Jump to content
FORUMS
Sign in to follow this  
Stan

A Good War Novella: Plot Summary

Recommended Posts

zwJNGe7.jpg

Why did Sylvanas decide to go to war and burn down Teldrassil? What's Saurfang's reaction to all this madness? Check out our plot summary of "A Good War" to find answers to some interesting questions!

The article contains spoilers.

After reading A Good War, I must admit that the in-game War of Thorns was insufficient and lacked a lot of information. If you thought that it was Blizzard's bad writing, the novel will prove you wrong. I still need to finish reading Elegy to get the full picture, but here's a summary of the Horde novel.

A Good War Summary

Sylvanas wants war, because she believes there can't be a long-lasting peace between the factions, unless the Horde wins it on the battlefield on their terms, so why delay the inevitable? She also fears of imminent Alliance attacks carried out by Anduin/Greymane. Both factions still do not understand the full potential of Azerite, but they know for sure that it will create a new generation of warfare.

Alliance spies have infiltrated Orgrimmar and Sylvanas wants to use that to her advantage by making the Alliance's intelligence tell the wrong story and fool them into sending an army to Silithus. She has a private meeting with Saurfang and asks him if it was possible to destroy Stormwind. She trusts the High Overlord, because he's the only person she knew who had conquered both Stormwind and Orgrimmar. Stormwind has a huge terrain advantage over Orgrimmar and it would not be possible to conquer it with just one direct assault. As opposed to Stormwind, Orgrimmar has docks outside of the city, making it vulnerable if attacked from both fronts.

Anduin is an inexperienced leader, he's not like Varian. Sylvanas thinks that Genn could wage war against the Horde without Anduin's permission. In the past, he attempted to murder her without any approval of the Alliance and got away with it without any form of punishment.

Sylvanas asked Saurfang if it was feasible to take control over Kalimdor, given that the Alliance hold on Eastern Kingdoms was strong. She would like to destroy the Alliance from within and cause chaos among the leaders. If Genn, Tyrande & Malfurion, all, wanted different things from Anduin, he would not be able to make the right decision for everybody. Defeating and making deals with the individual Alliance leaders would make the Alliance crumble.

Sylvanas and Saurfang next discuss if it was possible to attack Darnassus. Sylvanas literally wants to inflict a wound that can never heal. She knows there's no turning back and if successful, the Alliance would attack Undercity and Silvermoon City.

a good war-page-010.jpga good war-page-011.jpga good war-page-012.jpga good war-page-013.jpga good war-page-014.jpg

Both the Horde and the Alliance have lost their naval power after defeating the Burning Legion. Sylvanas specifically mentions that the Horde can't use their ships for both transport and war.

Malfurion Stormrage and Tyrande Whisperwind are considered unbeatable, those two would be a terror for the Horde once the fighting began. They had lived for so long, and survived so much, that Saurfang had to consider the possibility that they could hold off the Horde long enough for the Alliance to send help. The next stage was to wait for an opportunity and take it if they give the Horde one.

a good war-page-021.jpga good war-page-022.jpg

Sylvanas praised Saurfang for learning the ways of deceptions well. Next, they needed the Alliance to believe the rift between them is widening. They let a caught spy escape and the Alliance gladly took the bait.

a good war-page-023.jpga good war-page-024.jpga good war-page-025.jpga good war-page-026.jpg

Everything is going so smoothly that they launch the attack in just one week. Horde forces march into Northern Barrens, but at the Crossroads, Saurfang orders them to go to Ashenvale instead of Silithus. Horde Rogues (Lorash and Rifen) kill an Ashenvale Commander, but Rifen's hand is bitten off by a nightsaber, he's killed while Lorash manages to escape.

The Horde advancement in Ashenvale is described thoroughly. Lorash's portraited as a cunning rogue in combat. His goal is to get Malfurion's head. Alliance Druids are trying to fend off the Horde by burning down bridges, but they only delay the inevitable. It's more than clear that the Alliance knows about the Horde presence in Ashenvale, but they won't be able to send reinforcements in time to make a difference.

Malfurion summons a wisp wall to win enough time for Night Elf forces to arrive. Sylvanas orders the forces to retreat and Saurfang to find a way route from Felwood to Darkshore.

Mr. Honor interferes in the duel between Sylvanas and Malfurion. Saurfang delivers an almost fatal blow, but regrets it shortly after. Sylvanas tells him how well he did and orders him to finish off Malfurion. When she later finds out that Saurfang failed to kill him, in other words, inflict a wound that would never heal, Sylvanas decides to take things into her own hands and burn down Teldrassil. Saurfang is obviously not happy with her choice and wonders if it had been the plan all along.

a good war-page-080.jpga good war-page-081.jpga good war-page-082.jpga good war-page-083.jpga good war-page-084.jpga good war-page-085.jpga good war-page-086.jpga good war-page-087.jpga good war-page-088.jpga good war-page-089.jpg

...and what exactly did the Alliance leaders do to help Elves defend Teldrassil? Well... nothing. Malfurion was only trying to win time for more forces to arrive and Anduin was just casually chilling in Stormwind. Many questions still remain unanswered, I'll report back after reading Elegy.

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You've covered why conquering Darnassus was a step towards conquering Stormwind but you failed to cover why conquer Stormwind or go to war at all. This is actually essential. I don't know if you wanted to give people reasons to hate Sylvanas even more but such inaccuracy is the reason for the whole drama and "Sylvanas is Hitler" bullshit. Some idiots are afraid of books and you should cover such important details when attempting to summarize things for them.

  • Thanks 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

When she later finds out that Saurfang failed to kill him, in other words, inflict a wound that would never heal, Sylvanas decides to take things into her own hands and burn down Teldrassil.

Retconned so soon? Woah that's quick even for Blizz.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, Haheisenberg said:

You've covered why conquering Darnassus was a step towards conquering Stormwind but you failed to cover why conquer Stormwind or go to war at all. This is actually essential. I don't know if you wanted to give people reasons to hate Sylvanas even more but such inaccuracy is the reason for the whole drama and "Sylvanas is Hitler" bullshit. Some idiots are afraid of books and you should cover such important details when attempting to summarize things for them.

It's right there in the summery, Sylvanas doesn't think (long lasting) peace is possible unless the Horde has it on their own terms after a victory. I'm also reading that she wants to solidify her position as Warchief by conquest.

To be fair she has a point, cold wars tend to become hot eventually unless M.A.D is involved as powerful as the factions are, they aren't there yet. It's always better to start a war on your terms rather then let the enemy chose the time. That doesn't excuse her behaviour with the burning of course, but it goes a long way to explaining it... Of course if only this could have been told in-game...

Instead we get the lamest pre-patch event I can remember.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
20 minutes ago, tkioz said:

It's right there in the summery, Sylvanas doesn't think (long lasting) peace is possible unless the Horde has it on their own terms after a victory. I'm also reading that she wants to solidify her position as Warchief by conquest.


Of course she's creating a foregone conclusion.  She's doing what so many people do in life to ruin relationships.  I can't depend on this other person to stick around so I'm going to do everything I can to make that outcome happen.  Because being right and certain is easier than being uncertain and potentially happy.

Actually, she wants to take Stormwind to create more Forsaken out of the Human population.  She doesn't want to let the Forsaken that already exist to ever die and she wants to enslave the rest of Humanity to serve her.  "The Horde" is the instrument she's using to achieve this, because without their protection and boots on the ground they would be obliterated.

Whatever wrongs have happened in the past, her agenda is why this is happening and she's now not much better than the Lich King himself.  

Edited by Sholto
  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Sholto said:


Of course she's creating a foregone conclusion.  She's doing what so many people do in life to ruin relationships.  I can't depend on this other person to stick around so I'm going to do everything I can to make that outcome happen.  Because being right and certain is easier than being uncertain and potentially happy.

Actually, she wants to take Stormwind to create more Forsaken out of the Human population.  She doesn't want to let the Forsaken that already exist to ever die and she wants to enslave the rest of Humanity to serve her.  "The Horde" is the instrument she's using to achieve this, because without their protection and boots on the ground they would be obliterated.

Whatever wrongs have happened in the past, her agenda is why this is happening and she's now not much better than the Lich King himself.  

This. What further makes this all the more head scratching is that Voljin died firmly believing she had to be the next Horde leader. There were several candidates who had his guts and honor that could have been given the mantle, but the "Loa" chose her. Right now, the Loa look like total morons and Voljin the Rhonda Rousey of Horde leaders.

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
8 hours ago, Stan said:

Sylvanas wants to go to war, because she believes there can't be a long-lasting peace between the factions, unless the Horde wins it on the battlefield on their terms, so why delay the inevitable

Because there's - oh I don't know - an intergalactic faction that consumes planets that have their eyes set on Azeroth?

 

Was this not obvious the past 10 or so years?

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, therainking said:

This. What further makes this all the more head scratching is that Voljin died firmly believing she had to be the next Horde leader. There were several candidates who had his guts and honor that could have been given the mantle, but the "Loa" chose her. Right now, the Loa look like total morons and Voljin the Rhonda Rousey of Horde leaders.

stealing "voljin was the rhonda rousey of horde leaders" ?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
12 hours ago, Haheisenberg said:

You've covered why conquering Darnassus was a step towards conquering Stormwind but you failed to cover why conquer Stormwind or go to war at all. This is actually essential. I don't know if you wanted to give people reasons to hate Sylvanas even more but such inaccuracy is the reason for the whole drama and "Sylvanas is Hitler" bullshit. Some idiots are afraid of books and you should cover such important details when attempting to summarize things for them.

Thanks for bringing this up, I updated the article with more info ?.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A good summary, thanks for posting here.

It is such a shame we didn't get even half of the details and insights from the books in the game. We really have no friggin idea of Sylvanas motives from the quests and cinematics, and they skipped the whole spying/mind games/war preparation detailed in the books.

There were a few points where the plot felt kinda forced, specially near the end, but they were good reads. I would recommend everyone to read them fully, at your time. The writing is very good and most characters depictions are on point.

  • Like 2
  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In fact, the burning of Teldrassil is Saurfang fault.. He had the chance to inflict a wound that would never heal By killing Malfurion and no burning then. 

It's sad to see that in game when we start the questline Sylvanas is portrayed as a brain dead who wants war for the sake of it. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, Eukray said:

In fact, the burning of Teldrassil is Saurfang fault...


In fact, it isn't.  He and the rest of the Horde have been brought into this conflict by Sylvanas' agenda and her agenda alone.  Prior to all of this her and Blightcaller's ultimate goal is to take Stormwind and create more Forsaken.  And she wants more Forsaken, not because she loves them, at least no more than a wife beater loves his wife.  And that's what she is, her mentality.  They are the weakest group within the Horde, without a viable means to grow, and she has to remove all hope that they have anything but Her to rely on.  Because without them she's got nothing, and so if they will not be hers she would rather they meet their final death.  

Sylvanas will murder and slaughter The Forsaken themselves to achieve her psychopathic goals.  And she has.   She is a villain.  Plain and simple.  And the rest of the Horde leaders are simply being manipulated.

Edited by Sholto

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 hours ago, Eukray said:

In fact, the burning of Teldrassil is Saurfang fault.. He had the chance to inflict a wound that would never heal By killing Malfurion and no burning then.

Debatable. But I fell like Saurfang did what many horde characters (maybe even most of, also debatable) would do in that situation. And no one, not even Sylvannas, had thought about burning the tree. It is something both the book and in game depict as a last minute decision/realization.

Not to mention that burning the tree would backfire much more violently, as it did happen. We might not get the immediate start of the war if only Malfurion was killed. Sylvannas would have gotten some extra time to plot and prepare, and might even be able to star a war in more favorable terms, since at this time both factions are weak and of similar strength.

7 hours ago, Eukray said:

It's sad to see that in game when we start the questline Sylvanas is portrayed as a brain dead who wants war for the sake of it. 

That I agree.

Edited by lChronosl

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Starym
      Today's hotfixes are still very Plunderstorm-heavy, but we do get fixes for more achievement-related mount issues and PvP catch-up, in addition to the limited time event's adjustments.
      March 27 (Source)
      Achievements
      Fixed bugs causing mounts related to A World Awoken to be unavailable, including Bestowed Ottuk Vanguard, Bestowed Trawling Mammoth, Bestowed Thunderspine Packleader, Bestowed Sandskimmer, Bestowed Ohuna Spotter, Coralscale Salamanther, Stormtouched Bruffalon, and Taivan. Player versus Player
      Fixed an issue that prevented Splintered Sparks of Dreams from dropping from PvP sources while eligible for catch-up. Plunderstorm
      The Storm’s fury swells! Lightning strikes during the final stage of the Storm are faster and more dangerous than before. There is now a delay of 20 seconds after being revived where players no longer drop collected Plunder. Additional enemies now spawn at Witherbark Village, the wild area northeast of Go’Shek Farm, and the wild area between Witherbark Village and Boulderfist Hall. Fixed an issue where swapping back to default sword and gun appearances were not saving correctly. Fixed an issue so that now, picking up an additional rank 2 spell while the same rank 2 spell is equipped properly grants the rank 4 version of the spell. The Captain’s Orders quest “X Marks the Spot” now requires 1 item to be picked up (was 2 items).
    • By Staff
      Well that didn't take long! We found out someone had broken the 700,000 Plunder milestone yesterday evening, and we're already done with the full amount now! Soularpower_ managed to grind it out a couple of hours ago in duos, and grabbed the Plunderkind achievement, so huge congratulations! It's been a week and a day since the event was released, and despite there being plenty of Plunder drop buffs since then it's still great to see someone get it all done already. 


      Unsurprisingly, the first thing Soularpower_ after reaching that goal was... play more Plunderstorm! He's actually still at it if now you want to check the stream out. 
    • By Starym
      Here's our first post-patch look at the Mythic+ log rankings. While the patch didn't really touch any of the DPS or tank specs, there's still some movement there, especially in the raw DPS chart. Healers got some solid changes in the patch, and the definitely had an effect.
      Warcraft Logs Points
      The below logs are based on POINTS, and not actual damage or healing, meaning they log the timed completion for the specs, with higher keys getting more points, obviously. The time in which the dungeon is completed is also a factor, but a much, much smaller one, as it grants very few points if you do it significantly faster than just any in-time completion. We're also using the Normalized Aggregate Scores numbers, for clarity, meaning the top spec is marked as 100 and then the rest are ranked in relation to that peak point.
      All Keys
      95th percentile DPS
      The top percentiles are extremely stable, which makes sense since the patch didn't really bring any significant changes for DPS specs. We have to go down to number 7 to see the first bit of movement, as Destruction moves two up, leaving its fellow Warlock down in 9th, as Arms gets between them, gaining 3 spots. Havoc closes out the top 10 three down, and right behind it we find the newly buffed Elemental moving three up. While Augmentation is being properly calculated, we still find an Evoker in the bottom 3, as Devastation drops one down and takes Marksmanship's place.

      Mythic+ All Keys 95th Percentile Data by Warcraft Logs.
      All Percentiles
      It took Shadow a little longer to get into the top in the generalist bracket, as we find it in 3rd now, pushing Outlaw down one. Balance also moves up, 2 spots into 6th, as it and Arms take advantage of Havoc's fall. The Demon Hunter finds itself 3 down in 9th, while Fury remains stable at the very end of the top 10.

      Mythic+ All Keys All Percentile Data by Warcraft Logs.
      Raw DPS U.GG DPS Rankings
      U.gg's rankings are based on actual DPS taken from Warcraft Logs data, focusing on the top players and span the past two weeks.
      While Outlaw remains at the top, pretty much everything's changing beneath it. Shadow and Retribution joined forces and moved two up together, breaking into the top 3. Fire is also on the rise, gaining 3 spots, and right behind it we find another big leaper, as Arms moves a whopping 5 spots up.
      Mythic+ All Keystone DPS rankings by u.gg.
       
      All Percentiles Tank (Points)
      There's actually some solid movement here, as we see Paladin take 2nd away from DK and Druid take Monk down, with Warrior remaining in last place and DH being far ahead of the pack.
      Mythic+ All Keys All Percentile Data by Warcraft Logs.
      Healer (Points)
      Healers had some significant changes with the patch, but it hasn't stopped Monk from remaining at the top. Druid moves into 2nd, taking Discipline Priest down a peg, and it seems the Holy Priest patch reworks helped it out, as it gains a spot in 4th.

      Mythic+ All Keys All Percentile Data by Warcraft Logs.
       
      For even more in-depth data for each individual key head on over to Warcraft Logs and u.gg. And if you're interested in more info on the specs themselves you can always check out our class guides, as well as our Mythic+ guides and Mythic+ tier list.
    • By Staff
      In Dragonflight Season 4, Awakened/Fated raids will be on a weekly rotation.
      Upon accessing the Adventure Guide and navigating to the Raids section, you'll notice a green gem icon beside the raid that's Awakened for the current week.

      When a raid is Awakened, bosses are more powerful and loot drops are upgraded to a higher item level. The upcoming season revisits the Fated system introduced in Shadowlands Season 4.
    • By Staff
      We've already taken a look at all the items coming to the Trading Post next month, as the Season 4 PTR revealed them, but now let's see them in movement as well! MrGM has detailed everything coming in April, from the awesome Dreadwake mount to a pretty cool polearm, some new capes, and all the other pirate-themed items. Let's take a look. 

      If you'd rather just scroll through some images, you can head on to our original post here. 
×
×
  • Create New...