but here's to hoping the "Call of the Nexus" incentive will be enough to entice players into checking out classes they haven't tried out just yet. A strong enough incentive could have the positive side effect of allowing players to develop a better global understanding of the game through approaching roles they're less used to.
      Classy new classes
      The new class system builds on the old system simply by further specializing the existing classes and removing specialists. Reworking the class system was necessary to allow team compositions to be reworked themselves.
      Heroes in the old warrior class were divided into the tank and bruiser classes, with tanks now being mandatory for Quick Match team compositions. This makes sense, as many bruisers were typically unable to fulfill the role of true tanks completely, which is to reliably initiate and peel. Allowing the warrior class to continue existing in its current state would have created the kind of lopsided team composition problems we experienced back when Varian was treated as a damage dealer.
      Heroes in the support class were divided into pure healers and support heroes, which is just a way of identifying heroes who do not use healing as their primary means of assisting teammates. Given that healers must now be included in team compositions to the same extent as tanks, this change also makes sense.
      The specialist class was merged with the assassin class because it hadn't made sense in a long time to treat them any differently; most of them were simply fancy damage dealers. The assassin class itself was split up into melee and ranged assassins.
      If you've been keeping up with some of the more recent versions of my tier lists - I don't blame you if you haven't - you'll note that I had already opted to further divide the classes, with a focus on play style rather than role a few months ago. Specifically, melee assassins are divided into fighters and stalkers, and ranged assassins into marksman and casters. My system has the advantage of being a bit more flexible for edge cases such as Genji and Tracer, who play more like melee assassins yet were labeled as ranged by Blizzard. Still, this distinction is of little relevance to most players.
      Conclusion
      Short conclusions mean I am happy with things.
      Oxygen discusses why the announced changes might just be the best thing to happen to HotS.
    • By Stan
      A shroud of uncertainly looms over the future of HGC and Heroes Esports as a whole due to the lack of HGC updates for the upcoming year and many pro players as well as casters are either done with the game or transferring to other games.
      Gillyweed (HGC Caster)
      The well-known female HGC caster is moving to Rocket League in 2019.
      Placeholder for tweet 1070532465503088640 Trikslyr (HGC Caster)
      Tim announced he won't be casting HGC in 2019 and he plans to make streaming his major focus.
      Placeholder for tweet 1071925490473152518 Tetcher (HGC China Caster)
      Chris voiced his uncertainty on Twitter today, following the lack of HGC information.
      Placeholder for tweet 1072029712514510849 We're going to closely monitor any announcements, so keep an eye out on the Heroes news section!
    • By Stan
      Free Hero rotation has been updated for the week of December 11.
      Free-to-Play Hero Rotation: December 11, 2018
      Raynor Muradin Sonya Nazeebo Uther Jaina Zarya Li-Ming Deckard Blaze Yrel (Slot unlocked at Player Level 5) Junkrat (Slot unlocked at Player Level 10) Tychus (Slot unlocked at Player Level 15) Whitemane (Slot unlocked at Player Level 20) (Source)
    • By Stan
      The first Season of 2019 starts next week with the release of the latest patch. New rewards are up for grabs. Check out the official preview of the Season!
      Blizzard (Source)
      Heroes of the Storm’s fourth 2018 ranked season is ending soon, and we’ve got a host of new rewards that you can earn through ranked gameplay in the coming months. Read on for details!
      Season Roll Dates
      2019 Season 1 will begin as soon as our next patch becomes available for download in each region. Check the start and end dates below to make sure you’re able to dive in as soon as the season begins:
      EVENT DATE 2019 Season 1 Start Week of December 11, 2018* 2019 Season 1 End Week of March 19, 2019* *Exact date may vary slightly by region.
      2019 Season 1 Rewards
      Players who manage to climb the ranks in the upcoming season can claim new portraits, mounts, and gold rewards for their achievements in Hero and Team League. Take a look at everything that’s up for grabs this season!
      This Season's Ranked Portraits are still in progress and will be shown at a later date. Please stay tuned!
      Mount Rewards

      HERO LEAGUE RANK REWARDS Bronze 500 Gold Bronze Hero League Portrait Silver 750 Gold Silver Hero League Portrait Gold 1000 Gold Gold Hero League Portrait Platinum 1250 Gold Season 1 Mount Platinum Hero League Portrait Diamond 1500 Gold Season 1 Mount Diamond Hero League Portrait Master 1750 Gold Season 1 Mount Epic Season 1 Mount Master Hero League Portrait Grand Master 2000 Gold Season 1 Mount Epic Season 1 Mount Grand Master Hero League Portrait TEAM LEAGUE RANK REWARDS Bronze 500 Gold Season 1 Mount Bronze Team League Portrait Silver 750 Gold Season 1 Mount Silver Team League Portrait Gold 1000 Gold Season 1 Mount Gold Team League Portrait Platinum 1250 Gold Season 1 Mount Platinum Team League Portrait Diamond 1500 Gold Season 1 Mount Diamond Team League Portrait Master 1750 Gold Season 1 Mount Epic Season 1 Mount Master Team League Portrait Grand Master 2000 Gold Season 1 Mount Epic Season 1 Mount Grand Master Team League Portrait If you’re ready to begin your Ranked Play journey in Heroes of the Storm but are unsure how, head over to our Ranked Play Guide to get started on the right foot. 
    • By Stan
      This week's brawl is Temple Arena. Harness the power of the Temples to destroy the enemy Core. The first team to win 2 rounds is victorious. Complete three matches to earn a Loot Chest.
      Blizzard (Source)
      This week’s brawl is the Temple Arena! Harness the power of the Alligator, Cobra, and Jackal Temples to destroy the enemy Core!

      Rules:
      Choose from one of three randomly selected Heroes before entering the Arena. Be quick about it though, you only have 30 seconds to choose! Everyone will begin the round at level 10 and will be asked to choose a Heroic Ability. No other talents will be available. During each round, slay the enemy team’s Heroes and capture the Temple Shrines to take shots at their Core! The Core for each team will have set amounts of health based on the number of active Shrines. Each round can have 1-3 active Shrines. The first team whose Core reaches 0 health will lose the round. Be the first team to win 2 rounds and claim victory! Rewards:
      Complete three matches of the Temple Arena to earn a Loot Chest! Find out more about the Heroes Brawl game mode on our Heroes Brawl site; and as always, you can find more information on this week’s Brawl by clicking the Brawl Info button at the bottom of the play screen when preparing to queue for the Brawl game mode.