Jump to content
FORUMS
Sign in to follow this  
Stan

Blizzard Removes Insult from the Dialogue Between Garrosh and Sylvanas

Recommended Posts

51600-will-garrosh-hellscream-return-in-

Blizzard recently removed the word b**** and the associated sound file from the dialogue between Garrosh Hellscream and Sylvanas Windrunner.

EgW8z3LU0AMi9VE?format=jpg&name=small

Image courtesy of Krexxal.

Lead Narrative Designer Steve Danuser said Garrosh's point of view comes across just fine even after the edit, so the word will not be returning back.

Placeholder for tweet 1298728022653075456

For those of you who haven't played in Cataclysm, here's the original version without the edit.

  • Like 3
  • Confused 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Oh noes, how daŕe a character that is known for his fiery temper express his disdain for necromantic practice after a bloody war with undead hordes with semi-harsh language! SHAME!

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 minutes ago, Teufel said:

Oh noes, how daŕe a character that is known for his fiery temper express his disdain for necromantic practice after a bloody war with undead hordes with semi-harsh language! SHAME!

The line always came off as rather crude to me, which for all his aggression, Garrosh was not crude. 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The joke this company has become. On top of everything else bad in game they managed to find some other things to ruin.

 

Signs that it is time for me to go.

  • Like 1
  • Confused 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I’m very glad to see Blizzard addressing the details like this where unacceptable language (in this case, a misogynist term) was being used.

19 minutes ago, kokodesuka said:

The joke this company has become. On top of everything else bad in game they managed to find some other things to ruin.

Signs that it is time for me to go.

Responsible this company has become. In the context of an oppressive culture, they managed to find another thing to do better.

Sign that it is time for me to stay.

 

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 minutes ago, Trest said:

I’m very glad to see Blizzard addressing the details like this where unacceptable language (in this case, a misogynist term) was being used.

Responsible this company has become. In the context of an oppressive culture, they managed to find another thing to do better.

Sign that it is time for me to stay.

 

"oppressive culture"

Goddamn, I had no idea we lived in the Middle East XD

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Isn't Steve Danuser the guy that turned Nathanos into his self-insert so he can simp for Sylvanas?

Imagine being that desperate for Undead coochie

  • Like 2
  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I wonder, do they plan to remove what she did to Teldrassil? cause i am thinking burning Innocent civilians to death is ALOT worse than calling her a *filtered*.

  • Like 5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 minutes ago, Lithari said:

I wonder, do they plan to remove what she did to Teldrassil? cause i am thinking burning Innocent civilians to death is ALOT worse than calling her a *filtered*.

no no no, my friend

>committing genocide

A-ok

>being called a naughty word

horrible XD

The hypocrisy of modern times

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I mean, Garrosh is a fictional character who is heavy into racism (species-ism?) and extremely opinionated.     Are writers no longer allowed to write offensive characters even as villains?   It's a minor thing but at the same time it shows an extreme level of censorship that they're willing to take.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Dejo93 said:

Isn't Steve Danuser the guy that turned Nathanos into his self-insert so he can simp for Sylvanas?

Ayup. At first I wondered if removing the word had something to do with a ESRB rating of the game, and the limited amount of swear words a 12+ game could contain. If they were adding more in Shadowlands, they may have felt the need to scale back elsewhere... Nope! It's just this guy backwriting and retconning things so no one says mean words about his waifu. It's not even some lefty PR move. It's literally simping.

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I like how people complain about how soft everyone has become, and then come and complain about a video game removing a word that is derogatory to 1 gender.  Hypocrisy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Dejo93 said:

no no no, my friend

>committing genocide

A-ok

>being called a naughty word

horrible XD

The hypocrisy of modern times

The former is a story device, the latter isn't xD

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, kokodesuka said:

The joke this company has become. On top of everything else bad in game they managed to find some other things to ruin.

 

Signs that it is time for me to go.

image.thumb.jpeg.a5e2902ac89145af974871e53166ee68.jpeg

  • Like 2
  • Haha 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, Trest said:

I’m very glad to see Blizzard addressing the details like this where unacceptable language (in this case, a misogynist term) was being used.

Responsible this company has become. In the context of an oppressive culture, they managed to find another thing to do better.

Sign that it is time for me to stay.

 

Imagine being this cringe.

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's weird how character who hated non-orc species isn't allowed to say word "*filtered*". As if saying "bad" word is a bigger issue here.

Edit: Oh, it's even filtered here. ?

Edited by Arcling

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
8 hours ago, Trest said:

Responsible this company has become. In the context of an oppressive culture, they managed to find another thing to do better.

Sign that it is time for me to stay.

 

Where did you get this context from? This is a game, not the country you're from or the whiteboard for expressing political opinions. This is fiction.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

IIRC WoW is rated T for teen, so if the parent is letting their child play the game, that's on them, not the game.

Sad they're doing this to Garrosh, he can't catch a break even in death.

  • Confused 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Imagine this being a real issue for you to stomach... honestly, if you aren't happy that it's gone, why do you feel anything at all?

The word was GLARINGLY out of place, even in context. In no other line of dialogue is the word ever used. I didn't even assume they used all the same swear words in Azeroth as we do, nor do I remember any other character saying anything like this. I'm not sure I even hear characters use curse words outside of the extremely-thematically-appropriate use of "damn." 

Edited by durdyenglish

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
19 hours ago, Arcling said:

It's weird how character who hated non-orc species isn't allowed to say word "*filtered*". As if saying "bad" word is a bigger issue here.

Edit: Oh, it's even filtered here. ?

Racism and hatred as the primary device behind generations of factional violence is a realistic plot device used in many stories throughout time. World of Warcraft has done a decent job (given the platform) showcasing the pain, devastation, and horror found in the aftermath. We've now had two expansions that address the brutality and futility of this violence head-on.

This is, of course, not very comparable to callously inserting a vulgar curse word for shock effect, which at-best could be described as unnecessary, and at-worst overtly distasteful.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
50 minutes ago, durdyenglish said:

Racism and hatred as the primary device behind generations of factional violence is a realistic plot device used in many stories throughout time. World of Warcraft has done a decent job (given the platform) showcasing the pain, devastation, and horror found in the aftermath. We've now had two expansions that address the brutality and futility of this violence head-on.

This is, of course, not very comparable to callously inserting a vulgar curse word for shock effect, which at-best could be described as unnecessary, and at-worst overtly distasteful.

 

Okay... what? Are you roleplaying Steven Danuser's alt account?

Since you seem to be (and correct me if I'm wrong of course) using lore as a defense of this bizarre snap-reaction censoring, let me pivot this to you:

Garrosh spent, theoretically, years in the cold North, battling against death and Undeath left and right. Finally, after this war, he sees in the Horde's own backyard in the Eastern Kingdoms, Sylvanas doing no different than Arthas. So maybe it would have been more apropos for Garrosh's demeanor to simply bury Gorehowl into Sylvanas then and there, but they wanted a slow burn. So instead they wrote language that would encapsulate the raw rage of an already hot-headed orc warchief. Does that word get thrown around often? No. That's the point - that's the evidence of his loss of composure.

 

It's not about people "not being able to stomach the change," it's about retconning a justifiable dialogue to appease the guilt of a parent for an "oopsie-parent-moment."

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Uncommon Patron
On 8/28/2020 at 8:59 AM, durdyenglish said:

The line always came off as rather crude to me, which for all his aggression, Garrosh was not crude. 

hmmm...throws someone off a cliff, but is not crude....seems legit.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Stan
      From dungeons to the new raid and Khaz Algar, we're looking at the loading screens of the War Within.
      Please note not all loading screens have been implemented right now, but we've datamined many belonging to the new dungeons, the raid, and even Khaz Algar!
      Khaz Algar (Continent)
      Ara-Kara (Dungeon)

      City of Threads (Dungeon)

      Priory of the Sacred Flame (Dungeon)

      Darkflame Cleft (Dungeon)

      The Stonevault (Dungeon)

      Cinderbrew Meadery (Dungeon)

      The Dawnbreaker (Dungeon)

      Rookery (Dungeon)

      Nerub-ar Palace (Raid)

      What do you think about the architecture/themes from the loading screens?

    • By Staff
      Find out how many times you need to kill Garrosh to buy Tusks of Mannoroth and the Heirloom Weapons in MoP Remix!
      Bones of Mannoroth drops from Garrosh on Normal or higher difficulty in Siege of Orgrimmar and keep in mind all raids are on a daily lockout.
      You will receive 1 Bones of Mannoroth from killing Garrosh on Normal Difficulty. You will receive 4 Bones of Mannoroth from killing Garrosh on Heroic Difficulty. You will receive 10 Bones of Mannoroth from killing Garrosh on Mythic Difficulty. To buy Tusks of Mannoroth from Pythagorus, you must farm 38500 Bronze and 20 Bones of Mannoroth. As mentioned during soulsobreezy's interview, one Heroic clear gets you around 30,000 Bronze. You will need to kill Garrosh at least twice on Mythic Difficulty or 5 times on Heroic to have enough bones to buy the tusks.
      The Heirloom weapons are much cheaper, as they only cost 8,000 Bronze and 2 Bones of Mannoroth each.
    • By Stan
      Take a look at the veggie weapons coming in the War Within expansion!
      Extra Large Leak
      This is a One-Hand Mace equipped in your main hand. The item comes from Cooking and the associated spell (Extra Large Leak) suggests you need to collect 999 Twined Herbs.

      Garlic Knots
      A garlic off-Hand to keep vampires at bay. We don't know how to obtain the item at this time.

      What do you think about the new weapons? Let us know in the comments!
    • By Stan
      Plenty of changes for Rogues went live in the latest War Within Alpha build. Check them out!
      Rogue
      Mean Streak- Fatebound Coins flipped by Envenom multiple times in a row are 33% more likely to match the same outcome face as the last flip. Threads of Fate [NYI]- Fate Intertwined duplicates 15% of Dispatch critical strikes duplicate 20% of their damage as Cosmic to 2 additional nearby enemies. If there are no additional nearby targets, duplicate 20% 15% to the primary target instead. Delivered Doom- Damage dealt when your Fatebound Coin flips tails is increased by 35% while Blade Flurry is not active  21% if there are no other enemies near the target. Inevitability [NYI]- Cold Blood now benefits the next 2 two abilities but only applies to Dispatch. Fatebound Coins flipped by these abilities are guaranteed to match the same face as the last flip. Assassination Rogue- Assassination Rogue core passive Increases damage/healing by 7%: Ambush, Blade Rush, Deadly Poison, Death from Above, Eviscerate, Feint, Gloomblade, Improved Shiv, Instant Poison, Internal Bleeding, Killing Spree, Main Gauche, Mind-Numbing Poison, Poison Bomb, Secret Technique, Shiv, System Shock, Wound Poison Increases periodic damage/healing by 7%: Ambush, Blade Rush, Deadly Poison, Death from Above, Eviscerate, Feint, Gloomblade, Improved Shiv, Instant Poison, Internal Bleeding, Killing Spree, Main Gauche, Mind-Numbing Poison, Poison Bomb, Secret Technique, Shiv, System Shock, Wound Poison Decreases Increases damage/healing by 3%: Ambush, Blade Rush, Deadly Poison, Death from Above, Eviscerate, Feint, Gloomblade, Improved Shiv, Instant Poison, Internal Bleeding, Killing Spree, Main Gauche, Mind-Numbing Poison, Poison Bomb, Secret Technique, Shiv, System Shock, Wound Poison Decreases Increases periodic damage/healing by 3%: Ambush, Blade Rush, Deadly Poison, Death from Above, Eviscerate, Feint, Gloomblade, Improved Shiv, Instant Poison, Internal Bleeding, Killing Spree, Main Gauche, Mind-Numbing Poison, Poison Bomb, Secret Technique, Shiv, System Shock, Wound Poison Hand of Fate- Flip a Fatebound Coin each time a damaging finishing move consumes 5 or more combo points. Heads increases the damage of your attacks by 5%, lasting until you flip Tails. Tails deals Cosmic damage to your targets target. struck. Each effect is increased by 20% each time your Fatebound Coin flip matches the same outcome as the last flip.
    • By Stan
      Find out which specs were the most popular during the third week of Season 4.

      DISCLAIMER
      The following post is based on data taken from u.gg, which has combined thousands of parses from live servers.
      The Most Popular Specializations for Mythic+ in Season 4 Week 3
      This week's affixes are Fortified, Afflicted, and Raging.
      An upward arrow (▲) represents an increase in popularity, while a downward arrow (▼) represents a decrease, compared to the previous week.
      The Most Popular DPS Specializations
      Shadow Priest saw a significant increase in popularity this week. Other DPS specs like Fire Mage or Beast Mastery Hunter slightly decreased in popularity.
      Shadow Priest - 17.9% (▲2.9%) Retribution Paladin - 13.9% (▲0.1%) Augmentation Evoker - 11.0% (▲3.1%) Destruction Warlock - 6.4% (▲0.6%) Fire Mage - 5.6% (▼0.3%) Frost Mage - 4.9% (▲1.1%) Beast Mastery Hunter - 3.7% (▼1.1%) Outlaw Rogue - 2.9% (▼0.9%) Devastation Evoker - 2.7% (▼0.9%) Demonology Warlock - 2.6% (▼1.1%) Balance Druid - 2.5% (▲0.2%) Havoc Demon Hunter - 2.4% (▼0.7%) Arms Warrior - 2.4% (▼1.0%) Windwalker Monk - 2.1% (▼0.5%) Elemental Shaman - 2.0% (▼0.1%) Fury Warrior - 1.8% (▼0.1%) Unholy Death Knight - 1.7% (▼0.2%) Enhancement Shaman - 1.6% (▼0.2%) Arcane Mage - 1.5% (▼0.2%) Assassination Rogue - 1.5% (▼0.1%) Subtlety Rogue - 1.5% (▼0.1%) Feral Druid - 1.5% (▼0.1%) Marksmanship Hunter - 1.5% (▼0.2%) Frost Death Knight - 1.5% (▼0.1%) Survival Hunter - 1.4% (▼0.2%) Affliction Warlock - 1.4% (▼0.1%)
      The Most Popular Tanks
      Vengeance DH saw a notable increase in popularity this week while other tank specs saw a decrease.
      Vengeance Demon Hunter - 64.7% (▲5.4%) Protection Paladin - 9.5% (▼1.4%) Blood Death Knight - 7.8% (▼1.8%) Guardian Druid - 7.3% (▼0.9%) Protection Warrior - 5.5% (▼0.3%) Brewmaster Monk - 5.1% (▼1.1%)
      The Most Popular Healers
      We see Restoration Druid rising in popularity among the healers by nearly 5% this week. 
      Restoration Druid - 36.0% (▲4.9%) Mistweaver Monk - 16.2% (▼0.7%) Holy Priest - 14.2% (▼0.1%) Restoration Shaman - 12.6% (▼1.7%) Preservation Evoker - 7.3% (▼1.3%) Discipline Priest - 6.9% (▼0.4%) Holy Paladin - 6.8% (▼0.7%)
×
×
  • Create New...