Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  

Castle Nathria 9.0.5 DPS Log Rankings and Analysis, Week 4: Shadow and Fire

Recommended Posts


Another week of Nathria raiding has passed for both NA and EU guilds and we can see some changes in the rankings, but the very top has become fairly stable at this point, with Arcane being the latest to join and seems to be sticking there! This week we'll also be taking a more in-depth look at two of the most consistent and top performing specs throughout Shadowlands, as our guide writer experts take a look at Shadow (the top single target DPS) and Fire.

In the 95th percentile we see Unholy moving back up in the world, coming in right behind its fellow Frost DK after the chilly spec had a major lead in recent times, after having come up from the bottom. Last week's golden boy Demonology dropped just a little, but it's still very high compared to previous weeks, and while Affliction remains in it's extremely solid top 3 spot, Destruction has also risen this week. The bottom of the charts moved around a little, but it's still the same Subtlety, Arms, Enhancement and two Hunter specs at the rear end of the rankings.

95th percentile Mythic data by Warcraft Logs.

In the all percentiles chart things are a little different, especially for Assassination, as it's risen even higher this week, passing Elemental and getting in the top 5!

All percentiles Mythic data by Warcraft Logs.

And here's an in-depth look at two of the most stable specs at the top of the meters, as we haven't talked about them in a long time, since they just do not move around the rankings much, preferring to keep to the very top.

Shadow Priest by Publik


As more guilds start to get Castle Nathria fully on farm, it is clear to see that Shadow Priest remains one of the most consistent  top performing DPS in the raid. In fact, when looking at Boss Damage specifically, you can see that Shadow Priest is the clear favorite top DPS across all specs.


Truthfully you would see Shadow do even better in aggregate if it weren’t for the specs performance on Sire Denathrius and Stone Legion Generals.

Looking at why this is, you can see that having a durable base toolkit to work from paired with some real choices in the talent tree and legendary power section can really give Shadow Priest the edge over other DPS specs. In addition, having the strongest single target in the game clearly comes to its advantage, especially with the many different ways we can tailor this depending on the given fight. Being able to choose Void Torrent Void Torrent and Talbadar's Stratagem Talbadar's Stratagem for great single target, or Mindbender Mindbender and Shadowflame Prism Shadowflame Prism for good cleave damage gives the spec some options for how to handle the more common aspects of encounter design. On top of this you can easily make any of the four covenants work for you as a Shadow Priest, giving even further depth into the existing toolkit for the Priest. That being said, you are now seeing a confident amount of players parsing well as Night Fae specifically, giving you even more cooldown uptime to help sync up more Mindbenders with Voidform Voidform for extra Shadowflame Prism damage. All of these things are perpetuating Shadow being one of the best DPS in the opening tier of Shadowlands.

Fire Mage by Dutchmagoz


Fire Mages have been in a good spot since the start of the tier. There are various reasons for this, and below I'll go over some of them.

One of the biggest reasons is how well Fire's cooldowns line up with mechanics in the raid. Combustion Combustion being on a one minute cooldown (as Night Fae Covenant, with Kindling Kindling talented), makes it so that Fire can do good damage at the right time in pretty much every situation. This, combined with how strong Combustion is for a one minute cooldown, means Fire can utilize additional targets very well since you will have Combustion up any time additional targets are part of the fight.

Another major reason is gearing. Aside from having multiple items that are best in slot being very easy to achieve, a lot of the conduits, legendaries, trinkets, etc, are very good for both single target and AoE damage, meaning Fire does not have to compromise on either. One of its best trinkets comes from PvP (Badge), which is completely farmable. It is both great on single target and on AoE since it lines up perfectly with Combustion. Additionally, Fire's best in slot legendary (now Disciplinary Command Disciplinary Command, Fevered Incantation Fevered Incantation before DC buffs) boosts Combustion damage significantly, meaning it is also great for both single target and AoE.

Additionally, Fire can handle all mechanics the raid throws at it very efficiently, and thus has to barely give up any DPS to do these mechanics. There are barely any mechanics that require much more movement than just Shimmer Shimmer, and if there are, Fire generates a lot of instant casts in the form of Hot Streak Hot Streak, making it so it can easily stutter step for most mechanics where Shimmer isn't enough. On top of that, the spec is extremely mobile during execute phases due to the Searing Touch Searing Touch talent, which allows it to use Scorch Scorch as a filler, which is castable while moving.

Finally, Fire is simply tuned quite well, where even if the fights did not work in its favour, it would still be able to do decent DPS. Combine this with all the reasons listed above, and it is easy to see why Fire has been a constant strong spec in Castle Nathria.

Things remained the same in Heroic this week, with Assassination being even higher than in Mythic all percentiles, indicating that regular players really prefer the spec to the top-end and are performing very well with it.

All percentiles Heroic data by Warcraft Logs.

As always, if you want even more info on a spec, you can check out our class guides here.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Starym
      Another response from a Blizzard veteran on the sexual harrassment and discrimination lawsuit filed against Activision Blizzard, as Chris Metzen, former Senior Vice President of Story & Franchise Development, the man behind the story and lore for most Blizzard franchises up until 2016, voice of Thrall and many more has now talked about the issue. He mentions his response was "later than it should have been" and continues:
    • By Starym
      To take our minds off the news that's been in focus for a few days now, just for a second, here's a very cool machinima by Pivotal and MasterVertex. If the names sound familiar, it's because they are part of the team that brought us the incredible "Judgement" machinima recently.
      While we'll have to wait quite a while to see how/if Sylvanas is punished for what she did to Teldrassil, In "Eye for an Eye" we see Tarren Mill getting a visitor:
      Hopefully the cameo at the end indicates we get to see the actual person behind what happened to Teldrassil also get a little machinima where she is dealt with.
    • By Starym
      We have another old Blizzard employee joining in on the commentary surrounding the Activision Blizzard lawsuit, as former Lead Systems Designer Greg "Ghostcrawler" Street offered his thoughts on the matter.
      More specifically, there's an old 2010 BlizzCon WoW Q&A video clip that's been posted to reddit and received a lot of attention, which was pointed to as being related to the issues/atmosphere alleged in the lawsuit, and while Street barely even said anything in it, he still thought he should explain the situation and apologize.
      As he was then asked directly about the situation at Blizzard at the time relating to the lawsuit, he also responded:
      You can read even more replies in this thread.
    • By Starym
      The recent Activision Blizzard lawsuit is having effects in World of Warcraft as well, with many players staging various kinds of protests, including sit-ins in Oribos while raising money for charity, and checking up on a disappearing NPC.
      The most prominent of the protests is from the Fence Macabre RP guild who stages a sit-in on the Oribos steps with hundreds of players, and also managed to raise a huge $9,500 for the Black Girls Code non-profit organization during it:
      The guild tried to get as many individual players together on the same shard via raid groups, but there were still plenty you can't see in the screenshots.
      Another interesting "event" in the game is players heading to Stormwind to "check up" on a specific NPC, namely Field Marshal Afrasiabi (who is named for Alex Afrasiabi, one of the people mentioned in the lawsuit allegations, and who also left Blizzard in 2020).

      The more interesting thing, however, is that Blizzard has seemingly started despawning the NPC, as he was not there when some players arrived. Players had actually been asking for the removal of all references related to Afrasiabi, so this might just be Blizzard listening, although there are other references still in-game.

      And finally, a message from one group of players to the other:

      In terms of actual player comments on the matter there are, of course, many more threads discussing the issue over on r/wow, so if you want to see more community reactions head on over there, with most comments in the main lawsuit thread.
    • By Starym
      A bigger batch for the end of the week, focusing on Mythic+ dungeon changes, with some Torghast and minor class and item tweaks as well, with the Paragon reputation from the Archivist's Codex now working properly.
      July 23 (Source)
      Demon Hunter Fixed an issue with Hidden Helm and Hidden Cloak transmog options for Demon Hunters not using the correct appearances. Covenants
      Soulbinds Night Fae Fixed an issue where Podtender (Dreamweaver) would cause the player to die when accepting a queue. Dungeons and Raids
      Sanctum of Domination Remnant of Ner’zhul Fixed an issue that allowed cleave effects to hit his armor pieces on Mythic difficulty. Mythic+ Fixed an issue where dying after completing the dungeon in time could cause you to lose the ability to trade your keystone with Ta'hsup. Tormented Affix The spawn location of the 4th Tormented Affix lieutenant in Sanguine Depths has been adjusted to be available before Grand Proctor Beryilla. Spires of Ascension Devos Fixed an issue that would cause Archon's Bastion damage reduction buff to be removed with player immunity effects. Tazavesh, the Veiled Market Fixed an issue where Lethal Force would continue to affect players after Commander Zo’far’s defeat. Items and Rewards
      Paragon reputation gains for The Archivists' Codex faction now function properly. Torghast, Tower of the Damned
      Torments Raging can now be dispelled by spells that remove enrage effects such as Soothe . Reinforced: Unstoppable is no longer removed from the enemy upon the player’s defeat.
  • Create New...